Complexity through combination: an account of knitwear design
Section snippets
Why knitwear design?
Knitwear is an example of ‘practical design’ in a fast-moving and highly competitive manufacturing industry that makes both technical and aesthetic demands of the designer. It is a constrained, tractable design domain, typically involving individual designers designing independent, low-resolution, static artefacts. The fast design turn-around (driven by an annual cycle of fashion ‘seasons’) provides opportunities to observe the design cycle in a limited period. Because of the technical and
Methodology for phase 1
In the first phase, knitwear designers at work in industry on real product lines were interviewed and observed, with particular attention to designers' source-gathering activities. This encompassed 18 companies involved in knitwear design in the UK, Italy, and Germany, plus one hand-knitting designer.
Observations — shadowing staff designers as they were available — were conducted over a number of days in three companies. In two of these three cases, it was possible both to follow particular
Methodology for phase 2
The second phase focused on designers performing realistic but constrained design tasks with supplied resources. It aimed to gather evidence on the use of sketching, on decision sequences, on spatial manipulation and reasoning, and on mental imagery. The tasks were constrained in a way that removed some design considerations (like shape design) while preserving realistic complexity of others (like motif design) — hence facilitating our identification of abstraction and transformation
Methodology for phase 3
Based on the results of the first two phases, we proposed a simple computational model divided into four steps: selection of ‘interesting’ graphical objects; adaptation of those objects; placing of the resulting objects onto the garment shape; and evaluation of the resulting garment. All phases are regarded as iterative, whether singly or in combination. In human performance, these steps appear to be bundled up in continuous multiple cycles of selection, adaptation and transformation, placement
Summary discussion
Our findings suggest that the source-to-design transformation process uses a repertoire of relatively few, simple mechanisms for selecting and adapting design elements from inspirational sources. Our simple cognitive accounts are based on a view of designs as elements in combination and configuration. Simple mechanisms may be employed in sequences or combinations. Complexity in the overall design arises from combination and configuration, so that simple design elements may stand in a complex
Acknowledgements
The project was funded by ESRC Award L127251030 under the title ‘MIND: Mechanisms of Inspiration in Novel Design’. The research reported here relied on other contributors, whom the authors thank: Most of the data collection was done by the MIND project's Research Fellow, Dr. Claudia Eckert. Dr. Martin Stacey and Prof. Nigel Cross also contributed to the project. Dr. Anne Anderson, the co-ordinator of the Cognitive Engineering Initiative, provided support throughout. The research would of course
References (36)
- et al.
Frames of reference in architectural design: analysing the hyperacclamation (A-h-a!)
Design Studies
(1996) - et al.
Sources of inspiration: a language of design
Design Studies
(2000) - et al.
Close encounters of the architectural kind
Design Studies
(2003) - et al.
Powers of observation in creative design
Design Studies
(1996) Schemata, gambits and precedent: some factors in design expertise
Design Studies
(2004)Prior knowledge in design: a dynamic knowledge-based model of design and creativity
Design Studies
(1990)- et al.
Kinds of seeing and their functions in designing
Design Studies
(1992) - et al.
The cognitive bias of emergence: implications for design support
Design Studies
(1996) Thinking styles and modelling systems
Design Studies
(1986)- Akin, Ö (1978) How do architects design? in J-C Latombe (ed) Proceedings of the IFIP Working Conference on Artificial...
Visual discovery in mind and on paper
Memory and Cognition
Putting ethnography to work: the case for a cognitive ethnography of design
International Journal of Human-Computer Studies
The relevance of visual imagery to thinking
British Journal of Psychology
Remembering: an experimental and social study
Study of ideologies and methods in contemporary architectural design teaching. Part 1: ideology
Design Studies
Information and information seeking of novice versus expert lawyers: how experts add value
The New Review of Information Behaviour Research
Engineering design methods
Descriptive models of creative design: application to an example
Design Studies
Cited by (36)
Exploratory and exploitative capability paths for innovation: A contingency framework for harnessing fuzziness in the front end
2022, TechnovationCitation Excerpt :High complexity requires extensive testing to evaluate the interplay between components that create additional costs (Alam, 2006). Challenges involve project size (Kim and Wilemon, 2003), which is influenced by the number of technologies (Tatikonda and Rosenthal, 2000), possible components and their independence (Petre et al., 2006), and relations and functions designed for new markets (Chang et al., 2007). Uncertainty and complexity may have more of an objective core (e.g., an objectively identifiable information deficit) (Frishammar et al., 2019).
Development of a mobile app for generating creative ideas based on exploring designers' on-line resource searching and retrieval behavior
2016, Design StudiesCitation Excerpt :The results showed that paper-based sketching was more effective for producing design solutions and supporting synthesis strategies compared with computer-based sketching. Petre, Sharp, and Johnson (2006) observed the process of knitwear design and used various inspiration sources to investigate the characteristics of visual inspiration use. They identified three strategies used by designers during the design process: selection, adaptation, and transformation.
Randomness and control in design processes: An empirical study with architecture students
2014, Design StudiesCitation Excerpt :In Figure 1, we can see some steps of the design process, from a random start to an elaborated solution. In other research (Petre et al., 2006) on the exploration of ideas in knitwear design, evidence was gathered on how designers perform their task and then a computational model was implemented that placed motifs and objects partially at random. The program was able to produce interesting designs similar to those generated by human designers.
An application of generative AI for knitted textile design in fashion
2024, Design JournalMaterial-led creative processes in the context of design education
2023, Art, Design and Communication in Higher EducationYou Should Try These Together: Combinatory Recommendations Signal Expertise and Improve Product Attitudes
2023, Journal of Marketing Research