The manufacture of composite structures with a built-in network of piezoceramics

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0266-3538(02)00007-6Get rights and content

Abstract

A manufacturing method was developed for integrating a network of distributed piezoceramic actuators/sensors onto laminated carbon/epoxy composite structures. The network of built-in actuators/sensors is used to monitor the health of the host composite structure by acquiring information about the condition of the structure throughout its service life. The manufacturing method applies the printed circuit technique to fabricate a thin flexible layer with a network of piezoceramics. It is used as an extra ply that is either inserted into or bonded onto the surface of a composite laminate to give it actuating and sensing capabilities. This layer that provides the added functionality is referred to as the “SMART Layer” (Stanford Multi-Actuator-Receiver Transduction Layer). Using the developed method, several SMART Layer prototypes have been fabricated and embedded inside carbon fiber composite laminates successfully. Tests were conducted on composite panels integrated with the SMART Layer to validate the design and the manufacturing procedure.

Introduction

Carbon-fiber-reinforced composite structures are widely used in the aerospace industry because of their advantages of having high strength, high stiffness, and low weight. However, composite structures are susceptible to impact damage during service, which can cause internal damages (e.g. delaminations) that are not visible from the surface. Over time, these damages can grow and lead to catastrophic structural failure; hence, composite structures need to be inspected frequently.

Current available methods for composite inspection employ non-destructive evaluation (NDE) techniques, such as X-ray or c-scan, to obtain an image of the internal damage. To perform these NDE procedures, expensive equipment and specialist operators are needed, and the structures have to be taken out of service. This is inconvenient and inefficient for most aerospace applications because it results in vehicle downtime and incurs excessive expense, and for other applications such as satellites, it is simply impossible.

Owing to the drawbacks in the current inspection methods, recent developments in structural health monitoring systems have attracted significant attention. The proposed structural health monitoring system offer potentials in increasing structural reliability, reducing operating cost, and minimizing vehicle downtime. Among the different monitoring techniques, structural health monitoring systems can be roughly divided into two categories based on the type of inputs to the system: passive sensing diagnostics and active sensing diagnostics. A passive sensing system contains only sensors so it takes unknown external inputs to excite the structure and then monitors the structural response. Examples of a passive sensing system include structures with distributed strain gauges [1], fiber optic sensors [2], and accelerometers [3]. An active sensing system contains actuators as well as sensors so it can generate known (controlled) inputs internally to excite the structure and then monitor its response. Although the actuation power of such system is often too small for structural control applications [4], it is adequate for generating ultrasonic waves for non-destructive evaluation purpose. An example of an active sensing system is a structure integrated with a network of distributed piezoceramics (Fig. 1) [5], [6], [7]. This type of system is the focus of study here.

The development of structural health monitoring systems is typically separated into three parts: sensor, software, and integration. Most works [8], [9], [10] done to date have been focused on the development of sensor technologies and application software for interpreting information acquired from structures. However, little work has been done on the integration of sensors with structures, especially for piezoceramic sensors that are needed for the active sensing diagnostic system.

Section snippets

Issues in manufacturing

In order to integrate a network of piezoceramic sensors onto composite structures, several issues in manufacturing need to be addressed. The issues are

  • Electrical insulation

  • Structural integrity

  • Labor requirement

  • Uniformity of sensor response

  • Consistency of sensor response

The first problem is the electrical shorting of the sensors by carbon fibers. Due to the rugged conditions encountered during service, the piezoceramic sensors often need to be embedded inside structures to be protected from the

The SMART Layer approach

To fabricate a large composite structure with a network of distributed piezoceramics, it is insufficient and impractical to simply use the manufacturing techniques available in the composites industry today. In order to effectively address all the manufacturing issues mentioned in the previous section, a different approach is taken. The new approach adapts an idea from the electronics industry—the idea is Flexible Printed Circuits.

Flexible Printed Circuit, commonly referred to as “Flex,” is a

Validation testing

Tests were performed to validate the performance of the SMART Layer. Two aspects of the SMART layer were evaluated: Mechanical Performance and Electrical Performance. The purpose of the Mechanical Performance Tests is to examine the effect of embedding the SMART Layer on the structural integrity of the host composite structure. The purpose of the Electrical Performance Tests is to examine the performance of the SMART Layer after it's integrated onto a structure.

Application example: process monitoring

One of the major steps in the manufacturing of thermoset polymer matrix composite is the curing of the matrix resin that binds the fibers together. During the cure of the resin, the molecule chains of the resin crosslink to form a permanent rigid connection. The polymerization is initiated by elevated temperature that promotes the chemical reaction. This is most often done in an autoclave where heat and pressure are applied to cure the composite prepregs. Currently, industry practice is to use

Concluding remarks

From this study on the manufacturing of composite structures with an embedded network of piezoceramics, several major developments were made:

  • A new design and the associated manufacturing technique were developed for integrating a network of distributed piezoceramic actuators/sensors onto composite structures. As a result, the SMART Layer was invented.

  • Functional prototypes of composite structures with an embedded SMART Layer were successfully fabricated. The prototypes have been used to

Acknowledgements

The funding support of the Army Research Office to the project is greatly appreciated. The authors would also like to thank DuPont Electronics and Hexcel Corporation for donating the materials used in this study.

References (48)

  • T Itoh et al.

    Strain measurement with microsensors

    Journal of composite materials

    (1997)
  • Crawley EF, de Luis J, Hagood NW, Anderson EH. Development of piezoelectric technology for Applications in control of...
  • Warkentin DJ, Crawley EF. Embedded electronics for intelligent structures. The 32nd AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures,...
  • E.F Crawley et al.

    Recent progress in intelligent materials system

    Journal Materiaux et Techniques

    (1994)
  • Joshi SP, Chan WS. Fabrication and curing of laminates with multiple embedded piezoceramics sensors and actuators....
  • Sterns TH. Flexible printed circuitry. McGraw-Hill,...
  • Gilleo, K., editor. Handbook of flexible circuits. Van Nostrand Reinhold,...
  • Lin M, Chang FK. Development of SMART layers for built-in diagnostics for composite structures. The 13th Annual ASC...
  • Lund P. Printed circuit board precision artwork generation and manufacturing methods. Bishop Graphics,...
  • ASTM standards and literature references for composite materials, 2nd ed. American Society for Testing and Materials,...
  • K.S Kim et al.

    The effect of embedded sensors on the strength of composite laminates

    Journal of Reinforced Plastics and Composites

    (1992)
  • DuoMod® particulate tougheners. Product catalog. Zeon Chemical,...
  • Odagiri N, Kishi H, Nakae T. T800H/3900–2 toughened epoxy prepreg system: toughening concept and mechanism. Proceedings...
  • Y.K Lieu et al.

    Controlled energy dissipation in fibrous composites. II: Microscopic failure mechanisms

    Polymer Composites

    (1991)
  • Cited by (0)

    View full text