Abstract
The GIS-multicriteria decision analysis (GIS-MCDA) technique is increasingly used for landslide hazard mapping and zonation. It enables the integration of different data layers with different levels of uncertainty. In this study, three different GIS-MCDA methods were applied to landslide susceptibility mapping for the Urmia lake basin in northwest Iran. Nine landslide causal factors were used, whereby parameters were extracted from an associated spatial database. These factors were evaluated, and then, the respective factor weight and class weight were assigned to each of the associated factors. The landslide susceptibility maps were produced based on weighted overly techniques including analytic hierarchy process (AHP), weighted linear combination (WLC) and ordered weighted average (OWA). An existing inventory of known landslides within the case study area was compared with the resulting susceptibility maps. Respectively, Dempster-Shafer Theory was used to carry out uncertainty analysis of GIS-MCDA results. Result of research indicated the AHP performed best in the landslide susceptibility mapping closely followed by the OWA method while the WLC method delivered significantly poorer results. The resulting figures are generally very high for this area, but it could be proved that the choice of method significantly influences the results.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Atkinson PM, Massari R (2011) Autologistic modelling of susceptibility to landsliding in the Central Apennines, Italy. Geomorphology 130:55–64
Ayalew L, Yamagishi H (2005) The application of GIS-based logistic regression for landslide susceptibility mapping in the Kakuda-Yahiko Mountains, Central Japan. Geomorphology 65:15–31
Ayalew L, Yamagishi H, Ugawa N (2004) Landslide susceptibility mapping using GIS-based weighted linear combination, the case in Tsugawa area of Agano River, Niigata Prefecture, Japan. Landslides 1:73–81
Ayalew L, Yamagishi H, Marui H, Kanno T (2005) Landslides in Sado Island of Japan: part II. GIS-based susceptibility mapping with comparisons of results from two methods and verifications. Eng Geol 81:432–445
Ayele S (2009) Slope instability and hazard zonation mapping using remote sensing and GIS techniques in Abay Gorg (Gohatsion dejen) central Ethiopia. Faculty of Sciences, University of Addis Ababa, Master thesis
Bai S, Lu G, Wang J, Zhou P, Ding L (2011) GIS-based rare events logistic regression for landslide susceptibility mapping of Lianyungang, China. Environ Earth Sci 62:139–149
Banai R (1993) Fuzziness in geographic information systems: contributions from the analytic hierarchy process. Int J Geogr Inform Syst 7(4):315–329
Barredo JI, Benavides A, Hervas J, Van Westen CJ (2000) Comparing heuristic landslide hazard assessment techniques using GIS in the Tirajana basin, Gran Canaria Island, Spain. Int J Appl Earth Obs Geoinf 2:9–23
Barzilai J (1998) On the decomposition of value functions. Oper Res Lett 22:159–170
Bennett DA, Wade GA, Armstrong MP (1999) Exploring the solution space of semi-structured geographical problems using genetic algorithms. Trans GIS 3(1):51–71
Bodin L, Gass S (2003) On teaching the analytic hierarchy process. Comput Oper Res 30:1487–1497
Boroushaki S, Malczewski J (2008) Implementing an extension of the analytical hierarchy process using ordered weighted averaging operators with fuzzy quantifiers in ArcGIS. Comput Geosci 34:399–410
Boroushaki S, Malczewski J (2010) Using the fuzzy majority approach for GIS-based multicriteria group decision-making. Comput Geosci 36:302–312
Carrara A, Cardinali M, Detti R, Guzzetti F, Pasqui V, Reichenbach P (1991) GIS techniques and statistical models in evaluating landslide hazard. Earth Surf Proc Land 16(5):427–445
Carrara A, Cardinali M, Guzzetti F, Reichenbach P (1995) GIS technology in mapping landslide hazard. In: Carrara A, Guzzetti F (eds) Geographical information systems in assessing natural hazards. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 135–175
Carver SJ (1991) Integrating multi-criteria evaluation with geographical information systems. Int J Geogr Inform Syst 5(3):321–339
Cervi F, Berti M, Borgatti L, Ronchetti F, Manenti F, Corsini A (2010) Comparing predictive capability of statistical and deterministic methods for landslide susceptibility mapping: a case study in the northern Apennines (Reggio Emilia Province, Italy). Landslides 7:433–444
Chauhan S, Sharma M, Arora MK (2010) Landslide susceptibility zonation of the Chamoli region, Garhwal Himalayas, using logistic regression model. Landslides 7:411–423
