Conserving indigenous knowledge as the key to the current and future use of traditional vegetables

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2011.02.009Get rights and content

Abstract

Indigenous knowledge erodes rapidly. When the loss of this knowledge negatively affects the lives and health of traditionally living rural communities, a drive to conserve indigenous knowledge becomes vital. This article argues that the transfer of indigenous knowledge on traditional vegetables will ensure the availability and utilisation of this important food source for resource-poor rural communities. Data collected on the present use of traditional vegetables at a rural Xhosa village in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa documented indigenous practices of traditional vegetable use and measured attitudes and perceptions of young women. Findings revealed that although traditional vegetables are readily available, there is a decline in the use of traditional vegetables in this village. Since the loss of associated indigenous knowledge is a reality, and in view of the negative attitude towards traditional vegetables, future use of this valuable food source is threatened. The transfer of the associated indigenous knowledge holds the key to the potential future use of traditional vegetables. Altered perceptions of traditional vegetables are crucial for the conservation of the associated indigenous knowledge. As a result awareness campaigns to promote the use of traditional vegetables, related nutritional education, including proper cooking and preservation techniques are necessary.

Highlights

Indigenous knowledge key to utilisation of traditional vegetables as food source. ► Indigenous practices of traditional vegetable use documented, future use measured. ► Traditional vegetable use declining; preservation techniques disconcerting. ► Perceptions and attitudes threaten potential future use of valuable food source. ► Transfer of indigenous knowledge key to future use through altered awareness.

Introduction

“It is recognised that a major threat to the sustainability of natural resources is the erosion of people's knowledge, and the basic reason for this erosion is the low value attached to it. The erosion of people's knowledge associated with natural resources is under greater threat than the erosion of natural resources themselves” (Odora Hoppers, 2002, p. 7).

Indigenous knowledge involves knowledge about survival that is possessed by local people in their communities and is passed on from generation to generation (Kaya & Masoga, 2005). This knowledge is found in both rural and urban communities and deals with issues concerning the survival of the community, the protection and use of the local environment, and food security. Indigenous knowledge is found in different areas such as agriculture, social welfare, peace building and conflict resolution, medicine and food technology (Odora Hoppers, 2004). Indigenous knowledge is mostly undocumented and therefore at risk of being lost to future generations (Kaya & Masoga, 2005). Like many other types of indigenous knowledge systems the knowledge about traditional vegetables is vanishing and this situation warrants immediate action to retain or regain it (Aphane, Chadha, & Oluoch, 2003, pp. 1–17). Traditional vegetables are gathered from both cultivated and uncultivated lands and the knowledge about traditional vegetables is passed on from generation to generation as part of the indigenous knowledge system of the community (Lwoga, Ngulube, & Stilwell, 2010). Traditional vegetables, which are edible plants that are used as vegetables, are part of traditional production systems and local knowledge. These plants have been used locally over a number of years, but did not necessarily originate in that particular area (Keller et al., 2004, Keller et al., 2005). Indigenous vegetables are those edible plants that are biologically indigenous to an area, while introduced vegetables are those vegetables that have been introduced into a particular area and have not physiologically adjusted to the local conditions and subsequently require many agricultural inputs. Indigenised vegetables have adapted (indigenised) to local conditions after their introduction, with the result that they are considered as local. Examples of indigenised vegetables are maize, pumpkins and sweet potatoes (Laker, 2007, p. 311; Nesamvuni, 2000, p. 14). In this study the term ‘traditional vegetables’ is used to refer to both indigenous and indigenised vegetables, while the term ‘introduced vegetables’ refers to exotic vegetables that have not adapted to local conditions and require high inputs to thrive.

It is reported that in South Africa alone more than 100 different species of plants are used as traditional vegetables. The importance of traditional vegetables lies in their high nutritional value and their ability to thrive under adverse conditions (Lephole, 2004, Modi et al., 2006, Nesamvuni, 2000, Van Vuuren, 2006, pp. 22–25). Traditional vegetables and traditionally grown crops grow well during drought periods and in areas with low or unreliable rainfall, which is the case in many parts of South Africa. Traditional vegetables can survive poor soils, require less inputs and resources during production and are often available at times when introduced vegetables such as spinach and cabbage are not. Traditional vegetables require less chemical fertilizers and pesticides since they have adapted well to local growing conditions (Lephole, 2004, Modi et al., 2006, Nesamvuni, 2000, Van Vuuren, 2006, pp. 22–25).

The consumption of traditional vegetables is decreasing – even in the rural areas of South Africa – in favour of introduced vegetables. The neglect by both policy makers and researchers has led to the scarcity of information on traditional vegetables (Aphane et al., 2003, Jansen van Rensburg et al., 2007a, pp. 317–324). Since documentation on traditional vegetables is scarce, elderly people remain the most valuable sources of information. The fear exists that if nothing is done to conserve valuable information on traditional vegetables this information may soon disappear from society, because the youth are generally reluctant to gain such knowledge (Vorster, Jansen van Rensburg, Van Zijl, & Venter, 2007b). The youth's resistance to accepting indigenous knowledge is embedded in the negative attitudes associated with practices that appear outdated and unpopular, contrasted against perceived acceptable knowledge systems that have historically rejected indigenous knowledge systems. Through the global move to rediscovering indigenous knowledge and the systems that govern it, the practical and cognitive heritage of people around the world are regained to provide new insights into human society (Hountondji, 1977, p. 35).

