Skip to main content

2005 | Buch

Small-scale Freshwater Toxicity Investigations

Hazard Assessment Schemes

herausgegeben von: Christian Blaise, D.Sc, Jean-François Férard

Verlag: Springer Netherlands

insite
SUCHEN

Über dieses Buch

Developed, developing and emerging economies worldwide are collectively contributing multiple stresses on aquatic ecosystems by the release of numerous contaminants. This in turn demands that basic toxicological information on their potential to harm living species be available. Hence, environmental protection programs aimed at preserving water quality must have access to comprehensive toxicity screening tools and strategies that can be applied reliably and universally. While a good number of toxicity testing procedures and hazard assessment approaches have been published in the scientific literature over the past decades, many are wanting in that insufficient detail is available for users to be able to fully understand the test method or scheme and to be able to reproduce it successfully. Even standardized techniques published in recognized international standard organization documents are often lacking in thoroughness and minutiae. Paucity of information relating to biological test methods may be consequent and trigger several phenomena including generation of invalid data and resulting toxicity measurements, erroneous interpretation and decision-taking with regards to a particular chemical or environmental issue, or simply abandonment of testing procedures. Clearly, improperly documented toxicity testing methods can be detrimental to their promotion and use, as they open the doorway to unnecessary debate and criticism as to their raison d’être. Furthermore, this situation can indirectly contribute to delaying, minimizing or eliminating their application, thereby curtailing the important role toxicity testing plays in the overall protection and conservation of aquatic ecosystems.

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Frontmatter

Introduction

Overview of contemporary toxicity testing
Christian Blaise, Jean-François Férard

Hazard Assessment Schemes with batteries of bioassays

1. Effluent assessment with the Peep (Potential Ecotoxic Effects Probe) index
Christian Blaise, Jean-François Férard
2. A multitest index of effluent toxicity by PLS regression
Conclusion
An index of toxicity is intended to be a simple tool that allows integrating and summarizing several variables into a single value. Realistically, this cannot be inferred without a judgement by environmental protection experts who consider all parameters available for their classification. PLS regression helped calculate an index fitted to expert judgement. The loss of information owing to the transformation of a multivariate situation to a univariate one was thus minimized since it is an inherent characteristic of multivariate analytical tools.
The index is easily calculated and depends mainly on chronic toxicity tests associated with a sensitive measurement endpoint chosen to be the EC10 (concentration incurring a 10% effect). It can be used as a regulatory criterion that is more protective of aquatic ecosystems than those based on a single acute toxicity test.
The need for an appropriate battery of genotoxicity tests is also important and cannot be compensated or replaced by toxicity tests since the variables are clearly independent. Further research, especially on genotoxicity tests with eukaryotes, applied to effluents, should be encouraged.
Éric Vindimian
3. The pT-method as a Hazard Assessment Scheme for wastewaters
Falk Krebs
4. Strategies for monitoring environmental effects of industrial effluents
Rick P. Scroggins, Anne I. Borgmann, Jennifer A. Miller, Mary J. Moody
5. Overview of toxicity reduction and identification evaluations for use with small-scale tests
Conclusions
The Toxicity Reduction Evaluation process is a logical site-specific set of procedures which can be used for preventing and resolving toxicity with a variety of aqueous media, including industrial and municipal effluent, receiving water (surface water), groundwater, leachates and sediment porewater. Factors influencing success of a TRE include establishing a Toxicity Prevention/Response Plan prior to the initial toxicity episode, experience and knowledge of the investigators, inclusion of a multi-disciplinary team, effective mechanisms for communication and co-ordination among all stakeholders, and flexibility in site-specific studies. The methods for the prevention and reduction of toxicity are not limited to the guidance provided in the preceding sections. Significant new and useful advances in toxicant identification are made on a regular basis; as these methods or approaches are developed, they should be included for consideration as part of the TRE.
Lesley J. Novak, Keith E. Holtze
6. Determination of the Heavy Metal Binding Capacity (HMBC) of Environmental Samples
Gabriel Bitton, Marnie Ward, Roi Dagan
7. The Application of Hazard Assessment Schemes Using the Watertox Toxicity Testing Battery
Alicia Ronco, Gustavo Bulus Rossini, Cecilia Sobrero, Carina Apartin, Gabriela Castillo, M. Consuelo Díaz-Baez, Adriana Espinosa Ramírez, Inés Ahumada, Jorge Mendoza
8. The SED-TOX Index for Toxicity Assessment of contaminated solid matrices
Conclusions
Initiatives to develop new methodologies for the assessment of sediment and soil toxicity are ongoing. While there is a need for more sensitive and cost-effective bioassays, the question remains: what concept should be used to integrate as much information as possible from a diverse set of test species and assessment endpoints? It has been demonstrated that it is possible to summarize the results of multiple toxicity assays conducted on a solid matrix such as freshwater sediments by means of a single index. Although there is still little experience with this sediment toxicity index, it is expected to be of great utility in the assessment of sediment and soil quality as a tool for evaluating their toxic potential and tracking their condition over time. Information generated from the SED-TOX index may also prove helpful for investigators who wish to explore causality in future investigations. It might, for instance, be employed to pinpoint sites of concern where investigative strategies involving bioanalytical assessment of spiked sediments or toxicity identification evaluations (TIEs) might be appropriate.
Manon Bombardier
9. The pT-Method as a Hazard Assessment Scheme for sediments and dredged material
Conclusions/prospects
This simple pT-hazard assessment system designed to determine sediment quality for the management of freshwater and marine ecosystems was developed in the German Federal Institute of Hydrology (BfG). While sediment categorization into several toxicity classes is supported by scientific methodology, evaluation and routine application are based on a convention outlined in specific guidelines. The rationale defining sediment categories based on ecotoxicological principles (i.e., via application of a toxicity test battery) is still very much in its infancy. As the pT-database increases and toxicity test batteries are optimized, sediment toxicity categories will likely be better defined to the benefit of management practices for the protection of inland and coastal waters.
Falk Krebs
10. Using the Sediment Quality Triad (Sqt) in ecological risk assessment
Conclusions
The SQT has been accepted internationally as the most comprehensive approach available for assessing contaminated sediments. It has been widely used, not just in North America, but in Europe, Australasia, South America, and the Antarctic. It is extremely cost-effective for the level of information provided when applied in a tiered and iterative fashion. It can be used with all sediment types and can be adapted for use with soils and the water column. It provides information on potential effects of biomagnifying contaminants to the health of humans and wildlife, and can be adapted for use with bacterial contaminants and for human health assessments. It is a framework, not a formula, and thus will continue to be improved and possibly expanded by subsequent investigators.
Peter M. Chapman, Blair G. McDonald
11. Wastoxhas: A bioanalytical strategy for solid wastes assessment
Jean Francois-Férard, Benoit Ferrari
Backmatter
Metadaten
Titel
Small-scale Freshwater Toxicity Investigations
herausgegeben von
Christian Blaise, D.Sc
Jean-François Férard
Copyright-Jahr
2005
Verlag
Springer Netherlands
Electronic ISBN
978-1-4020-3553-1
Print ISBN
978-1-4020-3543-2
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/1-4020-3553-5