Research paperIntegrated two-stage chemically processing of rice straw cellulose to butyl levulinate
Graphical abstract
Introduction
In recent years, substantial research interest has been garnered towards chemically or biologically processing of lignocellulosic biomass to chemical products as a more sustainable system than fossil fuel derived chemicals (Jäger & Büchs, 2012). Currently more than 90% of the chemical industry relies on fossil fuel of petroleum and natural gas as feedstock to produce their products. Many researchers have proposed that lignocellulosic biomass substrates such as agricultural residues including rice, wheat, and sorghum straw, could be a potential resource in the near future for sustainable production of fuels (bio-ethanol and -butanol) and chemicals because of their abundant availability, and relatively low-cost, and renewable nature (Berndes, Hoogwijk, & van den Broek, 2003; Field, Campbell, & Lobell, 2008). Among crop residues, rice straw accounts for the largest portion of available biomass feedstock globally with annual production of ∼731 million tons of which about 90% comes from Asia alone (Belal, 2013; Wi, Choi, Kim, Kim, & Bae, 2013). Rice straw, like other agriculture residues, is primary composed of three biopolymers including cellulose (35–40%), hemicellulose (20–25%) and lignin (20–27%) polymers, and also considerable ash matter (10–15% wt. basis). Unlike some other lignocellulosic material such as grasses and legumes, rice straw is considered a low quality dietary fiber because of its higher silica level (or content) that results in poor digestion in animals (Wi, Choi, Kim, Kim, & Bae, 2013) and also reduces its ability to biodegrade in fields. Therefore, the major practice followed in many producing countries is in-field burning as the most cost-effective method of elimination to enable nutrient release and disposal to enable new plantings. However, this creates serious environmental, safety and health issues due to the atmospheric emissions of fine particulate matter and other toxic compounds from the low-temperature combustion (Gadde, Bonnet, Menke, & Garivait, 2009).
Levulinic acid (LA), which may be obtained directly from lignocellulosic materials, is a promising platform chemical that in turn is able to be converted into a wide variety of chemical and fuel products including gamma valerolactone, methyl tetrahydrofuran and others. LA contains a ketone and carboxylic acid functional groups that makes it a versatile building block for the synthesis of various bulk chemicals (Bozell et al., 2000; Galletti, Antonetti, De Luise, & Valentini, 2011). LA is generally prepared from a hexose sugar such as glucose through isomerization to fructose which undergoes dehydration to lose three H2O molecules to form 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (5-HMF) which then further degrades to levulinic and formic acid. Chemical approaches for LA production involves high temperatures under acidic conditions, using either mineral acids, such as sulfuric, hydrochloric and phosphoric acids (Runge & Zhang, 2012) or solid acids such as acid functionalized zeolites, heteropoly acids, or acid functionalized resins (Mukherjee, Dumont, & Raghavan, 2015). The final product yield is dependent upon the extent of the degradation reactions involved, which are significantly influenced by various reaction parameters including acid concentration, temperature and residence time (Chang, Cen, & Ma, 2007). Typically, this reaction yields less than 50% wt. (maximum theoretical yield is 64.5% wt.) due to the formation of undesired solid co-products typically referred to as humins, from the polymerization of HMF (de Souza, Yu, Rataboul, & Essayem, 2012).
Beyond the yield challenges from the reaction conditions, using biomass cellulose introduces additionally challenges to be effectively hydrolyzed to monomeric sugar molecules through either chemical or biological catalyst strategies because of its crystalline structure (Chundawat et al., 2011; Laureano-Perez, Teymouri, Alizadeh, & Dale, 2005). Extensive research has already been conducted for LA preparation from many possible biomass feedstocks including agricultural residues, energy crops, forestry residues, municipal wastes, algal marine biomass and biomass derived monomeric sugars (Jeong & Park, 2010; Mukherjee, Dumont, & Raghavan, 2015; Rackemann & Doherty, 2011). The majority of these studies have used sulfuric acid as the catalyst because of its low cost and effectiveness under severe conditions (maximum 250 °C and 10% wt. for 7 h), with yields approaching 33% wt. (Galletti, Antonetti, De Luise, & Valentini, 2011; Mukherjee, Dumont, & Raghavan, 2015).
