Abstract
Even if convergences are to be observed among the orientations adopted by higher education policies in European countries, they still are characterized by strong national features. One of the most striking national patterns of each system is its academic labor market, salaries, status, recruitment procedures, workloads, career patterns, promotion rules, being very different from one country to another. Nevertheless, specific national academic labor markets are experiencing a common evolution that can be summed up by the emergence of more regulated internal labor markets. At the same time, the qualification of the academic production (knowledge) as a public good is questioned and academic activities rely less on individual autonomy than before. Two main transformations can be mentioned: the development of individual assessment and incentive devices in universities and the increasing role of higher education institutions in the issues previously in the domain of the academic profession. The paper relies on a limited number of cases and on empirical studies recently carried out in France and Germany. The evolution engaged in the two countries will be reviewed in order to show that they lead, in different ways, to more regulated ‘‘internal labor markets’’. It will also be argued that this is a general trend. In the last section, the implications linked to this evolution and the questions raised, the role of the academic profession, and the transformation of the status of scientific and pedagogical activities will be discussed.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A. Alchian (1977) ‘The relative cost of tenure’ A. Alchian (Eds) Economic Forces at Work, Selected Works of Armen A. Alchian Liberty Press Indianapolis
P. Altbach (2000) The Changing Academic Workplace. Comparative Perspectives Boston College Center for International Higher Education Boston
M. Blangy C. Musselin (1996) Etude de cinq commissions de spécialistes en histoire Rapport d’enquête CSO Paris
P. Blau (1973) The Organization of Academic Work Wiley-Interscience New York
C. Brisset-Sillion (1997) Les universités publiques aux Etats-Unis : Une autonomie sous tutelle L’Harmattan Paris
H.L. Carmichael (1988) ArticleTitle‘Incentives in Academics: why is there Tenure?’ Journal of Political Economy 96 IssueID3 453–472 Occurrence Handle10.1086/261547
R.P. Chait (Eds) (2002) The Questions of Tenure Harvard University Press Cambridge
B.R. Clark (1983) The Higher Education System: Academic Organization in Cross-national Perspectives University of California Press Berkeley
Cytermann, J.R., Bideault, M., Rossi, P. and Thomas, L. (2002). Recrutements et renouvellement des enseignants-chercheurs: Disparités entre établissements et disciplines. Contribution to the RESUP research seminar, 7th of March, Nanterre.
J. Dearlove (1997) ArticleTitle‘The Academic Labour Process: From Collegiality and Professionalism to Managerialism and Proletarianisation?’ Higher Education Review 30 IssueID1 56–75
Dejean, J. (2002). L’évaluation de l’enseignement dans les universités françaises: rapport suivi de I’avis du Haut conseil de l’évaluation de I’école, report to the Haut conseil de l’évaluation de I’école.
P.B. Doeringer M.J. Piore (1971) Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis Heath Lexington Books Lexington
J. Enders (1956) Die Wissenschaftlichen Mitarbeiter Campus Verlag Frankfurt, New York
Enders, J. (ed.) (2000). Employment and Working Conditions of Academic Staff in Europe, Materialen und Dokumente, Hochschule und Forschung, Francfort sur le Main.
J. Enders (2001) Academic Staff in Europe, Changing Contexts and Conditions Greenwood Press Westport
Espéret, E. (2001). Nouvelle définition des tâches des enseignants et des enseignants chercheurs dans l’enseignement supérieur français, commission report to the French Ministry of Education.
Fresse, A. (1998). Commissions de recrutement : Commissions de spécialistes. Etude du recrutement des professeurs d’histoire dans quatre universités allemandes, Mémoire de DEA de l’Institut d’Etudes Politiques de Paris.
