Chapter 8 Moral Identity, Moral Functioning, and the Development of Moral Character
Introduction
There are few more pressing problems before psychological science than to account for human moral functioning. This is because moral agency is crucial to our conception of what it means to be a person (Carr, 2001). The belief in our own moral integrity is so central to our self‐understanding that often we are tempted to shield it from refutation by recourse to sanitizing euphemisms and protective belts of denial, rationalization, and special pleading (Bandura, 1999). Indeed, as Taylor (1989) put it, “being a self is inseparable from existing in a space of moral issues” (p. 112).
The alignment of moral integrity with our sense of self‐identity might be one of those facts about ourselves that is so obvious that it hardly bears examination — something along the lines of fish being the last to discover water. This might go part of the way to explain the odd fact that the moral self does not have a long research tradition in psychology; but there are other explanations as well. These explanations point to paradigmatic doubts about whether the self is a legitimate construct for a behavioral science, and doubts evident in the study of moral development about how “thick” a self must be to render a rationally adequate moral judgment.
It does not help that psychological research is fragmented and that relevant fields of study, or even research programs within fields, do not easily talk with one another. The relevance of findings on, say, motivation, social cognition, or personality is not drawn easily for understanding moral motivation, moral cognition, or moral personality. The literatures on expertise, decision making, and cognitive science more generally provide few explicit guidelines for understanding moral expertise, moral decision making, and moral cognition. Although self‐identity has attracted significant research attention for decades, the frameworks of developmental and social psychologists who study it have often bypassed each other. Similarly research on temperament, attachment, and other developmental processes are often silent on their implications for the moral domain. Research on moral development has availed itself rarely of the theories, constructs, and methods of other disciplines; and these other disciplines rarely speculate on the developmental trajectories that bring one to adult moral functioning. Moreover, those interested in the educational implications of the self divide on the purpose and pedagogy of moral‐character education, and on the very terms of reference for understanding the moral dimensions of selfhood (see Lapsley and Narvaez, 2006). What is virtue, for example, as a psychological construct? How is character to be understood as a dimension of personality?
Fortunately there are signs that the estrangement of the moral self from the main currents of contemporary psychological research is coming to an end. Although the search for integrative linkages is of longer standing (e.g., Lapsley and Power, 1988, Lapsley and Quintana, 1985), there is a discernible increase in the pace and momentum of integrative research on moral cognition and moral self‐identity (Narvaez and Lapsley, in press). Indeed, the ascendance of the moral self now animates integrative research at the intersection of several provinces of psychology, and, along with increasing research into the neuroscientific (Sinnott‐Armstrong, 2008) and evolutionary bases of moral behavior (Narvaez, 2008b), the appearance of handbooks on moral development (Killen and Smetana, 2005) and education (Nucci and Narvaez, 2008), it is now clear that moral psychology is enjoying a renascence of interest in many areas of research.
In this chapter, we review how the construct of the moral self has arisen within developmental studies of moral judgment, and how the search for integrative linkages with other domains of psychology, particularly with social cognition and personality, took on a certain urgency after the marginalization or collapse of the dominant stage‐and‐structure (“Piagetian”) approaches to moral development. We examine theoretical approaches to moral self‐identity and moral personality, along with their developmental accounts, including a broader integrative theory that implicates evolutionary themes in the development of a moral brain.
Section snippets
Moral Self‐Identity
In this section, we begin our exploration of moral self‐identity by examining briefly how it is considered in recent ethical theory. We then trace how Augusto Blasi's view of the moral personality has evolved out of the problematic of moral development theory. Finally we describe theories of moral personality that have arisen in recent decades.
Development of Moral Self‐Identity
The literature on moral self‐identity and the moral personality seems largely preoccupied with sketching out what it looks like in its mature form in adulthood. This is not inappropriate. Often it is useful, if not essential, to get a handle on the telos of development before one can investigate the possible developmental trajectories that can get one there (Kitchener, 1983). Still, the relative paucity of work on the development of the moral self is striking. This is due partly to the lack of
Schemas and Moral Information Processing
According to schema theories of development and understanding, schemas are the key structures that reflect ongoing changes in understanding. Schemas (generalized knowledge structures) develop first from sensorimotor experience, forming embodied knowledge that underlies thought and language (Lakoff and Johnson, 1999). The individual interprets subsequent experience according to existing schemas (assimilation) and modifies them in kind and number in response to new information (accommodation) in
Moral Development as Ethical Expertise Development
Taking the view of the mind sciences today and looking back, one can see that the ancients (e.g., Aristotle, 1988, Mencius, 1970) considered virtue as a form of expertise. The virtuous person is like an expert who has a set of highly cultivated skills, perceptual sensibilities, chronically accessible schemas for moral interpretation, and rehearsed sequences for moral action. Moral exemplars display moral wisdom (knowing the good) and practical wisdom (knowing how to carry it out in the
New Directions: Neuroscience and Moral Personality
As knowledge about human development increases, so too has interest in the neurobiology of human behavior. For example, the neurobiology of infant attachment is far more important than previously realized for lifetime brain development and emotion regulation (Gross, 2007). There appear to be critical periods for fostering the systems that lead to sociality (Karr‐Morse and Wiley, 1997). Developmental psychology finds that emotion regulation development begins neonatally and crucially depends on
Conclusions
The field of moral development has traveled beyond a narrow focus on moral judgment to include the moral self across the lifespan. No longer relegated to an individual's conscious moral reasoning, the scope has moved beyond the individual and her decision making or virtue. Moral development and moral action are embedded in community contexts. Moral functioning is assumed to involve the whole brain and multiple systems inside and outside the individual. As moral psychology and the study of moral
References (203)
- et al.
