The experimental results of the study focused on the effect of drying processes of modified air drying and warm air-steam mixture drying of pine and beech wood on the size of sawdust particles created in cutting using PRW-15M sash gang saw, are presented in the paper. Particle size analysis of dry sawdust was performed using two methods—sieving method and laser diffraction analysis. The results showed that the drying process did not affect the general particle size distribution of the sawdust, but the content of very fine dust particles in beech wood sawdust is many times higher when the beech wood was dried in the warm air-steam mixture drying process and sawn at a feed per tooth of 0.105 mm.
Notes
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations
1 Introduction
Industries of material processing and the use of natural waste to produce energy are the main sources of dust emissions (Wilnhammer et al. 2017). Dust produced during sharpening, sanding or polishing surfaces is the most harmful to human health (Tong et al. 2018). The properties of dust depend primarily on the species of the raw material that was processed. Wood dust is particularly harmful, especially the dust of hardwood species such as oak and beech, which are considered as carcinogenic. Beech wood is one of the most dangerous materials used in the production of furniture and other wood products (Baran and Teul 2007; Jacobsen et al. 2010). This is confirmed by the International Agency for Research on Cancer, which classified wood dust to group 1, i.e. to substances with proven carcinogenic effect for humans (IARC 2012). Dust particles smaller than < 10 µm are considered to be particularly harmful to the respiratory system. Even particles smaller than 100 µm remain dispersed in the air, and can easily settle in the eyes, nose, skin and even penetrate the respiratory system. Epidemiological studies have shown a causal relationship between the incidence of nasal and paranasal sinuses cancers and wood dust exposure of woodworking industry employees (Pakulska et al. 2017). Therefore, air dustiness resulting from mechanical wood processing is one of the most important problems occurring in woodworking industry.
In addition to the type and dimensions of the material, the amount of waste generated and the content of fine dust particles is also influenced by the processing method, type of tool, the sharpness of cutting tools and technological parameters of the process, i.e. feed per tooth (Dzurenda and Kučerka 2005; Dzurenda et al. 2006; Očkajová et al. 2006, 2014, 2016; Hlásková et al. 2015, 2016; Mračková et al. 2016; Pałubicki and Rogoziński 2016). Bejlo-Lučič et al. (2005) compared the particle sizes resulting from the processing of wood and wood-based materials on seven different machines: a belt sander, manual belt sander, band saw, drill, circular saw, multi-circular saw and a four-side planer. By far the largest amount of harmful dust < 100 µm is generated on sanding workstations compared to the results of other woodworking processes. Wood dust containing more than 90% of the particles with size ≤ 80 µm is generated when grinding hardwood. Therefore, it is considered as one of the most dangerous to health and safety (Očkajová et al. 2018). CNC milling is another method of woodworking associated with the risk of dust. The milling process on the CNC machining center produces dust particles with size < 125 µm in an amount of 1.4% for beech wood, 1.95% for oak and 3.8% for softwood, while dust particles < 32 µm have not been determined by the sieve analysis (Kminiak and Banski 2019).
Advertisement
Recently, much attention has been paid to studies on the influence of high temperature on the formation of fine dust during the machining of wood that has been thermally modified or dried. Kminiak and Dzurenda (2019) investigated the effect of heat treatment on changing the particle size of maple wood chips created in milling. Size analysis showed that more than 2/3 of the chips created were a fraction with a particle size above 1 mm. Inhalable dust particles smaller than 125 µm did not exceed 2.5%. Kučerka and Očkajová (2018) have done thermal modification of oak and spruce wood in accordance with ThermoWood technology. From the analysis of the dust obtained as a result of sanding modified wood, they showed that the proportion of dust fraction ≤ 80 µm obtained in these experiments is comparable with the results of natural wood (Očkajová and Kučerka 2017; Dzurenda and Očkajová 2003). On this basis, it was concluded that the content of fine dust fraction decreases as the temperature increases. This means that the thermal treatment of wood does not have negative impact on the dustiness in the working environment.
