Abstract
In ecology textbooks prior to the 1970s, Aldo Leopold’s classic story of predator control, overpopulation of deer, and habitat degradation on the Kaibab Plateau during the 1920s epitomized predator regulation of herbivore populations. However, the story disappeared from texts in the late 20th century after several papers noted uncertainties in estimations of the deer population and provided alternative explanations. We re-examined the case study by determining the age structure of aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) on the plateau. Aspen comprises the majority of deer browse in the summer, and the absence of a normal cohort of aspen from the 1920s would indicate deer overpopulation. The number of aspen (at 1.4 m) dating to the 1920s was an order of magnitude lower than the null expectation. Other periods of unusual numbers of aspen included high numbers of aspen dating to the 1880s and 1890s (when regular surface fires ceased), few aspen dating from 1953 to 1962 (after a second irruption of the deer population), and very high numbers from 1968 to 1992 (coincident with widespread logging). These convergent lines of evidence support the idea of extreme deer herbivory in the 1920s, consistent with food limitation of deer at high populations (bottom–up control) and predation limitation at low deer populations (top–down control). Some uncertainty remains within the overall story, and this level of ambiguity is common in case studies that involve population ecology, land management, and people at the scale of 1,000 km2 and 100 years. A complete version of the Kaibab deer story and its history would be a valuable, realistic case study for ecology texts.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams CC. 1925. The conservation of predatory mammals. J Mammal 6:83–96
Avery TC, Burkhart H. 2002. Forest measurements. New York: McGraw-Hill
Barlow J, McCulloch CY. 1984. Recent dynamics and mortality rates of the Kaibab deer herd. Can J Zool 62:1805–12
Bostick VB. 1949. North Kaibab deer–livestock forage relationship study. Progress report (15 September, 1949), USDA Forest Services, Fredonia, Arizona
Botkin D. 1990. Discordant harmonies: a new ecology for the twenty-first century. New York: Oxford University Press
Burk JC. 1973. The Kaibab deer incident: a long persisting myth. BioScience 9:43–7
Carson R. 1962. Silent spring. Boston: Houghton-Mifflin
Caughley G. 1970. Eruption of ungulate populations, with emphasis on Himalayan thar in New Zealand. Ecology 51:53–71
Colinvaux P. 1973, 1986. Introduction to ecology. New York: Wiley
Cook ER, Meko DM, Stahle DW, Cleaveland MK. 1999. Drought reconstructions for the continental United States. J Clim 12:1145–62
Dasman RF. 1964. Wildlife biology. New York: Wiley
Dunlap TR. 1988. That Kaibab myth. J For Hist 31:60–8
Elton C. 1927. Animal ecology. New York: Macmillan
Fulé PZ, Covington WW, Moore MM, Heinlein TA, Waltz AEM. 2002. Natural variability in forests of the Grand Canyon, USA. J Biogeogr 29:21–47
Fulé PZ, Crouse JE, Heinlein TA, Moore MM, Covington WW, Verkamp G. 2003. Mixed-severity fire regime in a high-elevation forest of Grand Canyon, Arizona, USA. Landscape Ecol 18:465–86
Gasaway WC, Boertje RD, Grangaard DV, Kelleyhouse DG, Stephenson RO, Larsen DG. 1992. The role of predation in limiting moose at low densities in Alaska and Yukon and implications for conservation. Wildlife Monogr 120:1–59
Grey Z. 1924. The deer stalker. New York: Harper
Hungerford CR. 1970. Response of Kaibab mule deer to management of summer range. J Wildlife Manage 34:852–62
Joy SM. 2002. Northern goshawk habitat on the Kaibab National Forest in Arizona: factors affecting nest locations and territory quality [dissertation]. Fort Collins (Co): Colorado State University
Kimball TL, Watkins AG. 1951. The Kaibab North cooperative deer–livestock forage relationship study. Phoenix: Arizona Game and Fish Commission
Kormandy EJ. 1969. Concepts of ecology. Englewood Cliffs (MJ): Prentice-Hall
Krebs CJ. 2001. Ecology: the experimental analysis of distribution and abundance. San Francisco: Benjamin Cummings
Krebs CJ, Danell K, Angerbjorn A, Agrell J, Berteaux D, Brathen KA, Danell O, and others. 2003. Terrestrial trophic dynamics in the Canadian Arctic. Can J Zool 81:827–43
Lang DM, Stewart SS. 1910. Reconnaissance of the Kaibab National Forest. On file at North Kaibab Ranger District, Kaibab National Forest, Fredonia, Arizona