Chen SJ, Hwang CL (1992) Fuzzy multiple attribute decision making. Springer, Berlin
Chen J, Zhu Q (2010) Uncertainty and decision strategy analysis of GIS-based ordered weighted averaging method. In: International conference on information networking and automation (ICINA)
Chen Y, Khan S, Paydar Z (2009) To retire or expand? A fuzzy GIS-based spatial multi-criteria evaluation framework for irrigated agriculture. Irrig Drain 59(2):174–188
Dai FC, Lee CF (2002) Landslide characteristics and slope instability modelling using GIS, Lantau Island, Hong Kong. Geomorphology 42:213–228
Das I, Sahoo S, van Westen C, Stein A, Hack R (2010) Landslide susceptibility assessment using logistic regression and its comparison with a rock mass classification system, along a road section in the northern Himalayas (India). Geomorphology 114:627–637
Das S, Stein A, Kerle N, Dadhwal VK (2011) Probabilistic landslide hazard assessment using homogeneous susceptible units (HSU) along a national highway corridor in the northern Himalayas, India. Landslides 8:293–308
Dempster AP (1967) Upper and lower probabilities induced by a multivalued mapping. Ann Math Stat 28:325–339
Deng H (1999) Multi-criteria analysis with fuzzy pairwise comparisons. Int J Approx Reason 21:215–231
Eastman JR (1997) IDRISI for windows, version 2.0: tutorial exercises. Clark University, Worcester
Eastman JR (2001) Guide to GIS and image processing, release 32. Clark Labs, Clark University, Worcester
Feick RD, Hall GB (1999) Consensus building in a multi-participant spatial decision support system. URISA J 11(2):17–23
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2011) Landslide risk assessment based on gis multi-criteria evaluation: a case study Boston Abad county, Iran. J Earth Sci Eng 1:66–71
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2012a) Land suitability analysis for Tabriz County, Iran: a multi-criteria evaluation approach using GIS. J Environ Planning Manag. doi:10.1080/09640568.2011.646964
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2012b) Uncertainty analysis of GIS-based ordered weighted averaging method for landslide susceptibility mapping in Urmia Lake Basin, Iran. In: Paper presented at the seventh International Geographic Information Science conference, September 18–21, Ohio, Columbus, USA, 2012
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T (2012c) Comparing GIS-multicriteria decision analysis for landslide susceptibility mapping for the Urmia lake basin, Iran. In: Paper presented at the IEEE international geoscience and remote sensing symposium, Igarss, 22–27 July, Munich, Germany
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T, Rafiq L (2011) GIS based landslide susceptibility mapping: a case study Bostan abad County, Iran. Paper presented at the International conference Geoinformatics for Disaster Management, 03-08 May 2011, Antalya, Turkey
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T, Nazmfar H (2012a) GIS-based ordered weighted averaging and dempster shafer methods for landslide susceptibility mapping in Urmia lake Basin, Iran. Int J Digit Earth (in press)
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T, Rezaei Moghaddam M.H (2012b) Landslide susceptibility mapping for the Urmia Lake basin, Iran: a multi-criteria evaluation approach using GIS. Int J Environ Res (in press)
Feizizadeh B, Blaschke T, Nazmfar Z, Akbari E, Kohbanani (2012c) Monitoring land surface temperature relationship to land use/land cover from satellite imagery in Maraqeh County, Iran. J Environ Planning Manag. doi:10.1080/09640568.2012.717888
Fell R, Corominas J, Bonnard C, Cascini L, Leroi E, Savage WZ (2008) Guidelines for landslide susceptibility, hazard and risk zoning for land-use planning. Eng Geol 102:99–111
Forman EH, Selly MA (2001) Decision by objective, how to convince others that you are right. World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd, Singapore
Gorsevski PV, Jankowski P (2008) Discerning landslide susceptibility using rough sets. Comput Environ Urban Syst 32:53–65
Gorsevski PV, Jankowski P (2010) An optimized solution of multi-criteria evaluation analysis of landslide susceptibility using fuzzy sets and Kalman filter. Comput Geosci 36:1005–1020
Gorsevski PV, Jankowski P, Gessler PE (2006) An heuristic approach for mapping landslide hazard by integrating fuzzy logic with analytic hierarchy process. Control Cybern 35:21–141
Gorsevski PV, Donevska KR, Mitrovski CD, Frizado JD (2012) Integrating multi-criteria evaluation techniques with geographic information systems for landfill site selection: a case study using ordered weighted average. Waste Manag (Oxford) 32:287–296
