Skip to main content

2018 | OriginalPaper | Buchkapitel

2. Law Reform and Legal Pluralism Developments

verfasst von : Teleiai Lalotoa Mulitalo Ropinisone Silipa Seumanutafa

Erschienen in: Law Reform in Plural Societies

Verlag: Springer International Publishing

Aktivieren Sie unsere intelligente Suche, um passende Fachinhalte oder Patente zu finden.

search-config
loading …

Abstract

In England, Australia and Canada, there are records of early attempts to establish law reform machinery dating as far back as the fifteenth century. The systematic process of law reform achieved in the nineteenth century was in the form of temporary and part time law reform commissions. The first formal body established to carry out law reform was the 1934 Law Revision Committee in England appointed by Lord Chancellor Sankey. The institutional Law Commission was established under the Law Commission Act of 1975 to be an independent and permanent office staffed by lawyers and support staff. The early literature on law reform offers useful insights for this book on how the forces of government, the bureaucracy and civil society transform law reform machineries and agencies at a given place and time.

Sie haben noch keine Lizenz? Dann Informieren Sie sich jetzt über unsere Produkte:

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft+Technik" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 102.000 Bücher
  • über 537 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Automobil + Motoren
  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Elektrotechnik + Elektronik
  • Energie + Nachhaltigkeit
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Maschinenbau + Werkstoffe
  • Versicherung + Risiko

Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Springer Professional "Wirtschaft"

Online-Abonnement

Mit Springer Professional "Wirtschaft" erhalten Sie Zugriff auf:

  • über 67.000 Bücher
  • über 340 Zeitschriften

aus folgenden Fachgebieten:

  • Bauwesen + Immobilien
  • Business IT + Informatik
  • Finance + Banking
  • Management + Führung
  • Marketing + Vertrieb
  • Versicherung + Risiko




Jetzt Wissensvorsprung sichern!

Fußnoten
1
Hurlburt (1986), p 15; Sutton (1970), p. 19; Kirby (1983).
 
2
Law Commission Act 1965 (UK) ch 22; Geoffrey Sawer (1970), p. 183.
 
3
Neave (2001).
 
4
Commonwealth Secretariat (2005); Sutton, above n 1.
 
5
For example, the Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1996 (Cth) which repealed the Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1973 (Cth), and the Law Reform Commission Act 1970 (Canada) which was later repealed and the Commission was re-established under the Law Commission Act 1996 (Canada).
 
6
Ross (1982), King (1969), pp. 403–410.
 
7
Weisbrot (2002).
 
8
Handford (1999), p. 519.
 
9
Weisbrot (2005), p. 38.
 
10
Law Commission of India, Government of India, Early Beginnings http://​www.​lawcommissionofi​ndia.
 
11
Law Commission Act 1969 (Sri Lanka).
 
12
Constitutional and Law Reform Commission Act 2004 (Papua New Guinea); Law Reform Commission Act (Fiji) ch 26; Law Commission Act (Vanuatu) ch 115; Law Reform Commission Act 1994 (Solomon Islands); Law Commission Act 2007 (Tonga); Law Reform Commission Act 2008 (Samoa).
 
13
Kirby (1983), p. 51.
 
14
Sayers (2009), p. 70.
 
15
Lindsey (2007).
 
16
Atkinson (2005), p. 160; Davis (2005), p. 148.
 
17
Partington (2005), p. 134.
 
18
Sackville (2005), p. 274.
 
19
Glenfield (2005), p. 288.
 
20
Payne (2005), p. 302.
 
21
Mason (2005), p. 314.
 
22
Kirby (2005), p. 433.
 
23
Powles (2005), pp. 404–421.
 
24
Ibid, 414.
 
25
Slade (2004).
 
26
Lindsey (2007).
 
27
Goodpaster (2007), p. 134.
 
28
Dick (2007), p. 42.
 
29
Neilson (2007), p. 313.
 
30
Lindsey, above n 26.
 
31
Watson (1974).
 
32
Dale (1993), p. 80.
 
33
Legal transplantation has its origins in Montesquieu C The Spirit of Laws [Thomas Nugent trans] Available online http://​www.​thefederalistpap​ers.​org/​wp-content/​uploads/​2013/​01/​The-Spirit-of-The-Laws.​pdf; Teubner (1998), p. 12; Lindsey, above n 26.
 
34
Grajzl and Dimitrova-Grajzl (2009), p. 615.
 
35
Ojwang (1986), p. 115.
 
36
Lindsey, above n 26, 3–41.
 
37
Ojwang, above n 35, 99–123.
 
38
Watson, above n 31.
 
39
Watson (1976), p. 79; Berkowitz et al. (2003), p. 168.
 
40
Grajzl and Grajzl, above n 34.
 
41
For example, the Constitution of Samoa (Samoa) art 111; Constitution of Solomon Islands (Solomon Islands) sch 2.
 
42
Constitution of Samoa 1962 (Samoa) art 103; Constitution of Vanuatu (Vanuatu) arts 51, 52.
 
43
Cotterell (2001), p. 79.
 
44
Watson, above n 39, 83.
 
45
Nelken (2001), p. 47.
 
46
Ibid.
 
47
Lamour (2005).
 
48
Ibid 189.
 
49
Black (2011), p. 184.
 
50
Salman (2006) p. 13. Codification has received many definitions and has been fully studied in many areas such as in the United States, France, England and African states.
 
