Original contribution
Effects of sulfurous, salty, bromic, iodic thermal water nasal irrigations in nonallergic chronic rhinosinusitis: a prospective, randomized, double-blind, clinical, and cytological study

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amjoto.2010.02.004Get rights and content

Abstract

Objectives

Nasal irrigations are mentioned among the adjunctive measures for treating several sinonasal conditions. Hyperchromatic supranuclear stria (HSS) in the ciliated cells (CCs) has recently been suggested as a potential cytological marker of the anatomofunctional integrity of nasal mucosa. The aim of this study was to compare the effects of nasal irrigations with sulfurous, salty, bromic, iodic (SSBI) thermal water or isotonic sodium chloride solution (ISCS) in patients with nonallergic chronic rhinosinusitis, considering the endoscopic, functional, microbiological, and cytological evidence (including the ratio of HSS-positive CCs to total CCs [the HSS+ rate]).

Methods

In a prospective, randomized, double-blind setting, 80 patients were recruited for nasal irrigations with SSBI water or ISCS for 1 month.

Results

An endoscopically assessed significant clinical improvement was seen after both SSBI thermal water and ISCS irrigations. Before treatment, Staphylococcus aureus was isolated in 5 patients in the SSBI thermal water group and 4 in the ISCS group. After the nasal irrigations, there was no sign of the bacteria in either group. Only the SSBI water irrigations significantly reduced total nasal resistance, as determined by rhinomanometry. Mild nasal irritation (6 cases) and episodes of extremely limited epistaxis (5 cases) were only reported after SSBI thermal water irrigations. Neither type of nasal irrigation significantly increased the mean HSS+ rate at cytological control after 1 month.

Conclusions

Both types of nasal irrigation improved the endoscopic and microbiological features of patients with nonallergic chronic rhinosinusitis, whereas only SSBI irrigations significantly reduced total nasal resistance. Further investigations are needed based on longer treatments and follow-up periods to establish whether the HSS+ rate is useful for monitoring clinical improvements in chronic rhinosinusitis treated with nasal irrigations.

Introduction

Rhinosinusitis is a common disease that affects more than 31 million people in the United States every year [1]. Nasal irrigations are often recommended among the adjunctive measures for treating several sinonasal conditions. In 2000, Hamilos [2] discussed the rational treatment of chronic sinusitis and advocated the use of nasal irrigations; Benninger et al [3] also suggested including nasal irrigations in the treatment of most patients with rhinosinusitis. There is some controversy over the efficacy of nasal irrigation solutions of different tonicities and the use of additives in the solution [4]. In 2002, Rabago and coworkers [5] found that hypertonic nasal irrigations improved quality of life and overall symptom severity in patients with rhinosinusitis. Further investigations confirmed that hypertonic nasal irrigations were superior to isotonic solutions [6], [7]. When Staffieri and Abramo [8] measured the mucociliary transport time before and after inhalatory treatment with sulfurous, arsenical, ferruginous thermal water in 37 consecutive patients with chronic rhinosinusitis, they found a significant reduction in the transport time after the treatment. However, most of the available studies on nasal irrigations are based on limited, inadequately controlled series; and the exact mechanism behind the effects of nasal irrigations remains highly controversial. Some believe that nasal irrigations take effect mainly by clearing the mucus; others are convinced that they remove nasal inflammatory mediators [9]. Staffieri et al [10] found a direct correlation between sulfurous, salty, bromic, iodic (SSBI) thermal water irrigations and nasal secretory immunoglobulin A and albumin concentrations, concluding that this might be one of the mechanisms by which such irrigations may be effective in treating nasal inflammation.

Interest in cytological studies on the nasal mucosa is due to the relative simplicity of sample collection and to their utility in the clinical follow-up, especially to monitor the efficacy of medical and surgical treatments [11]. Normal nasal mucosa contains 4 types of cell: ciliated cells (Fig. 1), mucus-secreting cells, basal cells, and striated cells. In 2003, Gelardi and coworkers [11] found a hyperchromatic area in the cytoplasm of ciliated cells (Fig. 2) of healthy individuals, termed the hyperchromatic supranuclear stria (HSS) because of its position above the nucleus; the authors hypothesized that the HSS might express a high protein content because of a good metabolic activity of the cells and that it might consequently be a valid marker of the anatomical and functional integrity of the ciliated cells in the nasal mucosa [11].

