Skip to main content
Top

2021 | OriginalPaper | Chapter

An Untenable Compromise? Liberal Democracy Between Populism and Globalization

Author : Alberto Ghibellini

Published in: Democracy and Globalization

Publisher: Springer International Publishing

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

Over time, globalization has deeply affected western liberal democracies, impairing their social fabric and undermining their legal and political foundations. Such an impact can, however, be wholly appreciated only if the nature of those democracies is first understood. With this aim in view, in this chapter a genealogy of the concept of liberal democracy is outlined and its heterogeneous character, resulting from the historical encounter of the distinct traditions of liberalism and democracy, is underscored. As a result, liberal democracy emerges as a compromise which globalization has now put under severe strain. More specifically, in this perspective globalization represents an outgrowth of the liberal, individualistic component of that compromise which has largely subverted—from the inside, as it were—the balance on which liberal democracy rested. This has driven the democratic elements in the compromise to seek new outlets to voice their concerns and claim their interests. No matter how much at odds with the liberal-democratic tradition, so called “populism” appears to be one of those outlets. If so, populism should be regarded as a still “democratic” symptom of an issue that, due to its largely unprecedented nature, now requires new measures to be addressed.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 390 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe




 

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Footnotes
1
This chapter draws from a paper I first delivered at the Boston College Political Science Department, under the co-sponsorship of the MIT Benjamin Franklin Project, on April 5, 2019. I wish to thank Susan Shell and Bernhardt Trout for their kind invitation. I am also grateful to Lynn Phalen, Charlotte Sieber-Gasser, Giovanni Giorgini, Raimondo Cubeddu, Ajume Wingo, Rory Schacter, and Antonio Masala for reading and commenting on previous versions of the essay.
 
2
Bobbio (2005), pp. 1, 25.
 
3
Aristotle, Politics, 1265b 26–28; 1279a 32-1279b 10; 1291b 14-1292a 38.
 
4
Sartori (2000), pp. 195–212.
 
5
Strauss (1995a); Bobbio (2005), p. 25.
 
6
Matteucci (1990), p. 567.
 
7
Manent (1987); Parmentier (2008); Malcolm (2016).
 
8
Strauss (1953), pp. 181–182. Cf. Strauss (1995b), pp. 101–102.
 
9
Hobbes, Leviathan, XIV.
 
10
Sartori (2000), p. 198.
 
11
Bobbio (2005), p. 25.
 
12
Herodotus, Histories, III, 80–82.
 
13
Plato, Republic, 557a, 558c, 561e, 562a; Aristotle, Politics, 1291b 30–38; 1301b 26-1302a 15; 1317a 40-1317b 17; 1318a 3-10. Cf. Bobbio (2005), pp. 31–32.
 
14
Bobbio (1990), p. 288.
 
15
Sinclair (2010), p. 33. See Bobbio (2009), pp. 19–24.
 
16
Plato, Republic, 557b, 560e–561a, 561d, 562b. Cf. Aristotle, Politics, 1291b 34–35; 1317a 40-1317b 2.
 
17
Herodotus, Histories, III, 80, 2. See Carillo (2003), pp. 15, 27–28.
 
18
Plato, Republic, 557b.
 
19
Vlastos (1993), p. 103; Hansen (1999), p. 81.
 
20
Vlastos (1993), p. 103; Hansen (1999), p. 81.
 
21
Rousseau, The Social Contract, II, 6.
 
22
Bobbio (1990), p. 291.
 
23
Carillo (2003), pp. 29, 31–34, 44, 46.
 
24
Schmitt (1996), p. 74.
 
25
Constant (1988).
 
26
Constant (1988), p. 316.
 
27
Constant (1988), p. 317.
 
28
Constant (1988), p. 316.
 
29
Constant (1988), p. 317.
 
30
De Luca (1993), pp. 79–81.
 
31
Constant (1988), p. 326.
 
32
Rousseau, The Social Contract, III, 15.
 
33
Constant (1988), p. 326.
 
34
de Tocqueville (2002), p. 664.
 
35
Alexis de Tocqueville, “Letter to Louis de Kergorley, November 12, 1836,” quoted in Mansfield and Winthrop (2002), p. xxx.
 
36
de Tocqueville (2002), p. 664.
 
37
Alexis de Tocqueville, “Letter to Eugène Stoeffels, July 24, 1836,” quoted in Mansfield (2016), p. 250 (n. 1). Cf. Mansfield (2010), p. 3; Matteucci (1990), p. 578.
 
38
de Tocqueville (2002), pp. 482–484, 675.
 
