Skip to main content
Top

2021 | OriginalPaper | Chapter

3. Carbonwashing: ESG Data Greenwashing in a Post-Paris World

Authors : Soh Young In, Kim Schumacher

Published in: Settling Climate Accounts

Publisher: Springer International Publishing

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

Despite the increased attention and capital incentives around corporate sustainability, the development of sustainability reporting standards and monitoring systems has been progressing at a slow pace. As a result, companies have misaligned incentives to deliberately or selectively communicate information not matched with actual environmental impacts or make largely unsubstantiated promises around future ambitions. These incidents are broadly called “greenwashing,” but there is no clear consensus on its definition and taxonomy. We pay particular attention to the threat of greenwashing concerning carbon emission reductions by coining a new term, “carbonwashing.” Since carbon mitigation is the universal goal, the corporate carbon performance data supply chain is relatively more advanced than that of the entire sustainability data landscape. Nonetheless, the threat of carbonwashing persists, even far more severe than general greenwashing due to the financial values attached to corporate carbon performance. This chapter contextualizes sustainable finance-related carbonwashing via an outline of the communication as well as the measurement, reporting, and verification (MRV) of carbon emission mitigation performance.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 390 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe




 

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Literature
go back to reference Addicot, E., Badahdah, A., Elder, L., and Tan, W. 2019. Internal Carbon Pricing: Policy Framework and Case Studies. New Haven, CT: Yale Center for Business and the Environment. Addicot, E., Badahdah, A., Elder, L., and Tan, W. 2019. Internal Carbon Pricing: Policy Framework and Case Studies. New Haven, CT: Yale Center for Business and the Environment.
go back to reference Allen, H., A. Cury, T. Gaston, C. Graf, H. Wakley, and M. Willis. 2019. What Does Better Peer Review Look Like? Underlying Principles and Recommendations for Better Practice. Learned Publishing 32 (2): 163–175.CrossRef Allen, H., A. Cury, T. Gaston, C. Graf, H. Wakley, and M. Willis. 2019. What Does Better Peer Review Look Like? Underlying Principles and Recommendations for Better Practice. Learned Publishing 32 (2): 163–175.CrossRef
go back to reference Andersson, M., P. Bolton, and F. Samama. 2016. Hedging Climate Risk. Financial Analysts Journal 72 (3): 13–32.CrossRef Andersson, M., P. Bolton, and F. Samama. 2016. Hedging Climate Risk. Financial Analysts Journal 72 (3): 13–32.CrossRef
go back to reference Andrew, J., and C. Cortese. 2011. Accounting for Climate Change and the Self-regulation of Carbon Disclosures. Accounting Forum 35 (3): 130–138.CrossRef Andrew, J., and C. Cortese. 2011. Accounting for Climate Change and the Self-regulation of Carbon Disclosures. Accounting Forum 35 (3): 130–138.CrossRef
go back to reference Barzuza, M., Q. Curtis, and D. H. Webber. 2020. Shareholder Value(s): Index Fund ESG Activism and the New Millennial Corporate Governance. Available at SSRN: 3439516. Barzuza, M., Q. Curtis, and D. H. Webber. 2020. Shareholder Value(s): Index Fund ESG Activism and the New Millennial Corporate Governance. Available at SSRN: 3439516.
go back to reference Bento, N., and G. Gianfrate. 2020. Determinants of Internal Carbon Pricing. Energy Policy, 143, 111499. Bento, N., and G. Gianfrate. 2020. Determinants of Internal Carbon Pricing. Energy Policy, 143, 111499.