Guzzetti F, Reichenbach P, Cardinali M, Galli M, Ardizzone F (2005) Probabilistic landslide hazard assessment at the basin scale. Geomorphology 72:272–299
Intarawichian N, Dasananda S (2010) Analytical hierarchy process for landslide susceptibility mapping in lower Mae Chem watershed, Northern Thailand. Suranaree J Sci Technol 17(3):277–292
Iranian Census Centre (2007) Iranian cities population. Online available at, http://www.amar.org.ir
Jankowski P, Nyerges T (2001a) Geographic information systems for group decision-making: towards a participatory geographic information science. Taylor & Francis, New York, p 273
Jankowski P, Nyerges T (2001b) GIS-supported collaborative decision-making: results of an experiment. Ann As Am Geogr 91(1):48–70
Jankowski P, Richard L (1994) Integration of GIS-based suitability analysis and multicriteria evaluation in a spatial decision support system for route selection. Environ Planning 21(3):326–339
Jankowski P, Nyerges TL, Smith A, Moore TJ, Horvath E (1997) Spatial group choice: a SDSS tool for collaborative spatial decision-making. Int J Geogr Inform Sci 11(6):577–602
Jiang H, Eastman JR (2000) Application of fuzzy measures in multi-criteria evaluation in GIS. Int J Geogr Inform Sci 14:173–184
Joerin F, Theriault M, Musy A (2001) Using GIS and outranking multicriteria analysis for land-use suitability assessment. Int J Geogr Inform Sci 15:153–174
Komac M (2006) A landslide susceptibility model using the analytical hierarchy process method and multivariate statistics in perialpine Slovenia. Geomorphology 74(1–4):17–28
Kritikos T, Davies TRH (2011) GIS-based Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis for landslide susceptibility mapping at northern Evia, Greece. Z dt Ges Geowiss 162:421–434
Kyem PAK (2004) On intractable conflicts participatory GIS applications: the search for consensus amidst competing claims and institutional demands. Ann As Am Geogr 94(1):37–57
Lee S, Choi J (2004) Landslide susceptibility mapping using GIS and the weight of-evidence model. Int J Geogr Inform Sci 18:789–814
Lei Z, Jing-feng H (2006) GIS-based logistic regression method for landslide susceptibility mapping in regional scale. J Zhejiang Univ Sci A 7(2):2007–2012
Leskinen P (2000) Measurement scales and scale independence in the analytic hierarchy process. J Multi-Criteria Decis Anal 9:163–174
Lootsma FA (1993) Scale sensitivity in the multiplicative AHP and SMART. J Multi-Criteria Decis Anal 2:87–110
Makropoulos C, Butler D, Maksimovic C (2003) A fuzzy logic spatial decision support system for urban water management. J Water Resour Planning Manag 129(1):69–77
Malczewski J (1996) A GIS-based approach to multiple criteria group decision- making. Int J Geogr Inform Syst 10(8):955–971
Malczewski J (1999) GIS and multicriteria decision analysis. Wiley, Toronto
Malczewski J (2000) On the use of weighted linear combination method in GIS: common and best practice approaches. Trans GIS 4(1):5–22
Malczewski J (2004) GIS-based land-use suitability analysis: a critical overview. Prog Planning 62(1):3–65
Malczewski J (2006a) GIS-based multicriteria decision analysis: a survey of the literature. Int J Geogr Inform Sci 20(7):703–726
Malczewski J (2006b) Multicriteria decision analysis for collaborative GIS. In: Balram S, Dragicevic S (eds) Collaborative Geographic Information Systems. Idea Group Publishing, Hershey, pp 167–185
Malczewski J, Rinner C (2005) Exploring multi-criteria decision strategies in GIS with linguistic quantifiers: a case study of residential quality evaluation. J Geogr Syst 7(2):249–268
Malczewski J, Chapman T, Flegel C, Walters D, Shrubsole D, Healy MA (2003) GIS-multi-criteria evaluation with ordered weighted averaging (OWA): a case study of developing watershed management strategies. Environ Planning 35:1769–1784
MANR Ministry of Agriculture and Natural Resources (2008) Land use land cover mapping for Iran, Tehran, Iran
Marinoni O (2004) Implementation of the analytical hierarchy process with VBA in ArcGIS. Comput Geosci 30(6):637–646
Meng Y, Malczewski J, Boroushaki S (2011) A GIS-Based multicriteria decision analysis approach for mapping accessibility patterns of housing development sites: a case study in Canmore, Alberta. J Geogr Inform Syst 3:50–61
Mikhailov L (2003) Deriving priorities from fuzzy pairwise comparison judgements. Fuzzy Sets Syst 134:365–385
MNR, Ministry of Natural Resources, East Azerbaijan Province (2010) Landslide event report, Tabriz, Iran
Nyerges TL, Montejano R, Oshiro C, Dadswell M (1997) Group-based geographic information systems for transportation improvement site selection. Transp Res Part C Emerg Technol 5(6):349–369
Oh HJ, Pradhan P (2011) Application of a neuro-fuzzy model to landslide-susceptibility mapping for shallow landslides in a tropical hilly area. Comput Geosci 37(9):1264–1276
Park NW (2011) Application of Dempster-Shafer theory of evidence to GIS-based landslide susceptibility analysis. Environ Earth Sci 62:367–376
Phua M, Minowa M (2005) A GIS-based multi-criteria decision making approach to forest conservation planning at a landscape scale: a case study in the Kinabalu Area, Sabah, Malaysia. Landsc Urban Planning 71:207–222
Prakash TN (2003) Land suitability analysis for agricultural crops: A fuzzy multicriteria decision making approach. MSc thesis, ITC, Netherlands
Robinson TP, van Klinken DR, Metternicht G (2010) Comparison of alternative strategies for invasive species distribution modelling. Ecol Model 221:2261–2269
Saaty TL (1977) A scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structures. J Math Psychol 15:231–281
Saaty TL (1980) The analytic hierarchy process. McGraw-Hill, New York, p 437
Saaty TL, Vargas LG (1991) Prediction, projection and forecasting. Kluwer, Dordrecht, p 251
Sener S, Sener E, Karaguzel R (2010) Solid waste disposal site selection with GIS and AHP methodology: a case study in Senirkent-Uluborlu (Isparta) Basin, Turkey. J Environ Monit Assess 10:1010–1023
Shafer G (1976) A mathematical theory of evidence. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Starr MK, Zeleny M (1977) MCDM—state and future of the arts. In: Starr MK, Zeleny M (eds) Multiple criteria decision-making. North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp 5–29
Thanh LN (2008) Landslide susceptibility mapping of the mountainous area in a Luoi District, Thua thien hue province, Vietnam, PhD Thesis, Department of Hydrology & Hydraulic Engineering, University of Brussels
Vaidya OS, Kumar S (2006) Analytic hierarchy process: an overview of applications. Eur J Oper Res 169:1–29
Van Westen CJ, Soeters R, Sijmons K (2000) Digital geomorphological landslide hazard mapping of the Alpago area, Italy. Int J Appl Earth Obs Geoinf 2:51–60
Van Westen CJ, van Asch TWJ, Soeters R (2006) Landslide hazard and risk zonation-why is it still so difficult? Bull Eng Geol Environ 65:167–184
Van Westen CJ, Castellanos E, Kuriakose SL (2008) Spatial data for landslide susceptibility, hazard, and vulnerability assessment: an overview. Eng Geol 102(3–4):112–131
Vargas LG (1990) An overview of the analytic hierarchy process and its applications. Eur J Oper Res 48:2–8
Varnes DJ (1984) International association of engineering geology comm. on landslides and other mass movements on slopes: landslide hazard zonation: a review of principles and practice, UNESCO Band 63, Paris
Voogd H (1983) Multi-criteria evaluations for urban and regional planning. Princeton University, Princeton
Yager RR (1988) On ordered weighted averaging aggregation operators in multicriteria decision making. IEEE Trans Syst Man Cybern 8:183–190
Yager RR (1996) Quantifier guided aggregation using OWA operation. Int J Intell Syst 2(1):49–73
Yager RR (1997) On the inclusion of importances in OWA aggregation. In: Yager RR, Kacprzyk J (eds) The ordered weighted averaging operators: theory and applications. Kluwer, Boston, pp 41–59
Yahaya S, Ilori C, Whanda JS, Edicha J (2010) Land fill site selection for municipal solid waste management using geographic information system and multicriteria evaluation. Am J Sci Res 10:34–49
Yalcin A (2008) GIS-based landslide susceptibility mapping using analytical hierarchy process and bivariate statistics in Ardesen (Turkey): comparisons of results and confirmations. Catena 72:1–12
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank the reviewers for their helpful and constructive comments on earlier versions of the manuscript and the Department of Geoinformatics (Z_GIS) University of Salzburg for partial financial support. We also appreciate the help of Dr. Hasan Ahmadzadeh, University of Tabriz, for his help and in particular for providing rights for Fig. 2. This work was carried out as part of a PhD study funded by the Iranian Ministry of Science, Research and Technology and including a study period at the University of Salzburg.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Feizizadeh, B., Blaschke, T. GIS-multicriteria decision analysis for landslide susceptibility mapping: comparing three methods for the Urmia lake basin, Iran. Nat Hazards 65, 2105–2128 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-012-0463-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-012-0463-3