2010 | OriginalPaper | Chapter
IR between Science and Engineering, and the Role of Experimentation
Author : Norbert Fuhr
Published in: Multilingual and Multimodal Information Access Evaluation
Publisher: Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.
Select sections of text to find matching patents with Artificial Intelligence. powered by
Select sections of text to find additional relevant content using AI-assisted search. powered by
Evaluation has always played a major role in IR research, as a means for judging about the quality of competing models. Lately, however, we have seen an over-emphasis of experimental results, thus favoring engineering approaches aiming at tuning performance and neglecting other scientific criteria. A recent study investigated the validity of experimental results published at major conferences, showing that for 95% of the papers using standard test collections, the claimed improvements were only relative, and the resulting quality was inferior to that of the top performing systems [AMWZ09].
In this talk, it is claimed that IR is still in its scientific infancy. Despite the extensive efforts in evaluation initiatives, the scientific insights gained are still very limited – partly due to shortcomings in the design of the testbeds. From a general scientific standpoint, using test collections for evaluation only is a waste of resources. Instead, experimentation should be used for hypothesis generation and testing in general, in order to accumulate a better understanding of the retrieval process and to develop a broader theoretic foundation for the field.