go back to reference Benz, L., A. Jacob, S. Paulus, and M. Wilkens. 2020. Herds on Green Meadows: The Decarbonization of Institutional Portfolios. Journal of Asset Management 21 (1): 13–31.CrossRef Benz, L., A. Jacob, S. Paulus, and M. Wilkens. 2020. Herds on Green Meadows: The Decarbonization of Institutional Portfolios. Journal of Asset Management 21 (1): 13–31.CrossRef
go back to reference Berg, F., J. Kölbel, and R. Rigobon. 2020. Aggregate Confusion: The Divergence of ESG Ratings. Available at SSRN: 3438533. Berg, F., J. Kölbel, and R. Rigobon. 2020. Aggregate Confusion: The Divergence of ESG Ratings. Available at SSRN: 3438533.
go back to reference Bjørn, A., S. Lloyd, and D. Matthews. 2021. From the Paris Agreement to Corporate Climate Commitments: Evaluation of Seven Methods for Setting “Science-based” Emission Targets. Environmental Research Letters, 16 (054019). Bjørn, A., S. Lloyd, and D. Matthews. 2021. From the Paris Agreement to Corporate Climate Commitments: Evaluation of Seven Methods for Setting “Science-based” Emission Targets. Environmental Research Letters, 16 (054019).
go back to reference Black, R., K. Cullen, B. Fay, T. Hale, J. Lang, S. Mahmood, and S. Smith. 2021. Taking Stock: A global assessment of net zero targets. Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit and Oxford Net Zero. Black, R., K. Cullen, B. Fay, T. Hale, J. Lang, S. Mahmood, and S. Smith. 2021. Taking Stock: A global assessment of net zero targets. Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit and Oxford Net Zero.
go back to reference Blanco, C., F. Caro, and C.J. Corbett. 2016. The state of supply chain carbon footprinting: Analysis of CDP disclosures by US firms. Journal of Clearner Production 135: 1189–1197.CrossRef Blanco, C., F. Caro, and C.J. Corbett. 2016. The state of supply chain carbon footprinting: Analysis of CDP disclosures by US firms. Journal of Clearner Production 135: 1189–1197.CrossRef
go back to reference Bowen, F., and J. Aragon-Correa. 2014. Greenwashing in corporate environmentalism research and practice: The importance of what we say and do. Organization & Environment 27 (2): 107–112.CrossRef Bowen, F., and J. Aragon-Correa. 2014. Greenwashing in corporate environmentalism research and practice: The importance of what we say and do. Organization & Environment 27 (2): 107–112.CrossRef
go back to reference Carbon Disclosure Project. 2021. Technical Note on Science-based Targets: CDP Climate Change Questionnaire. Carbon Disclosure Projects. Carbon Disclosure Project. 2021. Technical Note on Science-based Targets: CDP Climate Change Questionnaire. Carbon Disclosure Projects.
go back to reference Chasan, E. 2020. Spending on ESG Data Seen Rising to $1 Billion Amid Asset Growth. Bloomberg Green. Chasan, E. 2020. Spending on ESG Data Seen Rising to $1 Billion Amid Asset Growth. Bloomberg Green.
go back to reference Chatterji, A.K., R. Durand, D.I. Levine, and S. Touboul. 2016. Do Ratings of Firms Converge? Implications for Managers, Investors and Strategy Researchers. Strategic Management Journal 37 (8): 1597–1614.CrossRef Chatterji, A.K., R. Durand, D.I. Levine, and S. Touboul. 2016. Do Ratings of Firms Converge? Implications for Managers, Investors and Strategy Researchers. Strategic Management Journal 37 (8): 1597–1614.CrossRef
go back to reference Chatterji, A.K., D.I. Levine, and M.W. Toffel. 2009. How Well Do Social Ratings Actually Measure Corporate Social Responsibility? Journal of Economics & Management Strategy 18 (1): 125–169.CrossRef Chatterji, A.K., D.I. Levine, and M.W. Toffel. 2009. How Well Do Social Ratings Actually Measure Corporate Social Responsibility? Journal of Economics & Management Strategy 18 (1): 125–169.CrossRef
go back to reference Climate Action 100+ . 2021. Climate Action 100+ Issues Its First-Ever Net Zero Company Benchmark of the World’s Largest Corporate Emitters. Climate Action 100+ . Climate Action 100+ . 2021. Climate Action 100+ Issues Its First-Ever Net Zero Company Benchmark of the World’s Largest Corporate Emitters. Climate Action 100+ .
