Productivity growth in Illinois electric utilities

doi:10.1016/0165-0572(90)90030-M

Resources and Energy

Volume 12, Issue 4, December 1990, Pages 383-398

Resources and Energy

https://doi.org/10.1016/0165-0572(90)90030-M Get rights and content

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to study productivity growth in Illinois electric utilities. We develop an input based Malmquist productivity index which makes use of Shephard's input distance functions. Our Malmquist productivity index does not require that firms be revenue maximizers or cost minimizers or that information be available on input prices. Moreover, our productivity index accounts for changes in technical efficiency as well as changes in the frontier technology. Linear programming techniques are used to calculate the Malmquist productivity index for a sample of 19 coal-fired steam electric generating plants in Illinois during 1975–1981. On average, rates of productivity growth are relatively stable but statistically significant productivity slowdown is found for the period of 1976–1977. The major contribution to this productivity slowdown is due to technological regress in that period. At the plant-specific level, we found that there are considerable variations in changes in both efficiency and technology and that efficiency change plays a major role in productivity growth. Our results suggest that neglecting technical efficiency in the analysis of productivity growth may lead to inappropriate conclusions.

References (14)

R. Färe et al.
The relative efficiency of Illinois electric utilities
Resources and Energy
(1983)
D.W. Caves et al.
The economic theory of index numbers and the measurement of input, output and productivity
Econometrica
(1982)
D.W. Caves et al.
Multilateral comparisons of output, input and productivity using superlative index numbers
Economic Journal
(1982)
L.R. Christensen et al.
Economies of scale in U.S. electric power generation
Journal of Political Economy
(1976)
T.G. Cowing et al.
Comparative measures of total factor productivity in the regulated sector: The electric utility industry
Energy Information Administration
Steam-electric plant construction cost and annual production expenses
Energy Information Administration
Thermal-electric plant construction cost and annual production expenses

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (82)

