Abstract
This article analyzes the use of economic instruments for environmental policy in four European countries. The study employs data from national and international sources for an ex post evaluation of the effects of economic policy instruments in the clean water programs of Denmark, France, Germany, and The Netherlands from 1970 to 1990. It is shown that among the four countries The Netherlands were the most successful in environmental terms, regarding social costs and with respect to technological innovation. On the one hand the study confirms that economic instruments can work as rather powerful stimuli for the implementation of public policies; on the other hand it provides some unexpected findings regarding the significance of the institutional context for the design and operation of market-based instruments. It is argued that institutionalized practices of public policy making influenced the specific design of the four water pollution control programs, including the design and role of economic instruments, and that the regulatory design in turn affected the degree to which the incentives provided by the economic instruments were able to influence the behavior of the polluters. The study hence points to the significance of taking into account the institutional setting of the design and operation of market-based instruments, an observation with both theoretical and practical implications.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andersen MS (1989) Miljøbeskyttelse—et implementeringsproblem. Politica 21:312–328
Andersen MS (1991) Hvordan er effektiviteten af den danske regulering af vandmiljøet sammenlignet med reguleringen i andre lande? Rapport fra konsensuskonference 31.1-4.2,1991, 18.1-18.15. Undervisningsministeriets Forskningsafdeling, Copenhagen
Andersen MS (1994) Governance by green taxes: making pollution prevention pay. Manchester University Press, Manchester
Baumol WJ, Oates WE (1975, 1988) The theory of environmental policy, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Berman P (1980) Thinking about programmed and adaptive implementation. In: Ingram H, Mann D (eds) Why policies succeed or fail. Sage, California
Bongaerts J, Kraemer A (1989) Permits and effluent charges in the water pollution control policies of France, West Germany and The Netherlands. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 12:127–147
Bower B, et al (1981) Incentives in water quality management. Johns Hopkins University Press, Washington, DC
Bressers H (1988) A comparison of the effectiveness of incentives and directives: the case of the Dutch water quality policy. Policy Studies Review 7:500–518
Coase RH (1988) The firm, the market and the law. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Cropper ML, Oates WE (1992) Environmental economics: a survey. Journal of Economic Literature 30:675–740
De Goede B, et al (1982) Het Waterschap, Kluwer, Deventer
Environmental Resources Limited (1982) The law and practice relating to pollution control in The Netherlands. Graham Trotman, Brussels
Folketingets forhandlinger (1973) del F, spalte 3929
Freeman AM III, Haveman RH, Kneese AV (1973) The economics of environmental policy. Wiley, New York, pp 10, 45
Friege H (1984) Das Abwasserabgabengesetz—erweitern, konkretisieren, vereinfachen. Zeitschrift für Umweltpolitik 2
Gunlicks A (1986) Local government in the German federal system. Duke University Press, Durham, NC
Hall P, Taylor R (1996) Political science and the three new institutionalisms. Political Studies 44:936–957
Harrison P, Derrick Sewell WR (1980) Water pollution control by agreement: the French system of contracts. Natural Resources Journal 20:765–786
Holm K (1988) Wasserverbände im internationalen Vergleich: eine ökonomische Analyse der französischen Agences Financiëres de Bassin und der deutschen Wasserverbände im Ruhrgebiet. In: IFO Studien zur Umweltökonomie No. 3. IFO, Munich
Howlett M (1991) Policy instruments, policy styles, and policy implementation: national approaches to theories of instrument choice. Policy Studies Journal 19(2):1–21
IFEN (1996) Environmental performance indicators in France. Institut Francais de l’Environnement. Orleans, p 48
Johnson RW, Brown GM (1976) Cleaning up Europe’s waters. Praeger, New York
Johnson RW, Brown GM (1984) Pollution control by effluent charges: it works in the Federal Republic of Germany, why not in the United States? Natural Resources Journal 24:929–966
Kirschen ES, et al (1964) Economic policy in our time. North Holland, Amsterdam
Larrue C (1992) The implementation of environmental policies by the French administration [mimeo]. Centre d’Etudes Supérieures d’Aménagement, Tours
Lorrain D (1991) Public goods and private operators in France. In: Batley R, Stoker G (eds) Local government in Europe. Macmillan, London, pp 89–109
Ministére de l’Tntérieur (1991) Les collectivités locales en chiffres. Documentation Française, Paris
Mitnick B (1980) The political economy of regulation. Columbia University Press, New York
Mørch S (1982) Den ny Danmarkshistorie 1880–1960. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Nicolazo J-L (1989) Les agences de l’eau. Pierre Johanet, Paris
North DC (1990) Institutions, institutional change, and economic performance. Cambridge Univer-sity Press, Cambridge
OECD (1989) Economic instruments for environmental protection. OECD, Paris
OECD (1994) Managing the environment: the role of economic instruments. OECD, Paris
Pearce D, Turner K (1990) Economics of natural resources and the environment. Harvester Wheatsheaf, New York
Pressman J, Wildawsky A (1973) Implementation. University of California Press, Berkeley
Rat von Sachverständigen für Umweltfragen (1974) Bundestagdrs, Gutachten, 7/2802, p 62
Richardson J, Watts N (1985) National policy styles and the environment: Britain and West Germany compared. IIUG dp 85-16. Wissenschaftszentrum, Berlin
Rijkswaterstaat (1990) De verontreinigingsheffing Rijkswateren in de toekomst. Rijkswaterstaat, The Hague
Schneider G, Sprenger R-U (eds) (1984) Mehr Umweltschutz für weniger Geld. IFO-Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung, Munich
Schuurman J (1988) De Prijs van Water. Gouda Quint BV, Arnheim
Van Waarden F (1995) Persistence of national policy styles: a study of their institutional foundations. In: Unger B, van Waarden F (eds) Convergence or diversity. Aldershot, Avebury, pp 333–372
Vogel D (1986) National styles of regulation: environmental policy in Great Britain and the United States. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Von Beyme K, Schmidt M (eds) (1990) Politik in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Westdeutscher Verlag, Opladen
Von Eyben WE (1989) Milørettens grundbog. Akademisk Forlag, Copenhagen
Weale A (1992) The new politics of pollution. Manchester University Press, Manchester see in particular Chap. 2 for an excellent overview
Wey K-G (1982) Umweltpolitik in Deutschland. Westdeutscher Verlag, Opladen
Wright V (1989) The government and politics of France. Unwin Hyman, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
About this article
Cite this article
Andersen, M.S. Governance by green taxes: implementing clean water policies in Europe 1970–1990. Environ Econ Policy Stud 2, 39–63 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03353902
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03353902