A BIM-based simulation framework for fire safety management and investigation of the critical factors affecting human evacuation performance
Introduction
The U.S. Fire Administration (USFA) has reported that, over the past decade, the fatalities and injuries, as well as the level of property loss due to fire hazards have increased. In 2017 alone, there were 3400 deaths, 14,670 injuries, and a loss of $23 billion in property caused by 1,319,500 fires [1], which indicate an urgent need for improvement in current fire safety management practices. In addition, different from fires in other types of buildings, densely occupied buildings have a number of unique features, such as high-density pedestrian flows, rapid oxygen consumption, limited space for movement, and fixed exits. For this reason, effective evacuation planning in densely occupied buildings should be primarily put in place if both the number of injuries and fatalities and the level of property loss are to be minimized. Thus, appropriate building design is key to improving evacuation efficiency as well as maximizing the usable space within a building. However, it is unethical and not realistic to study human evacuation performance during a fire. Therefore, computational tools are widely accepted as the best approach for simulating fire growth and human response to fire hazards. The simulation results can be used to predict fire safety performance and to assist in fire evacuation planning.
To date, advanced computational modeling concepts, such as building information modeling (BIM), Fire Dynamics Simulator (FDS), and agent-based modeling (ABM), have all been used to simulate the fire safety performance of buildings. Given the variety of modeling tools that are available on the market, it is arguably fortunate to take advantage of their respective strengths and implement them in fire safety management.
BIM is an advanced 3D modeling-based process that can be implemented to support the decision-making process with regard to a building or other built asset. Young et al. [2] reported that BIM have contributed to lean construction since mid-2000s. In fact, it has helped contractors to maximize project efficiency while also reducing the overall risks associated with a given project. As building fires are directly related to both casualties and building property losses, BIM implementation by design professionals have increased tremendously within the last decade due to the attempts to deliver better designs in terms of fire safety. Rüppel et al. [3], for example, designed a BIM-based serious game to determine human behavior during an emergency for evacuation planning. Similarly, Wang et al. [4] developed a BIM-based virtual environment to determine the evacuation flow given different building design options to optimize evacuation efficiency. In addition, Choi et al. [5] developed a BIM-based evaluation system to check the building regulations in place for fire safety assessment. Likewise, Eftekharirad et al. [6] integrated industry foundation classes (IFC) BIM and human behavior into a real-time fire emergency management system for fire safety control. Furthermore, Wang et al. [7] integrated BIM with a fire dynamics simulator to improve fire safety management practice, including evacuation assessment, egress planning, fire safety education, and fire equipment maintenance.
However, the full potential of such approaches has not yet been achieved. There are several obstacles including data interoperability as well as the technical limitations of the currently available BIM software, which cannot simultaneously model the fire-driven fluid flow and the occupant evacuation process. Therefore, this study aims to develop a comprehensive BIM-based simulation framework that is capable of implementing both FDS and ABM for fire safety management.
FDS is a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modeling tool that is used to simulate fire-driven fluid flows. FDS software is interoperable with architectural BIM software, i.e. architectural BIM file can be input into FDS software to simulate fire growth and display the results through a visualization software known as Smokeview (SMV) [8]. To date, FDS has helped to achieve various fire simulation goals, such as post-accident investigations [9], [10], fire safety assessments of existing buildings [11], and the analysis of factors that influence fire growth [12]. In an effort to integrate FDS with evacuation simulation tools (e.g., EVAC [13]), Tingyong et al. [14] developed a continuous model of FDS + EVAC to simulate the effects of fire on evacuation performance. However, they noted the difficulty of incorporating human behavior into an evacuation scenario design.
ABM technique enables to integrate human behavior into evacuation scenario design as it is a powerful modeling technique that is capable of facilitating both agent-to-agent interactions and agent-to-environment interactions. In ABM environment, agents can be defined as any type of individual that simulates behaviors in mathematical, theoretical, and logical ways [15]; it has been therefore applied across a wide range of research areas. For example, the prior applications of ABM in relation to evacuation scenarios have covered a variety of hazards, including earthquakes [16], [17], tsunamis [18], wildfires [19], hurricanes [20], and volcanic activity [21] among others. Additionally, ABM can be applied during design, construction, or maintenance phases in order to assist in the decision-making process regarding a given building. Papadopoulos et al. [22], for example, integrated ABM with the building performance simulation (BPS) technique to simulate energy consumption and to deliver an energy system design. Similarly, Azar et al. [23], [24] implemented ABM to investigate the effects of various occupancy parameters on energy usage in buildings during their maintenance phase. Therefore, it can be concluded that it is feasible to simulate indoor occupant responses using an ABM evacuation scenario design.
To date, a number of studies have been conducted with regard to the simulation of various emergency scenarios. Tang et al. [25] and Shi et al. [26], for example, designed ABM scenarios to simulate occupant performance in public building fires, while Peizhong et al. [27] designed an ABM simulation to investigate the evacuation outcomes in a given subway station. In [28], Joo et al. developed an affordance-based model to simulate agent reactions to different exit routes. Additionally, Boguslawski et al. [29] proposed a dynamic approach using agent-based models to determine optimal exit routes in hazardous environments. Nevertheless, their studies implied the difficulties of simulating human response to disasters and predicting the evacuation performance.
In addition to the human behavior (both individual and social behavior patterns), evacuation performance depends on physical properties of buildings (e.g. building design (building layout and materials) and occupant capacity) as well as the fire characteristics (e.g. changes in temperature, toxicity, and smoke layer height) [30]. Therefore, in order to deliver moderate predictions of evacuation outcomes, the human response during an emergency, more specifically the critical factors affecting human evacuation performance, should be further investigated.
