Abstract
Primarily the controverse discussions in didactical research concerning the foundations of analysis — especially the different approaches to the limit concept — are considered. In the recent years many suggestions have been made to overcome the difficulties of the “usual” limit concept (Epsilon-no, Epsilon-Delta Definition). The didactical analysis of these difficulties and the suggestions to overcome them led to the development of some new curricula. Hence it is now necessary to examine if the analysis of these difficulties exactly reflects the difficulties which pupils really have. In a first step the consequences of the above mentioned didactical analysis are transformed into questions which the authors — in a second step — tried to answer in the last three years by different tests which were presented to pupils and students. The results of these tests are reported and the consequences of these results are compared with different observations of other authors.
Similar content being viewed by others
Verzeichnis der zitierten Literatur
Blum, W.: Zum vereinfachten Grenzwertbegriff in der Differentialrechnung. In: MU (1979), Heft 3
Bock, H.: Automatische Klassifikation. In: Verlag Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen (1974)
Byers, V. & Herscovics, N.: Understanding School mathematics. In: Mathematics Teaching, No 81, (1977)
Churchman: A Comparative Study of Three Different Approaches To The Limit Concept. In: Diss. Univ. Georgia (1972)
Fischer, R.: Die Rolle des Exaktifizierens im Analysis-Unterricht. In: DdM (1978), Heft 3
Knoche, N.: Zum Problem exakter Begriffsbildungen im Analysisunterricht. In: Schriftenreihe des IDM. Bielefeld 7/1976/81
Otte, M. & Steinbring, H.: Probleme der Begriffsentwicklung zum Stetigkeitsbegriff. In: DdM (1977), Heft 1
Pfanzagl, J.: Allgmeine Methodenlehre der Statistik II. In: Verlag de Gruyter (1974)
Pickert, G.: Analysis in der Kollegstufe. In: MU (1976), Heft 5
Skemp, R.R.: Symbolic understanding. In: Mathematics Teaching, No 99, (1982)
Seyfferth, S.: Ein Vorschlag zur Milderung der Diskrepanz zwischen naivanschaulichem Verständnis und exakter Definition des Grenzwertes einer Funktion. In: DdM (1975), Heft 4
SPSS: Statistical Package For The Social Sciences. In: Mac Graw Hill, New York (1975)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Herden, G., Knoche, N. & Pickartz, U. Eine Untersuchung zur Diskussion über Schwierigkeiten im Umgang mit dem Konvergenzbegriff. JMD 4, 263–305 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03339236
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03339236