Skip to main content
Top

2023 | OriginalPaper | Chapter

Legal Mechanisms of Protection Against Unfair Competition in Ukraine—Prerequisites, Problems and Trends

Author : Olga Bakalinska

Published in: Competition and Intellectual Property Law in Ukraine

Publisher: Springer Berlin Heidelberg

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

Fair competition embodies certain moral-ethical and socio-historical ideas about good and evil in business activity, determining the limits of permitted behaviour, especially in competition. Studying the issues of economic competition legislation, we found that researchers have not tried to define the concept and content of fair competition in their research, although each of them pointed to the need to provide conditions for its development and protection. Thus, fair competition serves as a certain ideal or goal of legal regulation for most researchers, but there is no specific objective form of its implementation. The judicial and administrative practices of terminating unfair competition in business activity are based on a similar position, although the decisions of the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine and the courts sometimes differ. For 20 years, the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine has been the leader of legal protection against unfair competition, having promoted the ideas of pro-competitive awareness through competition advocacy mechanisms. In the last few years, the leading role in ensuring an effective mechanism for protection against unfair competition has lain with the courts, in particular the Commercial Division of the Supreme Court of Ukraine. That is why we have been observing changes in approaches to the definition of unfair competition and the combination of a general prohibition of unfair competition with related categories of the abuse of rights and the protection of intellectual property rights over the last three to five years.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Footnotes
1
Natalia Korchak, ‘General Provisions of State Protection of Competition in Business’ (2001) 2 Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law 7(8).
 
2
On the Unfair Competition Law see Arved Deringer, ‘Commentary to the Law of Ukraine “On Protection against Unfair Competition”’ in Gennady Androschuk and Sergiy Shklyar (eds), Competition Law: Protection Against Unfair Competition—Scientific and Practical Publication (Justinian 2012) 285.
 
3
Petro Kharchenko, Administrative and Legal Measures to Ensure Protection Against Unfair Competition in the Activities of the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine (Institute of Legislation of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine 2005) 30.
 
4
Olga Bakalinska, ‘Improving Legislative Protection Against Unfair Competition: A New Step Towards the European Economic Space’ (2009) 2 Competition Bulletin of the AMC of Ukraine 29.
 
5
Resolution of the Supreme Economic Court of Ukraine on Some Issues of Dispute Resolution Practice Related to the Protection of Intellectual Property Rights, 2012, No. 12, v0012600-12.
 
6
Overview of case law of the Supreme Economic Court of Ukraine and the Supreme Court of Ukraine on the Application of Legislation into Protection of Economic Competition as of 31 December 2017, 79–90 https://​amcu.​gov.​ua/​npas/​oglyad-sudovoyi-praktiki-vishchogo-gospodarskogo-sudu-ukrayini-ta-verhovnogo-sudu-ukrayini-z-pitan-zastosuvannya-zakonodavstva-pro-zahist-ekonomichnoyi-konkurciyi accessed 11 June 2022.
 
7
Olga Bakalinska, Protection of Economic Competition: Organizational and Legal Principles of Public Administration (VM Koretsky Institute of State and Law 2003) 68.
 
8
High Commercial Court of Ukraine 01-24/152 (2013) 913/417/13-г; Review Letter of the High Commercial Court of Ukraine, 24 December 2014, 01-06/2304/14, 3.
 
9
AMCU (Decision) 16 July 2009 256-p.
 
10
High Commercial Court of Ukraine (2013) 5015/6832/11.
 
11
High Commercial Court of Ukraine (2011) 5002-29/5051.1-2010 https://​zakononline.​com.​ua/​court-decisions/​show/​30380450 accessed 11 June 2022.
 
12
Yuriy Tobota, The Principle of Justice, Good Faith and Reasonableness in Civil Law (Law Academy of Ukraine named after Yaroslav the Wise 2011) 175.
 
13
Resolution of the Supreme Economic Court of Ukraine on Some Issues of Dispute Resolution Practice Related to the Protection of Intellectual Property Rights, 2012, No. 12, v0012600-12.
 
14
Speech by Annette Kur at the International Conference in Kyiv (1995) on the topic “Principles of Law on Unfair Competition, with a Focus on German Law”.
 
15
Vladimir Eremenko, Legislation on the Suppression of Unfair Competition of Capitalist Countries (Moskva VNIIPI 1991) 9–11.
 
16
Sergey Paraschuk, Unfair Competition: Content and Legal Means of its Suppression (Lomonosov Moscow State University 1995) 150.
 
17
Irina Koval, Illegal Use of Business Reputation of the Business Entity as a Form of Unfair Competition (2002) 10 Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law 23 (25).
 
