The problem of defining geochemical baselines. A case study of selected elements and geological materials in Finland
Abstract
Although the term ‘geochemical baseline’ appears in the international geochemical mapping programmes IGCP 259 and 360, it has never been well defined. Several considerations relevant to such a definition are discussed. A geochemical baseline for an element refers to its natural variations in concentration in the surficial environment. Geochemical baselines were studied in Finland by comparing results from regional geochemical mapping programmes based on samples of till, clay and organic stream sediment. The geochemical background changes regionally with the basic geology and locally with the type and genesis of the overburden. Baseline concentrations depend on sample material collected, grain size and extraction method. In Finland, concentrations of potentially harmful elements tend to be higher in fine-grained marine and lacustrine sediments than in glacial till. Concentrations are also systematically higher in the < 0.06 mm fraction than in the < 2 mm size fraction of till samples. Only small proportions of the total heavy metal concentrations in Finnish marine clays are bioavailable. Geochemical baselines are needed for environmental legislation and political decision-making, especially in the assessment of contaminated soil. In many areas of Finland, natural concentrations of several heavy metals exceed the guide or limit values designated for contaminated soils. Thus baselines must always be verified in any assessment of sites for contamination.
References (12)
- B. Bölviken et al.
Regional geochemical mapping of Western Europe towards the year 2000
J. Geochem. Explor.
(1996) - R. Salminen et al.
Geochemical mapping and databases at Geological Survey of Finland
J. Geochem. Explor.
(1995) - T. Tarvainen
The geochemical correlation between coarse and fine fractions of till in southern Finland
J. Geochem. Explor.
(1995) - A.G. Darnley et al.
Suomen geokemian atlas, osa 2: morceni — Geochemical Atlas of Finland, Part 2. Till
- P. Lahermo et al.
Geochemical mapping of stream waters and sediments in Finland: selected results
Geol. Sun. Fin. Spec. Pap.
(1995)
Cited by (198)
Spatial distribution of molybdenum in catchment sediments in the Sino-Mongolian border region
2024, Journal of Geochemical ExplorationThe Sino-Mongolian border region is an important exploration hotspot in the Asia-Pacific margin and hosts one of the three major porphyry Cu-Au-Mo mineralization belts in the world. Variations in the concentration and spatial distribution of Mo in the region can indirectly reflect the distribution of other minerals, such as copper; therefore, Mo has been widely used as a pathfinder element for geochemical prospecting for porphyry Cu deposits. However, comprehensive and integrated analytical studies of single elements (e.g., Mo) in the Sino-Mongolian border region are lacking. Therefore, this study collected 10,453 catchment sediment samples from the study region and analyzed 69 elements. The concentration of Mo in these samples ranged from 0.10 to 84.96 mg/kg, with a median and mean of 0.84 mg/kg (considered the geochemical background value) and 0.97 mg/kg, respectively. The factors influencing the Mo concentration and spatial distribution along the Sino-Mongolian border region were investigated in terms of geological background, climate, precipitation, mineral distribution, and exploitation history. Influenced by climate and precipitation, Mo in catchment sediments is solubilized and easily transported under the oxidizing effect of hypergenesis. Mo concentrations were low in forested areas along the Altai Mountains in the west and Da Hinggan Ling Mountains in the east. Sixteen high-concentration Mo areas (geochemical province/domain, > 1.07 mg/kg, > Q75%) that contained 46 Mo geochemical anomalies (> 1.24 mg/kg, > Q85%) were circumscribed in this study. These anomalous areas were mainly related to the widespread distribution of minerals, coal-forming strata, and black shale deposits in the region. Compared to previous studies, this study identified more concentrated geochemical anomaly areas with a wider distribution in the Sino-Mongolian border region and provided higher quality geochemical data to promote further mineral exploration and support environmental change studies in this area.
