Background
- How do children conceptualize water, molecule, and chemistry before and after participating in a playful dramatization of chemical concepts and processes?
Children making sense of science
Previous research on children’s understanding of and engagement with chemistry
Theorizing concept formation
Method
Ethical considerations
Description of the lesson
- Introduction
- Experience
- Experiment
- Summary
Findings: ways of conceptualizing water
Conceptions | Number |
---|---|
Water conceptualized in everyday terms | 7 |
Water conceptualized in terms of lived experience | 13 |
Explored generalized science | 2 |
Total | 22 |
- Interviewer: What is water?
- Anna: Something that you can drink.
- Andy: I don’t know, I never thought of it.
- Interviewer: What is water made of?
- Andy: It is made by nothing; it is just made by water.
- Bo: Cloud?
- Interviewer: Cloud…yes, can you tell me how you mean?
- Bo: The clouds soak all the water and then drop it down.
- Interviewer: Yes? What is it then, when it falls down?
- Bo: Raindrops…
- Bo: The cloud has soaked a lot of water… Then it has soaked a lot of steam.
- Interviewer: You said steam, what’s that?
- Bo: It is sort of when it becomes really warm then… A little bit of water is transformed to steam that can… that rises. So water is rising instead of going downwards.
- Barbara: Water is made of oxygen.
- Interviewer: What is oxygen?
- Barbara: Something you breathe, you breathe air!
- Interviewer: You mean that oxygen is in water?
- Barbara: Yes!
- Interviewer: Do you know what chemistry means?
- Carla: Chemistry is surface tension.
- Interviewer: How do you mean?
- Carla: Chemistry makes the water striders float.
- Interviewer: The water striders float? What are water striders?
- Carla: They are small animals living on top of the water. They have small feet and glide on the surface tension. When the surface tension disappears they go down from the water…
- Chris:…water can become different forms.
- Interviewer: Yes? How is that?
- Chris: It can become steam, or ice.
- Interviewer: Or ice…, is it water then?
- Chris: Mm, it is different things that water can become sometimes. If it is cold enough, water becomes a… to a… to ice and if it is warm, then water can become steam!
- Interviewer: So, the ice out here, is it water? [The interviews were carried out on one of the first days of winter, with snow on the schoolyard]
- Chris: It is frozen water!
- Interviewer: Frozen water? How does that happen?
- Chris: Because it has become… It has become cold enough for it to freeze and then it turns into ice.
- Chris:…sometimes I use to make experiments.
- Interviewer: So you make experiments? Can you tell me more? What kind of experiments?
- Chris: I experiment a little bit, with water to see how it can be with water and, and how it can’t be with water, so that I can examine with it.
What did the children learn from partaking in the chemistry activity?
- Interviewer: …I have another picture here, where you can see even better… what are you doing there?
- Andy: Playing water molecules too.
- Interviewer: Ah, yes… what happened then, when it was cold, how did you do then?
- Andy: Then we did slowly.
- Interviewer: Then, as it became warmer and warmer, how did you do then?
- Andy: Fast!
- Bill: They are such round balls, although they resemble Mickey Mouse.
- Interviewer: Why is that?
- Bill: Because they live there and make the water blue.
- Interviewer: How?
- Bill: Because they are soft, really soft.
- Interviewer: Water molecules, what’s that?
- Bo: Hm… water! Blue caps since water molecules are blue. Just like small drops of water, only tinier.
- Carla: I remembered that I told you the last time that it was water monopoles but it was water molecules.
- Interviewer: It is just water molecules that are…
- Carla: …no, there are sugar molecules, apart from that I don’t know much more about molecules. There is a molecule in us that has been in the dinosaur, so there might be a water molecule from a dinosaur.
- Interviewer: Do you remember where we can find molecules?
- Carla: In the air, air molecules. And if water starts to boil it turns to mist that goes up in the air. They can go up there in the clouds and then they rain down.
- Interviewer: What is a molecule?
- Chris: A molecule is a little, tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny… tiny, tiny part of something.
- Interviewer: Of what? What can it…?
- Chris: …of anything!
- Berta: I liked to be there and watch, sit and watch and see. We were watching those, water molecules, sugar molecules!
- Bekim: We looked at theatre with Karl-Berit! [i.e., the enacted molecule, see description of the lesson above]
- Bim: We played that we were a glass of water!
- Bill: They squirt out green.
- Interviewer: Why did they do that?
- Bill: Because they, they wanted to see, all the children to see that it was green.
- Interviewer: What happened with the green?
- Bill: It became green.
- Bim: She is testing how warm or cold the water is.
- Interviewer: What did you do then?
- Bim: We put in some candy color.
- Interviewer: What happened with the candy color?
- Bim: In the cold glass they move slowly and in the warm glass the candy color moved quickly. The cold was a bit lighter and the warm was dark.
- Interviewer: Do you remember something else from the experiment you made?
- Chris: That we mixed a lot of molecules. Water with sugar molecules and sugar molecules mixed with water and then sugar molecules with water. And candy color, candy color molecules were mixed together.
- Interviewer: What happened with the color?
- Chris: Then it became green.
- Interviewer: And what did that mean then, when it became green?
- Chris: That it had spread. And it, like water… the water was cold, then it formed like a beam, down… but when it was warm, then it became almost like a cloud… then it became almost like smoke.