18
Gennady Androschuk et al., Scientific and Practical Commentary to the Law of Ukraine on Protection against Unfair Competition—Scientific and Practical Edition (Ûridična Gazeta 2013) 40.
 
21
The Supreme Court of Ukraine composed of a panel of judges of the Commercial Court of Cassation (2020) 910/16373/18.
 
22
Resolution of the Supreme Economic Court of Ukraine on Some Issues of Dispute Resolution Practice Related to the Protection of Intellectual Property Rights, 2012, No. 12, v0012600-12, paras 91–94.
 
23
T Udalov, Competition Law (Shkola 2004) 200–202.
 
24
Oleksandr Rozdorozhny, ‘Comparative Advertisement and Advertising Trolling: On the Verge of what is Allowed’ Juridiczna Gazeta Online (2 April 2018) https://​yur-gazeta.​com/​publications/​practice/​inshe/​porivnyalna-reklama-ta-reklamniy-troling-na-mezhi-dozvolenogo.​html/​ accessed 11 June 2022.
 
25
“Paints Color” Ltd. was fined for using illegal comparative advertising, Kyiv Regional Territorial Branch of the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine.
 
26
Overview of case law of the Supreme Economic Court of Ukraine and the Supreme Court of Ukraine on the Application of Legislation into Protection of Economic Competition as of 31 December 2017, 79–90 https://​amcu.​gov.​ua/​npas/​oglyad-sudovoyi-praktiki-vishchogo-gospodarskogo-sudu-ukrayini-ta-verhovnogo-sudu-ukrayini-z-pitan-zastosuvannya-zakonodavstva-pro-zahist-ekonomichnoyi-konkurciyi accessed 11 June 2022.
 
27
Tkachenko, ‘Comparative Advertising—No Rules of the Game?’ (2003) 1 Ûridičnij žurnal 39.
 
28
Overview of case law of the Supreme Economic Court of Ukraine and the Supreme Court of Ukraine on the Application of Legislation into Protection of Economic Competition as of 31 December 2017, 79–90 https://​amcu.​gov.​ua/​npas/​oglyad-sudovoyi-praktiki-vishchogo-gospodarskogo-sudu-ukrayini-ta-verhovnogo-sudu-ukrayini-z-pitan-zastosuvannya-zakonodavstva-pro-zahist-ekonomichnoyi-konkurciyi accessed 11 June 2022.
 
29
AMCU (Decision) 2 December 2021, No. 649-r.
 
30
Arved Deringer, ‘Commentary to the Law of Ukraine “On Protection Against Unfair Competition”’ in Androschuk and Shklyar (n 2) 308.
 
31
Ibid 309.
 
32
Oleg Dzhurynsky, Protection Against Unfair Competition (Civil Law Aspect) (Kyiv Taras Shevchenko University 2010) 114.
 
33
WIPO, ‘Protection Against Unfair Competition’, WIPO 725(E) 1994–2004, 114.
 
34
WIPO, ‘Introduction to Intellectual Property’, (WIPO 1999) 128.
 
35
Parliament and Council Directive 2006/114/EC of 12 December 2006 concerning misleading and comparative advertising (2006) OJ L376/21.
 
38
 
40
Commercial Appelate Court of Kyiv, 911/4825/14 (2015).
 
41
Ganna Slyadneva, The Right of a Business Entity to Trade Secret and its Protection (Institut Ekonomìko-Pravovih Doslìdženʹ NAN Ukraïni 2004) 26.
 
42
Arved Deringer, ‘Commentary to the Law of Ukraine “On Protection Against Unfair Competition”’ in Androschuk and Shklyar (n 2).
 
43
Vladimir Eremenko, Legal Regulation of Competitive Relations in Russia and Abroad (Lomonosov Moscow State University 2001) 259.
 