51
Field (1866), Onuoha (2008).
 
52
Narebo (1991), p. 55. For the benefits of codification in certain American states, see Miller (1886), pp. 315–322.
 
53
Danino (2005), p. 5.
 
54
For example, on the experiences of some African states, see Fenrich et al. (2001). The difficulties of the application of the Natal Code of Native Law in 1878 (Welsh 1971) are further discussed in McClendon (1996).
 
55
Bennett and Vermeulen (1980).
 
56
Ali (1994).
 
57
Danino (2005).
 
58
Australian Law Reform Commission, Recognition of Aboriginal Customary Laws, Report 31 (1986) 122.
 
59
Webber (2009), p. 624.
 
60
Bennett and Vermuelen, above n 55, 216.
 
61
Ali, above n 56.
 
62
Ibid.
 
63
Powles, above n 23, 410.
 
64
Bennett and Vermuelen, above n 55, 209.
 
65
Danino, above n 57.
 
66
Allot and Cotran (1971), p. 18.
 
67
Salman (2006), p. 15.
 
68
Vanderlinden, 3 Journal of African Customary Law 165, 168.
 
69
Twining (1963), p. 221.
 
70
Epiphany (1991), p. 289.
 
71
Ali, above n 56, 359.
 
72
Roberts (1971), pp. 12–21. Roberts argues that one of the problems in recording the customary laws of Africa was the method employed. He opposes interviews as an interview respondent’s opinion cannot reflect a true account of customary laws. He proposes 3 methods of investigation consisting of interviews, investigating related court decisions and observations.
 
73
Ali, above n 56, noted that Kenya’s lengthy attempts to ascertain and restate the customary law of various tribes in Kenya produced more uncertainties than anticipated.
 
74
Oyebanji (1991), p. 270.
 
75
Vanderlinden, above n 68.
 
76
Morse and Woodman (1988), p. 13.
 
77
Australian Law Reform Commission, Recognition of Aboriginal Customary Laws, ALRC Report 31 (1986) 122.
 
78
Electoral Amendment Act 2009 No 21 (Samoa) s 5.
 
79
Constitution of Papua New Guinea (Papua New Guinea) sch 2.1; Constitution of Solomon Islands (Solomon Islands) sch 3(2); Constitution of the Republic of Vanuatu (Vanuatu) s 95(3), Constitution of the Federated States of Micronesia (Federated States of Micronesia) art V.1.
 
80
Village Fono Act 1990 (Samoa) s 8.
 
81
Australian Law Reform Commission, above n 77.
 
82
For example, the Constitution of Papua New Guinea (Papua New Guinea) sch 2.1; Constitution of Solomon Islands (Solomon Islands) sch 3(2); Constitution of the Independent State of Samoa (Samoa) art 111; Underlying Law Act 2000 (Papua New Guinea); Customs Recognition Act (Papua New Guinea) ch 19; Customs Recognition Act 2000 (Solomon Islands). There is useful literature that discusses the difficulties in implementing some of these legislation for example, see Care and Zorn (2001), p. 49.
 
83
Conte (2005), Boister (2005).
 
84
MacFarlane and Lakshman (2005).
 
85
Slade, above n 25, 74.
 
86
Sayers, above n 14.
 
87
MacFarlane and Lakshman, above n 84.
 
88
Six law reform institutions established under legislation in the Pacific Islands, see above, n 12.
 
89
Appendix C Section 2 presents a summary of the statutory functions of the law reform commissions of the Pacific Islands.
 
90
Leung-Wai (2008).
 
91
Kabui and Guthleben (2008).
 
92
Ishmael (2008).
 
93
Narokobi (1986), p. 227.
 
94
Corrin (2006), p. 185.
 
95
For example, see Weisbrot (1988), pp. 1–5.
 
96
Care (2005).
 
97
Slade, above n 25.
 
98
Nand (2008).
 
99
Powles, above n 23, 414.
 
100
Corrin (2008), p. 305.
 
101
Sharafi (2008), p. 139.
 
102
Galanter (1981), p. 36.
 
103
Griffiths (1986).
 
104
Baxi (1986), 51–61.
 
105
Santos (2002), pp. 85–98.
 
106
Tamanaha (2008), p. 378.
 
107
Merry (1988), pp. 869–896.
 
108
Chiba (1986).
 
109
Moore (1973), p. 720.
 
110
Tamanaha (2008), p. 390.
 
111
Merry, above n 107, 874; Chiba, 1986; and others discussed in this review. For contributions on legal pluralism in family law see for example Wardle (1998), pp. 381–396.
 
112
Moore, above n 109, 719; Santos, above n 105, 85–98.
 
113
Baxi, above n 104; Griffiths, above n 103; Galanter, above n 102.
 
114
Sack (1986).
 
115
Tamanaha, above n 110.
 
116
Sack, above n 114, 1.
 
117
Merry, above n 107.
 
118
Michaels (2009).
 
119
Santos, above n 105, 92. In chapter 5 of this text, Santos provides a useful overview of postmodern pluralism.
 
120
Griffiths (2002), pp. 289, 298.
 
121
Michaels, above n 118, 243–262.
 
122
Ibid.
 
123
Wardle, above n 111, 381–396.
 
124
Griffiths, above n 120.
 
125
Narokobi (1989), Corrin (2001), pp. 277–305.
 
126
Weisbrot (1984), pp. 51–59; Care (2006), pp. 27–60.
 
127
Weisbrot (1981), pp. 717–731; Corrin (2008), pp. 305–333.
 
128
The International Council on Human Rights (2009).
 
129
New Zealand Law Commission (2006).
 
130
Techera (2009).
 
131
Ntumy (1995), p. 17.
 
132
Farran (2009), 181–195.
 
133
Weisbrot, above n 95; Narokobi, above n 93, 227; Efi (2009), pp. 153–172.
 
134
New Zealand Law Commission, above n 129, 242.
 
135
Vaai (1999), p. 265.
 
136
Lunabek (2008).
 
137
Narokobi, above 93, 226.
 
138
Vaai (1997), pp. 225, 242.
 
139
Hassall and Saunders (2013), p. 186.
 
140
Ntumy, above n 131, 16.
 
141
Corrin and Paterson (2011), p. 9.
 
142
Efi, above n 133, 17.
 
Literatur
Zurück zum Zitat Ali OH (1994) The conversion of customary law to written law. In: Alison D, Rentlen AD (eds) Folk law: essays in the theory and practice of lex non scripta. University of Wisconsin Press, p 1 Ali OH (1994) The conversion of customary law to written law. In: Alison D, Rentlen AD (eds) Folk law: essays in the theory and practice of lex non scripta. University of Wisconsin Press, p 1
Zurück zum Zitat Allot AN, Cotran E (1971) A background paper on restatement of laws in Africa: the need, value and methods of such restatement. In: Allot AN (ed) Integration of customary and modern legal system in Africa. Africana Publishers Corporation, New York, p 18 Allot AN, Cotran E (1971) A background paper on restatement of laws in Africa: the need, value and methods of such restatement. In: Allot AN (ed) Integration of customary and modern legal system in Africa. Africana Publishers Corporation, New York, p 18
Zurück zum Zitat Atkinson R (2005) Law reform and community participation. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 160 Atkinson R (2005) Law reform and community participation. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 160
Zurück zum Zitat Australian Law Reform Commission (1986) Recognition of aboriginal customary laws. ALRC Report 31(1986) Australian Law Reform Commission (1986) Recognition of aboriginal customary laws. ALRC Report 31(1986)
Zurück zum Zitat Baxi U (1986) Disciplines, repression and legal pluralism. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop, vol VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra, pp 51–61 Baxi U (1986) Disciplines, repression and legal pluralism. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop, vol VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra, pp 51–61
Zurück zum Zitat Bennett TW, Vermeulen T (1980) Codification of customary law. J Afr Law 24(2):206CrossRef Bennett TW, Vermeulen T (1980) Codification of customary law. J Afr Law 24(2):206CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Berkowitz D, Pistor K, Richard JF (2003) The transplant effect. Am J Comp Law 51(1):163, 168 Berkowitz D, Pistor K, Richard JF (2003) The transplant effect. Am J Comp Law 51(1):163, 168
Zurück zum Zitat Black CF (2011) The land is the source of the law – A dialogic encounter with the indigenous jurisprudence. Routledge UK Black CF (2011) The land is the source of the law – A dialogic encounter with the indigenous jurisprudence. Routledge UK
Zurück zum Zitat Boister N (2005) Regional cooperation in the suppression of transnational crime in the South Pacific. In: Geoff L, von Tigerstrom B (eds) International law issues in the South Pacific. Ashgate, England Boister N (2005) Regional cooperation in the suppression of transnational crime in the South Pacific. In: Geoff L, von Tigerstrom B (eds) International law issues in the South Pacific. Ashgate, England
Zurück zum Zitat Care JC (2005) Legal representation, training and legislative drafting in smaller jurisdictions. Paper presented at the Commonwealth Law Conference, United Kingdom, 11–15 September 2005 Care JC (2005) Legal representation, training and legislative drafting in smaller jurisdictions. Paper presented at the Commonwealth Law Conference, United Kingdom, 11–15 September 2005
Zurück zum Zitat Care JC (2006) A green stick or a fresh stick? Locating customary penalties in the post-colonial era. Oxford Univ Commonw Law J 6(1):27–60 Care JC (2006) A green stick or a fresh stick? Locating customary penalties in the post-colonial era. Oxford Univ Commonw Law J 6(1):27–60
Zurück zum Zitat Care JC, Zorn JG (2001) Legislating pluralism: statutory developments in Melanesian customary law. J Leg Pluralism 46:49CrossRef Care JC, Zorn JG (2001) Legislating pluralism: statutory developments in Melanesian customary law. J Leg Pluralism 46:49CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Chiba M (ed) (1986) Asian indigenous law: in interaction with received law. KPI, New York Chiba M (ed) (1986) Asian indigenous law: in interaction with received law. KPI, New York
Zurück zum Zitat Commonwealth Secretariat (2005) Law reform agencies: their role and effectiveness. Paper presented at the meeting of commonwealth law ministers and senior officials, Accra, Ghana, 17–20 October 2005 Commonwealth Secretariat (2005) Law reform agencies: their role and effectiveness. Paper presented at the meeting of commonwealth law ministers and senior officials, Accra, Ghana, 17–20 October 2005
Zurück zum Zitat Conte A (2005) International terrorism and the South Pacific. In: Geoff L, von Tigerstrom B (eds) International law issues in the South Pacific. Ashgate, England Conte A (2005) International terrorism and the South Pacific. In: Geoff L, von Tigerstrom B (eds) International law issues in the South Pacific. Ashgate, England
Zurück zum Zitat Corrin J (2001) Customary land in Solomon Islands: a victim of legal pluralism. Revue Juridique Polynesienne 12:277–305 Corrin J (2001) Customary land in Solomon Islands: a victim of legal pluralism. Revue Juridique Polynesienne 12:277–305
Zurück zum Zitat Corrin J (2006) Finding the right balance in plural systems: training lawyers in the South Pacific. J Commonw Law Leg Educ 4(2):171, 185 Corrin J (2006) Finding the right balance in plural systems: training lawyers in the South Pacific. J Commonw Law Leg Educ 4(2):171, 185
Zurück zum Zitat Corrin J (2008) Customary law and the language of common law. Commonw Law World Rev 37 Corrin J (2008) Customary law and the language of common law. Commonw Law World Rev 37
Zurück zum Zitat Corrin J, Paterson D (2011) Introduction to South Pacific law. Palgrave Macmillan Corrin J, Paterson D (2011) Introduction to South Pacific law. Palgrave Macmillan
Zurück zum Zitat Cotterell R (2001) Is there a logic for legal transplants? In: Nelken D, Feest J (eds) Adapting legal cultures. Hart, Oxford, p 79 Cotterell R (2001) Is there a logic for legal transplants? In: Nelken D, Feest J (eds) Adapting legal cultures. Hart, Oxford, p 79
Zurück zum Zitat Dale W (1993) The making and remaking of commonwealth constitutions. Int Comp Law Q 42:67, 80 Dale W (1993) The making and remaking of commonwealth constitutions. Int Comp Law Q 42:67, 80
Zurück zum Zitat Danino R (2005) Customary law systems as vehicles for providing equitable access to justice for the poor and local governance, the Peruvian experience. In: Leadership dialogue with traditional authorities, Kumani, Ghana, December 5, 2005 Danino R (2005) Customary law systems as vehicles for providing equitable access to justice for the poor and local governance, the Peruvian experience. In: Leadership dialogue with traditional authorities, Kumani, Ghana, December 5, 2005
Zurück zum Zitat Davis I (2005) Targeted consultations. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 148 Davis I (2005) Targeted consultations. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 148
Zurück zum Zitat Dick H (2007) Why law reform fails, Indonesia’s anti-corruption reforms. In Lindsey T (ed) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York, p 42 Dick H (2007) Why law reform fails, Indonesia’s anti-corruption reforms. In Lindsey T (ed) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York, p 42
Zurück zum Zitat Efi TATT (2009) Samoa jurisprudence and the Samoan lands and titles court: the perspective of a litigant. In: Suaalii-Sauni et al (eds) Su’esu’e manogi: in search of fragrance: Tui Atua Tupua Tamasese Ta’isi and the Samoan indigenous reference. National University of Samoa, pp 153–172 Efi TATT (2009) Samoa jurisprudence and the Samoan lands and titles court: the perspective of a litigant. In: Suaalii-Sauni et al (eds) Su’esu’e manogi: in search of fragrance: Tui Atua Tupua Tamasese Ta’isi and the Samoan indigenous reference. National University of Samoa, pp 153–172
Zurück zum Zitat Epiphany A (1991) Codification of customary law: a mission impossible? In: Osinbajo Y, Kalu AU (eds) Towards a restatement of customary law. Federal Ministry of Justice Lagos, p 289 Epiphany A (1991) Codification of customary law: a mission impossible? In: Osinbajo Y, Kalu AU (eds) Towards a restatement of customary law. Federal Ministry of Justice Lagos, p 289
Zurück zum Zitat Farran S (2009) Palm tree justice? The role of comparative law in the South Pacific. Int Comp Law Q 58:181–195CrossRef Farran S (2009) Palm tree justice? The role of comparative law in the South Pacific. Int Comp Law Q 58:181–195CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Fenrich J, Galizzi P, Higgins T (eds) (2001) The future of African customary law. Cambridge University Press Fenrich J, Galizzi P, Higgins T (eds) (2001) The future of African customary law. Cambridge University Press
Zurück zum Zitat Field D (1866) Codification. Am Law Rev 20:1 Field D (1866) Codification. Am Law Rev 20:1
Zurück zum Zitat Galanter M (1981) Justice in many rooms: courts private ordering and indigenous Law. J Leg Pluralism Unofficial Law 19(25):36 Galanter M (1981) Justice in many rooms: courts private ordering and indigenous Law. J Leg Pluralism Unofficial Law 19(25):36
Zurück zum Zitat Grajzl P, Dimitrova-Grajzl V (2009) The choice in the lawmaking process: Legal transplants vs. Indigenous law. Review of Law & Economics 5(1):615 Grajzl P, Dimitrova-Grajzl V (2009) The choice in the lawmaking process: Legal transplants vs. Indigenous law. Review of Law & Economics 5(1):615
Zurück zum Zitat Glenfield L (2005) Law reform through the executive. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 288 Glenfield L (2005) Law reform through the executive. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 288
Zurück zum Zitat Goodpaster G (2007) Law reform in developing countries. In: Lindsey T (ed) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York, p 134 Goodpaster G (2007) Law reform in developing countries. In: Lindsey T (ed) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York, p 134
Zurück zum Zitat Griffiths J (1986) What is legal pluralism? J Leg Pluralism 24:1 Griffiths J (1986) What is legal pluralism? J Leg Pluralism 24:1
Zurück zum Zitat Griffiths A (2002) Legal pluralism. In: Banaka R, Travers M (eds) An introduction to law and social theory. Hart, p 298 Griffiths A (2002) Legal pluralism. In: Banaka R, Travers M (eds) An introduction to law and social theory. Hart, p 298
Zurück zum Zitat Handford P (1999) The changing face of law reform. Aust Law J 37:519 Handford P (1999) The changing face of law reform. Aust Law J 37:519
Zurück zum Zitat Hassall G, Saunders C (2013) Asia-Pacific constitutional systems. Cambridge University Press Hassall G, Saunders C (2013) Asia-Pacific constitutional systems. Cambridge University Press
Zurück zum Zitat Hurlburt WH (1986) Law reform commissions in the United Kingdom, Australia and Canada. Juriliber Limited, Canada Hurlburt WH (1986) Law reform commissions in the United Kingdom, Australia and Canada. Juriliber Limited, Canada
Zurück zum Zitat Ishmael KA (2008) The birth and rebirth of law reform agencies: the establishment of Vanuatu’s Law Reform Commission. Paper presented to the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008 Ishmael KA (2008) The birth and rebirth of law reform agencies: the establishment of Vanuatu’s Law Reform Commission. Paper presented to the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008
Zurück zum Zitat Kabui F, Guthleben A (2008) The establishment of a Commission in Solomon Islands. Paper presented to the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008 Kabui F, Guthleben A (2008) The establishment of a Commission in Solomon Islands. Paper presented to the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008
Zurück zum Zitat King DB (1969) The law reform challenge. Saint Louis Univ Law J 13:403–410 King DB (1969) The law reform challenge. Saint Louis Univ Law J 13:403–410
Zurück zum Zitat Kirby M (1983) Reform the law. Oxford University Press Kirby M (1983) Reform the law. Oxford University Press
Zurück zum Zitat Kirby M (2005) Are we there yet? In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 433 Kirby M (2005) Are we there yet? In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 433
Zurück zum Zitat Lamour P (2005) Foreign flowers. University of Hawaii Press Lamour P (2005) Foreign flowers. University of Hawaii Press
Zurück zum Zitat Leung-Wai MC (2008) Samoa’s experience with the establishment of a law reform commission. Paper presented to the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008 Leung-Wai MC (2008) Samoa’s experience with the establishment of a law reform commission. Paper presented to the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008
Zurück zum Zitat Lindsey T (ed) (2007) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York Lindsey T (ed) (2007) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York
Zurück zum Zitat Lunabek V (2008) Judicial activism. Paper presented at the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008 Lunabek V (2008) Judicial activism. Paper presented at the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Vanuatu, 10–12 Sept 2008
Zurück zum Zitat MacFarlane P, Lakshman C (2005) Law reform in the South Pacific. J S Pac Law 9(1) MacFarlane P, Lakshman C (2005) Law reform in the South Pacific. J S Pac Law 9(1)
Zurück zum Zitat Mason A (2005) Law reform and the courts. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 314 Mason A (2005) Law reform and the courts. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 314
Zurück zum Zitat McClendon TV (1996) A dangerous doctrine - twins, ethnography and the Natal code. Presented as a paper at the Stanford-Berkeley and UCLA Symposium on law, colonialism, and inheritance in Africa, 10 May 1996 McClendon TV (1996) A dangerous doctrine - twins, ethnography and the Natal code. Presented as a paper at the Stanford-Berkeley and UCLA Symposium on law, colonialism, and inheritance in Africa, 10 May 1996
Zurück zum Zitat Miller SF (1886) Codification. Am Law Rev 20:315–322 Miller SF (1886) Codification. Am Law Rev 20:315–322
Zurück zum Zitat Moore SF (1973) Law and social change: the semi-autonomous field as an appropriate subject of study. Law Soc Rev 7(4):720CrossRef Moore SF (1973) Law and social change: the semi-autonomous field as an appropriate subject of study. Law Soc Rev 7(4):720CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Morse BW, Woodman GR (1988) Introductory essay: the state’s options. In: Morse BW, Woodman GR (eds) Indigenous law and the state. Foris Publications, Dordrecht, p 13 Morse BW, Woodman GR (1988) Introductory essay: the state’s options. In: Morse BW, Woodman GR (eds) Indigenous law and the state. Foris Publications, Dordrecht, p 13
Zurück zum Zitat Nand N (2008) Legislative drafting, distance education and its contribution to good governance in the Pacific. Paper for the 5th Pan-Commonwealth forum on open learning, July London, 13–17 July 2008 Nand N (2008) Legislative drafting, distance education and its contribution to good governance in the Pacific. Paper for the 5th Pan-Commonwealth forum on open learning, July London, 13–17 July 2008
Zurück zum Zitat Narebo D (1991) Codification of customary law. In: Osinbajo Y, Kalu AW (eds) Towards a restatement of customary law in Nigeria. Nigeria Federal Ministry of Justice, p 55 Narebo D (1991) Codification of customary law. In: Osinbajo Y, Kalu AW (eds) Towards a restatement of customary law in Nigeria. Nigeria Federal Ministry of Justice, p 55
Zurück zum Zitat Narokobi B (1986) In search of a Melanesian jurisprudence. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra 227 Narokobi B (1986) In search of a Melanesian jurisprudence. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra 227
Zurück zum Zitat Narokobi B (1989) Lo bilong yumi yet, law and custom in Melanesia. The Melanesian institute for pastoral and socio-economic service and the University of the South Pacific Narokobi B (1989) Lo bilong yumi yet, law and custom in Melanesia. The Melanesian institute for pastoral and socio-economic service and the University of the South Pacific
Zurück zum Zitat Neave M (2001) Law reform in the 21st century – some challenges for the future. Commissioners’ Speeches with the Victorian Law Reform Commission, Victoria Australia, 11 October 2001 Neave M (2001) Law reform in the 21st century – some challenges for the future. Commissioners’ Speeches with the Victorian Law Reform Commission, Victoria Australia, 11 October 2001
Zurück zum Zitat Neilson WA (2007) Competition laws for Asian transnational economies: adaption to local legal cultures in Vietnam. In: Lindsey T (ed) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York, p 313 Neilson WA (2007) Competition laws for Asian transnational economies: adaption to local legal cultures in Vietnam. In: Lindsey T (ed) Law reform in developing and transitional states. Routledge, New York, p 313
Zurück zum Zitat Nelken D (2001) Towards a sociology of legal adaptation. In: Nelken D, Feest J (eds) Adapting legal cultures. Hart, Oxford, p 47 Nelken D (2001) Towards a sociology of legal adaptation. In: Nelken D, Feest J (eds) Adapting legal cultures. Hart, Oxford, p 47
Zurück zum Zitat New Zealand Law Commission (2006) Converging Currents: Custom and Human Rights in the Pacific. Study Paper 17 New Zealand Law Commission (2006) Converging Currents: Custom and Human Rights in the Pacific. Study Paper 17
Zurück zum Zitat Ntumy M (1995) The dream of a Melanesian jurisprudence. In Aleck J, Jackson R (eds) Customs at the Crossroads, UPNG Law Faculty, p 17 Ntumy M (1995) The dream of a Melanesian jurisprudence. In Aleck J, Jackson R (eds) Customs at the Crossroads, UPNG Law Faculty, p 17
Zurück zum Zitat Ojwang J (1986) Legal transplantation: rethinking the role and significance of Western Law in Africa. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra 115 Ojwang J (1986) Legal transplantation: rethinking the role and significance of Western Law in Africa. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra 115
Zurück zum Zitat Onuoha RA (2008) Discriminatory property inheritance under customary law in Nigeria: NGOs to the rescue. Int J Not-for-Profit Law 10:2 Onuoha RA (2008) Discriminatory property inheritance under customary law in Nigeria: NGOs to the rescue. Int J Not-for-Profit Law 10:2
Zurück zum Zitat Oyebanji MB (1991) Codification of customary law: prospect and problems. In: Osinbajo Y, Kalu AU (eds) Towards a restatement of customary law. Federal Ministry of Justice Lagos, p 270 Oyebanji MB (1991) Codification of customary law: prospect and problems. In: Osinbajo Y, Kalu AU (eds) Towards a restatement of customary law. Federal Ministry of Justice Lagos, p 270
Zurück zum Zitat Partington M (2005) Research. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 134 Partington M (2005) Research. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 134
Zurück zum Zitat Payne M (2005) Law reform and the legislature. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 302 Payne M (2005) Law reform and the legislature. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 302
Zurück zum Zitat Powles G (2005) The challenge of law reform in Pacific Island states. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, pp 404–421 Powles G (2005) The challenge of law reform in Pacific Island states. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, pp 404–421
Zurück zum Zitat Roberts S (ed) (1971) The recording of customary law: some problems of method, folk law: essays in the theory and practice of Lex Non Scripta. University of Wisconsin Press, p 1994 Roberts S (ed) (1971) The recording of customary law: some problems of method, folk law: essays in the theory and practice of Lex Non Scripta. University of Wisconsin Press, p 1994
Zurück zum Zitat Ross S (1982) Politics of law reform. Penguin Books, Melbourne Ross S (1982) Politics of law reform. Penguin Books, Melbourne
Zurück zum Zitat Sack PG (1986) Legal pluralism: introductory comments. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra Sack PG (1986) Legal pluralism: introductory comments. In: Sack P, Minchin E (eds) Legal pluralism, proceedings of the Canberra law workshop VII. Pink Panther, ANU Canberra
Zurück zum Zitat Sackville R (2005) Law reform agencies and royal commissions: tolling in the same field? In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 274 Sackville R (2005) Law reform agencies and royal commissions: tolling in the same field? In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press, p 274
Zurück zum Zitat Salman RK (2006) Codification and restatement of customary law in Africa: the journey so far. In: Borokini AA (ed) Kogi Reading in law. Stebak Books & Publishers, Akure Salman RK (2006) Codification and restatement of customary law in Africa: the journey so far. In: Borokini AA (ed) Kogi Reading in law. Stebak Books & Publishers, Akure
Zurück zum Zitat Santos BdeS (2002) Toward a new legal common sense, 2nd edn. Thompson Litho Ltd, Scotland, pp 85–98 Santos BdeS (2002) Toward a new legal common sense, 2nd edn. Thompson Litho Ltd, Scotland, pp 85–98
Zurück zum Zitat Sawer SG (1970) The legal theory of law reform. Univ Toronto Law J 20:183CrossRef Sawer SG (1970) The legal theory of law reform. Univ Toronto Law J 20:183CrossRef
Zurück zum Zitat Sayers M (2009) Law reform in the commonwealth, in small states and in the Caribbean. Commonw Law Bull 35(1):69, 70 Sayers M (2009) Law reform in the commonwealth, in small states and in the Caribbean. Commonw Law Bull 35(1):69, 70
Zurück zum Zitat Sharafi M (2008) Justice in many rooms since Galanter. Law Contemp Probl 71:139 Sharafi M (2008) Justice in many rooms since Galanter. Law Contemp Probl 71:139
Zurück zum Zitat Slade TN (2004) Law reform potential in the Pacific area. Paper presented at the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Wellington New Zealand, 13–16 April 2004 Slade TN (2004) Law reform potential in the Pacific area. Paper presented at the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference, Wellington New Zealand, 13–16 April 2004
Zurück zum Zitat Sutton TC (1970) The pattern of law reform in Australia. University of Queensland Press Sutton TC (1970) The pattern of law reform in Australia. University of Queensland Press
Zurück zum Zitat Tamanaha BZ (2008) Understanding legal pluralism: past and present, local to global. Sydn Law Rev 30:378 Tamanaha BZ (2008) Understanding legal pluralism: past and present, local to global. Sydn Law Rev 30:378
Zurück zum Zitat Techera EJ (2009) Law, customs and conservation, the role of customary law in community-based marine management in the South Pacific. Dissertation, Macquarie University Techera EJ (2009) Law, customs and conservation, the role of customary law in community-based marine management in the South Pacific. Dissertation, Macquarie University
Zurück zum Zitat Teubner G (1998) Legal irritants: good faith in British law or how unifying law ends up in new divergences. Mod Law Rev 61(1):12 Teubner G (1998) Legal irritants: good faith in British law or how unifying law ends up in new divergences. Mod Law Rev 61(1):12
Zurück zum Zitat The International Council on Human Rights (2009) When legal worlds overlap, human rights, state, and non-state law. ATAR Roto Press SA, Vernier, Switzerland The International Council on Human Rights (2009) When legal worlds overlap, human rights, state, and non-state law. ATAR Roto Press SA, Vernier, Switzerland
Zurück zum Zitat Twining W (1963) The restatement of African customary law: a comment. J Mod Am Stud 1(2):221 Twining W (1963) The restatement of African customary law: a comment. J Mod Am Stud 1(2):221
Zurück zum Zitat Vaai S (1997) The idea of law, a Pacific perspective. J Pac Stud 21:225 Vaai S (1997) The idea of law, a Pacific perspective. J Pac Stud 21:225
Zurück zum Zitat Vaai S (1999) Samoa faamatai and the rule of law. The National University of Samoa Vaai S (1999) Samoa faamatai and the rule of law. The National University of Samoa
Zurück zum Zitat Vanderlinden J, The recording of customary law in France during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries and in recording of African customary law. J Afr Customary Law 3:165, 168 Vanderlinden J, The recording of customary law in France during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries and in recording of African customary law. J Afr Customary Law 3:165, 168
Zurück zum Zitat Wardle LD (1998) Same-sex marriage and the limits of legal pluralism. In: Eekelaar J, Nhlapo T (eds) The changing family, family forms and family law. Hart, Oxford, pp 381–396 Wardle LD (1998) Same-sex marriage and the limits of legal pluralism. In: Eekelaar J, Nhlapo T (eds) The changing family, family forms and family law. Hart, Oxford, pp 381–396
Zurück zum Zitat Watson A (1974) Legal transplants: an approach to comparative law. Edinburgh Watson A (1974) Legal transplants: an approach to comparative law. Edinburgh
Zurück zum Zitat Watson A (1976) Legal transplants and law reform. Law Q Rev 92:79 Watson A (1976) Legal transplants and law reform. Law Q Rev 92:79
Zurück zum Zitat Webber J (2009) The grammar of customary law. McGill Law J 41(579):624 Webber J (2009) The grammar of customary law. McGill Law J 41(579):624
Zurück zum Zitat Weisbrot D (1981) Customizing the Common Law: The True Papua New Guinea Experience. Am Bar Association J 67:717–731 Weisbrot D (1981) Customizing the Common Law: The True Papua New Guinea Experience. Am Bar Association J 67:717–731
Zurück zum Zitat Weisbrot D (1984) The recognition of custom in Papua New Guinea and the Pacific. Ch 16 in the report of working seminar on the aboriginal customary law reference, Australian Law Reform Commission and Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies 51-59 Weisbrot D (1984) The recognition of custom in Papua New Guinea and the Pacific. Ch 16 in the report of working seminar on the aboriginal customary law reference, Australian Law Reform Commission and Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies 51-59
Zurück zum Zitat Weisbrot D (1988) Papua New Guinea’s indigenous jurisprudence and the legacy of colonialism. Univ Hawaii Law Rev 10(1):1–5 Weisbrot D (1988) Papua New Guinea’s indigenous jurisprudence and the legacy of colonialism. Univ Hawaii Law Rev 10(1):1–5
Zurück zum Zitat Weisbrot D (2002) What is the value of a full time standing law reform commission? Paper presented at the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference. Darwin, 20 June 2002 Weisbrot D (2002) What is the value of a full time standing law reform commission? Paper presented at the Australasian Law Reform Agencies Conference. Darwin, 20 June 2002
Zurück zum Zitat Weisbrot D (2005) The future for institutional law reform. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press Weisbrot D (2005) The future for institutional law reform. In: Opeskin B, Weisbrot D (eds) The promise of law reform. Federation Press
Zurück zum Zitat Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1996 (Cth) Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1996 (Cth)
Zurück zum Zitat Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1973 (Cth) Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1973 (Cth)
Zurück zum Zitat Constitutional and Law Reform Commission Act 2004 (Papua New Guinea) Constitutional and Law Reform Commission Act 2004 (Papua New Guinea)
Zurück zum Zitat Constitution of Papua New Guinea (Papua New Guinea) Constitution of Papua New Guinea (Papua New Guinea)
Zurück zum Zitat Constitution of Solomon Islands (Solomon Islands) Constitution of Solomon Islands (Solomon Islands)
Zurück zum Zitat Constitution of the Federated States of Micronesia (Federated States of Micronesia) Constitution of the Federated States of Micronesia (Federated States of Micronesia)
Zurück zum Zitat Constitution of the Independent State of Samoa (Samoa) Constitution of the Independent State of Samoa (Samoa)
Zurück zum Zitat Constitution of the Republic of Vanuatu (Vanuatu) Constitution of the Republic of Vanuatu (Vanuatu)
Zurück zum Zitat Customs Recognition Act 1963 (Papua New Guinea) Customs Recognition Act 1963 (Papua New Guinea)
Zurück zum Zitat Customs Recognition Act 2000 (Solomon Islands) Customs Recognition Act 2000 (Solomon Islands)
Zurück zum Zitat Electoral Amendment Act 2009 No 21 (Samoa) Electoral Amendment Act 2009 No 21 (Samoa)
Zurück zum Zitat Law Reform Commission Act 1970 (Canada) Law Reform Commission Act 1970 (Canada)
Zurück zum Zitat Law Reform Commission Act 1979 Cap 26 (Fiji) Law Reform Commission Act 1979 Cap 26 (Fiji)
Zurück zum Zitat Law Reform Commission Act 1994 (Solomon Islands) Law Reform Commission Act 1994 (Solomon Islands)
Zurück zum Zitat Law Reform Commission Act 2008 (Samoa) Law Reform Commission Act 2008 (Samoa)
Zurück zum Zitat Underlying Law Act 2000 (Papua New Guinea) Underlying Law Act 2000 (Papua New Guinea)
Metadaten
Titel
Law Reform and Legal Pluralism Developments
verfasst von
Teleiai Lalotoa Mulitalo Ropinisone Silipa Seumanutafa
Copyright-Jahr
2018
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-65524-6_2