Leopold A. 1943. Deer irruptions. Wisc Conserv Bull 8:3–11
Mann WG. 1931, 1941. The Kaibab deer: a brief history and present plan of management. USDA Forest Service, Kaibab National Forest, Fredonia, Arizona (original 1931 report amended 1934 and 1941)
McHenry DE. 1935. Quaking aspen — its future in the park. Grand Canyon Nat Notes 9:361–5
Merkle J. 1962. Plant communities of the Grand Canyon area, Arizona. Ecology 43:698–711
Mitchell JE, Freeman DR. 1993. Wildlife-livestock-fire interactions on the North Kaibab: a historical overview. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report RM-222. Fort Collins (Co): USDA Forest Service
Molles M Jr. 1999. Ecology: concepts and applications. Boston: McGraw-Hill
Moore MM, Huffman D. 2004. Tree encroachment on meadows of North Rim, Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona, USA. Arctic Alpine Res 36:474–483
National Research Council. 2002. Ecological dynamics on Yellowstone’s northern range. Washington (DC): National Academy Press
Owen OS. 1971. Natural resource conservation: an ecological approach. New York: Macmillan
Paine RT. 2000. Phycology for the mammalogist: marine rocky shores and mammal-dominated communities — how different are the structuring processes? J of Mammal 81:637–48
Rasmussen DI. 1941. Biotic communities of the Kaibab Plateau, Arizona. Ecol Monogr 11:229–75
Reynolds RT, Graham RT, Reiser MH, Bassett RL, Kennedy PL, Boyce DA Jr, Goodwin G, and others. 1992. Management recommendations for the northern goshawk in the southwestern United States. USDA Forest Service General. Technical. Report. RM-217. Fort Collins (CO): USDA Forest Service
Ricklefs RE. 1973. Ecology. Newton (MA): Chrion Press
Ricklefs RE. 2001. The economy of nature. New York: WH Freeman
Ripple WJ, Beschta RL. 2003. Wolf reintroduction, predation risk, and cottonwood recovery in Yellowstone National Park. For Ecol Manage 184:299–313
Ripple WJ, Beschta RL. 2004. Wolves and the ecology of fear: can predation risk structure ecosystems? BioScience 54:755–66
Ripple WJ, Beschta RL. 2005. Linking wolves and plants: Aldo Leopold on trophic cascades. BioScience 55:613–621
Russo JP. 1964. The Kaibab deer herd: its history, problems, and management. Wildlife Bulletin No. 7. Phoenix (AZ): Arizona Game and Fish Department
Schier GA. 1975. Deterioration of aspen clones in the middle Rocky Mountains. USDA Forest Service Report INT-170. Ogden (UT): USDA Forest Service
Sesnie SE, Bailey J. 2003. Using history to plan the future of old-growth ponderosa pine. J For 101:40–7
Shepperd WD, Binkley D, Bartos D, Stohlgren TJ, Eskew LG, Eds. 2001. Sustaining aspen in western landscapes. USDA Forest Service, Fort Collins, Colorado. General Technical Report RMRS-P-18. 460 p
Smith RL, Smith TM. 2001. Ecology and field biology. San Francisco: Benjamin Cummings
Stiling P. 2002. Ecology: theories and applications. Upper Saddle River (MJ): Prentice-Hall
Thompson BH. 1934. National parks and wilderness use. In: Fauna of the national parks of the United States. Fauna Series No. 2. Washington (DC): National Park Service. p 47–55
Young CC. 2000. A textbook history: use of the Kaibab lesson in teaching biology. Am Biol Teach 62:559–64
Young CC. 2002. In the absence of predators: conservation and controversy on the Kaibab Plateau. Lincoln (NE): University of Nebraska Press
Acknowledgements
Funding for this work was provided by McIntire-Stennis appropriations to Colorado State University and by the Ecological Restoration Institute at Northern Arizona University. Field work and core dating were performed by Matt Tuten, Melinda Erickson, Teresa DeKokker, Faith Rudebush, Scott Sink, Chris Hayes, Greg Newman, Joey Blankenship, Geoff Seymour, Jonas Feinstein, Heidi Steltzer, Megan Smith, and Dirk Hobman. We thank Dennis Lund (formerly with the Kaibab National Forest) for his insights and help with relocation of the exclosure study and background information; John Goodwin (of the Arizona Fish and Game Department) for sharing information on deer populations and hunting; and the people of the North Kaibab Ranger District for their logistical help during the field work.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Binkley, D., Moore, M.M., Romme, W.H. et al. Was Aldo Leopold Right about the Kaibab Deer Herd?. Ecosystems 9, 227–241 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-005-0100-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-005-0100-z