Skip to main content
Top
Published in: Empirical Economics 1/2021

19-04-2020

No place like home: geography and culture in the dissemination of economic research articles

Authors: Christiane Hellmanzik, Lukas Kuld

Published in: Empirical Economics | Issue 1/2021

Log in

Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

This paper examines the existence of distance and border effects in the dissemination of knowledge in economics research using a state-of-the-art gravity model for domestic and international citations between 1970 and 2016 for the top 20 source countries. We extend the model with two novel indicators, English proficiency and bilateral internet ties-two key forces in the dissemination of research and knowledge more generally. Our results show that (i) citations decrease with distance, (ii) citations exhibit a significant home bias greater than 1.68, i.e. a more than 50% higher propensity to cite domestic articles, (iii) home bias as well as geographic and cultural distance measures remain significant and at persistent levels over time, (iv) bilaterally high levels of English proficiency are insignificant for citations beyond the measure of general language similarity, (v) countries with closer internet ties have higher shares of bilateral citations, and (vi) geographic proximity is insignificant for citations to econometric articles while cultural linkages are significant.

Dont have a licence yet? Then find out more about our products and how to get one now:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Footnotes
1
More generally, Jaffe et al. (1993) provides evidence for strong geographic concentration of patent citations which is further confirmed by Breschi and Lissoni (2009) who links this concentration of knowledge back to the lack of mobility of inventors who are likely to remain in their co-inventor network.
 
2
The twenty leading countries are Australia, Belgium, Canada, China, Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Germany, India, Israel, Italy, Japan, Netherlands, Republic of Korea, Romania, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, United Kingdom, and USA.
 
3
Articles with authors in multiple countries are attributed to each country.
 
4
We exclude citing countries with less than 100 total citing articles from our analysis.
 
5
To understand why, imagine picking a random economics article written in 2016, it is reasonable to assume that the article cites at least one article from the United States. By just counting citing articles for the United States overall, we would end up simply counting all 2017 economics articles. However, a new article might not reference American articles from each of the last 10 years and is very unlikely to reference 47 American articles covering each year from 1970 to 2016. Technically, we only observe an article’s first citation to a given year-country which underestimates countries and years that have relatively high citation averages.
 
6
The average number of references given per paper almost doubled over the last 20 years from 25 to 40 [see Kuld and O’Hagan (2018)].
 
8
To this end Chung (2011) uses Yahoo’s search function and LexiURL Searcher, a social science web analysis tool developed by Thelwall (2009). At the time, Yahoo had indexed about 47 billion websites. For more detailed information on obtaining the measure of bilateral hyperlinks, please refer to Chung (2011).
 
9
For the United States, usually the sum of the domains .edu, .us, .mil and .gov has been used Barnett et al. (2001) in the literature. In previous studies [e.g. Barnett and Sung (2005)], the .com domain had either been disregarded or completely attributed to the United States.
 
10
For comparison, Gloetzl and Aigner (2017) count articles in 441 economics journals from 1980 to 2014. In this sample, North American researchers alone authored half of the world’s economics articles indexed by WoS between 1980 and 2014 which then received 75% of total citations. 98.4% of the economics articles from the top ten countries are written in English (WoS classification). The next two languages are French with 0.8% and German with 0.3% of the total indexed article output of these countries (WoS).
 
11
To obtain positive counts, we show the exponential of log demeaned by citing and cited country (thereby using the geometric mean).
 
12
In addition, incentives to cite articles within local networks create opportunity costs for citations to unconnected researchers.
 
13
\(P_i=\left( \displaystyle \sum _{j=1}^{N} (a_{ij}p_{ij})^{1-\sigma } \right) ^\frac{1}{1-\sigma }\).
 
14
The results are unchanged for Poisson with clustered errors, but other methods are less robust with respect to the aggregation level.
 
15
\(Asinh(x)=\ln (x+\sqrt{x^2+1})\). For \(x \ge 2, asinh(x)\approx \ln (x) + \ln (2)\), but \(asinh(0)=0\). Also suggested for citation counts by Card and DellaVigna (2020), for instance.
 