go back to reference Delmas, M.A., D. Etzion, and N. Nairn-Birch. 2013. Triangulating Environmental Performance: What Do Corporate Social Responsibility Ratings Really Capture? Academy of Management Perspectives 27 (3): 255–267.CrossRef Delmas, M.A., D. Etzion, and N. Nairn-Birch. 2013. Triangulating Environmental Performance: What Do Corporate Social Responsibility Ratings Really Capture? Academy of Management Perspectives 27 (3): 255–267.CrossRef
go back to reference Deloitte. 2020. Advancing Environmental, Social, and Governance Investing. London, UK: Deloitte. Deloitte. 2020. Advancing Environmental, Social, and Governance Investing. London, UK: Deloitte.
go back to reference Dragomir, V.D. 2012. The Disclosure of Industrial Greenhouse Gas Emissions: A Critical Assessment of Corporate Sustainability Reports. Journal of Cleaner Production 29–30: 222–237.CrossRef Dragomir, V.D. 2012. The Disclosure of Industrial Greenhouse Gas Emissions: A Critical Assessment of Corporate Sustainability Reports. Journal of Cleaner Production 29–30: 222–237.CrossRef
go back to reference Eccles, R.G., and M.P. Krzus. 2018. Why Companies Should Report Financial Risks from Climate Change. MIT Sloan Management Review 59 (3). Eccles, R.G., and M.P. Krzus. 2018. Why Companies Should Report Financial Risks from Climate Change. MIT Sloan Management Review 59 (3).
go back to reference ESMA. 2020. Sustainable Financial Markets: Translating Changing Risks and Investor Preferences into Regulatory Action. European Financial Forum 2020. Dublin: European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA). ESMA. 2020. Sustainable Financial Markets: Translating Changing Risks and Investor Preferences into Regulatory Action. European Financial Forum 2020. Dublin: European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA).
go back to reference European Commission. 2020a. Development of Tools and Mechanisms for the Integration of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Factors into the EU Banking Prudential Framework and into Banks' Business Strategies and Investment Policies. Brussels, Belgium: European Commission. European Commission. 2020a. Development of Tools and Mechanisms for the Integration of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Factors into the EU Banking Prudential Framework and into Banks' Business Strategies and Investment Policies. Brussels, Belgium: European Commission.
go back to reference European Commission. 2020b. Renewed Sustainable Finance Strategy and Implementation of the Action Plan on Financing Sustainable Growth. Brussels, Belgium: European Commission. European Commission. 2020b. Renewed Sustainable Finance Strategy and Implementation of the Action Plan on Financing Sustainable Growth. Brussels, Belgium: European Commission.
go back to reference Farand, C. 2021. “Science-based” Corporate Climate Targets Are No such Thing, Says Former Advisor. Climate Home News. Farand, C. 2021. “Science-based” Corporate Climate Targets Are No such Thing, Says Former Advisor. Climate Home News.
go back to reference Flammer, C. 2020. Green Bonds: Effectiveness and Implications for Public Policy. Environmental and Energy Policy and the Economy 1: 95–128.CrossRef Flammer, C. 2020. Green Bonds: Effectiveness and Implications for Public Policy. Environmental and Energy Policy and the Economy 1: 95–128.CrossRef
go back to reference Guo, T., G. Zha, C.L. Lee, and Q. Tang. 2020. Does Corporate Green Ranking Reflect Carbon-mitigation Performance? Journal of Cleaner Production 227: 123601. Guo, T., G. Zha, C.L. Lee, and Q. Tang. 2020. Does Corporate Green Ranking Reflect Carbon-mitigation Performance? Journal of Cleaner Production 227: 123601.
