Swipe to navigate through the articles of this issue
We thank Eric Anderson, Tomomichi Amano, Eric Bradlow, Pradeep Chintagunta, Yufeng Huang, Mitch Lovett, Carl Mela, Sridhar Narayanan, Aviv Nevo, Thomas Otter, Brad Shapiro, and participants of the INFORMS Marketing Science Conference 2016 and Yale Customer Insights Conference 2017 for their feedback. We thank Herb Sorensen for his invaluable help with the path-tracking data. We particularly thank Pedro Gardete for helping us compute wild bootstrap standard errors. All errors are our own.
We assemble a unique data set that combines information on supermarket feature advertising with path-tracking data on consumers’ movement within the store as well as purchase information. Using these novel data, we trace out how advertising affects consumer behavior along the path-to-purchase. We find advertising has no significant effect on the number of consumers visiting the category being advertised. The null effect is precisely estimated. At the upper bound of the confidence interval, a one-standard-deviation shift in advertising increases category traffic by only 1.3%. We do find a significant effect at the lower end of the conversion funnel. A one-standard-deviation change in advertising (evaluated at the point estimate) increases category-level sales by 10%. We further decompose the impact on sales and find the increase is driven by the same number of consumers buying a larger number of products of the same brand. We find no evidence of spillover effects of advertising between categories that are stocked in proximity of each other, nor between different products in the same category. Two mechanisms are consistent with these patterns: consumers retrieve memory of the ad only when interacting with the category or only consumers wanting to purchase the brand choose to consume the ad.
Please log in to get access to this content
To get access to this content you need the following product:
Anderson, E., Malin, B.A., Nakamura, E., Simester, D., & Steinsson, J. (2016). Informational rigidities and the stickiness of temporary sales. Journal of Monetary Economics, forthcoming.
Anderson, E.T., & Simester, D. (2013). Advertising in a competitive market: the role of product standards, customer learning, and switching costs. Journal of Marketing Research, 50, 489–504. CrossRef
Bagwell, K. (2007). The economic analysis of advertising. In M. Armstrong, & R. Porter (Eds.), Handbook of industrial organization. Elsevier Science, (Vol. 3 pp. 1701–1844).
Blattberg, R.C., & Neslin, S.A. (1990). Sales promotion: concepts, methods and strategies, 2nd edn. Prentice Hall.
Bodapati, A.V., & Srinivasan, V. (2006). The impact of feature advertising on customer store choice. Working Paper.
Bronnenberg, B.J., Kim, J.B., & Mela, C.F. (2016). Zooming in on choice: how do consumers search for cameras online? Marketing Science, 35, 693–712. CrossRef
Bronnenberg, B.J., Kruger, M.W., & Mela, C.F. (2008). The IRI marketing data set. Marketing Science, 27, 745–748. CrossRef
Cameron, A.C., Gelbach, J.B., & Miller, D.L. (2008). Bootstrap-based improvements for inference with clustered errors. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 3, 414–427. CrossRef
Chan, T., Ma, Y., Narasimhan, C., & Singh, V. (2006). An empirical analysis of store competition. Working Paper.
Chen, Y., & Yao, S. (2016). Sequential search with refinement: model and application with click-stream data. Management Science, forthcoming.
De Los Santos, B.I., Hortacsu, A., & Wildenbeest, M. (2012). Testing models of consumer search using data on web browsing and purchasing behavior. American Economic Review, 102, 2955–2980. CrossRef
Erdem, T., Imai, S., & Keane, M.P. (2003). Brand and quantity choice dynamics under price uncertainty. Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 1, 5–64. CrossRef
Hendel, I., & Nevo, A. (2006). Measuring the implications of sales and consumer inventory behavior. Econometrica, 74, 1637–1673. CrossRef
Honka, E., Hortacsu, A., & Vitorino, M.A. (2016). Advertising, consumer awareness and choice: Evidence from the U.S. Banking Industry. RAND Journal of Economics, forthcoming.