39
de Tocqueville (2002), pp. 646–650, 666, 670.
 
40
Croce (1943), pp. 288–289, English translation quoted in Sartori (1987), p. 384. Cf. Strauss (1995a), pp. 5, 10.
 
41
Sartori (1987), p. 373. Cf. Hayek (1980), p. 31, and Bobbio (2005), pp. 55–56.
 
42
Sartori (1987), p. 373.
 
43
Sartori (1987), p. 372. Cf. Schmitt (1996), p. 30.
 
44
Sartori (1987), p. 372.
 
45
Sartori (2000), p. 205 (my translation); cf. Sartori (1987), pp. 372–373. See Bobbio (1996a).
 
46
Sartori (1987), p. 373.
 
47
Bobbio (1996b); Cofrancesco (2003), p. 79.
 
48
Cofrancesco (2003), pp. 6–7, 12–13; cf. Mansfield (1978).
 
49
Schmitt (1988), pp. 16–17.
 
50
Cf. Strauss (1995a), p. 230; Forti (2001), pp. 11–12.
 
51
Schmitt (1996), p. 69.
 
52
Schmitt (1996), p. 22.
 
53
Schmitt (1996), p. 23.
 
54
Manin (1997).
 
55
See Mansfield and Winthrop (2002), p. xxvii.
 
56
de Tocqueville (2002), p. 55.
 
57
Manin (1997), p. 1.
 
58
Manin (1997), pp. 82, 174 (n. 21).
 
59
Hamilton et al. (2001), p. 46. Cf. Manin (1997), p. 2.
 
60
Hamilton et al. (2001), p. 295. Cf. Manin (1997), p. 116.
 
61
Hamilton et al. (2001), p. 46. Manin (1997), p. 117.
 
62
Manin (1997), p. 117.
 
63
Manin (1997), p. 238; cf. Mansfield (1978), pp. 8–9.
 
65
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 4.
 
66
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 9.
 
67
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 2.
 
68
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 1.
 
69
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 6.
 
70
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 7.
 
71
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 9.
 
72
Kriesi et al. (2006).
 
73
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 9.
 
74
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 10.
 
75
Ibid.
 
76
Habermas (2001).
 
77
Habermas (2001), p. 62.
 
78
Ibid.
 
79
Habermas (2001), p. 77.
 
80
Cf. ibid. with Dahrendorf (1995), p. 8.
 
81
See Habermas (2001), p. 80.
 
82
Crouch (2019).
 
83
Crouch (2004).
 
84
Crouch (2004), p. 29.
 
85
Crouch (2019), p. 6.
 
86
Ibid.
 
87
Ibid.
 
88
Crouch (2019), p. 25.
 
89
See Habermas (2001), p. 181 (n. 44).
 
90
Crouch (2017).
 
91
Crouch (2017), p. 10.
 
92
Crouch (2017), p. 11.
 
93
Cf. Masala (2017), pp. 7, 10.
 
94
See Went (2002), pp. 10–14; Rodrik (2011), pp. 9, 25. Cf. Hayek (1980), pp. 4–5, 7, 9, 11–12, and Cubeddu (2019).
 
95
Constant (1988), p. 324.
 
96
Constant (1988), pp. 324–325.
 
97
See how emphatically Constant states those property rights when he, describing modern liberty, defends, inter alia, the right of each person to “dispose of property, and even to abuse it.” (Constant 1988, p. 311).
 