On the other hand, Dzurenda et al. (2010) and Dzurenda and Orlowski (2011) indicated that sawdust formed during sawing of thermally modified oak and ash wood on the PRW-15M sash gang sawing machine using two rates of feed per tooth, has the fraction of particles in the size range 32–125 µm slightly smaller than the unmodified oak and ash wood. Similar dependencies were observed by Očkajová et al. (2020) for thermally modified oak and spruce wood processed at 160 °C using the milling and sanding processes. Dzurenda and Kučerka (2005) performed a comparative analysis of dry and wet spruce sawdust and found that as a result of hot air drying, the coarse fraction (125–1000 µm) increases by 7% and the fine fraction ≤ 125 µm by 6.2%. On the other hand, Orlowski et al. (2019) indicated that sawing pine and beech wood, regardless of the drying method, mainly produces sawdust with the size < 500 µm. Sawing beech wood dried with a mixture of warm air and steam at 105 °C causes an increase in the content of fine dust compared to wood dried in air. Based on particle size analyzes of sawdust generated from pine and beech wood processed on a sash gang saw, no fraction < 32 µm was found. The results of these studies are not conclusive. They were obtained by applying sieve analysis. However, this is an unreliable method for very fine wood dust (Rogoziński and Očkajová 2013). Therefore, it was decided to investigate the influence of drying method of various wood species on the content of fine dust in sawdust using two complementary methods of particle size analysis.
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Materials
The investigation was carried out for samples of pine wood (Pinus sylvestris L.) and beech wood (Fagus sylvatica L.) originating from the Baltic Natural Forest Region (PL) (the Pomeranian District, Poland). The wood specimens used in the sawing experiments were prepared as blocks in dimensions of W (Width) = 60 mm × Hp (Height) = 60 mm × Lp (Length) = 500 mm in the sawmill PHU Drew-Met, Kiełpino, Poland. Samples of beech wood were marked as BH, and samples of pine wood were indicated as PN. Examined samples were dried with different modes in industrial and laboratory conditions.
2.2 Drying processes
2.2.1 Warm air-steam mixture drying process
The drying process was conducted in an experimental semi-industrial kiln that was designed by employees of Gdansk University of Technology and manufactured by ASM Elektronik CLP, Szczaniec, Poland. The mentioned kiln is located at the Gdansk University of Technology. The methodologies of the experimental warm air-steam mixture drying process were described in detail by Baranski et al. (2017), Klement et al. (2018) and Baranski (2018). The drying process was carried out as a two-stage drying process and supervised by a control system. In the first stage, the drying medium temperature in the drying kiln was increased to 65 °C and in the second stage to 80 °C. The final moisture content was obtained at around 10%. Samples of wood dried in the warm air-steam mixture drying process were additionally marked with S.
2.2.2 The modified air-drying process
This process was conducted outside the workshop, at the Campus of the Gdansk University of Technology (Gdansk, Poland). The samples were stored under the sloped roof to keep from rain. Humidity and temperature were variable and dependent on weather conditions. At the end of the first process stage, the moisture content in dried material was approximately 16%. The second stage of the modified air-drying process was the conditioning of wood samples in a laboratory room (GUT laboratory), where thermal-flow conditions, such as temperature and air velocity, ensured reaching the final value of moisture content of around 10%. This modification allowed to receive values of moisture content similar to values obtained from other analyzed drying processes. Samples of wood dried in the modified air-drying process were marked with A.
2.3 Sash gang saw and saw blade
Cutting tests were conducted on the sash gang saw PRW15M (a prototype designed at the Department of Manufacturing Engineering and Automation. GUT, PL; manufactured by REMA-Reszel, PL) with a hybrid dynamically balanced driving system and elliptical teeth trajectory movement, as described by Wasielewski and Orlowski (2002). The sash gang saw and saw blade settings are shown in Table 1. Samples of wood, which have been sawn at fz1, were marked F1, and samples of wood, sawn at fz2 were marked F2.
Table 1
Sash gang saw and saw blade settings for performed cutting tests
Name of parameter
Symbol
Value
Unit
Machine tool setting
Number of strokes of saw frame per min
nF
685
spm
Saw frame stroke
HF
162
mm
Number of saws in the gang
m
5
–
Average cutting speed
vc
3.69
m s− 1
Feed speed
vf1
~ 0.9
m min− 1
vf2
~ 1.72
m min− 1
Feed per tooth
fz1
~ 0.105
mm
fz2
~ 0.202
mm
Tool setting
The sharp saw blades with stellite tipped teeth
–
–
–
Overall set (kerf width)
St
2
mm
Saw blade thickness
s
0.9
mm
Free length of the saw blade
L0
318
mm
Blade width
b
30
mm
Tooth pitch
P
13
mm
Tool side rake angle
γf
9
°
Tool side clearance
αf
14
°
Tension stresses of saws in the gang
σN
300
MPa
Advertisement
The re-sawing methodology was described in the work by Orlowski et al. (2019), in which the only varying cutting parameter was feed speed, which was applied at two levels: vf1 ≈ 0.9 m min− 1 and vf2 ≈ 1.72 m min− 1. This corresponds to a feed per tooth (fz) of ~ 0.105 mm and ~ 0.2 mm, respectively (Table 1). The actual value of the feed per tooth was calculated based on the sawing time taken from the plots of time changes of electrical power consumption (Fig. 1). The mean value of feed per tooth for a sash gang saw is calculated as:
Time changes in electrical power consumption while sawing at two levels of feed speed vf1 and vf2 of beech samples BH-A-F1 and BH-A-F2, which were dried in the experimental kiln at the GUT
where: nRP is stroke number of the frame in min− 1, HRP is stroke of the frame in mm, P is a tooth pitch in mm, and vf in m min− 1 is calculated as:
$$v_{f} = \frac{{60 \cdot L_{p} }}{{t_{c} }}$$
(2)
where: Lp is length of the sample in m and tc is the real cutting time in s, taken from the plot, (Fig. 1).
