Regular ArticleInformation Bias in Contingent Valuation: Effects of Personal Relevance, Quality of Information, and Motivational Orientation
Abstract
A laboratory experiment examined the potential for information bias in contingent valuation (CV). Consistent with the view that information about a public or private good can function as a persuasive communication, willingness to pay (WTP) was found to increase with the quality of arguments used to describe the good, especially under conditions of high personal relevance. Under low personal relevance, WTP for a public (but not for a private) good was higher when an altruistic, as opposed to an individualistic, orientation was activated. It is concluded that the nature of the information provided in CV surveys can profoundly affect WTP estimates, and that subtle contextual cues can seriously bias these estimates under conditions of low personal relevance.
References (0)
Cited by (210)
Willingness to pay for what? Testing the impact of four factors on willingness to pay for facilitating and sanctioning energy policy instruments
2023, Energy ReportsThe purpose of this study is to analyze individuals’ willingness to pay (WTP) for energy policies. The type of energy policy was divided into facilitating and sanctioning instruments. We studied the factors that influence WTP for two types of intrument for energy policy by using four theoretical frameworks: the Economic Model, the Theory of Planned Behavior, Value Theory, and Psychometric Paradigm (so called risk perception model). The results, first, showed that the WTP for the sanctioning instruments was lower than that for the facilitating instruments. Second, the values, trust, and norms were significant predictors of the WTP for both types of policy instruments. Third, the economic factors only influenced the WTP for sanctioning instruments. This study recommends policy mix considering the WTP for different types of instruments for energy policy.
Consumers' preferences for commons-based and open-source produce: A discrete choice experiment with directional information manipulations
2023, Food PolicyThe increasing privatization of seeds and varieties through intellectual property rights such as patents and exclusive seed multiplication rights has led to power imbalances and contributes to the continuous decline of genetic diversity. Diversified agricultural systems are, however, essential for climate change adaptation and the long-term resilience of our food systems. Common ownership of seeds and varieties can play a central role in supporting the development of diversified agricultural systems. With the first commons/open-source varieties entering consumer markets, consumer preferences and willingness-to-pay (WTP) for these varieties are worth exploring. On the example of tomatoes, we carried out a representative consumer survey with a discrete choice experiment. We find that consumers prefer commons/open-source varieties to company-owned varieties and are willing to pay a premium for these varieties. However, the premium they are willing to pay is smaller than for locally grown and organic produce. Providing additional information on the advantages of commons/open-source varieties positively affects WTP. There are no differences in WTP values for ‘commons varieties’ and ‘open-source varieties’. Our findings contribute to academic and policy discourses on consumers’ role in agrobiodiversity conservation and enhancement.
User preferences among households in hydrogen electricity storage using photovoltaic panels
2023, Electricity JournalIn studies on the effective use of renewable energy sources, the use of hydrogen as a storage medium for electricity has become a prominent topic. In 2020, a web-based survey was conducted of 1000 residents in western Japan who used a photovoltaic power generation system in their homes. Of the total respondents, 30% had at least some knowledge regarding hydrogen electricity storage. As part of the survey, a choice experiment was conducted to determine the respondents’ willingness to pay for improving or changing four attributes of hydrogen electricity storage. The respondents were randomly divided into two groups: one that was given information about carbon prices for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from residential energy use, and another that was not given any information. The carbon prices were calculated based on the information provided for each storage profile. Willingness to pay was calculated using mixed logit models. Including the carbon prices in the choice questions reduced the variance in the willingness to pay.
Information processing in stated preference surveys: A case study on urban gardens
2023, Journal of Environmental Economics and ManagementFor valid preference elicitation, stated preference surveys must provide information on the good to be valued, and respondents must process and recall the information. Previous studies show that the amount and type of information can affect stated preferences and the validity of value estimates, but how respondents process this information has been less researched. Some studies find correlations between preferences and respondent engagement with the information, but our study is the first to randomly and exogenously manipulate factors of engagement in a stated preference survey. Drawing on stated preference guidance and psychological concepts, we estimate the effect of quiz questions (asking about the content of the information) and self-reference questions (asking how the information personally relates to the respondent) on (i) engagement, (ii) information recall, and (iii) stated preferences in a discrete choice experiment survey valuing the ecosystem services of urban gardens in the German cities of Berlin and Stuttgart. Our results indicate that respondents spend more time on the information page when confronted with quiz rather than self-reference questions. For both question types, we do not find effects on recall or stated preferences. The results suggest that questions which increase engagement offer no simple fix to enhance information processing. Thus, alternative ways of reinforcing engagement, comprehension, and information recall in stated preference surveys should be developed and applied.
Securing online accounts and assets: An examination of personal investments and protection motivation
2023, International Journal of Information ManagementThis paper examines how personal investment influence the use of multi-factor authentication (MFA) for securing online accounts. We draw from the Protection Motivation Theory (PMT) that accounts for intrapersonal factors that increase one’s understanding of their threat and coping mechanisms and, subsequently, their motivation to protect such investments. We integrate size of investment – the amount of time, effort, and other personal resources that an individual has put into their online account. Based on PMT’s framework, we develop a research model that examines the influence of investment size as an information source that initiates and builds threat and coping appraisals. The model is tested with a survey of 263 responses, and the result shows that investment size influences threat and coping appraisals, which in turn increases MFA protection motivation and use. These results highlight the importance of eliciting individuals’ personal investments in order to improve their protective security behaviors.
The state of the art of discrete choice experiments in food research
2022, Food Quality and PreferenceDiscrete choice experiments (DCEs) have become an often-used research method in food research due to their ability to uncover trade-offs made when choosing among multiple alternatives, especially when dealing with credence attributes. Insights into the main elements of the consumers’ decision-making process are key to informing both public and private policies related to food production and consumption. However, DCEs are not confined to this field of study. This narrative methodological review sets out to provide a critical appraisal of the state of the art of DCEs in food research. We logically structure our review by comparing the field-independent state-of-the-art to its application in the specific food choice research domain. The comparison is presented for each of the steps required in implementing DCEs and allows for the identification of areas of improvement in best practice. We find that food research has adopted many of the methodological advances over the years, but further improvements are encouraged and outlined. Recommendations for future research are discussed.