Co-solvent systems, either as a mono- or bi-phasic systems, have been recently developed as a processing strategy to create furanics and their derivatives in higher yields. These systems typically consist of an aqueous solvent, containing an acid catalyst to perform the hydrolysis and dehydration reaction, and an organic solvent, serving as an extraction medium. Several detailed mechanistic studies have proposed that solvent plays a key role by offering continuous extraction of chemicals as soon as they are produced thereby exhibiting improved product recovery by protecting them from possible occurrence of side reactions that generates humic substances. Commonly used extraction solvent agents are methyl isobutyl ketone (MIBK), methyl-tetrahydrofuran (MTHF), dichloromethane (DCM), 2-butanol and tetrahydrofuran (THF) (Cao, Schwartz, McClelland, Krishna, Dumesic, & Huber, 2015; Saha & Abu-Omar, 2014). Among extraction solvents, THF is considered one of the most promising because it is biorenewable and has suitable physical properties for the reaction conditions. Recently, Cai, Zhang, Kumar, and Wyman (2013) have reported improved furanics yield using different biomass substrates in a dilute sulfuric acid-THF co-solvent system under high severity conditions. The researchers proposed that molecular similarities between THF and 5-HMF might be responsible for enhanced furan production by enabling increased extractability. In general, classical LA preparation methods, either through homogeneous or heterogeneous catalysis, encounter corrosion issues due to the reaction media’s corrosive nature of strong acids under severe conditions. Additionally, heterogeneous catalysis must also overcome expensive solid acid catalyst synthesis and its rapid deactivation (Mukherjee, Dumont, & Raghavan, 2015; Rackemann & Doherty, 2011).
Alkyl levulinates (denoted as BioEs) like ethyl, methyl, propyl and butyl levulinates, are derivatives of levulinic acid, (Chang, Xu, & Jiang, 2012; Chen, Zhao, & Chen, 2014; Hu & Li, 2011) and have recently gained attention due to their numerous potential industrial applications as solvent, plasticizer, flavour additive (Mascal & Nikitin, 2010) and oxygenated energy fuel additive to gasoline and diesel fuels (Gürbüz, Alonso, Bond, & Dumesic, 2011). These alkyl esters are generally obtained through Fischer esterification reaction of LA in the presence of strong mineral acids, either homogenous or heterogeneous, and alcohol (Nandiwale, Niphadkar, Deshpande, & Bokade, 2014). Numerous studies have also demonstrated for direct synthesis of alkyl levulinates from cellulose and lignocellulosic substrates through one-pot acid-catalysed reaction with alcohol (Le Van Mao, Zhao, Dima, & Petraccone, 2011; Li, Peng, Lin, Chen, & Zhang, 2013; Peng, Lin, Li, & Chen, 2013; Tominaga, Mori, Fukushima, Shimada, & Sato, 2011). For instance, recently, Chang et al. have reported ∼18% wt. levulinic acid ethyl ester yield from wheat straw using sulfuric acid and ethyl alcohol under elevated reaction conditions (200 °C; 3% wt. H2SO4 conc.) (Chang, Xu, & Jiang, 2012). However, most of these chemically processing strategies involve corrosive chemicals such as sulfuric acid, require more energy consuming techniques like distillation, and use environmentally unfriendly solvent chemicals for downstream product processing (Olson, Kjelden, Schlag, & Sharma, 2001). The present study was developed to produce butyl levulinate (BL) from rice straw cellulose via an integrated two-stage chemical transformation reactions with levulinic acid produced in a co-solvent system and then subjecting it to esterification reaction for BL synthesis. A novel combination of dilute phosphoric acid and tetrahydrofuran, as extraction solvent was evaluated for LA production in order to reduce corrosiveness (as compared to strong mineral acids; 150–250 °C; 2–6 h) and improved product yields. An attempt was also made to improve the BL yield by subjecting both LA and residual 5-HMF, which were selectively isolated from the post-reaction liquid medium by employing typical liquid–liquid solvent extraction protocol using ethyl acetate. Lastly, the post-reaction solid residues were subjected to enzymatic digestibility in order to investigate the effectiveness of the co-solvent dilute acid treatment on fermentable sugar release.