Domain‐Specific and Strategic Knowledge: Effects of Training on Students of Differing Ages or Competence Levels
Learning and Individual Differences
(1989) - et al.
A Grotesque and Dark Beauty: How Moral Identity and Mechanisms of Moral Disengagement Influence Cognitive and Emotional Reactions to War
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology
(2007) Moral Cognition and Moral Action: A Theoretical Perspective
Developmental Review
(1983)- et al.
Contextual Prerequisites for Understanding: Some Investigations of Comprehension and Recall
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior
(1972) - et al.
Stress during Gestation Alters Maternal Care and the Development of Offspring in a Rodent Model
Biological Psychology
(2006) - et al.
Perception in Chess
Cognitive Psychology
(1973) Neurobiological Views of Memory
- et al.
Surgical Intuition
(1995) Learners and Learning
- et al.
Lying in Negotiations: How Individual and Situational Factors Influence the Use of Neutralization Strategies
Journal of Organizational Behavior
(2005)
The Self‐Importance of Moral Identity
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Moral Disengagement in the Perpetration of Inhumanities
Personality and Social Psychology Review
Conditional Automaticity: Varieties of Automatic Influence in Social Perception and Cognition
Bypassing the Will: Toward Demystifying the Nonconscious Control of Social Behaviour
The Unbearable Automaticity of Being
American Psychologist
Helping Behaviour among Pre‐School Children
Child Development
Remembering
Beyond the “Village” Rhetoric: Creating Healthy Communities for Children and Adolescents
Applied Developmental Science
Moral Identity: Its Role in Moral Functioning
The Moral Personality: Reflections for Social Science and Education
Identity and the Development of the Self
Moral Character: A Psychological Approach
A Secure Base: Parent‐Child Attachment and Healthy Human Development
Perception of Moral Atmosphere in School and Norm Transgressive Behavior in Adolescents: An Intervention Study
International Journal of Behavioral Development
From Thought to Behavior: “Having” and “Doing” in the Study of Personality and Cognition
American Psychologist
Personality and Social Intelligence
Moral and Personal Identity
International Journal of Education and Religion
Neuroendocrine Perspectives on Social Attachment and Love
Psychoneuroendocrinology
The Importance of Bonding to School for Healthy Development: Findings From the Social Development Research Group
Journal of School Health
The Two Disciplines of Personality Psychology
Psychological Science
Personality Architecture: Within‐Person Structures and Processes
Annual Review of Psychology
Some Do Care
A Longitudinal Study of Moral Judgment
Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development
NEO PI‐R Professional Manual
Descartes' Error: Emotion, Reason and the Human Brain
Social Cognition, Prosocial Behavior and Emotion in Preschoolers: Contextual Validation
Child Development
The Beginnings of Social Understanding
The Social Construction of the Human Brain
American Journal of Psychiatry
Toward a General Theory of Expertise
The Psychobiology of Attachment and Separation
The Structure of Event Representations: A Developmental Analysis
Child Development
Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person
Journal of Philosophy
The Importance of What We Care About
Preschool Thought
American Psychologist
Cited by (75)
Understanding the food waste behaviour in university students: An application of the theory of planned behaviour
2024, Journal of Cleaner ProductionFostering workplace civility in the Financial Sector: The influence of ethical leadership practices and ethical work climate
2024, Social Sciences and Humanities OpenThe psychopath's moral choices through the prism of moral identity theory
2021, Evolution PsychiatriqueToward moral pathways to motivate wildlife conservation
2021, Biological ConservationCitation Excerpt :Wildlife conservation can benefit from elevating individuals' moral identities, particularly when people extend their moral considerations to wildlife. The development of moral identity as a character trait is a complex process that begins in early childhood (for a review, see Narváez and Lapsley, 2009). However, moral psychology research suggests that moral priming (i.e., increasing the accessibility of moral identity in a person's mind) can motivate individuals to act in a given situation (Aquino et al., 2009; Reed et al., 2007).
Understanding food waste behavior: The role of morals, habits and knowledge
2021, Journal of Cleaner ProductionCitation Excerpt :The findings of this study have implications for families and educational institutions. At the developmental stages of life, socialization agents such as parents and educators have a strong influence on defining the moral norms for an individual (Narvaez and Lapsley, 2009). Thus, presenting individuals with role models who can foster appropriate moral attitudes to prevent food waste can prove very useful.
Ethical Expertise and Moral Authority
2024, Res Publica