×
2.4 Wood dust particle size analysis
Determination of the content of the smallest dust particles in sawdust was carried out in accordance with the methodology previously described by Rogoziński et al. (2015, 2017), Hlásková et al. (2016), and Piernik et al. (2019). This methodology contains two complementary methods to determine particle size distributions of dust. There are sieving and laser light scattering. The set of sieves with standardized mesh sizes of 2, 1, 0.5, 0.25, 0.125 mm was used, and the particle mean diameter was calculated as follows:
where: q3i is the density distribution by mass, unitless, xi is the average value of particle size class in µm, n is the number of particle size classes, N is the the sum of the distribution by mass, unitless.
Laser particle sizer Analysette 22 Microtec Plus (Fritsch. Germany) with a measuring range of 0.08–2000 µm was used for determination of the mass content of the finest particles in the whole mass of sawdust. Three particle sizes of 2.5, 4 and 10 µm were used to estimate the concentration of very fine particles in the whole mass of sawdust.
3 Results
The results of the sieve analysis of the obtained sawdust are presented in Figs. 2 and 3. The arithmetic mean of the particle diameter and standard deviation were calculated based on the distributions shown there. The results of calculating these statistical parameters are presented in Table 2. A comparison of mean particle diameters of sawdust generated during sawing at two feed speeds indicates, to some extent, that sawing at a lower feed per tooth value results in smaller sized waste. It did not occur only in beech wood dried in the modified air-drying process.
Fig. 2
Particle size distributions of pine wood dust—by sieve analysis method as a function of both drying method and feed per tooth
Fig. 3
Particle size distributions of beech wood dust—by sieve analysis method as a function of both drying method and feed per tooth
Table 2
Statistics of particle size distributions obtained by the sieve analysis method
Sample
Arithmetic mean diameter
SD
PN-A-F1
550.3
201.7
PN-A-F2
812.0
238.0
PN-S-F1
770.1
251.1
PN-S-F2
816.2
249.4
BH-A-F1
729.5
285.4
BH-A-F2
663.2
256.9
BH-S-F1
489.9
196.5
BH-S-F2
661.0
351.8
×
×
The drying method does not affect the particle mean diameter of sawdust created when sawing at a feed per tooth of 0.202 mm. In the case of sawing at a feed per tooth of 0.105 mm, there was some variation in the value of the mean diameter of the particles, nevertheless, it is difficult to find any relationship based on the sieve analysis.
Comparing the cumulative distribution curves and the average dimension of sawdust by the type of wood species, it can be stated that generally beech sawdust is finer. In the case of pine wood, the smallest sawdust particles (mean particle diameter 550.3 µm) were formed from wood dried in the modified air drying process while sawing with lower feed speed. The curve corresponding to this sawdust is shifted to the left of the diagram scale (Fig. 2). Generally, the smallest mean particle diameter (489.9 µm) was measured for sawdust from beech wood dried in warm air-steam mixture drying process sawn at a slower feed speed. The cumulative distribution curve of this sawdust is hence located on the graph in the smaller particle size range (Fig. 3). This phenomenon may be associated with differences in the values of material properties, such as fracture toughness, that were shown by Chuchala et al. (2020) for beech wood air-dried and using a warm air-steam mixture drying process. Although no statistically significant differences in fracture toughness values were shown, these properties noticeably affected the differences values of the estimated shear angle for slow feed rates. The higher values of shear angle and lower values of fracture toughness can be the reason for the noticeably higher proportion of smaller sawdust particles obtained (Fig. 3) while sawing the beech wood dried in the experimental kiln with a lower feed speed. Moreover, for both species pine (Pinus sylvestris L) and beech (Fagus sylvatica L.), a decrease in fracture toughness as a result of accelerated drying in the kiln was also observed (Orlowski and Wierzbowski 2010; Chuchala et al. 2017). This phenomenon may indicate greater fragility of the processed material, and thus the appearance of finer particles in the tested chips.
