Skip to main content

2014 | Buch

Infrastructure and Poverty in Sub-Saharan Africa

verfasst von: Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon

Verlag: Palgrave Macmillan US

insite
SUCHEN

Über dieses Buch

Infrastructure and Poverty in Sub-Saharan Africa analyzes the extent to which, how, and how fast the infrastructure needs of the poor have been met in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA).

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Frontmatter

Introduction

Chapter 1. Introduction
Abstract
The main objective of this book is to analyze the extent to which, how, and how fast the infrastructure needs of the poor have been met in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). The book also documents the extent to which some key policies have hurt or helped progress in trying to speed up the coverage expansion so clearly needed in the region.1 Whenever possible, we also point to changes that are needed to speed up the processes.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon

Infrastructure, Growth, and the MDGs

Frontmatter
Chapter 2. Infrastructure, Growth, and Country Strategies
Abstract
Our collective understanding of the drivers of growth has evolved significantly over the last two decades (see box 2.1). Current theories and their empirical tests provided a strong case for an explicit recognition of infrastructure as an important driver of growth, and more so in the early stages of economic development. This should have been central to country strategies, including the PRSPs prepared by SSA countries since these were driving the allocation of resources across infrastructure sectors to sustain long-term development plans.1 Yet the treatment of infrastructure issues in PRSPs has long been very weak. More generally, despite some progress, the specific treatment of the key policy and institutional reforms that need to be put in place to ensure the effectiveness of infrastructure investments in terms of growth is still relatively weak. This chapter provides a brief overview of the way in which infrastructure is being addressed by the new “macropolicy” tools adopted by the development community and how infrastructure has been treated in country strategies including PRSPs to date.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Chapter 3. Infrastructure and the MDGs
Abstract
The only infrastructure sectors formally covered by the MDGs are W&S and the access to phone services. With respect to access to phone services, the progress in terms of fixed telephone lines has been slow between 1990 and 2011, with only nine countries registering significant increases in their numbers. This is, however, linked to the rapid adoption of mobile telephony by the population, and it has proven to be good for both growth and the poor. Technological innovation in the use of cellular phones has exploded as seen in money transfers, mobile banking, and bill payments.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Chapter 4. Africa’s Infrastructure Investment Needs
Abstract
For anyone traveling to Africa, the physical evidence of an infrastructure gap is hard to deny. Demand is unmet and this is also what is shown by models estimated to explain why SSA is growing, trading, and reducing its poverty less than it should. The natural follow-up question should then be how much does Africa need to allocate to the infrastructure sectors to meet its growth, trade, and social targets. There are a number of approaches to measure these investment needs in any given sector. The most common approach at the sector level is a bottom-up approach in which information collected at the local level can be added up to get a sense of the total figure needed. In that context, investment requirements are assessed for each sector for a targeted coverage rate, for a given service quality level at a standard local or an international best-practice cost. This type of effort had been conducted for the water MDGs in 2003 but it had not been done for the other infrastructure sectors until recently. One of the main contributions of the AICD study has been to update the estimations for the water sector in 2008 and to conduct similar assessments for a very wide definition of infrastructure needs. Readers interested in the details of the approaches followed for each sector are invited to read the summary report of that study.1
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon

Are Household Needs Being Met?