The primary aim of this paper is to present a computational simulation framework for fire safety management. To that end, BIM serves as the platform for conducting the simulation and visualizing the simulation results—more specifically, simulating fire growth via the FDS tool and accounting for the critical factors in an ABM evacuation design. In order to determine its effectiveness, the proposed framework is tested on a set of data obtained from a night club fire. The simulation outputs are used to evaluate the fire resistance level and to predict evacuation outcomes for the studied building. Additionally, in terms of the statistical analysis of the simulation outputs, a linear regression model is used to optimize the building design; as well as two-sample t- tests are conducted to evaluate the proposed framework.
The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 provides a comprehensive review of the relevant literature. Section 3 details the simulation framework and methodology. The experimental implementation and the results are then evaluated and discussed in Section 4. The final section draws conclusions based on the results and offers recommendations for future research.
Section snippets
Research background
A comprehensive review of the previous literature relevant to the proposed simulation techniques is provided in this section. Moreover, the critical factors that affect the evacuation time during building fires are also identified.
BIM-based simulation framework
The goal of this study is to develop a BIM-based simulation framework that is capable of implementing FDS and ABM to improve the accuracy of fire simulation results, thus fire safety management in densely occupied buildings. This should in turn help reduce fatalities and injuries as well as property loss during a fire hazard. The overall framework is shown in Fig. 1. The first step of the framework requires developing an architectural BIM for the facility of interest. In this study, we
Experiment overview
To validate the practicality of the proposed framework, it is feasible to conduct an experimental implementation using a well-documented fire emergency that has (1) precise physical information of the building to develop an architectural BIM at LOD 300 and (2) adequate records of injuries/fatalities to evaluate the simulation outputs. The proposed framework supports 3D geometry, thus multi-story buildings can be evaluated using the proposed framework, which can give more insights for stairways
Conclusions and future research
BIM can support the decision-making process regarding a building or other built asset. This study developed a BIM-based simulation framework that is capable of implementing FDS and ABM for fire safety management. To validate the proposed methodology, an experimental implementation involving the Station nightclub fire case is conducted. The analysis of the experimental results verifies the respective reliabilities of (1) using BIM as a platform for conducting simulation design, (2) simulating
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
References (56)
- et al.
Designing a BIM-Based Serious Game for Fire Safety Evacuation Simulations
Adv. Eng. Inf.
(2011) - et al.
Development of BIM-based evacuation regulation checking system for high-rise and complex buildings
Autom. Constr.
(2014) - et al.
Applying building information modeling to support fire safety management
Autom. Constr.
(2015) - et al.
Using fire dynamic simulation (FDS) to reconstruct an arson fire scene
Build. Environ.
(2008) - et al.
Simulation of pedestrian evacuation in a room under fire emergency
Proc. Eng.
(2014) - et al.
An agent-based model for earthquake pedestrians’ evacuation simulation in urban scenarios
Transp. Res. Proc.
(2014) - et al.
An agent-based model of a multimodal near-field tsunami evacuation: decision-making and life safety
Transport. Res. Part C: Emerg. Technol.
(2016) - et al.
Integrating building performance simulation in agent-based modeling using regression surrogate models: A novel human-in-the-loop energy modeling approach
Energy Build.
(2016) - et al.
Agent-based evacuation model incorporating fire scene and building geometry
Tsinghua Sci. Technol.
(2008) - et al.
Agent-based evacuation model of large public buildings under fire conditions
Autom. Constr.
(2009)
Agent-based simulation of affordable-based human behaviors in emergency evacuation
Simul. Model. Pract. Theory
A dynamic approach for evacuees distribution and optimal routing in hazardous environments
Autom. Constr.
Building safety and human behavior in fire: a literature review
Fire Saf.
A BIM-based visualization and warning system for fire rescue
Adv. Eng. Inf.
Post-earthquake fire simulation considering overall seismic damage of sprinkler systems based on BIM and FEMA P-58
Autom. Constr.
An agent-based simulation system for concert venue crowd evacuation modeling in the presence of a fire disaster
Expert Syst. Appl.
Agent-based simulation of alternative classroom evacuation scenarios
Front. Arch. Res.
Simulation of evacuation in a twin bore tunnel: analysis of evacuation time and egress selection
Proc. Eng.
Counterflow model for agent-based simulation of crowd dynamics
Build. Environ.
Study of the human evacuation simulation of metro fire safety analysis in China
J. Loss Prev. Process Ind.
A comprehensive method for environmentally sensitive and behavioral microscopic egress analysis in case of fire in buildings
Saf. Sci.
The Business Value of BIM. SmartMarket Report: Design & Construction Intelligence
BIM based virtual environment for fire emergency evacuation
Sci. World J.
Extending IFC for fire emergency real-time management using sensors and occupant information
EasyChair Preprints
Coupled fire/evacuation analysis of the station nightclub fire
Fire Saf. Sci.
Use of PyroSim for simulation of cinema fire
Int. J. Recent Trends Eng. Technol.
Cited by (93)
An agent-based simulation model for analyzing and optimizing omni-channel retailing operation decisions
2024, Journal of Retailing and Consumer ServicesEmergency fire evacuation simulation of underground commercial street
2024, Simulation Modelling Practice and TheoryEnriching BIM models with fire safety equipment using keypoint-based symbol detection in escape plans
2024, Automation in ConstructionEmergency evacuation of urban underground commercial street based on BIM approach
2024, Ain Shams Engineering JournalCrowd evacuation with human-level intelligence via neuro-symbolic approach
2024, Advanced Engineering Informatics