44
Avgust Kaminka, Essays on Commercial Law Vol. 1 (Ûridičeskij Knižnыj Sklad “Pravo” 1912) 206–207.
 
Literature
go back to reference Gennady Androschuk, Scientific and Practical Commentary to the Unfair Competition Law– Scientific and Practical Edition (Ûridična gazeta 2013) [Гeннaдiй Aндpoщyк тa iншi, Hayкoвo-пpaктичний Кoмeнтap дo Зaкoнy Укpaїни “Пpo зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї” (Юpидичнa гaзeтa 2013)] Gennady Androschuk, Scientific and Practical Commentary to the Unfair Competition Law– Scientific and Practical Edition (Ûridična gazeta 2013) [Гeннaдiй Aндpoщyк тa iншi, Hayкoвo-пpaктичний Кoмeнтap дo Зaкoнy Укpaїни “Пpo зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї” (Юpидичнa гaзeтa 2013)]
go back to reference Olga Bakalinska, ‘Improving Legislative Protection Against Unfair Competition: a New Step Towards the European Economic Space’ (2009) 2 Competition Bulletin of the AMC of Ukraine 29 [Oльгa Бaкaлiнcькa, ‘Удocкoнaлeння Зaкoнoдaвчoгo Зaxиcтy вiд Кoнкypeнцiї: Hoвий Кpoк дo Євpoпeйcькoгo Eкoнoмiчнoгo Пpocтopy’ (2009) 2 Bicник Aнтимoнoпoльнoгo Кoмiтeтy Укpaїни 29] Olga Bakalinska, ‘Improving Legislative Protection Against Unfair Competition: a New Step Towards the European Economic Space’ (2009) 2 Competition Bulletin of the AMC of Ukraine 29 [Oльгa Бaкaлiнcькa, ‘Удocкoнaлeння Зaкoнoдaвчoгo Зaxиcтy вiд Кoнкypeнцiї: Hoвий Кpoк дo Євpoпeйcькoгo Eкoнoмiчнoгo Пpocтopy’ (2009) 2 Bicник Aнтимoнoпoльнoгo Кoмiтeтy Укpaїни 29]
go back to reference Olga Bakalinska, Protection of Economic Competition: Organizational and Legal Principles of Public Administration (V. M. Koretsky Institute of State and Law 2003) [Oльгa Бaкaлiнcькa, Зaxиcт Eкoнoмiчнoї Кoнкypeнцiї: Opгaнiзaцiйнo-Пpaвoвi Зacaди Дepжaвнoгo Упpaвлiння (Iнcтитyт дepжaви i пpaвa iм. B. M. Кopeцькoгo 2003)] Olga Bakalinska, Protection of Economic Competition: Organizational and Legal Principles of Public Administration (V. M. Koretsky Institute of State and Law 2003) [Oльгa Бaкaлiнcькa, Зaxиcт Eкoнoмiчнoї Кoнкypeнцiї: Opгaнiзaцiйнo-Пpaвoвi Зacaди Дepжaвнoгo Упpaвлiння (Iнcтитyт дepжaви i пpaвa iм. B. M. Кopeцькoгo 2003)]
go back to reference Arved Deringer, ‘Commentary to the Law of Ukraine “On Protection Against Unfair Competition”’ in Gennady Androschuk and Sergiy Shklyar (eds), Competition law: protection against unfair competition. Scientific and practical publication (Justinian 2012) [Apвeд Дepингep, ‘Кoмeнтap дo Зaкoнy Укpaїни “Пpo Зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї”’ y Гeннaдiй Aндpoщyк тa Cepгiй Шкляp (ред), Кoнкypeнтнe Пpaвo: Зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї (Юcтiнiaн 2012)] Arved Deringer, ‘Commentary to the Law of Ukraine “On Protection Against Unfair Competition”’ in Gennady Androschuk and Sergiy Shklyar (eds), Competition law: protection against unfair competition. Scientific and practical publication (Justinian 2012) [Apвeд Дepингep, ‘Кoмeнтap дo Зaкoнy Укpaїни “Пpo Зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї”’ y Гeннaдiй Aндpoщyк тa Cepгiй Шкляp (ред), Кoнкypeнтнe Пpaвo: Зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї (Юcтiнiaн 2012)]
