Hydrology of the wetland Naarderemeer: Influence of the surrounding area and impact on vegetation

doi:10.1016/0378-3774(88)90098-4

Agricultural Water Management

Volume 14, Issues 1–4, August 1988, Pages 459-470

https://doi.org/10.1016/0378-3774(88)90098-4 Get rights and content

Abstract

The Naardermeer is a polder located in the central Netherlands at the foot of a sandy ice-pushed ridge. It has been put on the list of.internationally important wetlands. Groundwater flow is directed from the ice-pushed ridge in the east towards the river plain in the west. Seepage from the ice-pushed ridge occurs in the eastern part of the Naardermeer while in the western part infiltration occurs as a result of low water levels in the adjacent polders. During the last decades the water levels in the Naardermeer have become steadily lower due to increasing groundwater extractions in the hill ridge and lowering of the water levels in the adjacent polders. External surface water is suppleted threat to compensate water deficits in summer. These changes form a possible threat to the preservation of the botanical significance of the Naardermeer.

In 1985 a survey was started to establish the relation between hydrology and the occurrence of plant species in the Naardermeer. The hydrological data shows that water quantity and quality in the Naardermeer are strongly influenced by the surrounding area. As concerns quantity, the water input by seepage is inadequate to compensate for water loss through infiltration. This results in a mean net infiltration of 0.4 mm/day. The influence of the surrounding area also emerges from the quality of the groundwater. In the seepage area groundwater is generally of the calcium-bicarbonate type. In the most eastern part of the seepage area groundwater occurs with high nutrient load originating from polluted surface water just outside the Naardermeer. Infiltration recorded from piezometric data was confirmed by the presence of water with rain water attributes in the upper groundwater layers.

In the area a clear relationship exists between the pattern of hydrological attributes and the vegetation pattern in reed marshes. Vegetations related to the quality of rain water occur in a random pattern in the Naardermeer. Vegetations related to water rich in calcium and bicarbonate occur in the seepage area where they are supplied directly by groundwater of the calcium-bicarbonate type. Furthermore, they occur in the infiltration area where they are supplied by surface water. The surface water originates from groundwater in the seepage area which flows into the infiltration area. This seepage driven flow will prevent the suppletion water from spreading all over the Naardermeer. This is important as most of the species present respond negatively to the quality of the suppletion water.

This study illustrates the importance of hydrological information for the conservation of nature in wetlands. The impact of both internal and external (upstream and even downstream) processes has to be considered.

References (10)

W.J.van den Berg et al.
De vegetatie van het Oostelijk Vechtenplassengebied 1935–1980
H.v. Elburg et al.
FLOWNET: computer program for modelling two-dimensional stationary groundwater flow in an inhomogeneous anisotropic section
(1986)
Provinciale Waterstaat van Noord-Holland
Milieu inventarisatie Naardermeer
(1985)
Provinciale Waterstaat van Noord-Holland
Provinciaal Grondwaterplan Haarlem
(1986)
H.A. Stiff
The interpretation of chemical water analysis by means of patterns
Journal Petroleum Technology
(1951)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (21)

