Abstract
Quality-adjusted life year measures (QALYs) have been fervently debated by researchers and decision makers concerned with resource allocation in the health care sector. They have been heralded as important aids to planning and priority setting, but also criticised on technical and ethical grounds. This paper examines these arguments with special reference to mental health care, the intention being to highlight the strengths and shortcomings of QALYs in this context. Issues pertinent to the application of QALYs in health care evaluation more generally are also reviewed. Whilst the rationale and underlying principles of the utility measurement approach are sound, the generic QALY as it is currently constructed represents an insensitive measure of the outcomes of mental health care. In the event of an increasingly QALY-driven priority-setting environment, however, abandonment of QALYs runs the risk of inappropriately marginalising people with mental illnesses in the resource allocation process. This opens up the possibility of developing a mental-health specific measure of utility that, in combination with cost data, would provide useful and appropriate summary information across treatments and programmes of mental health care.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson TF, Mooney G (1990) The challenges of medical practice variations. Macmillan Press, London
Angst J (1992) The epidemiology of depression. Psychopharmacology 106 [Suppl]:71–74
Boevink WA, Wolf JR, Van Nieuwenhuizen C, Schene AH (1995) Quality of life of psychiatric patients who depend on long-term outpatient care: a conceptual exploration. Tijdschr Psychiatrie 37:97–110
Bowling A (1991) Measuring health: a review of quality of life measurement scales. Open University Press, Buckingham
Callahan D (1994) Setting mental health priorities: problems and possibilities. Milbank Q 72:451–470
Carr-Hill R (1989) Background material for the workshop on QALYs: assumptions of the QALY procedure. Soc. Sci Med 28:469–77
Culyer A, Wagstaff A (1993) QALYs versus HYEs. Health Econ 12:311–323
Dixon J, Welch GH (1991) Priority setting: lessons from Oregon. Lancet i 337:891–894
Donaldson C, Atkinson A, Bond J, Wright KG (1988) Should QALYs be programme specific? J Health Econ 7:239–257
Drummond MF, Stoddart GL, Torrance GW (1987) Methods for the economic evaluation of health care programmes. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Drummond MF, Mohide EA, Tew M, Streiner DL, Pringle DM, Gilbert RJ (1991) Economic evaluation of a support program for caregivers of demented elderly. Int J Technol Assess Health Care 7:209–219
Dunbar G, Stoker M (1992) The development of a questionnaire to measure quality of life in psychiatric patients. Br J Med Econ 4:63–73
Eddy DM (1991) Oregon's methods — did cost-effectiveness analysis fail? J Am Med Assoc 266:2135–2141
EuroQol Group (1990) EuroQol — a new facility for the measurement of health-related quality of life. Health Policy 16:199–208
Gafni A, Birch S, Mehrez A (1993) Economics, health and health economics: HYEs versus QALYs. J Health Econ 12:325–339
Gerard K, Mooney G (1992) QALY league tables: handle with care. Health Econ 2:59–64
Goldberg DP (1978) Manual of the General Health Questionnaire. NFER-Nelson, Windsor
Hadorn DC (1991) Setting health care priorities in Oregon — cost-effectiveness meets the rule of rescue. J Am Med Assoc 265:2218–2225
Hamilton M (1967) Development of a rating scale for primary depressive illness. Br J Soc Clin Psychol 6:278–296
Hatziandreu EJ, Brown RE, Revicki DA, Turner R, Martindale JJ, Levine S, Siegel JE (1994) Cost-utility of maintenance treatment of recurrent depression with sertraline versus episodic treatment with dothiepin. Pharmacoeconomics 5:249–264
Hunt S, McKenna S (1992) Do we need measures other than QALYs? In: Hopkins A (ed) Measures of the quality of life and the uses to which such measures may be put. Royal College of Physicians, London, pp 63–79
Huxley P (1986) Quality Measurement in Mental Health Services. Good Practices in Mental Health, London
Johannesson M, Jönsson B (1991) Economic evaluation in health care: is there a role for cost-benefit analysis? Health Policy 17:1–23
Kamlet MS, Wade M, Kupfer DJ, Frank E (1992) Cost-utility analysis of maintenance treatment for recurrent depression: a theoretical framework and numerical illustration. In: Frank RG, Manning WG (eds) Economics and mental health. The John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, pp 267–291
Kavanagh S, Stewart A (1995) Economic evaluations of mental health care: modes and methods. In: Knapp MRJ (ed) The economic evaluation of mental health care. Ashgate, Aldershot, pp 27–60
Kavanagh S, Schneider J, Knapp MRJ, Beecham JK, Netten A (1995) Elderly people with dementia: costs, effectiveness and balance of care. In: Knapp MRJ (ed) The economic evaluation of mental health care. Ashgate, Aldershot, pp 125–156
Lehman A (1983) The well-being of chronic mental patients: assessing their quality of life. Arch Gen Psychiatry 40:369–373
Lehman A (1995) Measuring quality of life in a reformed health system. Health Aff 14:90–101
Loomes G, McKenzie L (1989) The use of QALYs in health care decision making. Soc Sci Med 28:299–308
Mason J, Drummond M, Torrance G (1993) Some guidelines on the use of cost-effectiveness league tables. BMJ 306:570–572
Mehrez A, Gafni A (1989) Quality adjusted life years and healthy year equivalents. Med Decis Making 9:142–149
Mohide EA, Torrance GW, Streiner DL, Pringle DM, Gilbert R (1988) Measuring the wellbeing of family caregivers using the time trade-off technique. J Clin Epidemiol 41:475–482
Murray CJL (1994) Quantifying the burden of disease: the technical basis for disability-adjusted life years. Bull WHO 72:429–445
Nord E (1992) Methods for quality adjustment of life years. Soc Sci Med 34:559–569
Oliver JPJ (1993) The social care directive: development of a quality of life profile for use in community services for the mentally ill. Soc Work Soc Sci Rev 3:5–45
Pollack DA, McFarland BH, George RA, Angell RH (1994) Prioritisation of mental health services in Oregon. Milbank Q 72:515–550
Rosser R, Kind P (1978) A scale of valuation of states of illness: is there a social consensus? Int J Epidemiol 7:347–357
Rosser R, Watts VC (1972) The measurement of hospital output. Int J Epidemiol 1:361–368
Selai C, Rosser R (1993) The role of quality of life measurement in psychiatry. Curr Med Lit Psychiatry 4:67–71
Torrance GW (1986) Measurement of health state utilities for economic appraisal. J Health Econ 5:1–30
Wagstaff A (1991) QALYs and the equity-efficiency trace-on. J Health Econ 10:21–41
Wilkinson G, Croft-Jeffreys C, Krekorian H, McLees S, Falloon I (1990) QALYs in psychiatric care? Psychiatr Bull 14:582–585
Wilkinson G, Williams B, Krekorian H, McLees S, Falloon I (1992) QALYs in mental health: a case study. Psychol Med 22:725–731
Williams A (1994) Economics, QALYs and medical ethics: a health economist's perspective. Discussion Paper No. 121, Centre for Health Economics, University of York
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chisholm, D., Healey, A. & Knapp, M. QALYs and mental health care. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 32, 68–75 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00788923
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00788923