The critical success factors of business process management
Introduction
For 40 years the issue of fit between an organization and its strategy, structure, processes, technology and environment has been a basis for theory construction and research (Kanellis, Lycett, & Paul, 1999). The changing economic environment has led to an increasing interest in improving organizational business processes to enhance performance (McCormack et al., in press, Ranganathan and Dhaliwal, 2001). One of the fields dealing with these challenges is business process management (BPM) and there has been a surge of papers and practitioners interest in this area for more than a decade (Rhee et al., in press, Vergidis et al., 2008).
BPM is defined for the purpose of the paper as all efforts in an organization to analyze and continually improve fundamental activities such as manufacturing, marketing, communications and other major elements of company's operations (adapted from Zairi, 1997). A business process is a complete, dynamically coordinated set of activities or logically related tasks that must be performed to deliver value to customers or to fulfill other strategic goals (Guha and Kettinger, 1993, Strnadl, 2006).
Although various empirical researches indicate that there is a positive correlation between process management and business success (McCormack and Johnson, 2001, McCormack et al., in press, Skerlavaj et al., 2007) no comprehensive and substantial benefits that can justify the hype around the concept have been identified (Vergidis et al., 2008). Since the practical experience showed a large number of failed projects and programs, several papers tried to identify critical success factors (‘CSF’) of BPM (e.g. Ariyachandra and Frolick, 2008, Bandara et al., 2005). However, most of those papers failed to put their research within a theoretical framework. Therefore BPM still remains largely atheoretical (Karim et al., 2007, Melão and Pidd, 2000).
As a consequence, the field of research is currently disorganized, without a possibility to classify and/or compare such studies. BPM has mostly remained in the fad phase and papers still mainly describe what BPM actually means; what it constitutes; how it should be used etc. Management consultants and academics write similar papers on those topics (Dale, Elkjaer, van der Wiele, & Williams, 2001). Some even claim that BPM was just a repackaging of old ideas to fit a new context, and that this was ultimately used to drive growth in the consulting industry (Newell et al., 2000, Terziovski et al., 2003).
Therefore the main contribution of this paper is to provide a theoretical basis for the field. A novel combination of three underlying theories, namely contingency, dynamic capabilities and task–technology theory is proposed. It establishes a basis for the explanation of (un)successfulness of BPM efforts. This basis can then be used to study CSFs in general and can be applied to analyze CSFs in each particular example.
The structure of the paper is as follows: First, the need to further examine the CSFs for BPM is established. Then the approach is theoretically grounded and explained with the combination of three underlying theories. A case study of the bank that uses a theoretical framework to identify CSFs in their BPM efforts is presented. Finally, main implications and further research possibilities are discussed.
Section snippets
The need of CSFs for BPM and IT use
Since several different terms (e.g. business process reengineering, business process change etc.) are often used to describe similar concepts, the papers using different “buzzwords” are summarized together as long as their definition matches the one used in this paper. The term BPM is used consistently to describe the previously defined concept.
While there has been much research on process modeling techniques and corresponding tools, there has been little empirical research into the success
Theoretical background
Interestingly though, none of the studied papers tried to either develop a new theory or to base their thinking into the existing ones. This may derive from the inherent complexity of the field, since BPM challenges span from organizational, managerial, information systems and even social problems. However, the consequence is that the field of research is still in its infancy (Hung, 2006) and theoretical explanation and consequently analysis and categorization of both research and practitioners
Justification of the case study
A case study has been used as a research method to underline the theoretical findings set out in the previous sections, i.e. to show how the combination of three underlying theories can be used to identify CSFs and to improve the likelihood of a successful outcome of BPM efforts. The purpose of the case study is not to prepare a definitive list of CSFs but to show the connection of three underlying theories in the identification of case-specific CSFs. Nevertheless, the proposed CSFs are
Discussion and conclusion
Several interesting findings and considerations for the information systems field arise from the proposed theoretical framework and the case study. First, the paper has proposed a unique combination of three theories to respond to the question of the nature of competitive advantage and the role of BPM in it. Both the literature review and the presented case-study support the premise that a similar combination is needed to explain the complex interactions of various aspects, such as business
Acknowledgment
The research in this paper was partly funded by the Slovenian Research Agency (project no. J5-2105). The author would like to thank Dr. Andrej Kovacic and Rok Skrinjar for their help in conducting the case study.
Peter Trkman is an assistant professor at the Faculty of Economics of the University of Ljubljana in Slovenia. His research interests encompass e-government, telecommunications, technology adoption and various aspects of supply chain, business process and operations management. He has participated in various research and consulting projects and published over 60 papers/book chapters, including papers in Computers & Operations Research, European Journal of Operational Research, Government
References (115)
Exploring the relationship between information technology and business process reengineering
Information & Management
(2004)The importance of business process modeling in software systems design
Science of Computer Programming
(2008)Does IT investment improve bank performance? Evidence from Europe
Journal of Banking & Finance
(2007)- et al.
