Skip to main content

2019 | Buch

Banking Supervision and Criminal Investigation

Comparing the EU and US Experiences

insite
SUCHEN

Über dieses Buch

In the aftermath of the last financial crisis, on both sides of the Atlantic banking supervisors were given new supervisory and enforcement powers, which are often of a substantially punitive-criminal nature. In Europe in particular, the establishment of the Single Supervisory Mechanism within the European Central Bank substantially increased centralised investigatory and sanctioning powers. This major innovation, together with the development of forms of real-time monitoring of banking (often digital) records, challenges traditional banking criminal investigations in their national-based and analogue dimension.The book offers a comprehensive account and perspective analysis of the interactions between the criminal and administrative nature of such new powers, highlighting their “punitive” overall nature and their impact on fundamental rights. Covering both the US and the EU regulatory frameworks, it presents unprecedented, trans-systemic research between criminal law and procedure, and between regulatory and administrative law, at the international, European and national level.The book also includes a rich and detailed selection of case law from the US and the European supreme courts, with a specific focus on CJEU and ECtHR decisions.


Inhaltsverzeichnis

Frontmatter
Chapter 1. Introduction
Abstract
Financial transactions are a crucial element in the undertaking of criminal investigations, especially (but not exclusively) in their increasingly globalized dimension.
Giulia Lasagni

Mapping the Boundaries of an Intricate Playing-Field

Frontmatter
Chapter 2. Finding the Way in a Complex Multi-Level Legal Framework
Abstract
It is not unlikely for a criminal-law jurist who approaches the matter of banking and financial investigation for the first time to report an impression of mild bewilderment.
Giulia Lasagni
Chapter 3. Strengthening Financial Investigation and Supervision at the International Level
Abstract
The financial matter is just one of the fields of law where issues traditionally dealt with at the domestic level, are increasingly influenced by supranational and international actors, due to the globalisation of large sectors of the financial economy.
Giulia Lasagni

Criminal Profiles in Banking Supervision

Frontmatter
Chapter 4. The Institutional Design of EU Banking Supervision
Abstract
In the European Union, the burst of the 2006–2008 financial crisis brought to a dramatic change in the organisation and supervision of the financial market.
Giulia Lasagni
Chapter 5. The US Regulatory Framework of Banking Supervision
Abstract
To provide the basis to carry out the comparative analysis between the banking regulators in the EU and in the US in light of the Basel Core Principles which have a relevance also under a criminal law perspective, this Chapter delineates the main traits of the US banking supervisory system after the last financial crisis (Sect. 5.1), indicating relevant competent authorities, as well as their investigative and sanctioning powers (Sects. 5.2 and 5.3). In Sect. 5.4, a special focus is put on the changes produced in this field by the Dodd-Frank Act, the reform intervened in 2010 as a response to the distortions that brought to the crisis.
Giulia Lasagni
Chapter 6. The Hybrid Nature of Banking Supervision
Abstract
Independence and accountability, standards in information sharing, nature of supervisory sanctions, compliance with fair trial rights: Several are the profiles relevant under a criminal law perspective, that emerge as critical from the analysis carried out so far on the US and, above all, on the EU banking supervisory systems.
Giulia Lasagni

Banking Criminal Investigations

Frontmatter
Chapter 7. Real-Time Monitoring of Banking Data: State of Play
Abstract
If banking supervision in Europe stretches the boundaries of criminal investigations, defying the very definition of substantive criminal matter, and the content of the safeguards protecting the individuals’ fundamental rights, a non-less challenging element to criminal banking investigations (and to criminal proceedings in general) is represented today by the potential of real-time monitoring or surveillance investigative techniques.
Giulia Lasagni
Chapter 8. Introducing a Regulation on (Banking) Data Surveillance in the EU: Some Proposals
Abstract
Against the composite framework and the increasing urgency to provide for clear legal basis, and above all for adequate guarantees in case forms of real-time monitoring of banking records are performed, this Chapter concludes the present work, introducing some proposals on the key features that should characterize a regulation concerning surveillance on banking data within the EU legal framework.
Giulia Lasagni
Chapter 9. Conclusion
Abstract
The comparative research in this work has been driven by two leading questions: (a) In the field of banking investigations, what is a balance between the need to fight crimes and that of protecting human fundamental rights which can be fairly accepted in a democratic society?, and (b) under this perspective, is the current legal framework in the EU adequate? If not, what can be done about it?
Giulia Lasagni
Metadaten
Titel
Banking Supervision and Criminal Investigation
verfasst von
Dr. Giulia Lasagni
Copyright-Jahr
2019
Electronic ISBN
978-3-030-12161-7
Print ISBN
978-3-030-12160-0
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-12161-7