Weitere Artikel dieser Ausgabe durch Wischen aufrufen
The use of credit checks or credit scores in personnel selection has received widespread media attention of late. Though there is speculation that basing hiring decisions (even partially) on credit-related variables may produce or increase adverse impact, virtually no empirical literature exists to support or refute this claim. The present study explores the impact of using credit scores, in the context of a larger selection system, on adverse impact.
We conducted Monte Carlo simulations representing various real-world selection systems (i.e., multiple hurdle, multiple hurdle with cut-off score, single hurdle). In addition to applicant credit scores, each simulation included variables that organizations commonly use during selection (i.e., educational background, personality).
Results showed that in a majority of simulated hiring scenarios, using credit scores (as opposed to a random, race-neutral variable) widened the Black-White gap in hiring, producing more violations of the 4/5ths rule and statistically significant adverse impact.
These results imply that organizations should be cautious when using credit scores to evaluate potential or current employees for jobs.
This is one of the first studies to provide empirical evidence of a relationship between credit scores in selection and adverse impact. The use of simulations helps organizations be proactive in regards to choosing selection practices. Our results in particular pinpoint the situations where implementing credit scores as part of a larger selection process might be most problematic in terms of adverse impact, thereby providing much needed guidance to those considering credit scores for their selection processes.
Bitte loggen Sie sich ein, um Zugang zu diesem Inhalt zu erhalten
Sie möchten Zugang zu diesem Inhalt erhalten? Dann informieren Sie sich jetzt über unsere Produkte:
Ababneh, K. I., Hackett, R. D., & Schat, A. C. H. (2013). The role of attributions and fairness in understanding applicant reactions to selection procedures and decisions. Journal of Business Psychology.
Adelman, C. (2006). The tool box revisited: Paths to degree completion from high school through college. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
Agresti, A. (1992). A survey of exact inference for contingency tables. Statistical Science, 7, 131–153. CrossRef
Arvey, R., & Renz, G. (1992). Fairness in the selection of employees. Journal of Business Ethics, 11, 331–340. CrossRef
Avis, J. M., Kudisch, J. D., & Fortunato, V. J. (2002). Examining the incremental validity and adverse impact of cognitive ability and conscientiousness on job performance. Journal of Business Psychology, 17, 87–105. CrossRef
Barrick, M. R., & Mount, M. K. (1991). The big five personality dimensions and job performance: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 44, 1–26. CrossRef
Biddle, D. A. (2005). Adverse impact and test validation: A practitioner’s guide to valid and defensible employment testing. London: Gower.
Biddle, D. A. (2006). Adverse impact and test validation: A practitioner’s guide to valid and defensible employment testing (2nd ed.). Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing Company.
Bills, D. (1988). Credentials and capacities: Employers’ perceptions of the acquisition of skills. The Sociological Quarterly, 29, 439–449. CrossRef
Bills, D. (1992). The mutability of educational credentials as hiring criteria: How employers evaluate atypically highly credentialed job candidates. Work and Occupations, 19, 79–95. CrossRef
Birkenmaier, J., & Tyuse, S. W. (2005). Affordable financial services and credit for the poor: The foundation of asset building. Journal of Community Practice, 13, 69–85. CrossRef
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2007, August). Report to the congress on credit scoring and its effects on the availability and affordability of credit. Retrieved from http://www.transunion.com/docs/rev/business/clientSupport/legislativeUpdate/CreditScoreRpt.pdf.
Bobko, P., & Roth, P. L. (2010). An analysis of two methods for assessing and indexing adverse impact: A disconnect between the academic literature and some practice. In J. L. Outtz (Ed.), Adverse impact: Implications for organizational staffing and high stakes selection (pp. 29–49). New York: Routledge.
Bradley, J. P., Nicol, A. A. M., Charbonneau, D., & Meyer, J. P. (2002). Personality correlates of leadership development in Canadian forces officer candidates. Canadian Journal of Behavioral Science, 34, 92–103. CrossRef
Brody, R. G. (2010). Beyond the basic background check: Hiring the “right” employees. Management Research Review, 33, 210. CrossRef
Bureau of Labor Statistics (2011). Labor force characteristics by Race and Ethnicity, 2010. Retrieved on December 15, 2013 from http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsrace2010.pdf.