Nonetheless, due to the large standard deviation values for all mean particle sizes, all these differences are not statistically significant. Therefore, sieve analysis of sawdust could only be a method of a preliminary evaluation of sawdust in terms of the content of the finest particles that may pose a health risk to woodworking employees. Respirable fraction particles have a much smaller size than the mean diameters measured by sieve analysis. Consequently, methods making it possible to measure the content of particles of this size should be used to evaluate the particle size distribution of sawdust in this regard.
In this study, the particles collected < 125 µm were subjected to laser diffraction analysis. The particle size distributions of this fraction obtained in this way are shown in Figs. 4 and 5. Similarly to the results of the sieve analysis, the mean particle diameter and standard deviation were also calculated for the sawdust fraction < 125 µm (Table 3). These values also indicate that beech sawdust is slightly finer than pine sawdust. Furthermore, the lower feed per tooth 0.105 mm causes the creation of finer sawdust (except for air-dried pine wood). However, due to the high standard deviation values, the differences between the mean values are not statistically significant. Nevertheless, due to the large range of the laser particle size, it is possible to determine the content of particles, which due to their small sizes can penetrate deeply into the human respiratory system.
Fig. 4
Particle size distributions of pine wood dust fraction < 125 µm as a function of both drying method and feed per tooth
Fig. 5
Particle size distributions of beech wood dust fraction < 125 µm as a function of both drying method and feed per tooth
Table 3
Statistics of particle size distributions of wood dusts fraction < 125 µm
Sample
Arithmetic mean diameter
SD
PN-A-F1
117.51
68.61
PN-A-F2
106.16
74.17
PN-S-F1
110.36
68.84
PN-S-F2
140.51
132.85
BH-A-F1
106.69
75.84
BH-A-F2
111.08
67.44
BH-S-F1
101.55
80.59
BH-S-F2
113.29
74.66
×
×
The results of the content calculation of the finest dust particles taking into account the fractions with characteristic dimensions of 0.08–2.5 µm, 2.5–4 µm and 4–10 µm are shown in Fig. 6. The content of these fractions of dust particles in pine sawdust is negligible. The total content of these dust fractions is less than 0.01% except for sawdust created from the pine wood dried in the modified air-drying process sawn at a feed per tooth of 0.105 mm, where it is about 0.04% of the total mass of sawdust. It is different for beech wood sawdust, where the content of these fine particles is much higher and depends on both the feed per tooth and the drying method. The total content of particles with sizes below 10 µm for wood dried in the modified air method and a feed per tooth of 0.202 mm is around 0.07%, and a feed per tooth of 0.105 mm adequately equals to 0.25%. However, for wood dried in the warm air-steam mixture, the content of these dust particles is already more than 4.5 times. Nearly 0.33% of particles with sizes below 10 µm were found in sawdust from sawing of such beech wood. The formation of such small particles of beech wood during the cutting process introduces a significant risk of these particles getting into the air in the space where humans are (operators of machine tools). These particles, when dispersed in air, may pose a potential hazard to occupational health and safety (Aro et al. 2019; Beljo-Lučić et al. 2011). This threat is exacerbated by the carcinogenicity of this wood species.
Fig. 6
Content of the finest particles m in the total mass of sawdust
×
4 Conclusion
Based on these studies, it can be concluded that:
the drying mode does not affect the mean particle diameter of sawdust created in the sawing process of pine and beech wood on a PRW-15M sash gang saw;
the finer dust was created in the sawing process carried out with a feed per tooth of 0.202 mm; nevertheless, the difference is insignificant;
the beech wood sawdust was also finer. However, in this case the difference between wood species also was insignificant;
the content of the finest dust particles with size < 10 µm was many times larger in the beech wood sawdust than in the pine wood sawdust. The highest content was found in the sawdust created in sawing wood dried in the warm air-steam mixture drying process using the feed per tooth rate of 0.202 mm.
The particle size analyses of sawdust from pine and beech wood showed that the sawing of beech wood dried in warm air-steam mixture can be a source of very fine dust particles, especially when the sawing is carried out at a low feed per tooth rate.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations
