Impact of rice straw management practices on yield, nitrogen uptake and soil properties in a wheat-rice rotation in northern India

Abstract

To study the long term effects of rice straw management practices in a wheat-rice rotation, experiments were started from the dry season (Nov–May) of 1984 to wet season (July–Nov) of 1989. Each year, six straw management practices, viz. control (C), straw incorporation (SI), straw mulch (SM), straw burning (SB), animal manure incorporation (AM), and straw and animal manure incorporation together (SI+AM) were imposed to wheat crop and their subsequent residual effect was studied on the following rice crop under three levels of N, viz. 0, 60 and 120 kg N ha⁻¹. The rate of straw and animal manure used was 5 t ha⁻¹ on dry weight basis.

The wheat yield and N uptake did not vary significantly under control and SB throughout the experimental period. But, the production level of wheat and N uptake were consistently higher under AM and SM over these two treatments. The SI+AM which had significantly lower wheat yields and N uptake over the AM during the first crop, became equal to that of AM and SM during the second and third crops, and out yielded these two treatments from the fourth crop onward. Straw incorporation which produced wheat yield and N uptake even less than control and SB during the first two crops, resulted in wheat yield and N uptake equivalent to AM and SM from the fourth crop onward.

None of the straw management practices had residual effects on the yields and N uptake during the first rice crop, except SM which reduced the rice yields and N uptake in the first two crops. However, AM and SI+AM in the second crop; AM, SI+AM and SI in the third crop; and AM, SI+AM, SI and SM from the fourth crop onward had significant and positive residual effects on rice yields and N uptake. Among these four treatments, SI+AM produced residual effects which were significantly higher than the remaining three treatments. Considering the production levels of wheat and rice, SI+AM treatment resulted in savings of 60 kg N ha⁻¹ each for wheat and rice.

After five years of experimentation, the maximum soil build-up of organic carbon; available N, P and K; and DTPA-extractable Zn, Cu, Fe and Mn was observed under SI+AM, followed by AM and SM and it was minimal under SB and control treatments. The treatments of AM and SI+AM also resulted in a high percentage of water-stable aggregates of 70.25 mm in diameter (80.9%), larger mean weight diameter (0.82 mm), higher porosity (54.2%) and lower bulk density (1.19 Mg m⁻³).