First-principles calculation of microstructural processes in alloys
Introduction
Cluster Variation Method (hereafter CVM) [1] has been recognized as one of the most reliable theoretical tools to calculate configurational entropy and free energy of an alloy system. The level of the CVM approximation is specified by a largest cluster explicitly considered in the free energy formula, termed basic cluster, and it has been amply demonstrated [2], [3] that the calculated transition temperatures approaches a correct value obtained by other methods such as Monte Carlo simulation or high temperature expansion by increasing the size of the basic cluster. Although the employment of a bigger basic cluster demands heavy computational burden, recent development of high performance computer resolves such a difficulty.
The power of the CVM is not limited to the accuracy of the calculated results, but also the expandability and connectivity with other theoretical means to perform first-principles calculation of phase equilibria and phase transition dynamics are unique advantageous feature. In fact, the author have been attempting the first-principles calculations of phase diagrams [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9] by combining CVM with the electronic structure total energy calculations such as FLAPW method and reproduced the experimental phase diagram with high accuracy. The key to such an expandability of the CVM is ascribed to the correlation functions [2], [3], [10] which describe the atomic configurations of an alloy, and correlation functions are common variables shared by various theoretical methods in other realm of alloy theories including energetics and dynamics as will be discussed in this article.
Recently, Phase Field Method (hereafter PFM) [11] has been attracting broad attention as a powerful theoretical tool to predict and analyze microstructure evolution process of alloys. The key to the PFM is to define appropriate order parameters of which spatial distribution represents microstructure of interests, and the evolution process is described by Time Dependent Ginzburg Landau equation [12] and/or Cahn Hilliard equation [13]. The applicability of the PFM is surprisingly versatile, which can be ascribed to the phenomenological nature of the PFM in which the free energy is efficiently parametrized. It is, however, noted that the microstructure in the PFM is defined in a continuum medium, indicating that the order parameter is a continuous quantity of which atomistic origin is obscured. Hence, the length scale is not uniquely assigned based on the discrete nature of a lattice. This is regarded as a drawback of PFM to extend it to more quantitative and atomistic calculations.
The author’s group attempted [14], [15], [16], [17], [18], [19], [20] to combine PFM with the CVM by assigning correlation functions appearing in the CVM as order parameters in the PFM. Since the correlation functions are defined on a discrete lattice, it is necessary to perform the coarse graining operation in order to incorporate correlation functions in a coherent manner in the PFM which is defined in the continuum medium. Ohno [18] developed a unique procedure of the coarse graining operation by extending the traditional work by Kikuchi and Cahn [21], and performed multi-scale calculation for the growth process of Anti Phase Boundary (hereafter APB) associated with ordering reactions. Later, Mohri et al. further included the electronic structure total energy calculations and performed the first-principles microstructure evolution calculations for Fe–Pd [20] and Fe–Pt systems. The first half of the present paper is attributed to the introduction of the theoretical framework of these calculations.
However, there still remain room for improvement for these first-principles calculations in view of the recent development of the CVM. In particular, the lattice dealt with by the conventional CVM is allowed to deform only in a uniform manner and local lattice distortion is by no means introduced. This is deemed a serious drawback to achieve high accuracy in calculated results, since the system may still stay in the excited state without considering the local lattice relaxation. However, a fully satisfactory calculation of even static phase equilibria incorporating the local lattice relaxation effects is still pre-matured, and the implementation of such a scheme into PFM is far away. In the later half of the present report, preliminary calculations [22] for phase equilibria with local lattice relaxation effects are introduced and the significance of the effects are pointed out.
Furthermore, a brief discussion on the interface structure by the CVM is offered at the end, since the evolution kinetics of an APB is affected by the detailed atomistic structure and atomistic calculations of the interface should be more seriously explored. In fact, in the multi-scale calculation, interface falls in the medium scale range and it is a difficult task to reflect the atomistic structure of the interface efficiently into the microstructural formation and evolution processes.
The organization of the present report is as follows. In the next section, theoretical frameworks to perform the first-principles microstructure evolution calculation in the previous studies are reviewed and main results are reproduced. Two problems to be settled in the future calculations are pointed out in the third section and preliminary results are demonstrated. Finally the brief summary follows in the last section. Throughout this report, a particular focus is placed on the discussion of how the CVM free energy has been modified towards the first-principles microstructure calculations and how the CVM free energy should be further revised for accurate calculations.
Section snippets
First-principles calculation of time evolution of Anti Phase Boundary
The common parameters which connect three theoretical tools from FLAPW (electronic structure) to PFM (microstructure) through CVM (atomistic configuration) are the correlation functions as described below. In the electronic structure calculations, the main outcome is the total energy E(m) of a phase specified by m, and the heats of formation is derived with respect to an appropriate energy reference state. The heats of formation of a selected set of ordered phases including pure
Prospects for future first-principles calculations and local lattice relaxation effects
In order to further improve and generalize the free energy formula for first-principles calculations of phase equilibria and microstructural evolution process, two important modifications and applications are suggested in the present section. The first one is the incorporation of the local lattice relaxation effects. As pointed out in the earlier section, without local lattice relaxation effects, the system is still not fully in the equilibrium state and the introduction of the local lattice
Summary
First-principles calculation of time evolution process of APB is attempted for Fe–Pd L10-disorder transition by combining CVM and FLAPW with PFM through coarse graining operation. The length scale is uniquely fixed in a self-consistent manner in the theoretical framework and the resultant microstructural evolution is quite reasonable. It is pointed out that for further accurate calculations, it is indispensable to introduce local lattice distortion effects. Preliminary calculation on the square
Acknowledgements
The present work was partly supported by Next Generation Supercomputing Project, Nanoscience Program, MEXT, Japan. The author is grateful to Professor M. Ohno of Hokkaido University and Professor Y. Chen of U. Tokyo for their stimulating discussions and collaborations.
References (34)
- et al.
Acta Metal.
(1985) - et al.
Calphad
(2002) - et al.
J. Alloys Compd.
(2004) - et al.
Acta Mater.
(1997) - et al.
Mater. Sci. Eng.
(2001) - et al.
J. Phys. Chem. Solids.
(1962) - et al.
Physica
(1992) - et al.
Compt. Mater. Sci.
(1999) - et al.
Acta Metal.
(1979) - et al.
Intermetallics
(2008)
Phys. Rev.
Phys. Rev.
J. Phys. Condens. Matter
Mater. Trans.
Mater. Trans.
Physica (Utrecht)
Cited by (3)
Planar Superstructure Defects in Ordered Alloys with L1 Structure
2023, Metals and Materials InternationalCluster Variation Method as a Theoretical Tool for the Study of Phase Transformation
2017, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A: Physical Metallurgy and Materials Science