Adapting classical water quality diagrams for ecohydrological and policy applications
2022, Journal of Hydrology X
Citation Excerpt :
These groundwater types were determined by cluster analysis of a set of 1349 fresh groundwater samples (Cl < 300 mg/l) containing 12 different water quality variables, including the 10 used in our adapted diagrams. Flow directions and flow system boundaries indicated in Fig. 1 are based on extensive hydrological system analysis studies in the area a.o. using flow path modelling, isotope tracers and hydrochemical interpretation (Schot et al., 1988; Schot, 1990; Schot and Molenaar, 1992). The comprehensive diagrams allow for a detailed hydrogeological and ecohydrological interpretation.
Ecological values of water have gained increasing attention over the past decades in both (eco)hydrological research and water resources management. Water quality is an important ecological steering variable, and graphical water quality diagrams may aid in rapid interpretation of the hydrochemical status of a site. Traditionally used water quality diagrams for showing multiple variables (e.g. Stiff, Maucha) were developed primarily for hydrogeological purposes, with limited information on ecologically relevant nutrient parameters.
This paper presents adapted classical water quality diagrams that retain the traditional information on ions for hydrogeological characterization, and additionally provide information on nutrients for ecological water quality characterization.
A scaling factor is used for the minor ions to visually get them across more equally compared to the macro-ion ions in the water quality diagram. Scaling of minor ions is presented based on average concentrations, as well as on water quality policy norms. Four different water quality diagrams are presented, all with the same ions included, but with different appearances to suit different preferences of individual users. Regional, national and continental scale data are used to illustrate how the different diagrams show spatial and temporal water quality characteristics.
The adapted diagrams are innovative with respect to adding comprehensive visual information on the four ecohydrologically relevant nutrient species levels (NO₃, NH₄, PO₄, K), advanced insight in redox status from the combination of four redox sensitive parameters (Fe, NO₃, SO₄, NH₄) and the option to scale minor ions relative to average measured concentrations or to water quality policy norms. Using policy norms for scaling has the advantage of providing an ‘alarm function’ of exceedance of norms when concentrations surpass the ring used in the diagram. We discuss possible standardisation of scaling factors to enable comparability between sites.
Spatial and temporal variations in shallow wetland groundwater quality
2012, Journal of Hydrology
Citation Excerpt :
For terrestrial wetland vegetation this pertains to changes in groundwater levels and groundwater composition brought about by drainage, groundwater abstractions and pollution (Grootjans et al., 1991; Olde Venterink et al., 2009; Sival et al., 1997). These abiotic changes affect plant diversity in wetlands by shifts in vegetation types (e.g. Barendregt et al., 1995; Bootsma et al., 1999; Van Ek et al., 2000; Schot et al., 1988). Conservation and restoration of wetland terrestrial floristic biodiversity needs thus be based on monitoring spatial and temporal changes in groundwater levels and composition.
Wetlands worldwide are threatened by environmental change. Differences in groundwater composition is one of the factors affecting wetland terrestrial floristic biodiversity. However, few studies discuss variations in wetland groundwater composition. This study presents an analysis of local-scale spatial and short-term temporal variations in 15 groundwater composition parameters of the 7 km² Naardermeer wetland nature reserve in The Netherlands. Data is available from a network of 35 groundwater wells with 2–4 filters each, at depths between 50 and 800 cm, which were sampled about monthly over a 1-year period, totalling 1042 chemical analysis from 103 filter screens.
Relative standard deviations indicate large differences in variation between parameters. Largest spatial and temporal variations were found for nutrients ( ${NO}_{3}^{-}$ , ${PO}_{4}^{3 -}$ , ${NH}_{4}^{+}$ ) and redox sensitive parameters (Fe, Mn), and lowest variations for macroions and SiO₂. A horizontal zonation in groundwater concentrations has been found related to soil type and soil wetness, with largest horizontal decrease in ${NO}_{3}^{-}$ and ${SO}_{4}^{2 -}$ , and largest increase in Fe and SiO₂, going in the groundwater flow direction from dry sandy soils to wet peat/clay soils. No clear horizontal patterns have been found for the macroions. Spatial zonations in the north–south direction and with depth are absent for all parameters.
Spatial and temporal variations were found to be related. 3D-maps indicate highest temporal fluctuations at filter screens with lowest median concentrations for ${NO}_{3}^{-}$ , ${SO}_{4}^{2 -}$ and Fe, but the reverse pattern for SiO₂. High temporal variations of nutrients and redox sensitive parameters could not be traced back to a seasonal trend.
The spatial and temporal variability of groundwater quality parameters as presented in this study, together with their reported effects on different vegetation types, may be used to design efficient monitoring schemes by nature managers having set specific vegetation development targets for different spatial locations.
Effectiveness of reducing external nutrient load entering a eutrophicated shallow lake ecosystem in the Naardermeer nature reserve, The Netherlands
1999, Biological Conservation
This paper describes successes and complications in eutrophication abatement in the Naardermeer nature reserve, The Netherlands. Restoration of this lake started in 1985. The main measure was the reduction of external nutrient load by the supply of phosphate-free water. Water quality and aquatic vegetation were monitored and the usefulness of a modelling approach in designation of management programs was investigated. The monitoring showed that for the first 4 years, recovery was retarded, possibly because of phosphorus release from the lake-bed sediments. After 10 years, turbidity was reduced and characteristic vegetation with Najas marina and Characeae species had re-established in large parts of the lake. Due to spatial heterogeneity it appeared necessary to dredge the lake-bed sediments locally. The model predicted most changes in aquatic vegetation correctly, indicating its predictive value. However, to predict restoration perspectives for rare species, expert judgement still remains necessary. Suggestions are made for selection of successful management measures depending on the conditions of lake ecosystems.