go back to reference In, S.Y., D. Rook, and A. Monk. 2019. Integrating Alternative Data (Also Known as ESG Data) in Investment Decision Making. Global Economic Review 48 (3): 237–260.CrossRef In, S.Y., D. Rook, and A. Monk. 2019. Integrating Alternative Data (Also Known as ESG Data) in Investment Decision Making. Global Economic Review 48 (3): 237–260.CrossRef
go back to reference In, S.Y., K.Y. Park, and A.H. Monk. 2019. Is ‘Being Green’ Rewarded in the Market?: An Empirical Investigation of Decarbonization and Stock Returns. Available at SSRN: 3020304. In, S.Y., K.Y. Park, and A.H. Monk. 2019. Is ‘Being Green’ Rewarded in the Market?: An Empirical Investigation of Decarbonization and Stock Returns. Available at SSRN: 3020304.
go back to reference In, S.Y., K.Y. Park, and R.G. Eccles. 2021. What Does Carbon Data Tell You (or Not)? Available at SSRN: 3754098. In, S.Y., K.Y. Park, and R.G. Eccles. 2021. What Does Carbon Data Tell You (or Not)? Available at SSRN: 3754098.
go back to reference Jahnke, P. 2019. Holders of Last Resort: The Role of Index Funds and Index Providers in Divestment and Climate Change. Available at SSRN: 3314906. Jahnke, P. 2019. Holders of Last Resort: The Role of Index Funds and Index Providers in Divestment and Climate Change. Available at SSRN: 3314906.
go back to reference Kalesnik, V., M. Wilkens, and J. Zink. 2020. Green Data or Greenwashing? Do Corporate Carbon Emissions Data Enable Investors to Mitigate Climate Change? Kalesnik, V., M. Wilkens, and J. Zink. 2020. Green Data or Greenwashing? Do Corporate Carbon Emissions Data Enable Investors to Mitigate Climate Change?
go back to reference Kolk, A., D. Levy, and J. Pinske. 2008. Corporate Responses in an Emerging Climate Regime: The Institutionalization and Commensuration of Carbon Disclosure. European Accounting Review 17 (4): 719–745.CrossRef Kolk, A., D. Levy, and J. Pinske. 2008. Corporate Responses in an Emerging Climate Regime: The Institutionalization and Commensuration of Carbon Disclosure. European Accounting Review 17 (4): 719–745.CrossRef
go back to reference Li, J., Z.A. Haider, X. Jin, and W. Yuan. 2019. Corporate Controversy, Social Responsibility and Market Performance: International Evidence. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 60: 1–18.CrossRef Li, J., Z.A. Haider, X. Jin, and W. Yuan. 2019. Corporate Controversy, Social Responsibility and Market Performance: International Evidence. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 60: 1–18.CrossRef
go back to reference Matisoff, D.C. 2013. Different Rays of Sunlight: Understanding Information Disclosure and Carbon Transparency. Energy Policy 55: 579–592.CrossRef Matisoff, D.C. 2013. Different Rays of Sunlight: Understanding Information Disclosure and Carbon Transparency. Energy Policy 55: 579–592.CrossRef
go back to reference McNutt, M., M. Bradford, J. Drazen, B. Hanson, B. Howard, K. Jamieson, and S. Swaminathan. 2018. Transparency in Authors’ Contributions and Responsibilities to Promote Integrity in Scientific Publication. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 115 (11): 2557–2560. McNutt, M., M. Bradford, J. Drazen, B. Hanson, B. Howard, K. Jamieson, and S. Swaminathan. 2018. Transparency in Authors’ Contributions and Responsibilities to Promote Integrity in Scientific Publication. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 115 (11): 2557–2560.
go back to reference Mercereau, B., G. Neveux, J.P. Sertã, B. Marechal, and G. Tonolo. 2020. Fighting Climate Change as a Global Equity Investor. Journal of Asset Management 21: 70–83.CrossRef Mercereau, B., G. Neveux, J.P. Sertã, B. Marechal, and G. Tonolo. 2020. Fighting Climate Change as a Global Equity Investor. Journal of Asset Management 21: 70–83.CrossRef
