What makes a good modeling research contribution?

The article delves into the essential criteria for a strong modeling research contribution, particularly for submissions to the Software and Systems Modeling (SOSYM) journal. It identifies common types of modeling contributions, such as new models, languages, core techniques, applications, domains, and tools. The authors emphasize the importance of evaluating these contributions based on their novelty, significance, and rigor. They also highlight the value of incremental research and negative results. The article aims to initiate a community-wide discussion on these criteria and proposes strategies for their implementation and periodic review. Additionally, it suggests ways to attract diverse submissions from other research communities, emphasizing the importance of community validation and continuous adaptation to evolving domain needs.