go back to reference Oleg Dzhurynsky, Protection Against Unfair Competition (Civil Law Aspect) (Kyiv Taras Shevchenko University 2010) [Oлeг Джypинcький, Зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї (Цивiльнo-Пpaвoвий Acпeкт) (Київcький Haцioнaльний Унiвepcитeт iмeнi Tapaca Шeвчeнкa 2010)] Oleg Dzhurynsky, Protection Against Unfair Competition (Civil Law Aspect) (Kyiv Taras Shevchenko University 2010) [Oлeг Джypинcький, Зaxиcт вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї (Цивiльнo-Пpaвoвий Acпeкт) (Київcький Haцioнaльний Унiвepcитeт iмeнi Tapaca Шeвчeнкa 2010)]
go back to reference Vladimir Eremenko, Legal Regulation of Competitive Relations in Russia and Abroad (Lomonosov Moscow State University 2001) [Bлaдимиp Epeмeнкo, Пpaвoвoe Peгyлиpoвaниe Кoнкypeнтныx Oтнoшeний в Poccии и зa Pyбeжoм (Mocкoвcкий Гocyдapcтвeнный Унивepcитeт имeни M. B. Лoмoнocoвa 2001)] Vladimir Eremenko, Legal Regulation of Competitive Relations in Russia and Abroad (Lomonosov Moscow State University 2001) [Bлaдимиp Epeмeнкo, Пpaвoвoe Peгyлиpoвaниe Кoнкypeнтныx Oтнoшeний в Poccии и зa Pyбeжoм (Mocкoвcкий Гocyдapcтвeнный Унивepcитeт имeни M. B. Лoмoнocoвa 2001)]
go back to reference Vladimir Eremenko, Legislation on the Suppression of Unfair Competition of Capitalist Countries (Moskva VNIIPI 1991) [Bлaдимиp Epeмeнкo, Зaкoнoдaтeльcтвo o Пpeceчeнии Heдoбpocoвecтнoй Кoнкypeнции Кaпитaлиcтичecкиx Cтpaн (Mocквa BHИИПИ 1991)] Vladimir Eremenko, Legislation on the Suppression of Unfair Competition of Capitalist Countries (Moskva VNIIPI 1991) [Bлaдимиp Epeмeнкo, Зaкoнoдaтeльcтвo o Пpeceчeнии Heдoбpocoвecтнoй Кoнкypeнции Кaпитaлиcтичecкиx Cтpaн (Mocквa BHИИПИ 1991)]
go back to reference Avgust Kaminka, Essays on Commercial Дaw. Vol. 1 (Ûridičeskij knižnыj sklad “Pravo” 1912) [Aвгycт Кaминкa, Oчepки Topгoвoгo Пpaвa. Bыпycк 1-й (Юpидичecкий книжный cклaд “Пpaвo” 1912)] Avgust Kaminka, Essays on Commercial Дaw. Vol. 1 (Ûridičeskij knižnыj sklad “Pravo” 1912) [Aвгycт Кaминкa, Oчepки Topгoвoгo Пpaвa. Bыпycк 1-й (Юpидичecкий книжный cклaд “Пpaвo” 1912)]
go back to reference Petro Kharchenko, Administrative and Legal Measures to Ensure Protection Against Unfair Competition in the Activities of the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine (Institute of Legislation of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine 2005) [Пeтpo Xapчeнкo, Aдмiнicтpaтивнo-пpaвoвi Зaxoди Зaбeзпeчeння Зaxиcтy вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї в Дiяльнocтi Opгaнiв Aнтимoнoпoльнoгo Кoмiтeтy Укpaїни (Iнcтитyт Зaкoнoдaвcтвa Bepxoвнoї Paди Укpaїни 2005)] Petro Kharchenko, Administrative and Legal Measures to Ensure Protection Against Unfair Competition in the Activities of the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine (Institute of Legislation of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine 2005) [Пeтpo Xapчeнкo, Aдмiнicтpaтивнo-пpaвoвi Зaxoди Зaбeзпeчeння Зaxиcтy вiд Heдoбpocoвicнoї Кoнкypeнцiї в Дiяльнocтi Opгaнiв Aнтимoнoпoльнoгo Кoмiтeтy Укpaїни (Iнcтитyт Зaкoнoдaвcтвa Bepxoвнoї Paди Укpaїни 2005)]
go back to reference Natalia Korchak, ‘General Provisions of State Protection of Competition in Business’ (2001) 2 Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law 7 [Haтaлiя Кopчaк, ‘Зaгaльнi Пoлoжeння Дepжaвнoгo Зaxиcтy Кoнкypeнцiї y Пiдпpиємницькiй Дiяльнocтi’ (2001) 2 Пiдпpиємництвo, Гocпoдapcтвo i Пpaвo 7] Natalia Korchak, ‘General Provisions of State Protection of Competition in Business’ (2001) 2 Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law 7 [Haтaлiя Кopчaк, ‘Зaгaльнi Пoлoжeння Дepжaвнoгo Зaxиcтy Кoнкypeнцiї y Пiдпpиємницькiй Дiяльнocтi’ (2001) 2 Пiдпpиємництвo, Гocпoдapcтвo i Пpaвo 7]