Understanding behavioral sources of process variation following enterprise system deployment
Journal of Operations Management
(2008) - et al.
B-SCP: A requirements analysis framework for validating strategic alignment of organizational IT based on strategy, context, and process
Information and Software Technology
(2006) - et al.
Understanding the business–IT relationship
International Journal of Information Management
(2005) - et al.
Fad, fashion and fit: An examination of quality circles, business process re-engineering and statistical process control
International Journal of Production Economics
(2001) - et al.
Competition, contestability and market structure in European banking sectors on the eve of EMU
Journal of Banking and Finance
(2000) Organizational competence for harnessing IT: A case study
Information & Management
(2008)- et al.
Extending the technology acceptance model with task–technology fit constructs
Information & Management
(1999)
Strategy, IT applications for planning and control, and firm performance: The impact of impediments to IT implementation
Information & Management
An integrated approach to process and service management
International Journal of Information Management
Determining key capabilities of a firm using analytic hierarchy process
International Journal of Production Economics
A contingency model of the association between strategy, environmental uncertainty and performance measurement: Impact on organizational performance
International Business Review
Theory and research in strategic management: Swings of a pendulum
Journal of Management
Getting the most out of reverse e-auction investment
Omega
Towards E-government by business process change—A methodology for public sector
International Journal of Information Management
Assessment of process improvement from organizational change
Information & Management
The enigma of evaluation: Benefits, costs and risks of IT in Australian small-medium-sized enterprises
Information & Management
Critical success factors of inter-organizational information systems—A case study of Cisco and Xiao Tong in China
Information & Management
Modelling business processes with workflow systems: An evaluation of alternative approaches
International Journal of Information Management
Role of competences in creating customer value: A value-creation logic approach
Industrial Marketing Management
Implications of the fit between organizational structure and ERP: A structural contingency theory perspective
International Journal of Information Management
Examining the critical success factors in the adoption of enterprise resource planning
Computers in Industry
Customer relationship management (CRM) in financial services
European Management Journal
A survey of business process reengineering practices in Singapore
Information & Management
Best practices in business process redesign: An overview and qualitative evaluation of successful redesign heuristics
Omega
The effectiveness of workflow management systems: Predictions and lessons learned
International Journal of Information Management
Methodologies for information systems investment evaluation at the proposal stage: A comparative review
Information and Software Technology
Aligning operations, marketing, and competitive strategies to enhance performance: An empirical test in the retail banking industry
Omega
Information technology as a facilitator for enhancing dynamic capabilities through knowledge management
Information & Management
Task-based modeling method for construction business process modeling and automation
Automation in Construction
Does information technology provide banks with profit?
Information & Management
Challenging the paradigm of the process enterprise: A case-study analysis of BPR implementation
Omega
Organizational learning culture—The missing link between business process change and organizational performance
International Journal of Production Economics
Contingency research in operations management practices
Journal of Operations Management
Assessing readiness for business process reengineering
Business Process Management Journal
Cultures for continuous improvement and learning
Total Quality Management
Quality management and the process of change
Journal of Organizational Change Management
Critical success factors in business performance management—Striving for success
Information Systems Management
Factors and measures of business process modelling: Model building through a multiple case study
European Journal of Information Systems
Major issues in business process management: An expert perspective
BPTrends
From branches to call centres: New strategic realities in retail banking
The Service Industries Journal
Exploitation, exploration, and process management: The productivity dilemma revisited
The Academy of Management Review
The productivity paradox of information technology: Review and assessment
Communications of the ACM
Let chaos reign, then rein in chaos-repeatedly: Managing strategic dynamics for corporate longevity
Strategic Management Journal
IT doesn’t matter
Harvard Business Review
Information technology and productivity changes in the banking industry
Economic Notes
Information technology and supply chain collaboration: Moderating effects of existing relationships between partners
IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management
Systems design, process performance, and economic outcomes in international banking
Journal of Management Information Systems
Cited by (630)
Shift of ambidexterity modes: An empirical investigation of the impact of artificial intelligence in customer service
2024, International Journal of Information ManagementExploiting network science in business process management: A conceptual framework
2024, Chaos, Solitons and FractalsCritical success factors in the FinTech World: A stage model
2023, Electronic Commerce Research and ApplicationsBlockchain as a driving force for federalism: A theory of cross-organizational task-technology fit
2023, International Journal of Information ManagementIdentifying characterizations of BPM methodology in hotel industry: evidence from listed hotel companies in Egypt
2024, Business Process Management Journal
Peter Trkman is an assistant professor at the Faculty of Economics of the University of Ljubljana in Slovenia. His research interests encompass e-government, telecommunications, technology adoption and various aspects of supply chain, business process and operations management. He has participated in various research and consulting projects and published over 60 papers/book chapters, including papers in Computers & Operations Research, European Journal of Operational Research, Government Information Quarterly, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, International Journal of Production Economics, International Journal of Production Research, Journal of Computer Information Systems, Online Information Review, Technology Forecasting & Social Change and Telecommunications Policy.