Bureau of Labor Statistics (2012). Labor force characteristics by Race and Ethnicity, 2011. Retrieved on December 15, 2013 from http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsrace2011.pdf.
Bureau of Labor Statistics (2013). Labor force characteristics by Race and Ethnicity, 2012. Retrieved on December 15, 2013 from http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsrace2012.pdf.
Chideya, F. (1995). Don’t believe the hype: Fighting cultural misinformation about African Americans. New York: A Plume Book.
Costa, P. T, Jr, & McCrae, R. R. (1992). NEO PI-R professional manual. Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources Inc.
Darling-Hammond, L. (2004). The color line in American education: Race, resources, and student achievement. Du Bois Review, 11, 213–246.
Deschenaux, J. (2011, February). States seek to limit employment-related credit checks. Retrieved from www.shrm.org/LegalIssues/StateandLocalResources/Pages/CreditChecks.aspx.
Devereux, P. (2002). Occupational upgrading and the business cycle. Labour, 16, 423–452. CrossRef
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (1978). Uniform Guidelines on employment selection procedures. Federal Register, 43, 38289–38309.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (2010, October 10). EEOC public meeting explores the use of credit histories as employee selection criteria. Retrieved from http://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/newsroom/release/10-20-10b.cfm.
Fine, J., & Davis, J. (2003). Grade retention and enrollment in post-secondary education. Journal of School Psychology, 41, 401–411. CrossRef
Foldes, H. J., Duehr, E. E., & Ones, D. S. (2008). Group differences in personality: Meta-analyses comparing five U.S. racial groups. Personnel Psychology, 61, 579–616. CrossRef
Freeman, C., & Fox, M. A. (2005). Status and trends in the education of American Indians and Alaska Natives. NCES Publication No. 2005-108. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
Gallagher, K. (2006). Rethinking the fair credit reporting act: When requesting credit reports for “employment purposes” goes too far. Iowa Law Review, 91, 1593.
Guion, R. M. (1998). Assessment, measurement, and prediction for personnel decisions. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Gurchiek, K. (2011, November). SHRM: Credit checks are legitimate screening tool. Retrieved from www.shrm.org/about/news/Pages/LegitimateScreeningTool.aspx.
Hargis, M. B., Baltes, B. B., Friend, Y., & Levi, A. (2006). Race differences in termination at work: The role of educational inequality. Journal of Business Psychology, 20, 587–598. CrossRef
Hough, L., Oswald, F., & Ployhart, R. (2001). Adverse impact and group differences in constructs, assessment tools, and personnel selection procedures: Issues and lessons learned. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 9, 152–194. CrossRef
Hughes, R. (2003). Skill or diploma? The potential influence of skill-based pay systems on sources of skills acquisition and degree programs. Work Study, 52, 179–183. CrossRef
Karpoff, J., & Lott, J. (1993). The reputational penalty firms bear from committing criminal fraud. Journal of Law and Economics, 36, 757–802. CrossRef
Löckenhoff, C. E., Terracciano, A., Bienvenu, O., Patriciu, N. S., Nestadt, G., McCrae, R. R., et al. (2008). Ethnicity, education, and the temporal stability of personality traits in the East Baltimore epidemiologic catchment area study. Journal of Research in Personality, 42, 577–598. doi: 10.1016/j.jrp.2007.09.004. CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMed
Lotokowski, V. A., Robbins, S. B., & Noeth, R. J. (2004). The role of academic and non-academic factors in improving college retention. Iowa: American College Testing.
Marcus, B., Lee, K., & Ashton, M. C. (2007). Personality dimensions explaining relationships between integrity tests and counterproductive behavior: Big five, or one in addition? Personnel Psychology, 60, 1–34. CrossRef
Nielsen, M., & Kuhn, K. (2009). Late payments and Leery applicants: Credit checks as a selection test. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 21, 115–130. CrossRef
Ones, D. S., & Anderson, M. (2002). Gender and ethnic group differences on personality scales in selection: Some British data. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 75, 255–276. CrossRef
Outtz, J. A. (Ed.). (2009). Adverse Impact: Implications for organizational staffing and high stakes selection. New York: Routledge.