go back to reference Monasterolo, I., S. Battison, A.C. Janetos, and Z. Zheng. 2017. Vulnerable Yet Relevant: The Two Dimensions of Climate-related Financial Disclosure. Climatic Change 145: 495–507.CrossRef Monasterolo, I., S. Battison, A.C. Janetos, and Z. Zheng. 2017. Vulnerable Yet Relevant: The Two Dimensions of Climate-related Financial Disclosure. Climatic Change 145: 495–507.CrossRef
go back to reference Newell, P. 2020. The Business of Rapid Transition. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 1–14. Newell, P. 2020. The Business of Rapid Transition. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 1–14.
go back to reference Schumacher, K. 2020a. The Shape of Green Fixed Income Investing to Come. The Journal of Environmental Investing 10 (1): 5–29. Schumacher, K. 2020a. The Shape of Green Fixed Income Investing to Come. The Journal of Environmental Investing 10 (1): 5–29.
go back to reference Schumacher, K. 2020b. 'Competence Greenwashing’ Could Be the Next Risk for the ESG Industry. Responsible Investor. Schumacher, K. 2020b. 'Competence Greenwashing’ Could Be the Next Risk for the ESG Industry. Responsible Investor.
go back to reference Schumacher, K., Y. Baek, and S. Nishikizawa. 2021. The Impact of Endogenous Firm-level Sustainability Data on ESG Scores and Ratings. Tokyo, Japan: Tokyo Institute of Technology. Schumacher, K., Y. Baek, and S. Nishikizawa. 2021. The Impact of Endogenous Firm-level Sustainability Data on ESG Scores and Ratings. Tokyo, Japan: Tokyo Institute of Technology.
go back to reference Schumacher, K., H. Chenet, and U. Volz. 2020. Sustainable Finance in Japan. Journal of Sustainable Finance and Investment 10 (2): 213–246.CrossRef Schumacher, K., H. Chenet, and U. Volz. 2020. Sustainable Finance in Japan. Journal of Sustainable Finance and Investment 10 (2): 213–246.CrossRef
go back to reference Science-Based Targets Initiative. 2020. Science-Based Target Setting Manual Version 4.1 . Science-Based Targets Initiative. Science-Based Targets Initiative. 2020. Science-Based Target Setting Manual Version 4.1 . Science-Based Targets Initiative.
go back to reference Science-Based Targets Initiative. 2021a. From Ambition to Impact: How Companies Are Cutting Emissions at Scale with Science-based Targets. Science-Based Targets Initiative. Science-Based Targets Initiative. 2021a. From Ambition to Impact: How Companies Are Cutting Emissions at Scale with Science-based Targets. Science-Based Targets Initiative.
go back to reference Science-Based Targets Initiative. 2021b. SBTi Corporate Manual. Science-Based Targets Initiative. Science-Based Targets Initiative. 2021b. SBTi Corporate Manual. Science-Based Targets Initiative.
go back to reference Stanny, E. 2018. Reliability and Comparability of GHG Disclosures to the CDP by US Electric Utilities. Social and Environmental Accountability Journal 38 (2): 111–130.CrossRef Stanny, E. 2018. Reliability and Comparability of GHG Disclosures to the CDP by US Electric Utilities. Social and Environmental Accountability Journal 38 (2): 111–130.CrossRef
go back to reference Tolliver, C., A.R. Keeley, and S. Managi. 2019. Green Bonds for the Paris Agreement and Sustainable Development Goals. Environmental Research Letters 14 (6). Tolliver, C., A.R. Keeley, and S. Managi. 2019. Green Bonds for the Paris Agreement and Sustainable Development Goals. Environmental Research Letters 14 (6).
go back to reference Walenta, J. 2020. Climate Risk Assessments and Science-based Targets: A Review of Emerging Private Sector Climate Action Tools. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change 11 (2): 1–12. Walenta, J. 2020. Climate Risk Assessments and Science-based Targets: A Review of Emerging Private Sector Climate Action Tools. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change 11 (2): 1–12.
Metadata
Title
Carbonwashing: ESG Data Greenwashing in a Post-Paris World
Authors
Soh Young In
Kim Schumacher
Copyright Year
2021
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-83650-4_3