16
However, both, OLS and negative binomial regressions, have stronger identification assumptions and are not consistent with the theoretical multilateral resistance model. As an indication, they overestimate the actual sum of citing articles considerably. For instance, the total flows involving the United States are overestimated by 20% (OLS) and 31% (negative binomial) in the standard specification. While smaller countries are underestimated, the ratios of total estimated flows to actual flows are 1.15 (OLS) and 1.22 (NegBin2) as opposed to 1 using Poisson.
 
17
The estimation tables underlying the results for the figures presented are available upon request.
 
18
Additionally we ran a specification excluding the US (results not presented but available upon request). If we do so, this value rises to 16% but can be as big as 90% for larger language differences.
 
19
The lower effect estimated for geographic distance reflects the change in the sample size and year. Table 6, for instance, shows that the omission of the home variable alone does not affect the same distance estimate significantly in the baseline sample.
 
20
These articles are classified by WoS as economics as well as mathematics or statistics and probability. The data are collected for articles written in the top ten leading countries between 2004 and 2008.
 
Literature
go back to reference Arora A, Belenzon S, Lee H (2018) Reversed citations and the localization of knowledge spillovers. J Econ Geogr 18(3):495–521CrossRef Arora A, Belenzon S, Lee H (2018) Reversed citations and the localization of knowledge spillovers. J Econ Geogr 18(3):495–521CrossRef
go back to reference Balta N, Delgado J (2009) Home bias and market integration in the EU. CESifo Econ Stud 55(1):110–144CrossRef Balta N, Delgado J (2009) Home bias and market integration in the EU. CESifo Econ Stud 55(1):110–144CrossRef
go back to reference Barnett GA, Chon B-S, Rosen D (2001) The structure of the internet flows in cyberspace. NETCOM 15(2):61–80CrossRef Barnett GA, Chon B-S, Rosen D (2001) The structure of the internet flows in cyberspace. NETCOM 15(2):61–80CrossRef
go back to reference Barnett GA, Sung E (2005) Culture and the structure of the international hyperlink network. J Comput Med Commun 11(1):217–238CrossRef Barnett GA, Sung E (2005) Culture and the structure of the international hyperlink network. J Comput Med Commun 11(1):217–238CrossRef
go back to reference Boyack KW, Klavans R, Börner K (2005) Mapping the backbone of science. Scientometrics 64(3):351–374CrossRef Boyack KW, Klavans R, Börner K (2005) Mapping the backbone of science. Scientometrics 64(3):351–374CrossRef
go back to reference Breschi S, Lissoni F (2009) Mobility of skilled workers and co-invention networks: an anatomy of localized knowledge flows. J Econ Geogr 9(4):439–468CrossRef Breschi S, Lissoni F (2009) Mobility of skilled workers and co-invention networks: an anatomy of localized knowledge flows. J Econ Geogr 9(4):439–468CrossRef
go back to reference Card D, DellaVigna S (2020) What do editors maximize? Evidence from four economics journals. Rev Econ Stat 102(1):195–217CrossRef Card D, DellaVigna S (2020) What do editors maximize? Evidence from four economics journals. Rev Econ Stat 102(1):195–217CrossRef
go back to reference Chen N (2004) Intra-national versus international trade in the european union: why do national borders matter? J Int Econ 63(1):93–118CrossRef Chen N (2004) Intra-national versus international trade in the european union: why do national borders matter? J Int Econ 63(1):93–118CrossRef
go back to reference Choi C (2010) The effect of the Internet on service trade. Econ Lett 109(2):102–104CrossRef Choi C (2010) The effect of the Internet on service trade. Econ Lett 109(2):102–104CrossRef
go back to reference Chung CJ (2011) The geography of global internet hyperlink networks and cultural content analysis. Dissertation, University at Buffalo Chung CJ (2011) The geography of global internet hyperlink networks and cultural content analysis. Dissertation, University at Buffalo
go back to reference Disdier A-C, Mayer T (2007) Je t’aime, moi non plus: bilateral opinions and international trade. Eur J Polit Econ 23(4):1140–1159CrossRef Disdier A-C, Mayer T (2007) Je t’aime, moi non plus: bilateral opinions and international trade. Eur J Polit Econ 23(4):1140–1159CrossRef