Section snippets
Feedstock and chemical reagents
Rice straw samples were collected from the local agricultural field around Mohali, Punjab State, India. It was air-dried to less than 10% moisture (dry basis), size reduced using a commercial grinder (Kinematica PX-MFC 90 D) and sieved to a uniform particle size with maximum particle size falling between 0.5–1.0 mm. The processed material was then stored in plastic bags at room temperature until further use. All chemicals and reagents were purchased commercially (analytical grade) and used as
Levulinic acid production in co-solvent reaction system
A single reactor system was used to convert rice straw cellulose to levulinic acid (LA) in a co-solvent system consisting of dilute phosphoric acid (1.5 M) with different water-miscible solvents namely methanol, ethanol and THF (water miscible upto 30% w/w) to evaluate for most suitable co-solvent yielding maximum product concentration (acid to solvent ratio 1:2). Previous studies has suggested these solvents to be promising for substrate degradation via synergistic hydrolytic effect in
Conclusions
In the present study, an integrated two-stage chemical conversion of rice straw (raw) to butyl levulinate, a levulinic acid (LA) derivative chemical was demonstrated. In the first stage, rice straw was converted to LA in a single vessel, co-solvent reaction system. The co-solvent system used a novel combination of dilute phosphoric acid as the catalytic system combined with tetrahydrofuran (THF), as extraction solvent to improve yield, using an 1:2 acid to solvent ratio. Followed by LA
Acknowledgements
The authors (SE, BA and RSS) gratefully thank Department of Biotechnology (Govt. of India), New Delhi, India for their consistent financial support. The authors thank Prof. Ashok Pandey, CSIR-NIIST, Kerala, India for his valuable suggestions on this work.
References (57)
- et al.
The contribution of biomass in the future global energy supply: a review of 17 studies
Biomass and Bioenergy
(2003) - et al.
Production of levulinic acid and use as a platform chemical for derived products
Resources, Conservation and Recycling
(2000) - et al.
Levulinic acid production from wheat straw
Bioresource Technology
(2007) - et al.
Production of ethyl levulinate by direct conversion of wheat straw in ethanol media
Bioresource Technology
(2012) - et al.
Biomass energy: the scale of the potential resource
Trends in Ecology & Evolution
(2008) - et al.
Air pollutant emissions from rice straw open field burning in India, Thailand and the Philippines
Environmental Pollution
(2009) - et al.
Kinetic study of catalytic esterification of butyric acid and n-butanol over Dowex 50Wx8-400
Chemical Engineering Journal
(2011) - et al.
Synthesis, isolation and characterization of methyl levulinate from cellulose catalyzed by extremely low concentration acid
Journal of Energy Chemistry
(2013) - et al.
Competing forces during cellulose dissolution: from solvents to mechanisms
Current Opinion in Colloid & Interface Science
(2014) - et al.