98
Constant (1988), p. 325.
 
99
Ibid.
 
100
Habermas (2001), p. 78.
 
101
Cf. Strauss (1988), p. 49.
 
102
Cf. McGrew (1997), p. 12, quoted in Habermas (2001), p. 61.
 
103
Cf. Taguieff (2012).
 
104
Taguieff (2012), p. 107 (my translation).
 
105
Dahrendorf (1995), p. 4.
 
Literature
go back to reference Bobbio N (1990) Democrazia. In: Bobbio N, Matteucci N, Pasquino G (eds) Dizionario di politica. TEA, Milano, pp 287–297 Bobbio N (1990) Democrazia. In: Bobbio N, Matteucci N, Pasquino G (eds) Dizionario di politica. TEA, Milano, pp 287–297
go back to reference Bobbio N (1996a) Left and right. The significance of a political distinction. Polity Press, Cambridge Bobbio N (1996a) Left and right. The significance of a political distinction. Polity Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Bobbio N (1996b) The age of rights. Polity Press, Cambridge Bobbio N (1996b) The age of rights. Polity Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Bobbio N (2005) Liberalism and democracy. Verso, London Bobbio N (2005) Liberalism and democracy. Verso, London
go back to reference Bobbio N (2009) Eguaglianza e libertà. Einaudi, Torino Bobbio N (2009) Eguaglianza e libertà. Einaudi, Torino
go back to reference Bobbio N, Matteucci N, Pasquino G (eds) (1990) Dizionario di politica. TEA, Milano Bobbio N, Matteucci N, Pasquino G (eds) (1990) Dizionario di politica. TEA, Milano
go back to reference Carillo G (2003) Katechein. Uno studio sulla democrazia antica. Editoriale Scientifica, Napoli Carillo G (2003) Katechein. Uno studio sulla democrazia antica. Editoriale Scientifica, Napoli
go back to reference Cofrancesco D (2003) La democrazia liberale (e le altre). Rubbettino, Soveria Mannelli Cofrancesco D (2003) La democrazia liberale (e le altre). Rubbettino, Soveria Mannelli
go back to reference Constant B (1988) The liberty of the ancients compared with that of the moderns. In: Constant B, Fontana B (ed) Political writings. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 309–328 Constant B (1988) The liberty of the ancients compared with that of the moderns. In: Constant B, Fontana B (ed) Political writings. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 309–328
go back to reference Croce B (1943) Etica e politica. Laterza, Bari Croce B (1943) Etica e politica. Laterza, Bari
go back to reference Crouch C (2004) Post-democracy. Polity Press, Cambridge Crouch C (2004) Post-democracy. Polity Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Crouch C (2017) Can neoliberalism be saved from itself? Social Europe Edition, London Crouch C (2017) Can neoliberalism be saved from itself? Social Europe Edition, London
go back to reference Crouch C (2019) The globalization backlash. Polity Press, Cambridge Crouch C (2019) The globalization backlash. Polity Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Cubeddu R (2019) L’individualismo secondo Hayek. In: Individualismo e religione nella Scuola Austriaca. Edizioni ETS, Pisa, pp 43–118 Cubeddu R (2019) L’individualismo secondo Hayek. In: Individualismo e religione nella Scuola Austriaca. Edizioni ETS, Pisa, pp 43–118
go back to reference De Luca S (1993) Il pensiero politico di Constant. Roma-Bari, Laterza De Luca S (1993) Il pensiero politico di Constant. Roma-Bari, Laterza
go back to reference de Tocqueville A (2002) Mansfield HC, Winthrop D (eds) Democracy in America. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago de Tocqueville A (2002) Mansfield HC, Winthrop D (eds) Democracy in America. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
go back to reference Forti S (2001) Il totalitarismo. Laterza, Roma-Bari Forti S (2001) Il totalitarismo. Laterza, Roma-Bari
go back to reference Habermas J (2001) The post-national constellation and the future of democracy. In: Habermas J, Pensky M (ed) The post-national constellation. Political essays. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 58–112 Habermas J (2001) The post-national constellation and the future of democracy. In: Habermas J, Pensky M (ed) The post-national constellation. Political essays. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 58–112
go back to reference Hamilton A, Jay J, Madison J (2001) Carey GW, McClellan J (eds) The federalist, The Gideon Edition. Liberty Fund, Indianapolis Hamilton A, Jay J, Madison J (2001) Carey GW, McClellan J (eds) The federalist, The Gideon Edition. Liberty Fund, Indianapolis
go back to reference Hansen MH (1999) The Athenian democracy in the age of Demosthenes: structure, principles and ideology. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman Hansen MH (1999) The Athenian democracy in the age of Demosthenes: structure, principles and ideology. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman
go back to reference Hayek FA (1980) Individualism and economic order. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago Hayek FA (1980) Individualism and economic order. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
go back to reference Kriesi H, Grande E, Lachat R, Dolezal M, Bornschier S, Frey T (2006) Globalization and the transformation of the national political space: six European countries compared. Eur J Polit Res 45: 921–956CrossRef Kriesi H, Grande E, Lachat R, Dolezal M, Bornschier S, Frey T (2006) Globalization and the transformation of the national political space: six European countries compared. Eur J Polit Res 45: 921–956CrossRef
go back to reference Manent P (1987) Histoire intellectuelle du libéralisme: Dix leçons. Calmann-Lévy, Paris Manent P (1987) Histoire intellectuelle du libéralisme: Dix leçons. Calmann-Lévy, Paris
