Abstract
In recent years, much attention has been focused on the need to develop effective and efficient strategies and procedures for the assessment of laboratory work. Increasingly, the emphasis has moved towards a skills-based approach. The paper addresses a number of philosophical issues concerning this orientation and argues that the skills-based approach is philosophically unsound (because it isn't based on a valid model of science), educationally worthless (because it trivializes learning) and pedagogically dangerous (because it encourages bad teaching). An alternative, more holistic approach to assessment, based on a more valid model of scientific practice, is proposed.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Assessment of Performance Unit (APU): 1984,Science in Schools: Ages 13 and 15, Research Report No. 3, Department of Education and Science, London.
BeasleyW. F.: 1980, ‘Analysing Laboratory Performance — What do we really Measure?’,The Australian Science Teachers Journal 26 (1), 69–72.
Ben-ZviR., HofsteinA., SamuelD., and KempaR. F.: 1977, ‘Mode of Instruction in High School Chemistry’,Journal of Research in Science Teaching 14(59), 433–439.
BryceT., McCallJ., MacGregorJ., RobertsonI., and WestonR.: 1983,Techniques for the Assessment of Practical Skills in Foundation Science, Heinemann, London.
BryceT. G. K., McCallJ., MacGregorJ., RobertsonI. J., and WestonR. A. J.: 1987,TAPS Report of the Project Phase 2, Jordanhill College of Education, Glasgow.
BryceT. G. K. and RobertsonI. J.: 1985, ‘What Can They Do? A Review of Practical Assessment in Science’,Studies in Science Education 12, 1–24.
Department of Education and Science: 1979,Aspects of Secondary Education in England: A Survey by HM Inspectors of Schools, HMSO, London.
Department of Education and Science: 1987,The National Curriculum Science Working Party Interim Report, HMSO, London.
EdwardsJ. and PowerC.: 1990, ‘Role of laboratory Work in a National Junior Secondary Science Project: Australian Science Education Project (ASEP), in Hegarty-HazelE. (ed.),The Student Laboratory and the Science Curriculum, Routledge, London.
FeyerabendP. K.: 1962, ‘Explanation, Reduction and Empiricism’,Minnesota Studies in The Philosophy of Science III, 28–97.
FeyerabendP. K.: 1975,Against Method, New Left Books, London.
GagnéR. M.: 1963, ‘The Learning Requirements for Enquiry’,Journal of Research in Science Teaching 1(2), 144–153.
GottR. and MurphyP.: 1987,Assessing Investigations at Ages 13 and 15, APU Science Report for Teachers 9, DES, London.
HarrisJ. (ed.): 1985,Physics Examinations and Investigations, Revised Nuffield Advanced Science, Longman, London.
HodsonD.: 1986, ‘The Role of Assessment in the ‘Curriculum Cycle’: A Survey of Science Department Practice’,Research in Science & Technological Education 4 (1), 7–17.
HodsonD.: 1988, ‘Experiments in Science and Science Teaching’,Educational Philosophy and Theory 20(2), 53–66.
HodsonD.: 1990 ‘A Critical Look at Practical Work in School Science’,School Science Review 71(256), 33–40.
JakewaysR.: 1986, ‘Assessment of A-level Physics (Nuffield) Investigations’,Physics Education 21(4), 212–214.
KempaR. F.: 1979, ‘Teacher Assessment of Practical Skills in Chemistry’ in HoareD. E., KempaR. F. and OngleyP. A. (eds.),Research in Assessment II, The Chemical Society, London.
KempaR. F.: 1986,Assessment in Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
KimbellR.: 1991, ‘Tackling Technological Tasks’ in WoolnoughB. E. (ed.),Practical Science, Open University Press, Buckingham.
KreigerA. G.: 1982, ‘Written Tests of Laboratory Skills’,Journal of Chemical Education 59(3), 230–231.
LynchP. P.: 1987, ‘Laboratory Work in Schools and Universities: Structures and Strategies Still Largely Unexplored’,The Australian Science Teachers Journal 32(4), 31–39.
MillarR.: 1991, ‘A Means to an End: the Role of Processes in Science Education’ in WoolnoughB. E., (ed.),Practical Science, Open University Press, Buckingham.
MillarR. and DriverR.: 1987, ‘Beyond Processes’,Studies in Science Education 14, 33–62.
Northern Examining Association (NEA): 1990.GCSE Science (Modular) Syllabus for the the 1991 Examination, NEA, Manchester.
NorrisS. P.: 1985, ‘The Philosophical Basis of Observation in Science and Science Education’,Journal of Research in Science Teaching 22(9), 817–833.
OakeshottM.: 1962, ‘Rational Conduct’ inRationalism in Politics and Other Essays, Methuen, London.
PowerC.: 1986, ‘Criterion-based Assessment, Grading and Reporting at Year 12 Level’,Australian Journal of Education 30(3), 266–284.
QualterA., StrangJ., SwattonP., and TaylorR.: 1990,Exploration — A Way of Learning Science, Blackwell, Oxford.
ReidD. J. and HodsonD.: 1987,Science For All. Teaching Science in the Secondary School, Cassell, London.
ShapereD.: 1982, ‘The Concept of Observation in Science and Philosophy’,Philosophy of Science 49(4), 485–525.
StevensP.: 1978, ‘On the Nuffield Philosophy of Science’,Journal of Philosophy of Education 12, 99–111.
WhiteR. T.: 1991, ‘Episodes, and the Purpose and Conduct of Practical Work’ in WoolnoughB. E. (ed.),Practical Science, Open University Press, Buckingham.
WoolnoughB. E.: 1988, ‘Reductio ad Absurdum?’,Physics Education 23(1), 1–2.
WoolnoughB. E.: 1991, ‘Practical Science as a Holistic Activity’, in WoolnoughB. E. (ed.),Practical Science, Open University Press, Buckingham.
WoolnoughB. and AllsopT.: 1985,Practical Work in Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
WoolnoughB. E. and TohK. A.: 1990, ‘Alternative Approaches to Assessment of Practical Work in Science’,School Science Review 71(256), 127–131.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hodson, D. Assessment of practical work. Sci Educ 1, 115–144 (1992). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00572835
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00572835