Review: sustainable production of hydroxymethylfurfural and levulinic acid: challenges and opportunities
Biomass and Bioenergy
(2015)
Characterization of Canadian biomass for alternative renewable biofuel
Renewable Energy
Solid acid catalyzed glucose conversion to ethyl levulinate
Applied Catalysis A: General
The effect of volatile fatty acid additions on the anaerobic digestion of cellulose and glucose in batch reactors
Process Biochemistry
Optimization of dilute acid and hot water pretreatment of different lignocellulosic biomass: a comparative study
Biomass and Bioenergy
Increased tolerance and conversion of inhibitors in lignocellulosic hydrolysates by Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology
Solubility of d-glucose in water and ethanol/water mixtures
Journal of Chemical & Engineering Data
Acidic ionic liquid catalyzed one-pot conversion of cellulose to ethyl levulinate and levulinic acid in ethanol-water solvent system
Bioenergy Research
Bioethanol production from rice straw residues
Brazilian Journal of Microbiology
THF co-solvent enhances hydrocarbon fuel precursor yields from lignocellulosic biomass
Green Chemistry
Dehydration of cellulose to levoglucosenone using polar aprotic solvents
Energy & Environmental Science
Efficient production of 5-hydroxymethylfurfural and alkyl levulinate from biomass carbohydrate using ionic liquid-based polyoxometalate salts
RSC Advances
Restructuring the crystalline cellulose hydrogen bond network enhances its depolymerization rate
Journal of the American Chemical Society
Introduction to solvent extraction
Solvent extraction, principles and practice
Epigallocatechin gallate incorporation into lignin enhances the alkaline delignification and enzymatic saccharification of cell walls
Biotechnology for Biofuels
Combined sodium hydroxide and ammonium hydroxide pretreatment of post-biogas digestion dairy manure fiber for cost effective cellulosic bioethanol production
Sustainable Chemical Processes
Acid hydrolysis of cellulose
Reactive extraction of levulinate esters and conversion to γ-valerolactone for production of liquid fuels
ChemSusChem
Conversion of biomass to levulinic acid: a new feedstock for the chemical industry
Chimica e l’Industria
Cited by (26)
Magnetic rice-straw-derived biochar for adsorptive removal of Hg(II) from aqueous solution: Optimization using response surface methodology
2023, Journal of Environmental Chemical EngineeringDesign and synthesis of SO<inf>3</inf>H-functionalized acidic ionic liquids for catalytic conversion of wheat straw to ethyl levulinate
2023, FuelCitation Excerpt :The recent years have witnessed rapid development in the chemical fields of medicine, materials, and fragrance [4–6], such as the synthesis of γ-valerolactone and its derivatives and other industrial chemicals, since AL emerged as an important chemical raw material [7,8]. The direct conversion of lignocellulose into AL in alcohol is a promising route [4], however, the lignocellulose into EL is still limited, such as low yield and poor economic benefits [9,10]. The mainly reason is that the lignin component in lignocellulosic biomass affects the conversion of lignocellulose [11,12].
Sustainable production of furan-based oxygenated fuel additives from pentose-rich biomass residues
2022, Energy Conversion and Management: XCitation Excerpt :The reaction mixture after the extraction process consisted of BL and levulinic acid, where BL separated, and levulinic acid was further esterified in n-butanol catalyzed by H2SO4 at 100 °C into BL [113]. Rice straw was converted into BL in a two-step process, which began with the degradation of biomass using H3PO4 in THF with levulinic acid and HMF as intermediates, followed by esterification of levulinic acid catalyzed by H2SO4 (0.5 M) in n-butanol for 60 min to BL (yield of 7.0%) [115]. One-pot alcoholysis of the cellulose-rich feedstock of Eucalyptus nitens into BL in n-butanol catalyzed by diluting H2SO4 (1.2 wt%) at 190 °C for 120 min with the highest yield of BL at 49 mol%, which was higher than that under microwave heating [82].
Production of levulinic acid and alkyl levulinates: A process insight
2022, Green ChemistryDirect conversion of furfural to levulinic acid/ester in dimethoxymethane: Understanding the mechanism for polymerization
2019, Green Energy and EnvironmentCitation Excerpt :Levulinate esters, the esters from esterification of levulinic acid with alcohols, are also the important platform compounds that can be used as solvents and additives [12–17]. The productions of levulinic acid or levulinates from cellulose in biomass or the C6 sugars (glucose, fructose, levoglucosan) have been the focus of many studies [18–29]. Levulinic acid can be formed via the dehydration of C6 sugars to 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF), and the subsequent decomposition of HMF to levulinic acid and formic acid [19,30–34].