Hui, S.K., Bradlow, E.T., & Fader, P.S. (2009a). The traveling salesman goes shopping: the systematic deviations of grocery paths from TSP optimality. Marketing Science, 28, 566–572.
Hui, S.K., Fader, P.S., & Bradlow, E.T. (2009b). Path data in marketing: an integrative framework and prospectus for model building. Marketing Science, 28, 320–335.
Hui, S.K., Huang, Y., Suher, J., & Inman, J. (2013a). Deconstructing the first moment of truth: understanding unplanned consideration and purchase conversion using In-Store video tracking. Journal of Marketing Research, 50, 445–462.
Hui, S.K., Inman, J., Huang, Y., & Suher, J. (2013b). Estimating the effect of travel distance on unplanned spending: applications to mobile promotion strategies. Journal of Marketing, 77, 1–16.
Jedidi, K., Mela, C.F., & Gupta, S. (1999). Managing advertising and promotion for long-run profitability. Marketing Science, 18, 1–22. CrossRef
Johnson, G.A., Lewis, R., & Nubbemeyer, E. (2016). The online display ad effectiveness funnel & carry-over: a meta-study of ghost ad experiments. Working Paper.
Keller, K.L. (1987). Memory factors in advertising: the effect of advertising retrieval cues on brand evaluations. Journal of Consumer Research, 14, 316–333. CrossRef
Kim, J.B., Albuquerque, P., & Bronnenberg, B.J. (2010). Online demand under limited consumer search. Marketing Science, 29, 1001–1023. CrossRef
Lee, A.Y. (2002). Effects of implicit memory on memory-based versus stimulus-based brand choice. Journal of Marketing Research, 39, 440–454. CrossRef
Lee, A.Y., & Labroo, A.A. (2004). The effect of conceptual and perceptual fluency on brand evaluation. Journal of Marketing Research, 41, 151–165. CrossRef
Lewis, R.A., & Nguyen, D. (2014). A Samsung Ad for the iPad? Display advertising’s competitive spillovers to search. Working Paper.
Lewis, R.A., & Rao, J.M. (2015). The unfavorable economics of measuring the returns to advertising*. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130, 1941. CrossRef
Lewis, R.A., & Reiley, D.H. (2014). Online ads and offline sales: measuring the effect of retail advertising via a controlled experiment on Yahoo! Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 12, 235–266. CrossRef
Mela, C.F., Gupta, S., & Lehmann, D.R. (1997). The long-term impact of promotion and advertising on consumer brand choice. Journal of Marketing Research, 34, 248–261. CrossRef
Osborne, M. (2011). Consumer learning, switching costs and heterogeneity: a structural examination. Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 9, 25–70. CrossRef
Quelch, J.A., & Court, A.M. (1983). PROCTER & GAMBLE CO. (B). HBS Case, 584048.
Rossi, P.E. (2014). Invited paper – even the rich can make themselves poor: a critical examination of IV methods in marketing applications. Marketing Science, 33, 655–672. CrossRef
Sahni, N.S. (2016). Advertising spillovers: evidence from online field experiments and implications for returns on advertising. Journal of Marketing Research, 53, 459–478. CrossRef
Sahni, N.S., Zou, D., & Chintagunta, P.K. (2016). Do targeted discount offers serve as advertising? Evidence from 70 field experiments. Management Science, forthcoming.
Seiler, S., & Pinna, F. (2016). Estimating search benefits from path-tracking data: measurement and determinants. Marketing Science, forthcoming.
Shapiro, B.T. (2016). Positive spillovers and free riding in advertising of prescription pharmaceuticals: The case of antidepressants. Journal of Political Economy, forthcoming.
Sorensen, H. (2003). The science of shopping. Marketing Research, 15, 31–35.
- The impact of advertising along the conversion funnel
- Publication date
- Springer US