go back to reference Fally T (2015) Structural gravity and fixed effects. J Int Econ 97(1):76–85CrossRef Fally T (2015) Structural gravity and fixed effects. J Int Econ 97(1):76–85CrossRef
go back to reference Felbermayr GJ, Toubal F (2010) Cultural proximity and trade. Eur Econ Rev 54(2):279–293CrossRef Felbermayr GJ, Toubal F (2010) Cultural proximity and trade. Eur Econ Rev 54(2):279–293CrossRef
go back to reference Fourcade M, Ollion E, Algan Y (2015) The superiority of economists. J Econ Perspect 29(1):89–114CrossRef Fourcade M, Ollion E, Algan Y (2015) The superiority of economists. J Econ Perspect 29(1):89–114CrossRef
go back to reference Francois J, Hoekman B (2010) Services trade and policy. J Econ Lit 48(3):642–92CrossRef Francois J, Hoekman B (2010) Services trade and policy. J Econ Lit 48(3):642–92CrossRef
go back to reference Frenken K, Hardeman S, Hoekman J (2009) Spatial scientometrics: towards a cumulative research program. J Inf 3(3):222–232 Frenken K, Hardeman S, Hoekman J (2009) Spatial scientometrics: towards a cumulative research program. J Inf 3(3):222–232
go back to reference Frenken K, Hoekman J (2014) Spatial scientometrics and scholarly impact: a review of recent studies, tools, and methods. In: Ding Y, Rousseau R, Wolfram D (eds) Measuring scholarly impact. Springer, Berlin, pp 127–146 Frenken K, Hoekman J (2014) Spatial scientometrics and scholarly impact: a review of recent studies, tools, and methods. In: Ding Y, Rousseau R, Wolfram D (eds) Measuring scholarly impact. Springer, Berlin, pp 127–146
go back to reference Gloetzl F, Aigner E (2017) Six dimensions of concentration in economics: scientometric evidence from a large-scale data set. Ecological economics papers IEEP15, Institute of Ecological Economics Gloetzl F, Aigner E (2017) Six dimensions of concentration in economics: scientometric evidence from a large-scale data set. Ecological economics papers IEEP15, Institute of Ecological Economics
go back to reference Guellec D, van Pottelsberghe de la Potterie B (2001) The internationalisation of technology analysed with patent data. Res Policy 30(8):1253–1266CrossRef Guellec D, van Pottelsberghe de la Potterie B (2001) The internationalisation of technology analysed with patent data. Res Policy 30(8):1253–1266CrossRef
go back to reference Guiso L, Sapienza P, Zingales L (2009) Cultural biases in economic exchange? Q J Econ 124(3):1095–1131CrossRef Guiso L, Sapienza P, Zingales L (2009) Cultural biases in economic exchange? Q J Econ 124(3):1095–1131CrossRef
go back to reference Head K, Mayer T (2002) Illusory border effects: distance mismeasurement inflates estimates of home bias in trade, vol 1. CEPII, Paris Head K, Mayer T (2002) Illusory border effects: distance mismeasurement inflates estimates of home bias in trade, vol 1. CEPII, Paris
go back to reference Hellmanzik C, Schmitz M (2015) Virtual proximity and audiovisual services trade. Eur Econ Rev 77:82–101CrossRef Hellmanzik C, Schmitz M (2015) Virtual proximity and audiovisual services trade. Eur Econ Rev 77:82–101CrossRef
go back to reference Hellmanzik C, Schmitz M (2017) Taking gravity online: the role of virtual proximity in international finance. J Int Money Finance 77:164–179CrossRef Hellmanzik C, Schmitz M (2017) Taking gravity online: the role of virtual proximity in international finance. J Int Money Finance 77:164–179CrossRef
go back to reference Jaffe AB, Trajtenberg M, Henderson R (1993) Geographic localization of knowledge spillovers as evidenced by patent citations. Q J Econ 108(3):577–598CrossRef Jaffe AB, Trajtenberg M, Henderson R (1993) Geographic localization of knowledge spillovers as evidenced by patent citations. Q J Econ 108(3):577–598CrossRef
go back to reference Kimura F, Lee H-H (2006) The gravity equation in international trade in services. Rev World Econ 142(1):92–121CrossRef Kimura F, Lee H-H (2006) The gravity equation in international trade in services. Rev World Econ 142(1):92–121CrossRef
go back to reference Kuld L (2017) The university as a local idea space: benefits from research links. Working paper, Trinity College Dublin Kuld L (2017) The university as a local idea space: benefits from research links. Working paper, Trinity College Dublin