Our prospective, double-blind, randomized study investigated the effects of nasal irrigations with SSBI thermal water vs isotonic sodium chloride solution (ISCS) in patients with nonallergic chronic rhinosinusitis, considering the clinical and microbiological evidence, and the cytological picture (the numbers of the HSS-positive and total ciliated cells).

Section snippets

Study design

The present investigation was a prospective, randomized, double-blind study conducted in accordance with the 1996 Helsinki Declaration. The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of Padova University Hospital in Italy (protocol no. 7302).

The inclusion criteria were age ranging from 18 to 65 years and nonallergic chronic rhinosinusitis; the exclusion criteria were autoimmune diseases, cystic fibrosis, and diabetes. At enrolment, patients provided microbiological nasal swabs and

Results

Sixty-six patients (82.5%) completed the 1-month treatment protocol and underwent final clinical, functional, microbiologic, and cytological assessment. Of these, 35 had used SSBI thermal water; and 31, ISCS.

Discussion

Epithelial cells play an important part in host defense and regulating immune response. They mediate innate immune responses by secreting dozens of distinct antimicrobial products; and they regulate adaptive immune responses by involving dendritic cells and also T and B cells, which are regulated by the release of cell-subtype–specific chemokines and the expression of soluble and cell-surface–expressed molecules that govern T and B cell differentiation, proliferation, and survival. In airway

Conclusions

We demonstrated the efficacy of a 1-month treatment with nasal irrigations (using either SSBI thermal water or ISCS) in improving the clinical (endoscopic) and microbiological features of patients with nonallergic chronic rhinosinusitis. From a functional respiratory standpoint, only the SSBI thermal water irrigations significantly reduced the total nasal resistance determined by active anterior rhinomanometry. Nasal irritation (6 patients) and extremely limited epistaxis (5 patients) were

Acknowledgments

The present study was partially supported by a grant from Federterme Scientific Foundation, Italy. Prof A Staffieri is a member of the Scientific Committee of Sirmione Spa, Italy. The authors thank Frances Coburn for checking the English version of this paper.

References (15)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (34)

  • Nasal function before and after rapid maxillary expansion in children: A randomized, prospective, controlled study

    2018, International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology
    Citation Excerpt :

    PNIF measurements were conducted as previously reported [6,13,14]. Nasal respiratory evaluation was also conducted using AAR (Rhinolab, Rendsburg, Germany) as previously described [7,16]. AAR values were expressed in Pascal (Pa).

  • Silver sucrose octasulfate nasal applications and wound healing after endoscopic sinus surgery: a prospective, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study

    2015, American Journal of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Medicine and Surgery
    Citation Excerpt :

    Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a common disorder that affects more than 31 million people in the United States every year [1].

  • N-butanol olfactory threshold and nasal patency before and after palatal expansion in children. A preliminary study

    2014, International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology
    Citation Excerpt :

    PNIF measurements were conducted as previously reported [8,10]. Nasal patency was also evaluated using AAR (Rhinolab, Rendsburg, Germany) as previously described [23]. AAR values were expressed in Pascal (Pa).

  • Smoking and chronic rhinitis: Effects of nasal irrigations with sulfurous-arsenical-ferruginous thermal water: A prospective, randomized, double-blind study

    2012, American Journal of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Medicine and Surgery
    Citation Excerpt :

    The thermal water group also had a more evident improvement in nasal patency than in the controls, which persisted throughout the follow-up, indicating that thermal water irrigations would have a lasting effect on nasal resistances. In another recent study on the effects of nasal irrigations with sulfurous, salty, bromic, iodic thermal water in patients with nonallergic chronic rhinosinusitis, Ottaviano et al [22] found a statistical trend toward lower nasal resistances in patients treated with thermal water nasal irrigations. Nasal cytology has been an important diagnostic tool for more than 100 years and has been used in rhinology to distinguish between different types of rhinopathy.

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text