A new approach to quantification of metamorphism using ultra-small and small angle neutron scattering
Introduction
The microstructure of pore space in sedimentary rocks and its evolution during reaction with pore- or fracture-contained fluids is a critically important factor controlling fluid flow properties in geological formations, including the migration and retention of water, gas and hydrocarbons, and the evolution of both contact and regional metamorphic terranes. The size, distribution and connectivity of these confined geometries (pores, fractures, grain boundaries), collectively dictate how fluids of various chemistry migrate into and through these micro- and nano-environments, wet, and ultimately react with the solid surfaces. In order to interpret the time-temperature-pressure history of any geological system, the physical and chemical “fingerprints” of this evolution preserved in the rock must be fully explored over widely different length scales from the nanoscale to the macroscale.
In the case of a sedimentary rock exposed to fluids at extreme temperatures and pressures at the contact with an intrusive magma a fundamental question is how much energy, either in the form of heat or stress, is available to do work, and how is this energy expended. In a contact aureole a significant portion of the energy budget must be expended outside the range of the inner aureole where classic metamorphic reactions occur. Some of this heat will simply be lost, but some will be expended in recrystallization and grain growth in far-field rocks, yielding more or less recognizable marbles or other metamorphic textures but possibly few, if any, of the classic metamorphic mineral assemblages. Because there are few metamorphic assemblages to study, little attention has been paid to these “far field” rocks even though simple observations commonly show that what was initially a limestone is clearly now a marble, and thus has been significantly affected by the metamorphic event.
Mineral growth due to recrystallization can be particularly diagnostic of thermal evolution. It is reasonable to assume that the earliest stages of metamorphism involve lowering the surface free energies of individual mineral grains by growth and/or surface smoothing. Standard techniques for looking at such phenomena, however, such as transmission electron microscopy, suffer from several drawbacks. First, they are, by nature, micro-analytical techniques, and thus may not describe the rock as a whole. Second, the images obtained are difficult to quantify in the same way the thermodynamics of a system is quantified.
In addition, analysis of two of the most critical properties of a contact metamorphic system, permeability and porosity, has proven especially elusive. A summary of this problem was presented by Baumgartner et al. (1997) who noted that “quantitative models of metamorphic fluid flow have largely overlooked the importance of permeability…”. They showed that studies of sedimentary basins and soils have documented both horizontal and vertical permeability variations and variations over spatial scales of many orders of magnitude, and noted that no in-situ permeability measurements were available for high-grade contact metamorphic rocks. Gerdes et al., 1995, Gerdes et al., 1998 showed that stochastic local permeability variations can have very large effects on flow patterns and temperatures in hydrothermal systems. Several authors have noted that large-scale flow in real systems may, in fact, be dominated by flow in multiscale fractures (e.g. Titley, 1990, Ingebritsen and Sanford, 1998), and may be temporally episodic, and enhanced by the effects of excess mixing volumes in H2O–CO2 fluids (Labotka et al., 2002).
Porosity should be easier to quantify than permeability, and linked to it. Norton and Knapp (1977) describe several types of pores (residual, diffusion, flow), and noted the effects of pore shape as well. They also measured the porosities of a number of different rock samples. Baumgartner et al. (1997), however, showed that paleo-pore structures are often poorly preserved. While they were able to study relict porosity in several environments, these were essentially special cases. In addition, very small pores, which may be quite abundant along grain boundaries, and can play important roles in controlling overall flow patterns, may be hard to observe petrographically, and even harder to quantify in a statistically meaningful manner. Even the porosity of the unmetamorphosed country rocks that form the boundary conditions in time and space for the metamorphic event may be poorly known, as are the “final” conditions of rocks in the aureole. Thus, a technique that could directly quantify rock porosity in a statistically meaningful manner, at least at the hand-sample scale, would be extremely useful.
Elastic scattering techniques provide a potential solution to this dilemma. Neutron scattering in particular is highly penetrating, and looks at thin-section scale samples while providing data on changes in grain surface and grain/pore distribution properties on length scales ranging from approximately 10 Å (depending on the incoherent background scattering level) to ∼3 μm. While the concept of using neutron or other scattering techniques (e.g. light, X-ray) to look at rocks is not new, work to date on scattering has been somewhat limited, although a number of materials have been studied (cf. Schmidt, 1989, Radlinski, 2006). These include coals and hydrocarbon source rocks (Bale and Schmidt, 1984, Reich et al., 1990, Radlinski and Radlinska, 1999, Sastry et al., 2000, Sen et al., 2001, McMahon et al., 2002, Prinz et al., 2004, Radlinski et al., 1996, Radlinski et al., 1999, Radlinski et al., 2000a, Radlinski et al., 2000b, Radlinski et al., 2000c, Radlinski et al., 2004, Connolly et al., 2006), sandstones, shales, and carbonates (Wong et al., 1986, Triolo et al., 2000, Triolo et al., 2006, Sen et al., 2002), clays (Knudsen et al., 2004), and even igneous rocks (Lucido et al., 1985, Lucido et al., 1988, Lucido et al., 1991, Floriano et al., 1994, Kahle et al., 2004, Kahle et al., 2006).