go back to reference Kuld L, O’Hagan J (2018) Rise of multi-authored papers in economics: demise of the ’lone star’ and why? Scientometrics 114(3):1207–1225CrossRef Kuld L, O’Hagan J (2018) Rise of multi-authored papers in economics: demise of the ’lone star’ and why? Scientometrics 114(3):1207–1225CrossRef
go back to reference Li YA (2014) Borders and distance in knowledge spillovers: dying over time or dying with age? Evidence from patent citations. Eur Econ Rev 71:152–172CrossRef Li YA (2014) Borders and distance in knowledge spillovers: dying over time or dying with age? Evidence from patent citations. Eur Econ Rev 71:152–172CrossRef
go back to reference Marco AD, Scellato G, Ughetto E, Caviggioli F (2017) Global markets for technology: evidence from patent transactions. Res Policy 46(9):1644–1654CrossRef Marco AD, Scellato G, Ughetto E, Caviggioli F (2017) Global markets for technology: evidence from patent transactions. Res Policy 46(9):1644–1654CrossRef
go back to reference Matthiessen C, Schwarz A, Find S (2002) The top-level global research system, 1997–99: centres, networks and nodality. An analysis based on bibliometric indicators. Urban Stud 39(5–6):903–927CrossRef Matthiessen C, Schwarz A, Find S (2002) The top-level global research system, 1997–99: centres, networks and nodality. An analysis based on bibliometric indicators. Urban Stud 39(5–6):903–927CrossRef
go back to reference Melitz J, Toubal F (2014) Native language, spoken language, translation and trade. J Int Econ 93(2):351–363CrossRef Melitz J, Toubal F (2014) Native language, spoken language, translation and trade. J Int Econ 93(2):351–363CrossRef
go back to reference Morescalchi A, Pammolli F, Penner O, Petersen AM, Riccaboni M (2015) The evolution of networks of innovators within and across borders: evidence from patent data. Res Policy 44(3):651–668CrossRef Morescalchi A, Pammolli F, Penner O, Petersen AM, Riccaboni M (2015) The evolution of networks of innovators within and across borders: evidence from patent data. Res Policy 44(3):651–668CrossRef
go back to reference Nitsch V (2000) National borders and international trade: evidence from the european union. Can J Econ Rev Can d’écon 33(4):1091–1105CrossRef Nitsch V (2000) National borders and international trade: evidence from the european union. Can J Econ Rev Can d’écon 33(4):1091–1105CrossRef
go back to reference Pan RK, Kaski K, Fortunato S (2012) World citation and collaboration networks: uncovering the role of geography in science. Scientific reports 2 Pan RK, Kaski K, Fortunato S (2012) World citation and collaboration networks: uncovering the role of geography in science. Scientific reports 2
go back to reference Peri G (2005) Determinants of knowledge flows and their effect on innovation. Rev Econ Stat 87(2):308–322CrossRef Peri G (2005) Determinants of knowledge flows and their effect on innovation. Rev Econ Stat 87(2):308–322CrossRef
go back to reference Picci L (2010) The internationalization of inventive activity: a gravity model using patent data. Res Policy 39(8):1070–1081CrossRef Picci L (2010) The internationalization of inventive activity: a gravity model using patent data. Res Policy 39(8):1070–1081CrossRef
go back to reference Silva JMCS, Tenreyro S (2006) The log of gravity. Rev Econ Stat 88(4):641–658CrossRef Silva JMCS, Tenreyro S (2006) The log of gravity. Rev Econ Stat 88(4):641–658CrossRef
go back to reference Thelwall M (2009) Introduction to webometrics: quantitative web research for the social sciences. Synth Lect Inf Concepts Retr Serv 1(1):1–116 Thelwall M (2009) Introduction to webometrics: quantitative web research for the social sciences. Synth Lect Inf Concepts Retr Serv 1(1):1–116
Metadata
Title
No place like home: geography and culture in the dissemination of economic research articles
Authors
Christiane Hellmanzik
Lukas Kuld
Publication date
19-04-2020
Publisher
Springer Berlin Heidelberg
Published in
Empirical Economics / Issue 1/2021
Print ISSN: 0377-7332
Electronic ISSN: 1435-8921
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00181-020-01860-0

Other articles of this Issue 1/2021

Empirical Economics 1/2021 Go to the issue

Premium Partner