Skip to main content
Top

2021 | OriginalPaper | Chapter

Allocation of IP for TP Purposes

Author : Susann Karnath

Published in: Intangibles in the World of Transfer Pricing

Publisher: Springer International Publishing

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

The ownership of an intangible asset is of particular importance for a transfer pricing analysis because ownership defines to a significant extent the allocation of profits of a multinational group to the individual companies and to the countries these companies are located in. According to national and international tax laws, different types of ownership exist that have to be considered. German tax law distinguishes between legal and economic ownership, which is mainly relevant for tax accounting. From an OECD and transfer pricing perspective, the notion of functional ownership is the main standard for the allocation of profits resulting from intangible assets. The functional owner of an intangible asset, who is entitled to the residual profits in connection with the asset, is determined on a functional approach that is based on the development, enhancement, maintenance, protection, and exploitation (“DEMPE”) of that asset. Any transfer pricing planning that involves intangible assets, therefore, has to start with the determination of the legal, economic, and functional owner of the intangible assets.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 390 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe




 

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Footnotes
1
See Pankiv (2016), p. 471.
 
2
See Ratschow (2020), §39 note 16.
 
3
See BFH, 13.10.1972, BStBl II 1973, p. 209; BFH, 11/29/1973, BStBl II 1974, p. 202; BFH, 4/28/1977, BStBl II 1977, p. 553; BFH, 11/7/1991, BStBl II 1992, p. 398; BFH, 10/13/2016, BFHE 255, p. 386.
 
4
See Lagarden (2014), p. 695.
 
5
See BFH, 2/27/1991, BStBl II 1991, p. 628; BFH, 9/12/1991, BStBl II 1992, p. 182; 7/28/1993, BStBl II 1994, p. 164.
 
6
See BFH, 9/24/1991, BStBl II 1992, p. 330; BFH, 9/28/1995, BFH/NV 1996, p. 314; BFH, 25.1.1996, BStBl II 1997, p. 382.
 
7
See BFH, 18.8.2015, BFHE 251, p. 190.
 
8
See Circular of the German Ministry of Finance of 4/19/1971, BStBl. I 1971, p. 264.
 
9
See Circular of the German Ministry of Finance of 1/23/2001, BStBl. I 2001, p. 175, notes 16, 53.
 
10
See Greinert (2014), Immaterielle Wirtschaftsgüter, note 6.555.
 
11
See Greinert and Metzner (2015), p. 257.
 
12
This is also in line with the Circular of the German Ministry of Finance of 2/23/1983, BStBl. 1983 I, p. 218, note 5.3.
 
13
See OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.42.
 
14
See Wilkie (2012), p. 236.
 
15
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.56.
 
16
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.59.
 
17
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.62.
 
18
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 1.60.
 
19
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 1.65.
 
20
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 1.66.
 
21
For example, see Schön (2015), pp. 81–82, Monsenego (2014), p. 14.
 
22
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 1.64.
 
23
Bullen (2010), p. 487.
 
24
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.65.
 
25
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.65.
 
26
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.63.
 
27
Bullen (2010), p. 503.
 
28
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 1.76.
 
29
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.57.
 
30
OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines (2017), note 6.63.
 
31
Rasch (2015), Artikel 9 DBA-MA, note 72; Eigelshoven and Ebering (2015), OECD Chapter I, note 101/1.49. Wittendorff (2010), p. 397.
 
32
BFH, 10/11/2012, BStBl II 2013, p. 1046. Similar: BFH, 12/17/2014, BStBl II 2016, p. 261; BFH, 6/24/2015, BStBl II 2016, p. 258. However, according to recent decisions of the German Federal Fiscal Court, also other conditions of the intercompany transaction as well as commercial or financial relations themselves could be subject to a transfer price adjustment; ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 2/27/2019, I R 73/16, Federal Tax Gazette II 2019, p. 394.
 