A wealth of structural information can be derived from scattering data. Radlinski et al. (1999) point out that rocks studied in this manner display the most extensive fractal systems observed in nature, with scaling over at least three orders of magnitude and sometimes higher (Bale and Schmidt, 1984 report 7.5 orders on coal). Both surface and mass fractal behavior have been observed, which describe the nature of the grain/pore boundary and the statistical distribution of pores within the sample, respectively. The characteristic lengths associated with these fractal systems describe the average maximum pore size and grain size of the rock. Scattering data also provide information on the pore volume and surface area/volume ratios, and therefore on changes in surface Gibbs Free energy and entropy during the metamorphic process. While it may be true, as noted by Baumgartner et al. (1997), that porosity in many high-grade parts of the aureole no longer reflects that during metamorphism due to pore filling and collapse, insight into their evolution may nonetheless be obtained by analysis of lateral spatial variations – from high-grade to unmetamorphosed – around the aureole. In addition, the extent and importance of stochastic variation within the initial country rock may be assessed. Thus these scattering properties provide an avenue for quantification of metamorphism, and can do so at low-grades, or for rock compositions where the utility of traditional metamorphic techniques is limited.
The purpose of this study is to use neutron scattering to quantitatively investigate changes in a marble during contact metamorphism, including changes in porosity, pore distributions (characterized by mass fractal dimensions), and grain surface roughness (characterized by surface fractal dimensions and derived surface to volume ratios and surface Gibbs Free Energy), and to show how scattering techniques provide a powerful new tool for analysis of metamorphism, as well as recrystallization phenomena in ceramics, metals and other materials. It will clearly be of interest to link these measurable quantities to the thermodynamics of the metamorphic process, as well as the rheology of the rocks involved (cf. Tanaka, 1992, Tanaka, 1993, Streitenberger et al., 1996) and to couple these to experimental investigations. These topics will be addressed in future work.
Section snippets
Geological setting and sample collection
Samples for this project were obtained from the Hueco limestone in the sanidinite-facies contact aureole at Marble Canyon, Texas. Marble Canyon is a box canyon on the eastern rim of the Sierra Diablo plateau, Culberson County, west Texas. It is located north of the town of Van Horn at approximately latitude 31°26′04″N, longitude 104°53′41″W, and is reached from State Highway 54. The regional and local geology around Marble Canyon (Fig. 1) have been described by Bridge, 1980, Bridge, 1986,
Application of small angle neutron scattering techniques
Small angle neutron scattering (SANS) is a nondestructive technique used to investigate structures in the size range of 10–1000 Å. Because neutrons are very penetrating this technique can probe the interior of the material of interest and provide bulk statistical information for samples up to approximately 25 mm diameter. For a statistically isotropic medium, the angular distribution of the scattering intensity, I(Q), is a function of the magnitude of the scattering vector, Q = (4π/λ)sin(θ/2),
XRD
A summary of the results of the XRD analysis is given in Table 1. The samples from transect H1 fall into three groups. The first consists of calcite and brucite, with brucite weight fractions from 0.26 to 0.27. These compositions are somewhat more calcite-rich than expected from simple breakdown of end-member dolomite to end-member calcite plus brucite (after periclase), but this is consistent either with the presence of some primary calcite or with formation of a magnesium-rich calcite during
Discussion and conclusions
The data presented above clearly demonstrate that a number of features of the pore structure of these rocks, both initially and related to the extent and nature of the contact metamorphism, can be effectively quantified by neutron scattering. In this section we discuss what the observed variations mean, and demonstrate how the interpretation aids our understanding of metamorphism at Marble Canyon.
Concluding remarks and future directions
We believe that this paper clearly demonstrates the potential for qualitative and quantitative analyses of metamorphism using scattering techniques. Profound changes in the pore structure and thermodynamics of a limestone/marble during metamorphism were discovered. While the pore-structure data obtained are, for the moment, limited to meso- and micro-sized porosity, pores in this size range may play an extremely important role in aureole hydrodynamics. As noted by Muller and McCauley (1992),
Acknowledgments
Research sponsored by the Division of Chemical Sciences, Geosciences and Biosciences, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, US Department of Energy under contract DE-AC05-00OR22725, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, managed and operated by UT-Battelle, LLC. We acknowledge the support of the NIST Center for Neutron Research, US Department of Commerce, in providing the research neutron facilities used in this work. G.W. Lynn was supported by the Center for Structural Molecular Biology (KP1102010) of the
References (95)
- et al.
Alternative calibration of the methylphenanthrene index against vitrinite reflectance – application to maturity measurements on oils and sediments
Org. Geochem.
(1988) - et al.
Application of the SAXS method and viscometry for determination of the thickness of adsorbed polymer layers at the ZrO2–polymer solution interface
J. Colloid Interface Sci.
(2003) - et al.
Comparison of the structure on the nanoscale of natural oil-bearing and synthetic rock
J. Petrol. Sci. Eng.
(2006) - et al.