go back to reference Manin B (1997) The principles of representative government. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRef Manin B (1997) The principles of representative government. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRef
go back to reference Mansfield HC (1978) Liberal democracy as a mixed regime. In: The spirit of liberalism. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp 1–15CrossRef Mansfield HC (1978) Liberal democracy as a mixed regime. In: The spirit of liberalism. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, pp 1–15CrossRef
go back to reference Mansfield HC (2010) Tocqueville: a very short introduction. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRef Mansfield HC (2010) Tocqueville: a very short introduction. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRef
go back to reference Mansfield HC (2016) Tocqueville on religion and liberty. Am Polit Thought A J Ideas Inst Cult 5: 250–276CrossRef Mansfield HC (2016) Tocqueville on religion and liberty. Am Polit Thought A J Ideas Inst Cult 5: 250–276CrossRef
go back to reference Mansfield HC, Winthrop D (2002) Editors’ Introduction. In: de Tocqueville A (2002) Mansfield HC, Winthrop D (eds), Democracy in America. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp xvii–lxxxvi Mansfield HC, Winthrop D (2002) Editors’ Introduction. In: de Tocqueville A (2002) Mansfield HC, Winthrop D (eds), Democracy in America. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp xvii–lxxxvi
go back to reference Masala A (2017) Stato, società e libertà. Dal liberalismo al neoliberalismo. Soveria Mannelli, Rubbettino Masala A (2017) Stato, società e libertà. Dal liberalismo al neoliberalismo. Soveria Mannelli, Rubbettino
go back to reference Matteucci N (1990) Liberalismo. In: Bobbio N, Matteucci N, Pasquino G (eds) Dizionario di politica. TEA, Milano, pp 566–583 Matteucci N (1990) Liberalismo. In: Bobbio N, Matteucci N, Pasquino G (eds) Dizionario di politica. TEA, Milano, pp 566–583
go back to reference McGrew A (1997) Globalization and territorial democracy. In: McGrew A (ed) The transformation of democracy? Polity Press, Cambridge McGrew A (1997) Globalization and territorial democracy. In: McGrew A (ed) The transformation of democracy? Polity Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Parmentier M (2008) Hobbes et le libéralisme. Cahiers Philosophiques 4(116): 87–104CrossRef Parmentier M (2008) Hobbes et le libéralisme. Cahiers Philosophiques 4(116): 87–104CrossRef
go back to reference Rodrik D (2011) The globalization paradox: democracy and the future of the world economy. W.W. Norton & Co., New York Rodrik D (2011) The globalization paradox: democracy and the future of the world economy. W.W. Norton & Co., New York
go back to reference Sartori G (1987) The theory of democracy revisited. Chatham House Publishers, Chatham, NJ Sartori G (1987) The theory of democracy revisited. Chatham House Publishers, Chatham, NJ
go back to reference Sartori G (2000) Democrazia: cosa è. BUR, Milano Sartori G (2000) Democrazia: cosa è. BUR, Milano
go back to reference Schmitt C (1988) The crisis of parliamentary democracy. The MIT Press, Cambridge Schmitt C (1988) The crisis of parliamentary democracy. The MIT Press, Cambridge
go back to reference Schmitt C (1996) The concept of the political. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago Schmitt C (1996) The concept of the political. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
go back to reference Sinclair TA (2010) A history of Greek political thought. Routledge, New York Sinclair TA (2010) A history of Greek political thought. Routledge, New York
go back to reference Strauss L (1953) Natural right and history. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago Strauss L (1953) Natural right and history. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
go back to reference Strauss L (1988) What is political philosophy? And other studies. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago Strauss L (1988) What is political philosophy? And other studies. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
go back to reference Strauss L (1995a) Liberalism ancient and modern. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago Strauss L (1995a) Liberalism ancient and modern. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
go back to reference Strauss L (1995b) Notes on Carl Schmitt, the concept of the political. In: Meier H, Carl Schmitt and Leo Strauss. The hidden dialogue. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 89–119 Strauss L (1995b) Notes on Carl Schmitt, the concept of the political. In: Meier H, Carl Schmitt and Leo Strauss. The hidden dialogue. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 89–119
go back to reference Vlastos G (1993) Studies in Greek philosophy: the Presocratics. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ Vlastos G (1993) Studies in Greek philosophy: the Presocratics. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
go back to reference Went R (2002) The enigma of globalization: a journey to a new stage of capitalism. Routledge, London and New YorkCrossRef Went R (2002) The enigma of globalization: a journey to a new stage of capitalism. Routledge, London and New YorkCrossRef
Metadata
Title
An Untenable Compromise? Liberal Democracy Between Populism and Globalization
Author
Alberto Ghibellini
Copyright Year
2021
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-69154-7_2

Premium Partner