33
Lagarden (2014), p. 696.
 
Literature
go back to reference BFH (1972) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 10/13/1972, Federal Tax Gazette II 1973, I R 213/69 BFH (1972) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 10/13/1972, Federal Tax Gazette II 1973, I R 213/69
go back to reference BFH (1973) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 11/29/1973, Federal Tax Gazette II 1974, IV R 181/71 BFH (1973) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 11/29/1973, Federal Tax Gazette II 1974, IV R 181/71
go back to reference BFH (1977) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 4/28/1977, Federal Tax Gazette II 1977, IV R 163/75 BFH (1977) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 4/28/1977, Federal Tax Gazette II 1977, IV R 163/75
go back to reference BFH (1991a) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 11/7/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1992, IV R 43/90 BFH (1991a) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 11/7/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1992, IV R 43/90
go back to reference BFH (2016) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 10/13/2016, Federal Tax Gazette II 2018, IV R 33/13 BFH (2016) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 10/13/2016, Federal Tax Gazette II 2018, IV R 33/13
go back to reference BFH (1991b) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 2/27/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1991, XI R 14/87 BFH (1991b) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 2/27/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1991, XI R 14/87
go back to reference BFH (1991c) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 9/12/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1992, III R 233/90 BFH (1991c) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 9/12/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1992, III R 233/90
go back to reference BFH (1993) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 7/28/1993, Federal Tax Gazette II 1994, I R 88/92 BFH (1993) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 7/28/1993, Federal Tax Gazette II 1994, I R 88/92
go back to reference BFH (1991d) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 9/24/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1992, VIII R 349/83 BFH (1991d) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 9/24/1991, Federal Tax Gazette II 1992, VIII R 349/83
go back to reference BFH (1995) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 9/28/1995, not published, IV R 34/93 BFH (1995) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 9/28/1995, not published, IV R 34/93
go back to reference BFH (1996) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 1/25/1996, Federal Tax Gazette II 1997, IV R 114/94 BFH (1996) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 1/25/1996, Federal Tax Gazette II 1997, IV R 114/94
go back to reference BFH (2015a) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 8/18/2015, Federal Tax Gazette II 2016, I R 88/13 BFH (2015a) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 8/18/2015, Federal Tax Gazette II 2016, I R 88/13
go back to reference BFH (2012) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 10/11/2012, Federal Tax Gazette II 2013, I R 75/11 BFH (2012) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 10/11/2012, Federal Tax Gazette II 2013, I R 75/11
go back to reference BFH (2014) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 12/17/2014, Federal Tax Gazette II 2016, I R 23/13 BFH (2014) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 12/17/2014, Federal Tax Gazette II 2016, I R 23/13
go back to reference BFH (2015b) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 6/24/2015, Federal Tax Gazette II 2016, I R 29/14 BFH (2015b) Ruling of the German Federal Fiscal Court of 6/24/2015, Federal Tax Gazette II 2016, I R 29/14
go back to reference BFH (1971) Circular of the German Ministry of Finance of 4/19/1971, Federal Tax Gazette I 1971, IV B/2-S 2170-31/71 BFH (1971) Circular of the German Ministry of Finance of 4/19/1971, Federal Tax Gazette I 1971, IV B/2-S 2170-31/71
