Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering
Finite element simulations of chemo-mechanical coupling in elastic–plastic homoionic expansive clays
Introduction
Swelling is an important property of natural or engineered soils used in foundations, contamination barriers, and petroleum engineering. Swelling may cause a non-uniform soil heave, resulting in damage of over-structures, or weakening of bore walls in petroleum drillings. On the other hand, swelling of bentonite is taken advantage of to build barriers to water flow, or contaminant transport in hazardous and nuclear waste disposal technologies.
Swelling of soils is generally understood to be driven by capillary forces and/or by chemical gradients. The former one, termed matric swelling, occurs when soil is unsaturated. The latter one, termed chemical swelling, is characteristic of so-called expansive clays, rich in mineral smectite. Saturation of pore space with water and salt is assumed here, and predominantly Na-Montmorillonite clays are considered. The presence of several cations in the clay clusters requires modifications with respect to this framework: then the electrolyte nature of pore water has to be accounted for (see [12]).
Saturated clay is viewed as a porous deformable continuum consisting of two overlapping phases, each phase containing several species. Phase identification follows a kinematic criterion and attributes the absorbed water to the solid phase based on the affinity of their velocities [15].
Modeling deformable porous media is mainly concerned with the coupling of the deformation of pore space in soil and the concomitant in- or out-flow of pore liquid. In chemically sensitive soils, this coupling is additionally affected by chemical potentials of the species of the solid and fluid phases. Thus, mechanics of the medium, e.g. balance of momentum, is considered at the phase level, whereas chemical processes, i.e. balances of masses, concern the species. The link between the two levels is obtained through energetic considerations. Whether or not the chemical potentials are in equilibrium, water absorbed in the clay platelets can transfer into free pore water, or conversely, depending on the chemical composition of the clay and pore water phase, and on the mechanical conditions in terms of volume and pressure. The chemo-mechanical elastic–plastic constitutive equations involve the species present in the solid phase but treat the fluid phase as a whole. The species of the latter only diffuse through the porous medium, obeying generalized diffusion equations. The transfer of absorbed water and species between the solid and fluid phases involves a fictitious membrane surrounding the clay platelets, which may be permeable to the chemical species at various degrees.
In LHG,1 this theoretical framework was illustrated by simulations of typical phenomena observed during laboratory experiments. Parameters involved in the model were calibrated. Although many phenomena are involved, the number of parameters is quite limited, and their range for different clays can be evaluated. This is an advantage, which is to be traced to the strong structuring of the model, which derives from a thermodynamical approach. Mechanical, chemical and chemo-mechanical loading and unloading paths were considered. Increase of the salinity of pore water at constant confinement was shown to lead to a volume decrease, so-called chemical consolidation. Subsequent exposure to a distilled water solution displayed swelling: however, the latter was smaller than the chemical consolidation so that the chemical loading cycle results in a net contractancy whose amount increases with the confinement. With respect to previous publications, the key feature of the present framework is that it is comprehensive and not only qualitative but able to simulate a rather extensive number of experimental data which have been recently published.
Although attention in LHG was paid mainly to the elastic–plastic constitutive equations, the latter are shown now to be embedded in a general formulation where both mass transfer and diffusion processes can be considered in initial and boundary value problems that can be formulated within a mixed finite element method.
The issues addressed here involve three aspects, none of them being susceptible to be neglected, namely
- •
the seepage of water and the water-advected diffusion of salt through the porous medium. Coupling between these two flows is introduced by osmotic efficiency whose intensity strongly decreases with salt concentration;
- •
the physico-chemical reaction picturing absorption of water from the fluid phase to clay clusters, and the converse desorption;
- •
the strong influence of the above mass of absorbed water on the elastic and elastic–plastic properties of solid phase.
Therefore, the analysis encompasses both the hydrogeologic point of view which addresses the two first aspects only and the conventional geomechanical perspective where only hydro-mechanical coupling is accounted for.
As for the geomechanical models of the issues addressed here, the ones we are aware of consider deformable materials which are linear elastic. While valuable, as it allows for analytical developments, such an approach is really limited in the interpretation of laboratory tests or field events. To our knowledge no one of the works mentioned below has provided a calibration of their parameters using either laboratory or field instrumented data, nor have been simulations of controlled situations presented. For analytical results to be obtained, simplifications were adopted a priori, especially by neglecting some couplings. The only case where the elastic assumption can be used with confidence concerns strongly overconsolidated materials. In fact, it is argumented here that couplings between elastic–plastic properties and chemistry are strong, and most experimental paths that we have simulated contain at least a portion of plastic loading.
