Abstract
The issue of adverse health effects from electric and magnetic fields (EMFs) has been brewing for the last decade or so. While the epidemiological evidence persists in linking proximity-to-powerlines to a few forms of cancer, exposure and dose remain undefined, and no clear mechanism of action has been identified. Despite this scientific ambiguity, there are frequent calls for governmental action; and yet, there is no unanimity on what action is appropriate, even among those asserting that something ought to be done. This article analyzes the various ways that the EMF problem has been socially constructed through distinctive forms of public discourse and the sources of contention among these different forms. It should appeal to ‘interpretive’ policy analysts and to those interested in the valuative assumptions behind policy claims. Those oriented exclusively to the technical side of EMF may find the interpretation offered here somewhat unsettling, however, since it relativizes many of the ‘factual’ claims surrounding the issue. Attention is also given to the ways that multiple EMF discourses are accommodated in the absence of scientifically conclusive evidence.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Banks, Robert S. (1989a).The EMF Health Effects Issue: An Overview of Developments, 1988–1989. Minneapolis: Robert S. Banks Associates, Inc.
Banks, Robert S. (1989b).Power Lines: Kids, Schools, and Cancer. Minneapolis: Robert S. Banks Associates, Inc.
Banks, Robert S (1991).EMF Regulation: A Look at the Present Status. Minneapolis: Robert S. Banks Associates, Inc.
Best, Joel, ed (1989).Images of Issues. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Brodeur, Paul (1974).Expendable Americans. New York: Viking Press.
Brodeur, Paul (1985).Outrageous Misconduct: The Asbestos Industry on Trial. New York: Pantheon.
Brodeur, Paul (1989a). ‘The hazards of electromagnetic fields, I — power lines.’The New Yorker June 12: 51–88.
Brodeur, Paul (1989b). ‘The hazards of electromagnetic fields, II — something is happening.’The New Yorker June 19: 47–73.
Brodeur, Paul (1989c).Currents of Death: Power Lines, Computer Terminals, and the Attempt to Cover Up Their Threat to Your Health. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Brodeur, Paul (1990). ‘Danger in the schoolyard.’Family Circle September 25.
[California EMF] California EMF Consensus Group (1992).Issues and Recommendations for Interim Response and Policy Addressing Power Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields. Before the Public Utilities Commission of the State of California, San Francisco, CA: March 20.
[California] California Public Utilities Commission and Department of Health Services (1989).Draft Report: Potential Health Effects of Electric Power Facilities. San Francisco, CA: July.
[California] California Public Utilities Commission (1993).Order Instituting Investigation on the Commission's Own Motion to Develop Policies and Procedures for Addressing the Potential Health Effects and Magnetic Fields of Utility Facilities. Decision 93-11-013. Before the Public Utilities Commission of the State of California, San Francisco, CA: November 2.
Cohen, Jean and Andrew Arato (1992).Civil Society and Political Theory. Cambridge: MIT Press.
DeCicco, J. M., J. Beyea and S. S. Bernow (1989). ‘Environmental concerns regarding the siting of transmission lines,’ a paper prepared for Consumer Energy Council of America/Research Foundation, December 14.
Dryzek, John (1993). ‘Informal logic in the design of policies and institutions,’ a paper presented at the annual meetings of the American Political Science Association, Washington, D.C., September.
Feychting, Maria, and Anders Ahlbom (1992).Magnetic Fields and Cancer in People Residing Near Swedish High Voltage Power Lines. IMM-rapport 6/92, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Fischer, Frank and John Forester (1993).The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Fraser, Nancy (1989).Unruly Practices: Power, Discourse and Gender in Contemporary Social Theory. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Furby, L., P. Slovic, B. Fischhoff, and R. Gregory (1988). ‘Public perceptions of electric power transmission lines.’Journal of Environmental Psychology 8: 19–43.
Gumperz, Joseph (1982).Discourse strategies. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Linder, Stephen (1994). ‘Ambiguous evidence and institutional interpretation: an alternative view of electric and magnetic fields.’Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 19: 165–190.
London, S., D. Thomas, J. Bowman, E. Sobel, T. Chen, and J. Peters (1991). ‘Exposure to residential electric and magnetic fields and risk of childhood leukemia.’American Journal of Epidemiology 134: 923–937.
Minow, Martha (1990).Making All the Difference. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Morgan, M. Granger (1989). ‘Alternative responses that utilities might take to the possible risks of 60-Hz electromagnetic fields,’ an unpublished paper, Department of Engineering and Public Policy, Carnegie-Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA.
Morgan, M. Granger (1990). ‘Exposé treatment confounds understanding of a serious public-health issue.’Scientific American, April: 118–123.
Morgan M. Granger, H. Keith Florig, I. Nair, and G. L. Hester (1988), ‘Controlling exposure to transmission line electromagnetic fields: a regulatory approach that is compatible with the available science.’Public Utilities Fortnightly, March, pp. 49–58.
Morgan, M. Granger and I. Nair (1990). ‘Electromagnetic fields: the jury's still out.’IEEE Spectrum, August: 23–35.
Murray, T. (1988). ‘Regulating Asbestos: ethics, politics, and the values of science,’ in Ronald Bayer, ed.The Health and Safety of Workers. New York: Oxford University Press.
[OTA] Office of Technology Assessment, U.S. Congress (1989).Biological Effects of Power Frequency Electric & Magnetic Fields, OTA-BP-E-53, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office, May.
Olsen, J., A. Nielsen, and G. Schulgen (1993). ‘Residence near high-voltage facilities and the risk of cancer children.’British Medical Journal 307: 891–895.
[Oregon] State of Oregon Panel on 60-Hz Electric and Magnetic Fields (1990).Report on Human Health Effects From Exposure To 60-Hz Electric and Magnetic Fields From High Voltage Power Lines. Presented to the Oregon Energy Facility Siting Council, January.
Philips, A., S. Best and R. Coghill (1990). ‘Killing fields.’Electronics World + Wireless World, February.
Phillips, Ann (1994). ‘Dealing with differences.’Constellations 1: 45–60.
Pool, R. (1990). ‘Is there an EMF-cancer connection?’Science 24: 1096–1098.
San Diego Gas & Electric Co. v. Daley et al. (1990). 205 Cal. App. 3d 1334.
Sandman, P. (1989). ‘Hazard versus outrage: expert versus public perception of food risks,’ a paper presented at the Intercollegiate Nutrition Consortiuum, St. Paul, MN, October 31.
Savitz, D., J. Wachtel, F. Barnes, E. John, J. Tvrdik (1988). ‘Case-control study of childhood cancer and exposure to 60-hz magnetic fields.’American Journal of Epidemiology 128: 21–38.
Schiffrin, Deborah (1994).Approaches to Discourse.New York:Blackwell.
Schram, Sanford (1993). ‘Postmodern policy analysis: discourse and identity in welfare policy.’Policy Sciences 26: 249–270.
Simons, Herbert, ed. (1990).The Rhetorical Turn. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Spector, Malcomb and Joseph Kitsuse (1977).Constructing Social Problems. Menlo Park, CA: Cummings.
Stone, R. (1992). ‘Polarized debate: EMFs and cancer.’Science 258: 1724–1725.
Sykes, T., and L. Ping (1990).Possible Health Effects of Electric and Magnetic Fields from Power Lines: A Summary of Scientific Studies. Washington State Institute for Public Policy, January.
[Texas] Public Utility Commission of Texas Electro-Magnetic Health Effects Committee (1992).Health Effects of Exposure to Powerline-Frequency Electric and Magnetic Fields. Report to the Public Utility Commission of Texas, Austin, Texas, May.
[Task Force] Task Force on Transmission Line Health and Safety (1989).Electric and Magnetic Field Issues: Draft Resolution. National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners, July 24.
US Department of Energy (1993).The National Electric and Magnetic Fields Research and Communication Program Draft Strategic Plan. Washington, D.C., May.
US Environmental Protection Agency (1990).Evaluation of the Potential Carcinogenicity of Electromagnetic Fields: Workshop Review Draft. EPA/600/6-90/005A, June.
US House of Representatives (1990).The Electric and Magnetic Field Research and Public Information Act of 1990, H.R. 4801, a bill introduced by Rep. Frank Pallone (D-NJ), May 10.
US House of Representatives (1992).The Energy Policy Act. Conference Report 102-1018, 102d Congress, 2e Session, October 5.
Van Dijk, Teun, ed. (1985).The Handbook of Discourse Analysis, Vols. 1–4. New York: Academic Press.
Wertheimer, N., and E. Leeper (1979). ‘Electrical wiring configurations and childhood cancer.’American Journal of Epidemiology 109: 273–284.
Wirick, D. W. (1990). ‘Some analytic tools and policy options for dealing with the potential adverse health effects of electromagnetic fields.’National Regulatory Research Institute Quarterly Bulletin 11: 141–151.
Yanow, Dvora (1992). ‘Silences in public policy discourse: organizational and policy myths.’Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 2: 399–423.
Yanow, Dvora (1993). ‘The communication of policy meanings: implementation as interpretation and text.’Policy Sciences 26: 41–61.
Zappavigna v. State of New York and Power Authority (1989). New York State Court of Claims, claim no. 74085, filed September 29.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Linder, S.H. Contending discourses in the electric and magnetic fields controversy: The social construction of EMF risk as a public problem. Policy Sci 28, 209–230 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00999676
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00999676