Validating verdancy or vacancy? The relationship of community gardens and vacant lands in the U.S.
Section snippets
Literature review: Community gardening, vacancy, and means versus ends
Community gardening embodies a diverse set of practices that vary over time and space; they are not merely instrumental interventions but become complexly interwoven into neighborhood and broader urban processes. Although numerous studies have shown how community gardening has assisted residents in times of crisis (Bassett, 1981, Lawson, 2005), many others show how community gardens become more than simply a stopgap measure. Empirical research indicates that community gardening facilitates many
Methods and materials
We believe that a historical perspective can shed light on the processes through which community gardening has often come to be identified as a temporary practice—an interim use of vacant land. Below, we engage the interpretive frame of genealogy, which is useful in tracing the complicated histories of taken-for-granted assumptions (Elden, 2009, Foucault, 1984). This form of analysis particularly focuses on the ways that dominant narratives persist even though exceptions repeatedly appear (
Vacant lot cultivation in the 1890s
In the American city of the 1890s, gardening was an attractive solution for a range of economic, social, and environmental concerns and spurred inter-connected efforts in income-generating vacant gardens, school gardening, and beautification efforts (Lawson, 2005). Of particular interest to this paper is the effort to engage unemployed workers in gardening for food and income, known as Vacant Lot Cultivation Associations (VLCAs). Advocacy directed toward the unemployed during this period
The domestic war front: Gardening and vacant land
During both World Wars I and II, federal agencies and national organizations framed gardening as a popular aspect of domestic war preparedness, addressing a strained food system, drawing people together, and encouraging health. In World War I, the message was that people were starving and Americans must grow food so more could be sent overseas. As President Woodrow Wilson stated, “everyone who creates or cultivates a garden helps, and helps greatly, to solve the problem of the feeding of
1970s to Present: Community gardeners setting the tone
From the 1970s onward, community gardeners and garden interest groups became key figures in community garden discourse. They talked about how community gardens are integral parts of their lives, but characterized vacant lots as the locations for such activities. By the 1970s, the nation faced very different social and economic picture than in previous decades. Political movements were often grassroots-oriented; community garden advocates included environmental groups, education groups, and
Discussion: The difficulty of means to ends and end in itself
There is a long history of understanding community gardening as a temporary practice. The previous critical examination reveals how a taken-for-granted assumption that links community gardens and vacant land came to be so prevalent. It continues to underpin many people’s thoughts about gardening and vacant lots, particularly those organizations that are not made up of community gardeners. Yet, as gardeners have become key actors in community garden discourse in recent decades they continue to
Conclusion
Community gardening is an effective lens through which to examine how vacant land is being repurposed in a variety of ways. Our genealogy highlights the historical trajectory of garden advocacy that has produced knowledge of community gardens as temporary uses of temporarily-available spaces and how advocates, and some gardeners themselves, reproduce that dominant narrative. By doing so, we seek to open a space of possibility in rethinking who gets to decide when land is “vacant” and also raise
References (96)
- et al.
Fruit and vegetable intake among urban community gardeners
Journal of Nutrition Education and Behavior
(2008) A survey of community gardens in upstate New York: Implications for health promotion and community development
Health & Place
(2000)- et al.
Can cities become self-reliant in food?
Cities
(2012) - et al.
Evidence-based strategies to build community food security
Journal of the American Dietetic Association
(2005) It takes a garden: Cultivating citizen-subjects in organized garden projects
Geoforum
(2008)Two gardeners feed 40 people
Journal of Community Gardening
(1985)Cultivation of vacant lots by the unemployed
AICP Notes
(1898)- et al.
Community gardening, neighborhood meetings, and social capital
Journal of community psychology
(2010) Reweaving the food security safety net: Mediating entitlement and entrepreneurship
Agriculture and Human Values
(1999)- American Community Gardening Association (2007). Understanding the benefits....
Policy guide to community and regional food planning
Nine men and a city acre
The Survey
Industrial cooperative gardening: The story of a cooperative farm plan
Reaping on the margins: A century of community gardening in America
Landscape
Old cities/green cities: Communities transform unmanaged land
Victory gardens
Terra incognita: Vacant land and urban strategies
Community gardens are not forever
Community Greening Review
Discourse
Association for improving the condition of the poor
Setting up a program of work relief
Community programs for subsistence gardens
The city and suburban vegetable garden
Community gardening for food security
Community Greening Review
Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science
Textual and discourse analysis
Actually existing commons: Three moments of space of community gardens in New York City
Antipode
From the ground up: Community gardens in New York City and the politics of spatial transformation
Genealogy
The emergency work relief program of the FERA
People, land and sustainability: Community gardens and the social dimension of sustainable development
Social Policy and Administration
The CFSC: The community food security coalition
Community Greening Review
A successful experiment for the maintenance of self-respecting manhood
Arena
Nietzsche, genealogy, history
The order of discourse
Some different meanings attached to a city park and community gardens
Landscape Journal
The work that parks do: Towards an urban environmentality
Social & Cultural Geography
Urban agriculture: A sixteen city survey of urban agriculture practices across the country
Community gardens are not portable
Journal of Community Gardening
Vacant lot garden work for 1910
The Survey
Four year experience with self-help or subsistence gardens in Monroe County, New York
Is getting into the community garden business a good way to engage citizens in local government?
National Civic Review
Cultivating citizen-subjects through collective praxis: Organized gardening projects in Australia and the Philippines
Urban community gardens: Greening the city and growing communities
Cultivating just planning and legal institutions: A critical assessment of the South Central Farm struggle in Los Angeles
Journal of Urban Affairs
Cited by (84)
Temporary reuse in leftover spaces through the preferences of the elderly
2022, CitiesCitation Excerpt :In the case of metropolitan cities of developing countries (Sanches and Pellegrino, 2016), applying the urban acupuncture approach in vacant lands can allow a convenient opportunity to revive the city. Leftover spaces are part of the infrastructure that have the potential to improve the process of social situations (Pallagst et al., 2017; Zhang et al., 2019), ecological conditions (Kremer et al., 2013a, 2013b; Sanches and Pellegrino, 2016a, 2016b), Economic (Drake and Lawson, 2014; Loures et al., 2016), and Aesthetics (Dall’Ara et al., 2019; Jorgensen and Tylecote, 2007). There is still a need for research on how to intervene in the different areas, management practices, and interim uses (Kremer et al., 2013a, 2013b).
Centering environmental justice: Gentrification beliefs, attitudes, and support of park development in a shrinking city
2021, Landscape and Urban PlanningDesign possibilities of leftover spaces as a pocket park in relation to planting enclosure
2021, Urban Forestry and Urban GreeningCitation Excerpt :Concepts such as ‘dead space’ and ‘voids’ present leftover spaces as negative parcels in urban fabric (Cox et al., 2017). However, Collins and Savage (1998); Fox (1989); Garde (1999), Jonas (2007), Desimini (2015); Gardiner et al. (2014); Drake and Lawson (2014); Loures et al. (2016), insist that these sites are likely to become key strategic places, recognizing the potential of the underused landscape to provide social, environmental, aesthetic aspects and hidden capacities (Ahern, 2007; Sanches and Pellegrino, 2016). Open spaces also include neighboring spaces between buildings (Ford, 2000; Faizi et al., 2011).
The shifting role of public–private partnerships in vacant property redevelopment
2021, Land Use PolicyPlanning urban community gardens strategically through multicriteria decision analysis
2021, Urban Forestry and Urban Greening