Background and geochemical baseline values of chalcophile and siderophile elements in soils around the former mining area of Abbadia San Salvatore (Mt. Amiata, southern Tuscany, Italy)
2023, Journal of Geochemical ExplorationBackground and geochemical baseline values of Potentially Toxic Elements (PTEs) in soils developed on natural or anthropogenically-affected areas are increasingly important parameters as they represent highly useful tools at local, regional, national and European level. While background values are mostly applied to uncontaminated areas to verify the presence of high to anomalous concentrations of PTEs due to geogenic sources, the geochemical baseline values are better representing those areas where the anthropogenic activities have altered more or less significantly the background values. This is the case of the Municipality of Abbadia San Salvatore, mostly lying above the volcanic products of Mt. Amiata (Tuscany, central Italy) and, subordinately, above sedimentary formations, where >100 years of exploitation of cinnabar (HgS) and production of liquid mercury have affected the environmental matrices, including the pedosphere compartment. Consequently, 51 top-soils and 51 sub-soils, developed on the volcanic and sedimentary domains were collected and analyzed for PTEs (Hg, As, Sb, Cr, Co, Ni, Cu and V). A CoDA (Compositional Data Analysis) approach (robust Principal Component Analysis) combined with geochemical mapping allowed to account for the compositional nature of geochemical data and define the spatial distribution of the investigated chalcophile and siderophile elements. The results obtained by CoDa are useful to understand data variability and relative variations of the elements compared to the barycenter of the total composition. Independently by the substratum (volcanic or sedimentary), the concentrations of Hg, As, Sb, Cr, Co, Ni, Cu and V were highly variable and up to 258, 276, 110, 261, 32, 132, 80 and 173 mg/kg, respectively. Owing to the significant differences between the two geological domains, the two datasets were considered separately in order to define the geochemical baseline values of the analyzed PTEs computed using ProUCL 5.2.0 software. Accordingly, the geochemical baseline values of Hg, As, Cr, Co and V were much higher than the values imposed by the Italian Legislative Decree 152/06, suggesting the importance of exploring the geological features of the investigated territories and their anthropic history, particularly in Italy where poly-metallic sulfide ore deposits have been exploited in many regions since the Etruscan and Roman times.
Soil is the foundation of agricultural green development and human survival; the study of local environmental geochemical baselines can guide soil management and ensure the safe use of soil. In this study, a total of 100 shallow farmland soil samples were collected in each township of Yongqiao District, Suzhou City, Anhui Province, China. Herein, the contents of 10 heavy metal elements including As, Hg, Cd, Pb, Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Zn and Fe were determined. In addition, the geochemical baseline of heavy metals was calculated based on the relative cumulative frequency curve method, and the soil pollution status was evaluated. The results show that the average contents of As, Hg, Cd, Cu, Mn and Zn exceeded the soil background values of Anhui Province by 3.82%–64.74% (1.04–1.65 times), meanwhile, the average contents of Pb and Cr were lower than the soil background values of Anhui Province. The average contents of Cd, Cr, Cu, Mn and Ni exceeded the Chinese soil background values by 1.61%–64.74% (0.98–1.65 times). The geochemical baseline values of As, Hg, Cd, Pb, Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Zn and Fe were 9.585 mg/kg, 0.028 mg/kg, 0.112 mg/kg, 21.59 mg/kg, 53.66 mg/kg, 19.31 mg/kg, 543.8 mg/kg, 24.93 mg/kg, 50.57 mg/kg and 2.654%, respectively. The pollution assessment results also showed that most of the farmland soil samples in the study area were non-polluting or slightly polluted based on geochemical baselines. Hg and Cu in a few samples were moderately polluted, and Cd in only one sample was moderately intensely polluted. Combined with the distribution of pollution and field investigation, it is considered that Hg comes from atmospheric deposition and agricultural non-point source pollution of industrial pollution. Cu comes from animal husbandry and agricultural pollution. Meanwhile, Cd is related to natural sources, wood processing and agricultural fertiliser application. The study demonstrated that the calculation of soil geochemical background value should take full account of the differences between the various regions, combined with the current state, particularly the pre-consideration of the distribution of elements or pollutants. Then, reasonably select the evaluation standard value so that the evaluation results can truly reflect the state of soil pollution.