Kaczmarek and Hueckel [18] and Smith [34] have presented one-dimensional linear elastic models intended to analyze the effect of contaminant diffusion on a deformable medium, and the converse effect of material deformation on contaminant migration. Kaczmarek and Hueckel [18] introduce coupling between chemistry and the deformation model by assuming that the change in contaminant concentration affects linearly the porosity. This assumption is quite close, at least at small concentrations, to that of Barbour and Fredlund [1] where the osmotic pressure is involved in place of the concentration. For both Kaczmarek and Hueckel [18] and Smith [34], the volume changes of the solid phase is not affected by chemistry, and therefore the chemo-mechanical coupling is weak. Two cross-couplings are introduced in the diffusion law, which relates fluxes of water and contaminant to gradients of pore pressure and concentration. These couplings are neglected by Smith [34]: in the present thermodynamic analysis, this assumption amounts to a zero osmotic efficiency (Section 3.2). The materials addressed by Kaczmarek and Hueckel [18] are not swelling and there is no mass transfer involved. On the other hand, Smith [34] introduces the possibility of contaminant transfer through an absorption/desorption isotherm, following the hydrogeological approach (see Section 3.3.2). Advection of contaminant by water is neglected by Kaczmarek and Hueckel [18], accounting for the low velocity of water.
Sherwood [29] has formulated a poroelastic constitutive behaviour referred to as inert, where the solid particles constitute the solid phase but the fluid phase contains several species, water and salts: at a fixed chemical potential, the mass of a species squeezed out is proportional to its molar fraction. The model has been used in a petroleum engineering context where, for a sufficient difference in salinity between mud in borehole and rock, the pore pressure in the rock may at equilibrium be forced to be lower than its initial value.
Bennethum and Cushman [3] and Murad [27] have addressed the transfer of water into interlamellar space in clays through a two- or three-spatial scale modeling using homogenization schemes. This type of approach entails a substantial number of constitutive assumptions, requiring sophisticated identification procedures. Absorbed water has been considered as a third phase by Murad [27] and endowed with a partial stress, related thermodynamically to the total fluid volume fraction.
Other models where, on top of the above couplings, the electrolytic nature of the water phase has to be accounted for, have been developed mainly for biological tissues undergoing large elastic strains (e.g. [16], [20], [33]). The model presented in [12] is an extension of the present elastic–plastic framework to heteroionic clays. The related finite element formulation and simulations are in progress.
The paper is comprehensive in order the reader not familiar with physico-chemical mechanisms in deformable materials can find the necessary definitions at one place.
Basic entities pertaining to the two-phase/multi species framework developed here are defined in Section 2, and the local balance equations are stated in view of future use in the finite element simulations. The mass transfer equations, diffusion equations and the elastic–plastic constitutive equations are motivated by satisfaction of a general dissipation inequality that naturally highlights chemo-mechanical couplings (Section 3). Mass transfer is viewed as a physico-chemical reaction. The generalized diffusion equations couple hydraulic and diffusion effects. The influences of these couplings in the balance equations are highlighted and the approach is compared with hydrogeological analyses where mass transfer is introduced through absorption isotherms and the deformability of the medium is neglected. For comprehensiveness, the elastic and elastic–plastic constitutive equations developed in LHG are summarized in 4 Elastic constitutive equations for incompressible species, 5 Elastic–plastic constitutive equations.
The weak form of the field equations and the time-integration procedure to solve the highly non-linear matrix equations through a finite element procedure are provided in Section 6. Non-linearity is contributed by all aspects of the model, inter alia chemical potentials and osmotic efficiency are strongly non-linear functions of salt concentration, and elasto-plasticity introduces another type of strong non-linearity. Non-symmetry of the global diffusion and stiffness arises due to the involvement of the couplings of different natures, even if each of them, taken individually, would lead to symmetry. Indeed, the generalized diffusion law obeys Onsager reciprocity principle, and plasticity can be associative. The cure of spurious oscillations due to advection–diffusion by an implicit SUPG method introduces another source of non-symmetry in the effective diffusion matrix. The choice of the four primary variables, and associated field equations, is motivated by the general perspective of this chemo-mechanical analysis in fluid-saturated porous media. In particular, they have to provide sufficient information to define at each time step the elastic–plastic state of the two-phase medium. These primary variables are the solid displacement vector, the fluid pressure, salt concentration in water phase and content of absorbed water in solid phase.