Frontmatter
Chapter 5. Where Do We Stand on Service Coverage for Households?
Abstract
This chapter focuses on the evidence available on the extent to which the residential demands are being met in Africa. The overview focuses on quantitative cross-country comparisons and hence leaves out a very large volume of anecdotal or country-specific case studies on the evolution of access rates. This is because the emphasis in this book is on data that can be reasonably compared across countries.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Chapter 6. How Big a Problem Is Access for the Poor?
Abstract
The first step in refining the evidence on an access problem and in particular testing the extent to which the poor are worse off than the rest of the population is to try to unbundle the data on access rate in infrastructure into income, consumption, or wealth groups. This raises a significant issue. The data on income and consumption are not available for all countries on a comparable basis. Fortunately, data on access by level of wealth can be provided and the sample is large enough to generate a relatively reliable sense of the level and distribution of access rates for the various infrastructure sectors across wealth groups.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Chapter 7. Are Infrastructure Services Affordable for All Users?
Abstract
Improving access is a step in the right direction. This step will, however, not achieve much if users cannot afford the services they potentially have access to. Being a subjective concept, affordability is quite difficult to define precisely. There are indeed disparities in views on what affordability means. But there are also few rules of thumb that can be used to assess whether a service imposes a reasonable financial burden or not on the users. These are usually defined as a maximum proportion of income or consumption that households should have to pay to meet the basic needs of a specific public service. Some of these rules of thumb have been suggested in the literature, others are more formal statements by international organizations, and yet others belong to the “tool kits” of field experts with a long oral tradition. We use some of these rules in this chapter to offer a diagnostic of the affordability problem in Africa. We then look into the main factors that drive that diagnostic, including the costs and quality of services.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Chapter 8. Are Quality and Production Costs a Problem?
Abstract
This chapter gives a rough sense of the level of the quality of infra-structure services in Africa. An assessment of quality is indeed an essential complement to the discussion of access provided previously. Access to water or electricity 4 hours a day is very different from access 24 hours a day both for households and for the investment climate that affects firms’ decisions. Access to well-maintained roads implies very different transport costs than having to rely on poorly maintained roads. Quality should thus be part of any assessment of the state of infrastructure in Africa. The chapter also looks at the available evidence of the cost efficiency with which services are delivered. If financing needs are to be minimized and tariffs aligned with the ability to pay, cost minimization should be a top concern for policymakers.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon

What Did Past Reforms Achieve and What’s Next?

Frontmatter
Chapter 9. Markets, Institutions, and Reforms
Abstract
This chapter provides an overview of the evolution in the market structures and institutions of the various sectors. The description is partial because it mostly focuses only on two dimensions of market structures and institutions: (1) the extent to which there is some degree of PPI and (2) the extent to which governments have decided to signal their commitment to transparent and accountable regulation by creating an IRA for the infrastructure sectors.1 In the mind of many, these two reforms have been the most important topic of discussion in policy circles working on the transformation of the institutions driving decisions and service delivery in infrastructure.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Chapter 10. Reforming Prices and Subsidies in the Interest of the Poor
Abstract
Ultimately, if Africa’s poor are to have an effective access to infrastructure services, it will be driven by prices and more precisely by the tariff structure that allocates the recovery of recurrent and capital expenditures not only across users but also between users and taxpayers. Indeed, in many instances, taxpayers will be called on simply because subsidies are unavoidable in many of the countries and for many of the services. Average tariffs need to ensure that all costs are recovered by the provider and when they do not, subsidies will have to close the gap between average costs and average tariffs. The main issue then becomes how to make sure that the subsidies are well targeted and do not send the wrong economic signal, that is, do not lead to over- or underconsumption of a service. These concerns are at the center of this chapter, which looks at both the extent to which the current tariff designs are consistent with the services affordability for the poor as well as the need for cost recovery for the operators. We then look at how subsidies and in particular their design could achieve much more than they do.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Chapter 11. Toward an African Infrastructure Strategy to Meet the Needs of the Poor
Abstract
This last chapter draws some lessons from the issues raised in the previous chapters that should be relevant to the design of an infrastructure policy that would include a focus on the poor directly (through prices, subsidies, and technological choices) or indirectly (through an organization of the sector that ensures that services are delivered at the lowest possible costs). The idea is to contribute to the public debate as the international community designs the next wave of reforms for Africa’s infrastructure sectors, given that the reforms of the last two decades have not delivered a big enough bang for the buck and certainly not for the large number of poor in Africa. The poor have not seen their fair share of many of the improvements when such improvements have been observed. The only sector that can be labeled a reasonable success story is telecom but this success can largely be credited to a technological revolution rather than to major institutional reforms in the region.
Antonio Estache, Quentin Wodon
Backmatter
Metadaten
Titel
Infrastructure and Poverty in Sub-Saharan Africa
verfasst von
Antonio Estache
Quentin Wodon
Copyright-Jahr
2014
Verlag
Palgrave Macmillan US
Electronic ISBN
978-1-137-34848-7
Print ISBN
978-1-349-47964-1
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137348487