Use of binary and ternary blends in high strength concrete
Introduction
Mixture proportioning of high strength concrete (HSC) is more critical than that of normal strength concrete (NSC) since, usually, specially selected pozzolanic and chemical admixtures are employed, and a low water-to-binder ratio (w/b) is considered essential. Optimum mixture proportions are obtained after a greater number of trial batches than needed for NSC [1]. There is no single method for the proportioning of HSC, and this leads to different approaches to the issue [1], [2], [3].
The advantages of using cement additions in concrete are, mainly, the improved concrete properties in fresh and hardened states, and economical and ecological benefits. The achievement of these advantages becomes more important for HSC proportioning since HSC requires high amounts of cementitious materials. However, the selection of additions needs more attention due to their different properties: initial reactions of fly ash (FA), ground granulated blast furnace slag (S) and natural pozzolans are slower than that of Portland cement (PC), which causes a slower rate of strength development and a longer curing period. Slags develop strength more rapidly than do most fly ashes [4]. Silica fume (SF), due to its high surface area, increases water demand and superplasticizer requirement for a certain consistency [5], [6]. In addition, the use of SF should be limited due to the high costs of SF itself and the superplasticizer required. High-calcium fly ash (FA/C) is much more reactive than low-calcium fly ash (FA/F) and, therefore, exhibits some similarity to the behavior of S [7], [8]. In some cases, combined usage of the additions may reduce the efficiency of the cementitious system. In other words, the compatibility of the additions is another point to be considered in concrete proportioning. For example, the reaction of FA/F requires a high alkalinity of the pore water and this alkalinity is reduced when SF or S is present in the mix. Consequently, the reactivity of FA in such mixes is reduced [8], [9].
Fortunately, combinations of additions may provide more benefits for concrete when compared to a single one [10], [11]. Some examples of the researches on the use of ternary blends are given below.
Since the additions having low surface area and reactivity do not contribute to the strength quickly, they are not able to improve early strengths of concrete. The solution given by Mehta and Gjørv is to use a mixture of normal and highly reactive additions, such as FA and SF, respectively [10]. A number of reports demonstrated that the combined usage of SF and FA resulted in improvements in compressive strength [6], [10], [11], pore size distribution [10], chloride permeability [11], [12], alkali-silica reactions [12], [13] and sulfate resistance [12].
The results of a study by Shannag [14] suggest that certain natural pozzolan-SF combinations can improve the compressive and splitting tensile strengths, workability, and elastic modulus of concretes, more than natural pozzolan or SF alone.
The incorporation of a combination of finely ground FA and S with PC was reported to produce higher compressive strengths at all ages than their binary blends [15]. Similarly, according to Li and Zhao, blending FA and S presents an excellent behaviour in both short- and long-term compressive strengths and in resistance to H2SO4 attack; and improves the microstructure and hydration rate [16]. Jianyong and Pei concluded that blending S and SF synergizes the advantages of these two admixtures so that the compressive strength, split tensile strength and rupture strength are improved while the fresh concrete mixture keeps a good workability [17]. The ternary blends of PC, SF and FA or S were also studied and it was found that these blends can increase the ASR resistance [13] and chloride resistance [18] of concrete.
This study investigates the compressive strengths of the high strength concretes containing (a) PC only, (b) PC + SF binary binders, and (c) PC + SF + FA/F or FA/C or S ternary binders. The binder content in the concrete mixtures was also varied. The main objective of this research is to determine the effects of using a third binder (FA/F or FA/C or S) accompanying PC and SF to produce high strength concretes. By using different amounts of the most widely known additions (silica fume, fly ash and slag) as binary and ternary binders in 80 high strength concrete mixtures, a large database was formed in this study.
Section snippets
Materials and experimental program
Portland cement used in this study was PC 42.5 (similar to ASTM type I) produced in ÇimSa Cement Factory, Mersin. Silica-fume was from Antalya Ferrosilicon Plant. Two types of fly ashes were used: Soma FA (Class C according to ASTM C 618) and Seyitömer FA (Class F according to ASTM C 618). Ground granulated blast furnace slag (S) was obtained from İskenderun Iron and Steel Works Co. The properties of these binders are given in Table 1.
2-, 7- and 28-day compressive strength values for the
PC + SF binary system
As stated in the experimental program, in this part of the study, PC was incorporated with SF at three replacement levels: 5%, 10% and 15% by mass. These mixtures were compared with the concretes without SF. The compressive strength values obtained for the binder contents of 500, 550, 600, 650 and 700 kg/m3 are summarized in Table 3. The highest values for a certain age and binder content were underlined.
As seen from Table 3, for a given binder content, w/b of concretes with or without SF are
Conclusions
The following conclusions can be drawn from the previous discussions:
- (1)
Water demand of concretes containing PC + SF was similar to that of the concretes with only PC.
- (2)
Incorporation of SF in binary mixtures improved the compressive strengths at all ages.
- (3)
FA/C and S did not increase the water requirement in ternary systems to attain a constant workability. However, water demands of PC + SF + FA/F blends were higher than those of PC + SF binary blends.
- (4)
Ternary blends almost always made it possible to obtain
References (21)
- et al.
Effect of different supplementary cementitious materials on mechanical properties of high performance concrete
Cem Concr Res
(1995) - et al.
The reaction of fly ash in concrete: a critical examination
Cem Concr Res
(1989) - et al.
Properties of portland cement concrete containing fly ash and condensed silica fume
Cem Concr Res
(1982) - et al.
Use of ternary cementitious systems containing silica fume and fly ash in concrete
Cem Concr Res
(1999) - et al.
Preventive measures for alkali-silica reactions (binary and ternary systems)
Cem Concr Res
(1999) High strength concrete containing natural pozzolan and silica fume
Cem Concr Comp
(2000)- et al.
Strengthening effects of finely ground fly ash, granulated blast furnace slag, and their combination
Cem Concr Res
(1998) - et al.
Properties of concrete incorporating fly ash and ground granulated blast-furnace slag
Cem Concr Comp
(2003) - et al.
Effect of slag and silica fume on mechanical properties of high strength concrete
Cem Concr Res
(1997) - et al.
Concrete containing ternary blended binders: resistance to chloride ingress and carbonation
Cem Concr Res
(1997)
Cited by (119)
Effect of processed sugarcane bagasse ash on compressive strength of blended mortar and assessments using statistical modelling
2023, Case Studies in Construction MaterialsPerformance characteristics of cementitious composites modified with silica fume: A systematic review
2023, Case Studies in Construction MaterialsInvestigations on high performance self-compacting concretes through ternary blends
2022, Materials Today: ProceedingsThe effect of content and fineness of natural pozzolana on the rheological, mechanical, and durability properties of self-compacting mortar
2021, Journal of Building Engineering