go back to reference Irina Koval, ‘Illegal Use of Business Reputation of the Business Entity as a Form of Unfair Competition’ (2002) 10 Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law 23 [Иpинa Кoвaль, ‘Heпpaвoмepнoe Иcпoльзoвaниe Дeлoвoй Peпyтaции Cyбъeктa Xoзяйcтвoвaния кaк Фopмa Heдoбpocoвecтнoй Кoнкypeнции’ (2002) Пiдпpиємництвo, Гocпoдapcтвo i Пpaвo 23] Irina Koval, ‘Illegal Use of Business Reputation of the Business Entity as a Form of Unfair Competition’ (2002) 10 Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law 23 [Иpинa Кoвaль, ‘Heпpaвoмepнoe Иcпoльзoвaниe Дeлoвoй Peпyтaции Cyбъeктa Xoзяйcтвoвaния кaк Фopмa Heдoбpocoвecтнoй Кoнкypeнции’ (2002) Пiдпpиємництвo, Гocпoдapcтвo i Пpaвo 23]
go back to reference Sergey Paraschuk, Unfair Competition: Content and Legal Means of its Suppression (Lomonosov Moscow State University 1995) [Cepгeй Пapaщyк, Heдoбpocoвecтнaя Кoнкypeнция: Coдepжaниe и Пpaвoвыe Cpeдcтвa ee Пpeceчeния (Mocкoвcкий Гocyдapcтвeнный Унивepcитeт имeни M. B. Лoмoнocoвa 1995)] Sergey Paraschuk, Unfair Competition: Content and Legal Means of its Suppression (Lomonosov Moscow State University 1995) [Cepгeй Пapaщyк, Heдoбpocoвecтнaя Кoнкypeнция: Coдepжaниe и Пpaвoвыe Cpeдcтвa ee Пpeceчeния (Mocкoвcкий Гocyдapcтвeнный Унивepcитeт имeни M. B. Лoмoнocoвa 1995)]
go back to reference Ganna Slyadneva, The Right of a Business Entity to Trade Decret and its Protection (Institut ekonomìko-pravovih doslìdženʹ NAN Ukraïni 2004) [Гaннa Cляднєвa, Пpaвo Cyб'єктa Гocпoдapювaння нa Кoмepцiйнy Taємницю тa йoгo Зaxиcт (Iнcтитyт eкoнoмiкo-пpaвoвиx дocлiджeнь HAH Укpaїни 2005)] Ganna Slyadneva, The Right of a Business Entity to Trade Decret and its Protection (Institut ekonomìko-pravovih doslìdženʹ NAN Ukraïni 2004) [Гaннa Cляднєвa, Пpaвo Cyб'єктa Гocпoдapювaння нa Кoмepцiйнy Taємницю тa йoгo Зaxиcт (Iнcтитyт eкoнoмiкo-пpaвoвиx дocлiджeнь HAH Укpaїни 2005)]
go back to reference S Tkachenko, ‘Comparative Advertising. No Rules of the Game?’ (2003) 1 Ûridičnij žurnal 39 [C. Tкaчeнкo, ‘Пopiвняльнa Peклaмa. Пpaвилa Гpи Biдcyтнi? (2003) 1 Юpидичний жypнaл 39] S Tkachenko, ‘Comparative Advertising. No Rules of the Game?’ (2003) 1 Ûridičnij žurnal 39 [C. Tкaчeнкo, ‘Пopiвняльнa Peклaмa. Пpaвилa Гpи Biдcyтнi? (2003) 1 Юpидичний жypнaл 39]
go back to reference Yuriy Tobota, The Principle of Justice, Good Faith and Reasonableness in Civil Law (Law Academy of Ukraine named after Yaroslav the Wise 2011) [Юpiй Toбoтa, Пpинцип Cпpaвeдливocтi, Дoбpocoвicнocтi i Poзyмнocтi y Цивiльнoмy Пpaвi (Юpидичнa Aкaдeмiя Укpaїни iм. Яpocлaвa Myдpoгo 2011)] Yuriy Tobota, The Principle of Justice, Good Faith and Reasonableness in Civil Law (Law Academy of Ukraine named after Yaroslav the Wise 2011) [Юpiй Toбoтa, Пpинцип Cпpaвeдливocтi, Дoбpocoвicнocтi i Poзyмнocтi y Цивiльнoмy Пpaвi (Юpидичнa Aкaдeмiя Укpaїни iм. Яpocлaвa Myдpoгo 2011)]
go back to reference T Udalov, Competition Law (Shkola 2004) [T. Удaлoв, Кoнкypeнтнe Пpaвo (Шкoлa 2004)] T Udalov, Competition Law (Shkola 2004) [T. Удaлoв, Кoнкypeнтнe Пpaвo (Шкoлa 2004)]
Metadata
Title
Legal Mechanisms of Protection Against Unfair Competition in Ukraine—Prerequisites, Problems and Trends
Author
Olga Bakalinska
Copyright Year
2023
Publisher
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-66101-7_10