go back to reference BFH (2001) Circular of the German Ministry of Finance of 2/23/2001, Federal Tax Gazette I 2001, IV A 6 - S 2241 - 8/01, note 16 and 53 BFH (2001) Circular of the German Ministry of Finance of 2/23/2001, Federal Tax Gazette I 2001, IV A 6 - S 2241 - 8/01, note 16 and 53
go back to reference Bullen, A. (2010). Arm’s Length Transaction Structures. Amsterdam: IBFD. Bullen, A. (2010). Arm’s Length Transaction Structures. Amsterdam: IBFD.
go back to reference Eigelshoven, A., & Ebering, A. (2015). OECD-Kapitel I. In H.-K. Kroppen (Ed.), Handbuch internationale Verrechnungspreise. Cologne: Otto Schmid. Eigelshoven, A., & Ebering, A. (2015). OECD-Kapitel I. In H.-K. Kroppen (Ed.), Handbuch internationale Verrechnungspreise. Cologne: Otto Schmid.
go back to reference Greinert, M. (2014). Immaterielle Wirtschaftsgüter. In F. Wassermeyer & H. Baumhoff (Eds.), Verrechnungspreise international verbundener Unternehmen. Cologne: Otto Schmid. Greinert, M. (2014). Immaterielle Wirtschaftsgüter. In F. Wassermeyer & H. Baumhoff (Eds.), Verrechnungspreise international verbundener Unternehmen. Cologne: Otto Schmid.
go back to reference Greinert, M., & Metzner, S. (2015). Eigentum an IP im Steuerrecht. IP-Rechts-Berater, 11, 256–260. Greinert, M., & Metzner, S. (2015). Eigentum an IP im Steuerrecht. IP-Rechts-Berater, 11, 256–260.
go back to reference Lagarden, M. (2014). Immaterielle Wirtschaftsgüter und Verrechnungspreise. Internationales Steuer- und Wirtschaftsrecht, 18, 689–700. Lagarden, M. (2014). Immaterielle Wirtschaftsgüter und Verrechnungspreise. Internationales Steuer- und Wirtschaftsrecht, 18, 689–700.
go back to reference Monsenego, J. (2014). The Substance Requirement in the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines: What Is the Substance of the Substance Requirement? International Transfer Pricing Journal, 21(1), 9–23. Monsenego, J. (2014). The Substance Requirement in the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines: What Is the Substance of the Substance Requirement? International Transfer Pricing Journal, 21(1), 9–23.
go back to reference Pankiv, M. (2016). Post-BEPS Application of the Arm’s Length Principle to Intangibles’ Structures. International Transfer Pricing Journal, 23(6), 463–476. Pankiv, M. (2016). Post-BEPS Application of the Arm’s Length Principle to Intangibles’ Structures. International Transfer Pricing Journal, 23(6), 463–476.
go back to reference Rasch, S. (2015). Artikel 9 DBA-MA. In D. Gosch, H.-K. Kroppen, & S. Grotherr (Eds.), DBA-Kommentar. Herne: NWB. Rasch, S. (2015). Artikel 9 DBA-MA. In D. Gosch, H.-K. Kroppen, & S. Grotherr (Eds.), DBA-Kommentar. Herne: NWB.
go back to reference Ratschow, E. (2020), § 39, In F. Klein (Eds.), Abgabenordnung. Munich: C. H. Beck Ratschow, E. (2020), § 39, In F. Klein (Eds.), Abgabenordnung. Munich: C. H. Beck
go back to reference Ratschow E (2020) § 39, In F. Klein (Eds) Abgabenordnung. C. H. Beck, Munich Ratschow E (2020) § 39, In F. Klein (Eds) Abgabenordnung. C. H. Beck, Munich
go back to reference Schön, W. (2015). Konzerninterne Risikoallokation und internationales Steuerrecht. Steuer und Wirtschaft, 92(1), 69–89.CrossRef Schön, W. (2015). Konzerninterne Risikoallokation und internationales Steuerrecht. Steuer und Wirtschaft, 92(1), 69–89.CrossRef
go back to reference Wilkie, S. (2012). The Definition and Ownership of Intangibles: Inside the Box? Outside the Box? What is the Box? World Tax Journal, 4(3), 222–248. Wilkie, S. (2012). The Definition and Ownership of Intangibles: Inside the Box? Outside the Box? What is the Box? World Tax Journal, 4(3), 222–248.
go back to reference Wittendorff, J. (2010). Transfer Pricing and the Arm’s Length Principle in International Tax Law. Austin: Wolters Kluwer. Wittendorff, J. (2010). Transfer Pricing and the Arm’s Length Principle in International Tax Law. Austin: Wolters Kluwer.
Metadata
Title
Allocation of IP for TP Purposes
Author
Susann Karnath
Copyright Year
2021
Publisher
Springer International Publishing
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-73332-6_2