Multifractal analysis of the pore- and solid-phases in binary two-dimensional images of natural porous structures
Geoderma
(2006) - et al.
Relationship between optical transparency and nanostructural features of silic aerogels
J. Non-Cryst. Solids
(1995) The role of fuzzy interfaces in the nucleation, growth and agglomeration of aluminum hydroxide in concentrated caustic solutions
Prog. Cryst. Growth Charact. Mater.
(2001)- et al.
Sedimentology and carbon sulfur geochemistry of the velkerri formation, a midproterozoic potential oil source in northern Australia
Precambrian Res.
(1991) - et al.
Small-angle neutron scattering from a nano-layered synthetic silicate
Physica B
(2004) - et al.
The pore structure in processed Victorian brown coal
J. Colloid Interface Sci.
(2002) Characterization of pore space in chalk by multifractal analysis
J. Hydrol.
(1996)
Small angle X-ray scattering study of coated porous materials
Colloids Surf. A: Physicochem. Eng. Asp.
Development of the meso- and macroporous structure of coals with rank as analysed with small angle neutron scattering and adsorption experiments
Fuel
Small angle neutron scattering signature of oil generation in artificially and naturally matured hydrocarbon source rocks
Org. Geochem.
Angstrom-to-millimeter characterization of sedimentary rock microstructure
J. Colloid Interface Sci.
The application of SAXS to determine the fractal properties of porous carbon-based materials
J. Colloid Interface Sci.
Structural variations in lignite coal: a small angle X-ray scattering investigation
Solid State Comm.
Temperature induced smoothing of initially fractal grain boundaries
Scripta Mater.
Petroleum geology and geochemistry of the middle proterozoic McArthur basin, northern Australia. 3. Composition of extractable hydrocarbons
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta
The representative elementary area (REA) in studies of quantitative soil micromorphology
Geoderma
Time-resolved phenomena in cements, clays and porous rocks
J. Appl. Crystallogr.
High-temperature metamorphism around the Marble Canyon intrusion, west Texas
Geol. Soc. Amer. Abst.
Constraints on fluids and mass transfer during high-temperature contact metamorphism: Marble Canyon west Texas
Geol. Soc. Amer. Abst.
Small-angle X-ray-scattering investigation of submicroscopic porosity with fractal properties
Phys. Rev. Lett.
Design and performance of a thermal-neutron double-crystal diffractometer for USANS at NIST
J. Appl. Crystallogr.
Porosity and permeability of carbonate rocks during contact metamorphism
Small-angle X-ray scattering studies on oxide layer thickness at the porous silicon interface
J. Appl. Crystallogr.
Bredigite, larnite, and dicalcium silicates from Marble Canyon
Amer. Mineral.
Focusing cold neutrons with multiple biconcave lenses for small-angle neutron scattering
J. Appl. Crystallogr.
Nucleation, growth, fractal aggregation, and late-stage coarsening on structural development of polymer physical gels
Macromolecules
Petroleum geology and geochemistry of middle proterozoic mcarthur basin, northern Australia. 2. Assessment of source rock potential
AAPG Bull.
Petrological and maturation characteristics of organic-matter from the middle proterozoic McArthur basin, Australia
Aust. J. Earth Sci.
Scattering by an inhomogeneous solid. II. The correlation function and its application
J. Appl. Phys.
The structure of pumice by neutron diffraction
J. Appl. Crystallogr.
Stochastic permeability models of fluid flow during contact metamorphism
Geology
Convective fluid flow through heterogeneous country rocks during contact metamorphism
J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth
Small Angle X-ray Scattering
The 30 m small-angle neutron scattering instruments at the National Institute of Standards and Technology
J. Appl. Crystallogr.
Epigenetic dolomitization and the origin of xenotopic dolomite texture
J. Sed. Petrol.
Road log from Van Horn to Marble Canyon and back
Groundwater in Geologic Processes
Small-angle neutron scattering investigation of the effect of a heat-treatment on the microstructure of porous basalt rocks
Miner. Mag.
Small-angle neutron scattering study of volcanic rocks
Eur. J. Miner.
Modified Porod’s law estimate of the transition-layer thickness between two phases: test of triangular smoothing function
J. Appl. Crystallogr.
Cited by (78)
Application of small angle scattering (SAS) in structural characterisation of casein and casein-based products during digestion
2023, Food Research InternationalUniformity and volume-representativity of consecutive submillimetre wafers of shale for SANS and USANS investigations
2023, International Journal of Coal GeologyHow to avoid multiple scattering in strongly scattering SANS and USANS samples
2022, FuelCitation Excerpt :The power-law scattering intensity is a consequence of (sample-specific) fractal geometry of the pore space. Fractal characteristics have been reported for numerous sedimentary rocks [5,7,18–22,25,46,51–60]. Table 1 lists representative examples of I (Q = 2.0 × 10-5 Å−1) values measured for different rock types.
Nanomaterials physics: A critical review
2022, Photophysics and Nanophysics in Therapeutics