Hydrological systems beyond a nature reserve, the major problem in wetland conservation of Naardermeer (The Netherlands)
1995, Biological Conservation
Ecological relations within a wetland depend on it is hydrology, but this is determined largely by what happens outside the wetland area. These statements are illustrated with respect to the Naardermeer nature reserve in the Netherlands. Succession and eutrophication have led to a reduction in the variety of vegetation types in the area. Eutrophication has been caused by a lowering of the water levels, deposition of guano in bird colonies, pollution of surface water and groundwater, and atmospheric deposition. The fact that most restoration activities have to be executed outside the wetland demonstrates that the management of the conservation of wetland ecosystems needs to operate on a regional scale.
The conservation of a wetland depends on water levels. However, the qualitative aspects of hydrology are also important. Since landscape ecological relations with the surrounding area provide for transport of nutrients, a wetland is not isolated. Changes in hydrology have an impact on processes that affect the ecosystems in different ways. These relations are illustrated from a reserve in the centre of the Netherlands.
Influence of groundwater development on the Doñana National Park ecosystems (Spain)
1993, Journal of Hydrology
A great percentage of the wetlands in many countries has been destroyed over the last century, mainly because of drainage for agricultural reclamation. The role of groundwater in the behavior of wetlands has usually been recognized in a general way, but there are still few studies on the hydrogeology of wetlands.
The Doñana National Park (DNP) is probably the most important National Park in the European Community. It is located on the estuary of the Guadalquivir River. The functioning of the DNP's ecosystems is closely related to the geohydrology of the area. The aquifer system consists essentially of unconsolidated Plio-Quaternary materials covering an area of 2400 km². Under the central marshy area (about 1800 km²) the aquifer system is confined below low-permeability estuary deposits. Around most of the marshland the aquifer crops out and is recharged by rainfall. The DNP has an area of 730 km²; part of it is in the marshland and part in the rechaarge area where the aquifer is phreatic. In the 1970s Spain's largest irrigation project using groundwater, covering a surface area of 240 km², was planned in an area bordering the national park. The initial project has been scaled down to 100 km², mainly as a result of protests by conservation groups.
A review is presented of the various evaluations of the influence of groundwater extraction on the functioning of the wetlands. The authors consider that the water table decline as a result of pumpage for current irrigation could cause a large part of the ecotone—situated at the contact-line between the marshland and the phreatic aquifer—to deteriorate. This ecotone exists because it is a natural groundwater discharge area. The small streams feeding the marshland will also be depleted by groundwater extraction. Another significant problem will be surface and groundwater caused by agricultural activities.
Human impact on regional groundwater composition through intervention in natural flow patterns and changes in land use
1992, Journal of Hydrology
The relations between groundwater composition, land use, soil conditions and flow patterns on a regional scale are studied for the Gooi and Vechtstreek area in the Netherlands. This densely populated area consists of a glacier-created ridge with dry sand soils bordered by the Vecht and Eem River plains with wet peat and clay soils. R-mode factor analysis and Q-mode cluster analysis were applied to a set of 1349 groundwater analyses to determine the factors controlling groundwater composition and the main resulting water types.
The results indicate that groundwater composition in the study area is affected on a regional scale by human activities through changes in land use and intervention in natural flow patterns. On the ridge, ground water is recharged by precipitation, which dissolves carbonates from the matrix of the sandy aquifer. Increased solute concentrations in shallow ground water, especially of nitrate, sulphate and potassium, indicate increased pollution resulting from urbanization and increasingly intensive agricultural activity over the past decades.
In the Vecht River plain infiltration occurs as a result of drainage of polders and groundwater extraction on the ridge. Recharge occurs by precipitation and from polluted surface water to which ammonium, organic complexes and carbonic acid are added through decomposition of organic matter in the peat and clay soils. The carbonic acid results in enhanced dissolution of carbonates present in the soil and the underlying sandy aquifer. Oxygen depletion and subsequent low redox potentials result in denitrification, dissolution of manganese and iron oxides, and sulphate reduction. The flow of ground water from high-level to low-level polders causes displacement of a former stagnant brakish groundwater body under the Vecht River plain accompanied by increased mixing of fresh and brackish ground water.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Hydrology of the wetland Naarderemeer: Influence of the surrounding area and impact on vegetation

Abstract

De vegetatie van het Oostelijk Vechtenplassengebied 1935–1980

FLOWNET: computer program for modelling two-dimensional stationary groundwater flow in an inhomogeneous anisotropic section

Milieu inventarisatie Naardermeer

Provinciaal Grondwaterplan Haarlem

The interpretation of chemical water analysis by means of patterns

Journal Petroleum Technology