Eco-efficiency changes of the electricity and gas sectors across 28 European countries: A value-based data envelopment analysis productivity approach
2023, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences
This paper assesses the relative eco-efficiency changes in the electricity and gas sector (E&G)' production and consumption chains in 28 European countries. We propose a novel robustness assessment for the productivity index, specifically adjusted to value-based data envelopment analysis. Overall, results indicate that total factor productivity gains have been mainly driven by the catch-up effect across all chains of the E&G sector. When a more demanding perspective concerning negative environmental externalities is adopted, we find that the number of European countries that achieved productivity gains across all chains decreases. Besides, results depict the existence of lower productivity gains for the direct production chain when compared with the direct and indirect supply chains of the E&G sector. Germany, Luxembourg, and Belgium were consistently viewed as innovators across all chains, according to the environmental perspective. Several Eastern Europe countries usually viewed as policy laggards that resisted adopting the ambitious European decarbonization targets, showed total factor productivity gains in the supply chain of the E&G sector under a more environmental demanding perspective. Czechia was the only country with productivity losses across all chains, due to increasing coal-fired electricity generation in the time horizon assessed. The current partial return to coal as a source of electricity, due to the geopolitical tensions between Russia and Europe, brings additional challenges to the enhancement of the eco-efficiency of the European E&G sector.
Has the market-oriented reform of 2015 affected the performance of China's power grid firms?
2022, Energy and Climate Change
The efficiency analysis of incentive regulations on utilities is an important issue to investigate the impact of the market-oriented reform. This paper analyzes the influence of the 2015 reform on 30 provincial power grid firms in China during 2011–2018. We employ a data envelopment analysis (DEA) model combined with bootstrap estimation to measure the efficiency through statistical inference, from both static and total factor productivity (TFP) perspectives. The results show that most provincial grid firms are difficult to achieve efficiency improvement by putting forward the reform in the short-term. However, the positive correlation between market transactions and efficiency indicates that the market-oriented reform improves efficiency significantly. Nevertheless, the gap between the studied DMUs and the efficient ones is the result of regional differences and the significant influence of weather heterogeneity.
Assessing the impact of COVID-19 on the efficiency of Portuguese state-owned enterprise hospitals
2022, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences
This paper uses Value-Based Data Envelopment Analysis (VBDEA), to assess the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the efficiency of 37 state-owned enterprises (SOE) hospitals by employing data publicly available from the Portuguese Health Service database between January and November 2019 and 2020, respectively. Furthermore, a productivity index (specifically adjusted to the VBDEA approach) is also used that allows identifying which factors are behind the relative efficiency changes of these hospitals. The factors considered to perform the efficiency assessment of the Portuguese SOE hospitals include labour, capacity, and activity-related indicators. Out of the 37 SOE hospitals, 21 and 17 were efficient in 2019 and 2020, respectively. Irrespective of the value functions considered, the hospitals more often viewed as a reference for best practices were Santa Maria Maior, Tâmega e Sousa and Entre Douro e Vouga. Santa Maria Maior and Algarve were the only hospitals found to be robustly efficient for both years. Overall, the majority of SOE hospitals showed negative productivity (except for Évora and Santa Maria Maior) and all of them presented negative technological change, thus highlighting the massive impact that the COVID-19 outbreak has had on the performance of these hospitals. An additional conclusion is that inefficient hospitals substantially increased all their resources in 2020 as compared to inefficient hospitals in 2019, suggesting that the inefficiency of these hospitals was not due to the lack of resources. Finally, irrespective of the model employed, the hospitals located in the Portuguese northern region were more resilient to the COVID-19 crisis. All in all, to become more resilient (even for future COVID-19 outbreaks), hospitals should undertake changes that are advantageous irrespective of the obstacles they face and that are even beneficial during normal times. A culture of cooperation within and across hospitals should also be cultivated, which allows exchanging resources where they can be used more efficiently.
A performance evaluation of China's coal-fired power generation with pollutant mitigation options
2018, Journal of Cleaner Production
Recently, performance evaluation of coal-fired power generation with high pollution based on data envelopment analysis (DEA) method has become an advanced research hotspot in China. Instead of a single process in previous studies, we divide the production system of coal-fired power plants into the production process and pollutants abatement process, with pollutant intermediates as the link to connect the two processes in the current paper. Then we present a new two-stage network DEA model to evaluate the performance of China's coal-fired power generation by improving the link constraint that different with traditional network DEA approaches. Meanwhile, we conduct an empirical study to verify the applicability of the proposed approach and find that the proposed model is more effective than the previous models in evaluating the inefficiencies of coal-fired power generation. The empirical results also show that: the inefficiencies of the pollutants abatement process bring poor performance of the regional coal-fired power plants; and the efficiency results vary greatly among different areas of China, efficiency is best in the west area but the worst in the northeast area. Finally, some appropriate propositions are present in order to create better conditions for China's sustainable development.
A literature study for DEA applied to energy and environment
2017, Energy Economics
This study systematically summarizes previous research efforts on Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) applied to energy and environment in the past four decades, including concepts and methodologies on DEA environmental assessment. Industrial developments are very important for all nations in terms of their economic prosperities. A problem is that the development produces various pollutions on air, water and other types of contaminations, all of which are usually associated with our health problems and climate changes. Thus, it is necessary for us to consider how to make a balance between economic success and pollution mitigation to maintain a high level of social sustainability in the world. It is widely considered that DEA is one of the methodologies to examine the level of sustainability. This study examines a recent research trend on DEA applications from 1980s to 2010s. Nowadays, many researchers have paid serious attention on how to combat various difficulties in the areas of energy and environment. As a result, the number of articles on DEA applications on energy and environment has dramatically increased, particularly after 2000s. However, it is true that DEA has strengths and drawbacks in the applications. Therefore, it is very important for us to carefully use DEA for guiding large policy issues and business strategies such as the global warming and climate change. An underlying premise of this study is that technology innovation in engineering and natural science may solve various problems by linking it with political and managerial efforts. The use of DEA provides a methodological linkage among them, so enhancing the practicality in mitigating problems due to climate change and environmental pollutions. This literature study, along with a summary on conceptual and methodological developments, provides us with guidelines for our future research works on DEA on energy and environment issues.
Productivity and efficiency measurement of the Danish centralized biogas power sector
2016, Renewable Energy
The widespread use of the renewable energy sources in the future's energy production is necessary, in order to avoid the predicted environmental, economic and social effects which can be derived from the overuse of fossil fuels. Denmark has announced to be fossil fuel independent with a renewable energy based heat and power source by 2050. Theoretically, the centralized biogas combined heat and power plants can play a determinant role in the subsequent Danish energy supply scheme, due to its feature to satisfy base load demand. The productivity and efficiency analysis of the currently operating Danish centralizes biogas CHP power plants is crucial in order to study whether there is a most efficient power plant which can be introduced as a “best practice” innovative technology for the future's Danish biogas power plants. In this paper we use the intertemporal Malmquist total factor productivity DEA method to analyze the change in the efficiency and productivity of the Danish centralized biogas power plants in the period 1992–2005.

View all citing articles on Scopus

^☆: The authors would like to thank an anonymous referee for insightful comments.

View full text

Productivity growth in Illinois electric utilities☆

Abstract

Resources and Energy

The economic theory of index numbers and the measurement of input, output and productivity

Econometrica

Multilateral comparisons of output, input and productivity using superlative index numbers

Economic Journal

Economies of scale in U.S. electric power generation

Journal of Political Economy

Comparative measures of total factor productivity in the regulated sector: The electric utility industry

Steam-electric plant construction cost and annual production expenses

Thermal-electric plant construction cost and annual production expenses