Advertisement
Published in:
2020 | OriginalPaper | Chapter
6. The Social Credit System and China’s Rule of Law
Author : Marianne von Blomberg
Published in: Social Credit Rating
Publisher: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden
Activate our intelligent search to find suitable subject content or patents.
Select sections of text to find matching patents with Artificial Intelligence. powered by
Select sections of text to find additional relevant content using AI-assisted search. powered by
Abstract
In 2014, the People’s Republic of China central government formally declared the construction of a Social Credit System (SCS) a national task. Meanwhile, government-designated localities and companies are experimenting with scoring systems for businesses, citizens and the administration. The government’s initiative introduces mechanisms for a massive aggregation and exchange of data about ‘credit subjects’, pushes for the application of such credit information in the decision-making processes in both the public and the private sector, and elevates the punishment of naming and shaming to new prominence. Its conceptual heritage is social management, a governance strategy born in the political apparatus of the PRC that does not operate with the traditional notion of law. The SCS’ potentially heavy impact, as well as its conceptual heritage in social management, begs the question of what difference it makes to the rule of law in the PRC. A legal framework for the SCS does not (yet) exist. It has been held that the SCS is a powerful tool to strengthen the rule of law. However, this thesis aims to bring to light challenges that arise from the SCS for the rule of law. It does so by considering the SCS’ conceptual cradle, and further mapping what has surfaced of the SCS to date in policy and legislative documents, the commercial credit market, and local pilot projects. Drawing on this comprehensive picture of the SCS, elements which appear at odds with rule of law will be pointed out. They include a lack of legal definitions for SCS key terms such as ‘trustworthiness’, opaque procedures and possible penalties that bypass the law. Ways to integrate them into the Rechtsstaat will be considered, all of which necessitate a re-definition of what law is. Finally, the angle of social management offers a meta-social credit system as a solution to conciliate the SCS and rule of law. The question remains whether the SCS can truly solve all problems that it brings about merely by means of its own conceptual heritage, social management theory – or whether an independent organ outside of itself is indispensable.
[Jiangsu’s Suining Town gives citizens credit grades]. Available from: 
[The Central Bank gives a strong command: Jack Ma officially gets incorporated]. Available from: 
[The Central Bank approved the business license of ‘Baihang Zhengxin’ in Shenzhen as the first personal credit information license. Techweb. Available from: 
. Adopted 28 September 2017 and effective 1st January 2018. Available from: 
[Raise the capacity of building a socialist harmonious society]. [Speech] Beijing,19th February. Available from: 
[Hubei Social Credit Management Regulations]. Adopted 30 March 2017 and effective on 1st July 2017. Available from: 
[The social credit system’s implications and denotations]. Available from: 
[Development and Innovation of the Social Credit System Theory].
[The SCS is no virtue Dang’an]. 
. Available from: 
[Notice on matters relating to the overall advancement of the standardization of social organizations under the social credit number system]. Available from: 
[Notice on publishing the first list of Social Credit System construction model cities.]. Available from: 
[Shanghai Social Credit Regulations]. Adopted 23 June 2017 and effective 1st October 2017. Available from: 
[Memorandum of understanding on joint incentives and discipline for judgment defaulters]. Available from: 
(2014—2020年) [The planning outline for the establishment of a Social Credit System (2014–2020)]. Available from: 
[Note on endorsing the Development and Reform Commission and other Departments’ overall plan for the establishment of a uniform system of credit numbers for legal persons and other organizations]. Available at: 
[Opinions on accelerating and advancing the construction of credit supervision, warning and punishment mechanisms for judgement defaulters]. Available from: 
[Suining Countytrial management rules formass credit]. Available from: 
[Sincerity is the strongest soft power, experts call for the perfection of an effective long-term system], 
, available from: 
[Jiangsu’s Suining credit rating has been running for 4 years, and people are unaware that their complaining about it lead to point deductions]. 
. Available from: 
[Xinlian arrived, the Central Bank handles the application of ‘Baihang Zhengxin’]. Available from: 
[Suining County’s ‘Mass Credit Management Trial Rules’ main substance]. 
. Available from: 
[Jack Ma begins to give credit marks to individuals, come check how you rank among your contacts]. 
. Available from: 
[Innovation and Challenges: Building up a Chinese Social Credit System]. Innovation. 4 (9), 25–32.
[Overview Report on the Construction of China’s Social Credit System]. Available from: 
[‘Credit China’ Website frightens off difficult implementation of court judgements and other trust breaking acts]. 
. Available from: 
[Social management shall defeat systemic obstacles]. 
. Available at: