Epidemiology StudyAir Pollution and Daily Mortality: A Review and Meta Analysis
Abstract
The air pollution disaster in London in 1952 established that very high levels of particulate-based smog can cause dramatic increases in daily mortality. Recently, more than a dozen studies at much lower particle concentrations have reported evidence that exposure to lower levels of airborne particles results in smaller, but nonzero increases in daily mortality. These studies were examined in a meta-analysis. A primary focus of the meta-analysis was to examine effect size estimates across large differences in both the levels of potential confounding factors and in their correlation with airborne particle concentration. In the primary meta-analysis, airborne particle concentration was a significant risk factor for elevated mortality (RR = 1.06, 95% CI = 1.05-1.07). The relative risk is for a 100 μg/m3 increase in TSP concentration. While mortality peaked in the cold months in all locations, in the majority of the studies airborne particle concentrations were highest in the warm months, indicating that seasonal patterns were not responsible for the observed associations. The relative risk was 1.06 (95% CI = 1.05-1.07) when the analysis was restricted to cities with summer peaking pollution. The relative risk was identical in cities with above average annual temperatures and cities with colder climates. It was also identical in drier and more humid climates, and similar across a wide range of correlations between temperature and airborne particle concentrations. These results suggest that inadequate weather control was not responsible for the association. A detailed examination of data from Philadelphia showed that control for season and weather was adequate for removing all long-term seasonal and subseasonal patterns from the mortality data, and that using a very flexible nonlinear fit to the weather factors did not disturb the association with TSP. The most reasonable interpretation of this pattern of results is that the association is causal. This is supported by other studies which have reported that particulate air pollution was associated with lung function deficits, increased symptoms, and increased hospitalization.
References (0)
Cited by (806)
Predicting PM<inf>2.5</inf> levels and exceedance days using machine learning methods
2024, Atmospheric EnvironmentMachine learning methods are increasingly being used in the field of air quality research to investigate the relationship between air pollutant levels, emissions, and meteorological changes over time. This research is used for both scientific investigation, and policy assessment and development. However, there is a lack of studies that have compared the performance of different machine learning methods. To address this gap, this paper employed various machine learning techniques, including decision tree, random forest (RF), support vector machine (SVM), support vector regression (SVR), k-nearest neighbor, neural network, and Gaussian process regression, to predict daily average PM2.5 levels and the number of days with PM2.5 exceedance in the South Coast Air Basin of California from 2000 to 2019. The models were trained using meteorological factors, estimated emissions, and large-scale climate indices as inputs. The SVR model demonstrated the highest predictive accuracy for PM2.5 levels and the SVM model gave the most accurate results for predicting the number of days with PM2.5 exceedances. Conversely, the decision tree model performed the least accurately. The results also showed that emissions have a greater impact on PM2.5 levels over time compared to meteorological factors, though meteorology is responsible for daily variability. The most important meteorological factors were identified as surface relative humidity and relative humidity at 850 mbars, which are related to partitioning, cloud cover and wet deposition. We conducted sensitivity tests on the model's response to emissions and meteorological factors. The predicted PM2.5 from RF and SVR showed large correlations with emissions at the early period (2000–2010). However, the changes were minimal in more recent years (2011–2019), implying that there are biases in machine learning models, in which the models consistently predict the minimum PM2.5 levels at a baseline.
Air quality disparities mapper: An open-source web application for environmental justice
2024, Environmental Modelling and SoftwareExposure to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) is linked to increased health risks and disproportionately affects minority and low-income communities. Current research lacks assessment of exposure disparities to PM2.5 components and effective communication of these disparities. We developed an interactive, web-based air pollution mapper, combining high-resolution predictions of PM2.5 components for 2010 across the contiguous United States with U.S. Census demographic data. The interface, hosted at https://disparitiesmapper.github.io/, allows users to visualize the relationship between variables, highlighting the racial, socioeconomic, and geographic disparities in exposure. By mapping individual PM2.5 components, it provides insights into specific sources driving PM2.5 concentrations, aiding in designing targeted reduction programs. This tool makes air quality data more accessible and informs policy outcomes.
Air pollution and agricultural labor supply: Evidence from China
2023, China Economic ReviewResearch on avoidance behaviors related to air pollution, particularly among low-income groups in developing countries, is relatively limited. This study aims to analyze the connection between air pollution and farmer labor supply in China, while also examining the labor relocation effect. The identification strategy relies on a widely used instrument variable, namely that thermal inversion exerts a plausibly exogenous shock on air quality. Two-stage least squares regression results indicate that at the intensive margin, farmer working hours in agricultural work during their busy farming seasons are reduced by 0.4 h/day for a 10 μg/m3 increment in PM2.5, whereas at the extensive margin, their working days in agricultural work throughout the year are reduced by 2.7 days for a 1 μg/m3 increase in the yearly average PM2.5 concentration. We also consider the labor relocation effect, as farmers are likely to shift their labor supply from agriculture to indoor off-farm work to avoid pollution damage. These findings add to the negative social externality of air pollution and expand the determinants of the agricultural labor supply.
Spatiotemporal graph neural networks for predicting mid-to-long-term PM<inf>2.5</inf> concentrations
2023, Journal of Cleaner ProductionPredicting the concentration of PM2.5 particles is of critical importance in public health management because their small size enables them to penetrate deep into the lungs and even enter the bloodstream. However, achieving accurate predictions is challenging due to the complexity of the transport and dispersion processes involved, which are influenced by multiple factors, including atmospheric pollutants, meteorological conditions, and geographic features. To address this challenge, we developed a novel framework for PM2.5 prediction that utilizes multiple edges for feature extraction and employs a multi-gated graph neural network for feature calculations. The model utilizes multiple edges, created by combining an atmospheric diffusion coefficient with a PM2.5 similarity metric, to elucidate the complex characteristics of PM2.5 interactions between different monitoring stations. Node features are computed by aggregating connected nodes' features, weighted by these multi-faceted edges. The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method outperforms conventional time-series prediction models in the mid-to-long-term prediction of PM2.5 concentrations (96 h in advance), with improvements in Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) by 2.613%, Critical Success Index (CSI) by 3.143%, and R-squared (R2) by 5.263%. Using the proposed model, the learning of global features can be achieved and issues related to local dependency can be mitigated.
Environmental gaseous pollutants are related to increase of acute coronary syndrome in Valencia region, Spain
2023, Medicina ClinicaEnvironmental pollution are one of the most relevant risk factors to atherosclerosis. To know awareness about the importance of urban air pollution as a trigger for hospital admission due to acute coronary syndrome (ACS), this study analyzed levels of different gaseous air pollutants in the air and its correlation with number of ACS.
Epidemiological data of patients admitted for ACS in five towns during the years 2006–2008 were recovered. Clinical data regarding admissions for ACS were obtained from the hospital admission services. Measures of seven air contaminants were recovered from the environmental stations. Mixed model including sex, age, location, and the average levels of air pollutants contaminants as fixed effects and its interaction were performed.
The incidence rate of ACS is higher in man than woman, and higher in older people than young. The maximum ACS were in the last trimester of the year, was the most elevated levels of gaseous pollutants have been found. Levels of NO2, NO, and CO are positively correlated between them, and negatively correlated with O3 levels. All air pollutants analyzed increase the number of ACS hospital admission in the five locations evaluated.
Levels of gaseous pollutants are related between them, being the levels of NO2, NO, and CO, positively correlated, and negatively correlated with levels of O3. Number of ACS hospital admission increases with levels of five air gaseous pollutants studied.
La contaminación ambiental es uno de los factores de riesgo más relevantes para la aterosclerosis. Para conocer la importancia de la contaminación del aire urbano como desencadenante del ingreso hospitalario por síndrome coronario agudo (SCA), este estudio analizó los niveles de diferentes contaminantes atmosféricos gaseosos en el aire y su correlación con el número de SCA.
Se recuperaron datos epidemiológicos de pacientes ingresados por SCA en 5 municipios durante los años 2006 a 2008. Los datos clínicos relativos a los ingresos por SCA se obtuvieron de los servicios de ingreso hospitalario. Se recuperaron medidas de 7 contaminantes del aire de las estaciones ambientales. Se realizó un modelo mixto que incluye sexo, edad, ubicación y los niveles promedio de contaminantes atmosféricos como efectos fijos y su interacción.
La tasa de incidencia de SCA es mayor en hombres que en mujeres, y mayor en personas mayores que en jóvenes. La mayoría de los SCA se dieron en el último trimestre del año, cuando se encontraron niveles más elevados de gases contaminantes. Los niveles de NO2, NO y CO se correlacionan positivamente entre ellos y negativamente con los niveles de O3. Todos los contaminantes atmosféricos analizados aumentan el número de ingresos hospitalarios por SCA en las 5 localidades evaluadas.
Los niveles de contaminantes gaseosos se relacionan entre sí, estando los niveles de NO2, NO y CO correlacionados positivamente entre sí y negativamente con los niveles de O3. El número de ingresos hospitalarios por SCA aumenta con los niveles de 5 contaminantes gaseosos del aire estudiados.
Pseudomonas stutzeri PM101005 inhaled with atmospheric particulate matter induces lung damage through inflammatory responses
2023, Environmental PollutionAtmospheric particulate matter (PM) contains a mixture of chemical and biological elements that pose threat to human health by increasing susceptibility to respiratory diseases. Although the identification of the microorganisms composing the PM has been assessed, their immunological impacts are still questionable. Here, we examined the mechanisms responsible for the pathogenicity of Pseudomonas stutzeri PM101005 (PMPS), a bacterium isolated from fine dust, in lung epithelial cells, alveolar cells, and macrophages. Relative to its comparative strain Pseudomonas stutzeri (PS), infections with PMPS induced higher production of inflammatory cytokines and chemokines, mediated by the activation of NF-κB and MAPK signaling pathways. Additionally, with three-dimensional (3D) airway spheroids which mimic the human bronchial epithelium, we confirmed that PMPS infections lead to relatively higher induction of pro-inflammatory cytokines than PM infections. Consistent results were observed in murine models as the infections with PMPS provoked greater inflammatory responses than the infections with PS. These PMPS-induced responses were mediated by the signaling pathways of the Toll-like receptors (TLRs), which regulated PMPS infection and played an important role in the expression of the antibiotic peptide β-defensin 3 (BD3) that suppressed PMPS proliferation. Moreover, PM pretreatment enhanced inflammatory responses and tissue damage of PMPS, while reducing BD3 expression. Overall, these results indicate that PM-isolated PMPS induce TLR-mediated inflammatory responses in lung tissues, and contributes to the understanding of the etiology of PM-induced respiratory damage.