Regional geochemistry of mercury in the Sino-Mongolian border region
2023, Applied GeochemistryThe Sino-Mongolian border region is a hotspot for international geoscience research and exploration. Mercury (Hg) can be used as a reference element for geochemical exploration and ore prospecting. This is because the change in Hg concentration and its spatial distribution can indirectly reflect the regional mineral distribution and regional environmental mercury pollution. Hg pollution caused by anthropogenic activities has received extensive attention because of its hazardous nature and Hg is generally regarded as a global pollutant. Although geochemical explorations have been conducted in the Sino-Mongolian border region, there have been relatively few studies with detailed and consolidated analyses of single elements such as Hg. To address this research gap we have examined the concentration and spatial distribution of Hg in this region. Influencing factors including the geological background, geomorphological landscapes, mineral distribution, development and use, and human activities, were also explored. The Hg concentration in the catchment sediment samples had a median value of 16.5 ng/g considered the geochemical background value, mean value of 18.9 ng/g, and a range of 0.5–712.5 ng/g. Low Hg concentrations are distributed in the Gobi Desert areas of Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia in China, and in the southern Gobi region of Mongolia because of the poor adsorption capacity for Hg by quartz-rich windblown sand. Areas with high Hg concentrations are distributed in the eastern and northwestern parts of the study region. Fifteen anomalous Hg enriched areas were delineated in the study region, among which 24 high Hg concentration centers (>25.4 ng/g, > Q85%) reached the scale of geochemical provinces. The high concentration of Hg in these centers is attributed to the widespread distribution of minerals containing elevated concentrations of Hg, minerals that produce substantial quantities of Hg as a by-product, and anthropogenic contributions such as mining and smelting activities. The enrichment of Hg in certain areas is an effective indicator of the occurrence of ore deposits. The Hg geochemical data obtained from the Sino-Mongolian border region is an important reference for further studies on geology, mineral exploration, and environmental protection.
Phosphorus reference conditions in lowland streams: Survey in old forests and anaerobic sediment release
2023, Science of the Total EnvironmentThe reference (pristine) concentrations of total dissolved phosphorus (TDP) in surface waters are difficult to define in lowland regions because of their high population density. Here, we estimated reference conditions of TDP from headwaters and their riverbed sediments (n = 140) in old forests. Surface waters and sediments were collected in the lowland region of Belgium as transects starting in 20 different old forests (before 1775; pristine) to up to 1.5 km outside the forest edge (disturbed). Sediment P concentrations in disturbed samples readily increased with increasing distance from the borders of old forests. The P mobilized from the sediments to the overlying water was also measured in laboratory incubations to mimic P release during seasonal redox cycles. The sediment respiration was larger in disturbed than in the reference sediments. Disturbed sediments released more P during anaerobic than aerobic incubations, while reference sediments did not show such a difference. The mean TDP in the reference surface water samples is 57 μg TDP L−1 [95 % confidence interval 41; 72], very close to the pre-industrial background previously estimated for the Scheldt river. The 90th percentile of the reference water is 137 [110; 180] μg TDP L−1. That P90 is just under the prevailing TP limit of 140 μg P L−1, illustrating that this limit is very close to the upper baseline of reference conditions. The P75, often proposed as the threshold for high ecological status, was 84 [55; 122] μg P L−1. This study showed that soil or sediments in old forests might serve to identify reference conditions. The well-established summer peaks of TDP in lowland rivers are unlikely to occur in pristine areas.
A review and critical assessment of sedimentary metal indices used in determining the magnitude of anthropogenic change in coastal environments
2023, Science of the Total EnvironmentThe current critical review examines the application of 11 frequently used sedimentary metal indices in their ability to accurately assess the magnitude of human-induced change (enrichment) in the highly vulnerable and intensely developed coastal environment.
The plethora and rapidly increasing number of sedimentary metal indices should, if not derived for special purposes, produce a consistent assessment on the basis that they use the same suite of metals and concentrations. Inconsistent numerical results produced by different index formulations should, when combined with their associated classification scheme, produce a common assessment of environmental condition. However, such a consistent outcome is seldom observed. Significant differences in assessment results are partly due to the historical evolution of indices and to the extraordinary diversity of background and reference values and materials being applied to account for pre-anthropogenic metal levels and confounding due to variable sediment characteristics. Size-normalised sample and background metal data used in the mCd and MEQ indices do not require reference values to account for textural variability and provide a quasi-direct measurement of enrichment with minimal computation (simple division). These priority indices should be combined into a single index (Enrichment Quotient, EQ). Results produced by the EF index were strongly correlated to mCd and MEQ and provide a similar classification and is recommended if normalised data are unavailable. Other indices assessed (MPI, PI, mPI, SEF, Igeo, PLI and Cf, original and current) provided a range of results, which either over- or under-estimated enrichment. The confusion concerning the choice and application of background and reference values in the assessment process is reviewed and their use in local and global assessment is clarified. Single- and combined-metal evaluations are recommended to provide detailed, local and more comprehensive assessments, respectively.