A. Fresse (1999) L’expertise importée: Monographie sur le recrutement des professseurs de mathématiques dans quatre universités allemandes Rapport d’enquête CSO Paris
O. Fulton (1994) Remote and Ineffectual Dons? The Academic Profession at the End of the Twentieth Century Lancaster University Inaugural Lecture
F. Hanin (1994) Gestion des carriéres et organisation disciplinaire : Les mathématiques Rapport d’enquête CSO Paris
M. Henkel (2000) Academic Identities and Policy Change in Higher Education Jessica Kingsley Publishers London and Philadelphia
L. Karpik (1989) ArticleTitle‘L’économie de la qualité’ Revue Française de Sociologie 30 IssueID2 187–210
M. Kogan M. Bauer I. Bleiklie M. Henkel (2000) Transforming Higher Education: A comparative study Jessica Kingsley Publishers London and Philadelphia
M. Kogan S. Hanney (2000) Reforming Higher Education Jessica Kingsley Publishers London and Philadelphia
J. Lazar (2001) Les secrets de famille de l’université Les empêcheurs de penser en rond Paris
E.P. Lazear S. Rozen (1981) ArticleTitleRank-Order Tournaments as Optimum Labor Contracts Journal of Political Economy 89 IssueID5 841–864 Occurrence Handle10.1086/261010
M. Maurice F. Sellier J.-J. Sylvestre (1982) Politique d’éducation et organisation industrielle en France et en Allemagne PUF Paris
M. Maurice A. Sorge (2000) Embedding Organizations. Societal analysis of Actors, Organizations and Socio-economic Context John Benjamins Amsterdam, Philadelphia
Mayer, K.-U. (2000). ‘Wissenschaft als Beruf oder Karriere?’, contribution to the conference on ‘Wissenschaft zwischen Geld und Geist’, Max-Planck-Institut für Wissenschaftsgeschichte, Berlin, 16--18 November.
P.-M. Menger (2002) Portrait de l’artiste en travailleur. Métamorphoses du capitalisme Seuil Paris
Merton, R.K. (1962). ‘Priorities in scientific discovery: a chapter in the sociology of science’, in Barber, B. and Hirsch, W. (eds.), The Sociology of Science. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press Publishers, pp. 447--485 (reprinted from Merton, K.R. (1957) in American Sociological Review 22, 635--659).
Merton, R.K. (1962). ‘Science and the Social Order’, in Barber, B. and Hirsch, W. (eds.), The Sociology of Science. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press Publishers, pp. 537–561 (reprinted from Merton, K.R. (1957). Social theory and Social Structure. New York: The Free Press of Glencoe, revised edition).
S. Mignot-Gérard C. Musselin (2000) Enquête quantitative des modes de gouvernement de 37 établissements CAFI-CSO et Agence de Modernisation des universités Paris
C. Musselin (1996) ArticleTitle‘Les marchés du travail universitaires comme économie de la qualité’ Revue Française de Sociologie 37 IssueID2 189–207
Musselin, C. (2000a). ‘The Role of ideas in the Emergence of Convergent Higher Education Policies in Europe: The Case of France’, Working Paper Series #73, Center for European Studies, Harvard University.
C. Musselin (2000b) Le recrutement et la carrière des historiens et des mathématiciens dans des universités privées américaines CSO Rapport d’enquête Paris
Musselin, C. (2002). ‘Constructing French Universities as Organisations’, Colloque ‘Regards croisés sur l’enseignement supérieur: France - Grande-Bretagne’, Maison Française, Oxford - 3rd and 4th of May 2002.
C. Musselin (2004) ArticleTitle‘Towards a European academic labour market?, Some lessons drawn from empirical studies on academic mobility’ Higher Education 48 55–78 Occurrence Handle10.1023/B:HIGH.0000033770.24848.41
B. O’Flaherty A. Siow (1992) ArticleTitle‘On the Job Screening, Up or Out Rules and Firm Growth’ Canadian Journal of Economics 25 IssueID2 346–368
B. O’Flaherty A. Siow (1995) ArticleTitle‘Up or Out Rules in the Market for Lawyers’ Journal of Labor Economics 13 IssueID4 709–735 Occurrence Handle10.1086/298390
S. Oliveira de (1998) Etude de cinq commissions de spécialistes en mathématiques Rapport d’enquête CSO Paris
Osterman, P. (2002). ‘Changing work Organization in the United States’, Contribution presented at the conference on ‘Transforming the Democratic Balance Among State, Market and Society: Comparative Perspectives on France and the Developed Democracies, Harvard University, April 2002.
Reed, M. (2001). ‘New Managerialism, Professional Power and Organisational Governance in UK Universities: A Review and Assessment’, Contribution to the Hedda -- Cipés Conference, Pinhao, Portugal, 14--16th October.
A. Renaut (1995) Les révolutions de l’université. Essai sur la modernisation de la culture Calmann-Levy Paris
Siow, A. (1995). The Organization of the Market for Professors, Working Paper No UT-ECIPA-SIOW-95-01, Université de Toronto.
A.B. Sørensen (1993) ‘Wissenschaftliche Werdegänge und akademische Arbeitsmärkte’ K.U. Mayer (Eds) Generationsdynamik in der Forschung Campus Verlag Frankfurt New York 83–109
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Musselin, C. European academic labor markets in transition. High Educ 49, 135–154 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-004-2918-2
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-004-2918-2