Simulations of oedometer tests, for which quite an extensive number of tests are available, evidence the influences of the various couplings in transient initial and boundary value problems (Section 7). Notice however that neither the formulation nor the parameter identification are restricted to this one-dimensional setting. Beyond hydro-mechanical coupling, comments focus on various aspects of transport of salt, transfer of water and chemo-mechanical coupling on the spatial and time profiles of strains, pore pressure and concentration during transient processes and at steady states. In fact, transient irreversible inhomogeneities might question the interpretation of laboratory tests.
Notation: Compact or index tensorial notation will be used throughout this note. Vector, matrix and tensor quantities are identified by boldface letters. is the identity tensor/matrix of appropriate order. Symbols ‘·’ and ‘:’ between tensors of various orders denote their inner product with single and double contraction respectively. tr denotes the trace of a second-order tensor, dev its deviatoric part and div is the divergence operator. Unless stated otherwise, the convention of summation over repeated indices does not apply.
Section snippets
General framework
We consider a two-phase porous medium. Each phase is composed of several species:
- •
the solid phase S contains three species, namely clay particles denoted by the symbol c, absorbed water (w) and salt in absorbed water (s);
- •
the fluid phase W contains two species, pore water (w) and salt in pore water (s).
The solid phase is surrounded by a semi-permeable membrane which is (see Fig. 1) always impermeable to clay particles, that is, the mass of clay mcS is constant,
- •
and either perfect, that is
The global picture: deformation, mass transfer and diffusion
In absence of thermal effects, starting from the statements of balance of mass for each species, and of momentum and energy for the phases (e.g. [10]), the Clausius–Duhem inequality for a mixture as a whole can be viewed as being contributed by three terms, δD=δD1+δD2+δD3, associated with mechanical work, mass transfer and diffusion (see LHG).
These contributions will be required to be positive individually, that is
Elastic constitutive equations for incompressible species
The absorption/desorption of water (and salt) into/from the solid phase introduces a chemo-mechanical coupling. On the other hand, the presence of salt in the water phase does not affect directly the mechanical behaviour of the porous medium, it just flows through. Its amount is governed by an equation of mass conservation and a flow law. Therefore, to develop the chemo-mechanical constitutive equations, we will treat the fluid phase as a whole and, temporarily, ignore its chemical composition.
Elastic–plastic constitutive equations
Exchange of matter between the clay cluster (solid phase) and pore water (fluid phase) affects both elastic and elastic–plastic properties. Chemical effects act on the plastic properties by increasing or decreasing the preconsolidation stress and also by changing the shear-strength. Therefore chemical effects are, even qualitatively, different from thermal effects which essentially decrease the preconsolidation stress or from desaturation effects which increase this preconsolidation stress.
Finite element formulation
A mixed formulation needs to be developed where the primary variables contain the complete information necessary to define the chemo-mechanical state of the two-phase reacting medium.
Simulations of chemo-mechanical oedometric tests
The model for mass transfer, diffusion/advection and elastic–plastic deformation for homoionic expansive clays described in the previous sections is now used to simulate oedometric tests performed by Di Maio [8], [9] on Ponza Clay.
Conclusions
This study is to be understood as a piece of a general framework to both model constitutive behaviour and simulate field problems where chemo-mechanical couplings cannot be neglected. To the elastic–plastic coupled constitutive equations developed in LHG have been added here equations for diffusion of salt and water through the porous skeleton and mass transfer equations describing the key physical phenomenon of absorption/desorption. The influence of this phenomenon on the mechanical
References (36)
Theory of mixtures
- et al.
Streamline upwind/Petrov–Galerkin formulations for convection dominated flows with particular emphasis on the incompressible Navier–Stokes equations
Comput. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engrg.
(1982) - et al.
A continuum theory for chemically reacting media––I
Int. J. Engrg. Sci.
(1965) - et al.
Electro-chemo-mechanical couplings in saturated porous media: elastic–plastic behaviour of heteroionic expansive clays
Int. J. Solids Struct.
(2002) - et al.
A globally convergent matrix-free algorithm for implicit time-marching schemes arising in finite element analysis in fluids
Comput. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engrg.
(1991) - et al.
A variational formulation for coupled physicochemical flows during finite deformations of charged porous media
Int. J. Solids Struct.
(1998) - et al.
The role of osmotic effects in fluid flow through shales
J. Petroleum Sci. Engrg.
(2000) - et al.
An effective stress elastic–plastic model for unsaturated soils
Mech. Mater.
(2002) - et al.