Pfeffer, J. (1998). The human equation: Building profits by putting people first. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Pruitt, S. W., & Nethercutt, L. L. (2002). The Texaco racial discrimination case and shareholder wealth. Journal of Labor Research, 23, 685–693. CrossRef
Risavy, S. D., & Hausdorf, P. A. (2011). Personality testing in personnel selection: Adverse impact and differential hiring rates. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 19, 18–30. CrossRef
Roberts, B. (2011). Your cheating heart. HR Magazine, 56, 55–60.
Robertson, I., & Smith, M. (2001). Personnel selection. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 74, 441–472. CrossRef
Roscigno, V., & Ainsworth-Darnell, J. (1999). Race, cultural capital, and educational resources: Persistent inequalities and achievement returns. Sociology of Education, 72, 158–178. CrossRef
Siskin, B. R., & Trippi, J. (2005). Statistical issues in litigation. In F. J. Landy (Ed.), Employment discrimination litigation: Behavioral, quantitative, and legal perspectives (pp. 132–166). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Smith, A. (2007, March). EEOC urges caution on unnecessary credit checks. Retrieved from www.shrm.org/Publications/HRNews/Pages/CMS_020975.aspx.
Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) (2010, January 22). Background checking: Conducting credit background checks. Retrieved from http://www.shrm.org/Research/SurveyFindings/Articles/Pages/BackgroundChecking.aspx.
Terpstra, D., Mohamed, A., & Kethley, R. (1999). An analysis of federal court cases involving nine selection devices. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 7, 26–34. CrossRef
Tett, R. P., & Christiansen, N. D. (2007). Personality tests at the crossroads: A response to Morgeson, Campion, Dipboye, Hollenbeck, Murphy, and Schmitt (2007). Personnel Psychology, 60, 967–993. CrossRef
Tett, R. P., Jackson, D. N., & Rothstein, M. (1991). Personality measures as predictors of job performance: A meta-analytic review. Personnel Psychology, 44, 703–742. CrossRef
Tews, M., Michel, J., & Lyons, B. (2010). Beyond personality: The impact of GMA on performance for entry-level service employees. Journal of Service Management, 21, 344–362. CrossRef
Thompson, M. S., Gorin, J. S., Obeidat, K., & Chen, Y.-H. (2006). Understanding differences in postsecondary educational attainment: A comparison of predictive measures for Black and White students. The Journal of Negro Education, 75, 546–562.
Thurm, S. (2011, October). Next frontier in credit scores: Predicting personal behavior. Retrieved from online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203687504576655182086300912.html?mod=googlenews.
Tracey, J., Sturman, M., & Tews, M. (2007). Ability versus personality. Cornell Hotel & Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 48, 313–322. CrossRef
Wentling, R. M., & Palma-Rivas, N. (1997). Diversity in the workforce: A literature review (MDS 934). Berkeley, CA: National Center for Research in Vocational Education.
What’s In Your FICO Score (2012) Retrieved June 2, 2012, from http://www.myfico.com/CreditEducation/WhatsInYourScore.aspx.
Williams, K. Z., Schaffer, M. M., & Ellis, L. E. (2013). Legal risk in selection: An analysis of processes and tools. Journal of Business and Psychology, 28(4), 401–410. CrossRef
Wright, P., Ferris, S., Hiller, J., & Kroll, M. (1995). Competitiveness through management of diversity: Effects on stock price valuation. The Academy of Management Journal, 38, 272–287. CrossRef
- Exploring the Use of Credit Scores in Selection Processes: Beware of Adverse Impact
Sabrina D. Volpone
Derek R. Avery
- Springer US
Neuer Inhalt/© Stellmach, Neuer Inhalt/© Maturus, Pluta Logo/© Pluta