This article argues that the transfer of indigenous knowledge on traditional vegetables will ensure that the availability and utilisation of traditional vegetables will be maintained as an important food source for resource-poor rural communities. Furthermore, the transfer of the indigenous knowledge associated with traditional vegetables to the younger generation holds the key to the potential future use of traditional vegetables.

Section snippets

Research design and methods

The argument of this article is supported by research findings from a study conducted at eMantlaneni village, approximately 40 km from the town of Lusikisiki in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa. eMantlaneni village, a traditional Xhosa village, was selected as a study area because it is fairly isolated and it is known as an area where traditional vegetables have commonly been utilised frequently, a fact confirmed during the scoping visit. Lusikisiki is linked to the village with a

Loss of indigenous knowledge

Several research works have indicated that indigenous knowledge of traditional vegetables is diminishing in communities (Flyman and Afolayan, 2006, Jansen van Rensburg et al., 2007b, Keller et al., 2005, pp. 400–413; Lwoga et al., 2010, p. 13; Musinguzi, Kikafunda, & Kiremire, 2006, pp. 1–14). The loss of indigenous knowledge results in reduced consumption of traditional vegetables, which contributes to the lack of diet diversity. This ultimately translates into food insecurity and

Food behaviour and attitudes

The term ‘food behaviour’ is used to refer to people's habits in utilising food, and includes the collection, storage, preparation and consumption of food. Maslow's theory of needs explains that people eat for survival before progressing to eat for status and self-actualisation. People tend to address the needs that are at the bottom of the hierarchy before advancing to needs that are at the higher level of the hierarchy. The need to survive is the most fundamental need of all the needs and is

Traditional vegetable use

Humans’ use of traditional vegetables has been reported all around the world. For centuries traditional vegetables have constituted a substantial part of the African diet. The vegetables and their edible parts vary from one region to the other. In some areas people choose to eat leaves and in some they prefer the seeds, flowers or tubers, depending on the type of indigenous plant and the area or region. The edible parts are mostly cooked as stews, soups or relishes (Keith, 1992, pp. 17–20). In

Traditional vegetables at eMantlaneni

The demographic data reported for the village indicates that the majority of households in this village could benefit considerably from traditional vegetables as they provide households with a cheap alternative source of food. Most households in this village are regarded as very vulnerable to food insecurity because the households are very large (more than six people), their income is low and they are female-headed. According to the Department of Agriculture (2002, pp. 22–26), larger households

Young women's knowledge of and attitudes to the use of traditional vegetables

In this study elderly women were found to be more knowledgeable about the number of traditional vegetables that were available at eMantlaneni village when compared to young women who participated in the study. Older women identified 33 traditional vegetables while young women only identified five traditional vegetables. These findings on the younger generation's knowledge of traditional vegetables corroborate previously published literature as reported by Odhav, Beekrum, Akula, and Baijnath

Conclusion

Given the demographic characteristics of the majority of families in this study, such as lower incomes, large families and the fact that most of the households are female-headed, traditional vegetables could play a major role in achieving food security. They could provide families with alternative sources of nutrients that are cheaper and easily accessible.

There is evidence that shows that the consumption of traditional vegetables is declining in eMantlaneni. This suggests that there is a need

Tulisiwe Dweba is a junior lecturer in the Department of Agriculture, Animal Health and Human Ecology at the University of South Africa. She lectures undergraduate courses in food processing, food preservation and community nutrition. Her research interests include alleviation of food insecurity through food-based strategies.

References (37)

  • A.P. Den Hartog et al.

    Food habits and consumption in developing countries: Manual for field studies

    (2006)
  • Department of Agriculture

    Integrated food security strategy for South Africa

    (2002)
  • L. Fish

    Preparing herbarium specimens

    (1999)
  • P. Hountondji

    Endogenous knowledge: Research trails

    (1977)
  • W. Jansen van Rensburg et al.

    African leafy vegetables in South Africa

    Water SA

    (2007)
  • W. Jansen van Rensburg et al.

    Conservation of African leafy vegetables in South Africa

    African Journal of Food, Agriculture, Nutrition and Development

    (2007)
  • H.O. Kaya et al.

    Balanced literacy: Enhancing the school curriculum through African indigenous knowledge system.

    (2005)
  • M. Keith

    Edible wild plants

    Lantern

    (1992)
  • Cited by (85)

    • Importance of indigenous knowledge in achieving environmental sustainability

      2023, Role of Green Chemistry in Ecosystem Restoration to Achieve Environmental Sustainability
    View all citing articles on Scopus

    Tulisiwe Dweba is a junior lecturer in the Department of Agriculture, Animal Health and Human Ecology at the University of South Africa. She lectures undergraduate courses in food processing, food preservation and community nutrition. Her research interests include alleviation of food insecurity through food-based strategies.

    Dr. Martie Mearns is a senior lecturer in the Department of Information and Knowledge Management at the University of Johannesburg. She lectures both undergraduate and postgraduate courses in knowledge management, competitive intelligence and research methodology. Her research interests include the conservation of indigenous knowledge specifically through cultural tourism and the management of information and knowledge within a variety of industries.

    View full text