Chemo-mechanical coupling in saturated porous media: elastic–plastic behaviour of homoionic expansive clays
Int. J. Solids Struct.
(2002) - et al.
Transport of water and ions through a clay membrane
J. Colloid Interf. Sci.
(2000)
Consistent tangent operators for rate-independent elastoplasticity
Comput. Meth. Appl. Mech. Engrg.
Porohyperelastic-transport-swelling theory, material properties and finite element models for large strains
Int. J. Solids Struct.
Mechanisms of osmotic flow and volume change in clay soils
Can. Geotech. J.
On the structuring of thermodynamic fluxes: a direct implementation of the dissipation inequality
Int. J. Engrg. Sci.
Coupled solvent and heat transport of a mixture of swelling porous particles and fluids: single time-scale problem
Transport Porous Media
Anion exclusion and coupling effects in nonsteady transport through unsaturated soils
Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J.
Quantitative Hydrogeology
Exposure of bentonite to salt solution: osmotic and mechanical effects
Géotechnique
Cited by (40)
Swelling and swelling pressure of a clayey soil: Experimental data, model simulations and effects on slope stability
2022, Engineering GeologyCitation Excerpt :Section 3 briefly recalls the concepts at the basis of the constitutive model and the FEM solution. The constitutive model is an evolution of the original chemo-mechanical model proposed by Loret et al. (2002) and Gajo and Loret (2003), in which a new hyperelastic law has been implemented for simulating the dependence of both the shear stiffness and the bulk stiffness on the applied stress state and on pore solution concentration, as well as for taking into account of elastic anisotropy. Section 4 presents the comparison between model simulations and experimental results, showing that the proposed theoretical framework can interpret and simulate successfully all the observed chemo-mechanical effects.
Modelling the behaviour of unsaturated non-active clays in saline environment
2021, Engineering GeologyCitation Excerpt :The simplicity of BBM has been here preferred, due to the limited number of material parameters and the satisfactory predictive capabilities when the effect of partial saturation on slightly or moderately expansive clays is of concern. Since the late 90's several researchers presented elasto-plastic models for reproducing the chemo-mechanical behaviour of active clays (e.g. Gajo and Loret, 2003; Guimarães et al., 2013; Hueckel, 1997; Liu et al., 2005; Loret et al., 2002; Witteveen et al., 2013; Yan, 2018), while the macroscopic behaviour of non-active saturated clays subjected to changes in pore fluid salinity has been recently addressed in Musso et al. (2021, 2020) and Scelsi et al. (2021), by extending the Cam clay model to include the effect of saline pore water. This work aims at providing a simple model to reproduce the chemo-mechanical behaviour of non-active unsaturated clays by joining the proposals of BBM and of Musso et al. (2020, 2021).
Modeling of dynamic hydrogel swelling within the pore space of a porous medium
2020, International Journal of Engineering ScienceCitation Excerpt :Kinematics and mass exchange are coupled by using a multiplicative split of the deformation gradient in a mass conserving and non-conserving part. Loret, Gajo, and Simões (2004); Loret, Hueckel, and Gajo (2002) and Gajo and Loret (2003) established a mixture-based model to describe chemically active expansive clays. The coupling between mass exchange and deformation represents chemical swelling and shrinking on the macroscale.
A chemo-elastic-plastic model for unsaturated expansive clays
2016, International Journal of Solids and StructuresCitation Excerpt :This assumption is valid when loadings are slow enough compared to the characteristic time of the phase transformation. When such conditions are not fulfilled (case of a quick loading for example), it can be accounted for by a characteristic time parameter, following the line of approach reported by Gajo and Loret (2003) and Lei et al. (2014). The two state variables φL and φG which are not easily measurable are then reduced to one state variable ϕ.
Shear displacements induced by decrease in pore solution concentration on a pre-existing slip surface
2016, Engineering GeologyCitation Excerpt :Dominijanni et al. (2013), for a Na-montmorillonite with characteristics similar to those of the clay of this study, showed that the osmotic efficiency ω, a measure of the extent to which the theoretical osmotic pressure develops (Mitchell and Soga, 2005), is practically null for concentration higher than 0.1 M. The case of a clay saturated with a salt solution and exposed to distilled water was analysed by Gajo and Loret (2003) who modelled the behaviour of the Ponza bentonite in oedometer, finding pore pressure variations associated to osmotic processes. In our case, the direct contact of the slip surface with the cell solution probably allowed the dissipation of possible pore pressure increments.
A thermo-chemo-electro-mechanical framework of unsaturated expansive clays
2014, Computers and Geotechnics