Modelling and analysis of micro scale milling considering size effect, micro cutter edge radius and minimum chip thickness
Introduction
Recent years, the production of miniaturized components with complex small features is gaining increasing importance due to the trend of miniaturization which is determining the development of products for various industries, such as biomedical instruments, electronic products, defence industry and so on. Most of these components fall into the scales from 10 μm to 1 mm known as micro/meso scale in mechanical engineering. Considered as one of the most effective techniques, micro scale milling process can be used to fabricate these components with complex micro features over a wide range of material types. However, further advances in both the efficiency and the quality are limited by the incomplete understanding of its basic mechanisms. To satisfy the increasing need of miniaturized manufacturing, the mechanisms studies are becoming more and more important.
Micro scale milling is not simply downsized from the conventional operation but has its own characteristics, such as size effect, cutter edge radius and minimum chip thickness. Shaw [1] studied the effect of round edges on the chip formation in micro scale machining and stated that the plastic deformations would be prevented when the cutter edge radius is relatively larger than the uncut chip thickness. Kim [2] investigated the effect of static tool deflection on the micro milling and proposed a static chip model based on the attainable micro scale machining force data. Ni [3] investigated the chip formation using molecule dynamic (MD) simulations and presented an approach to calculate the minimum chip thickness by identifying a local maximum in the radial thrust forces in the micro milling. Vogler [4] determined the minimum chip thickness for steel using finite element (FE) simulations with regard of the microstructure properties of work material. According to their research, the critical chip thickness is 0.2 and 0.3 times of the edge radius for pearlite and ferrite, respectively. In addition, several analytical cutting force models ([5], [22], [23], [26]) had been developed to investigate the micro scale machining process. Chae [6] surveyed the state of art of micro scale machining and reported that current researches had made valuable attempts in this field though most of them were carried out by means of nano-level and macro-level approaches. From the discussions above, it is obviously that the processing system for micro scale milling is far from established. Its characteristics need to be studied and the related mechanisms need to be revealed through experiments and theoretical modelling.
One of the most significant characteristics of the micro scale milling operation is the size effect. Some efforts have been carried out to explain it. Lucca [7] investigated the size effect of cutting energy of micro scale machining process through the experiments; they found nonlinear increase in specific cutting energy or cutting forces as the uncut chip thickness was decreased. Kopalinsky and Oxley [8] studied the size effect with sharp tools by turning tests. They concluded that the cause was the decrease in the tool chip interface temperature. Nakayama and Tamura [9] analyzed the size effect through experiments performed at a very low cutting speed to minimize the temperature and strain rate effects. They attributed this effect to plastic flow in the workpiece subsurface. The experiments of the literature (Oxley, [8]; Nakayama, [9]) implied that there should be other underlying mechanisms for the size effect besides cutter edge radius, temperatures and strain rate. On the other hand, a similar size effect in micro indentation tests was found in the mechanics studies, which was shown as remarkable material strengthening behaviours at the micron level.
Fleck [10] found that the torsion strengthened three times when the diameter of the sample was decreased from 170 to 12 μm. Stolken and Evans [11] found the similar trend in bending material tests. The bending strength increased significantly when the thickness of thin beam was decreased from 100 to 12.5 μm. This size effect in material properties has turned to be the focus of mechanics research recent years. Strain gradient (SG) plasticity is the most effective method to interpret this phenomenon. Fleck [12] developed SG theory by introducing the material inner variable. Then, Nix and Gao [13] improved it by describing the concept of inner variable and mechanism-based strain gradient (MSG) theory was developed. From this point, it is supposed that there might be some similarities between the two size effect phenomena. The size effect of material behaviours may be the cause of size effect in micro scale machining. Melkote [14] attempted to analyze the size effect using SG plasticity based on analytical solutions. The results showed that it is capable of explaining the size effect. However, this model could not consider many other characteristics of micro scale machining process, such as large strain, high strain rate, cutter edge radius, minimum chip thickness and so on. Therefore, further studies are needed and more precise FE models should be developed.
The goal of this research is to provide deeper understanding of micro scale milling process. Firstly, a modified Johnson–Cook (JC) constitutive equation is formulated using SG plasticity. A FE model for micro scale orthogonal machining process is developed considering material strengthening behaviours, tool geometry and fracture behaviour. Then, a milling force model is developed based on the FE simulations using the cutting principles and slip-line theory. Finally, chip formation and size effect of micro scale milling are investigated by applying the model, and the effects of the main characteristics of micro scale process, size effect of material behaviours, micro mill cutter radius and minimum chip thickness are discussed as well. The results demonstrate that the proposed approach for micro scale milling is capable of the analysis of micro scale milling process and provides the academic foundation for further process design and optimization studies.
Section snippets
Micro scale milling process modelling
Milling operation is a very complex process as shown in Fig. 1a. Its performance is affected by so many parameters that it is not possible to take all the factors into account at the same time. According to the analysis of micro scale milling process and its characteristics, two assumptions are made:
- (a)
The objective of the first assumption is to simplify the complicated 3D milling process (Fig. 1a) to a 2D process shown as Fig. 1b. It is reasonable because the depth of cut (DOC) of the micro scale
Experimental details
To perform the experiments needed for the research, a miniaturized machine tool is established, as shown in Fig. 8. The overall volume of the machine tool is 270×190×220 mm, and the working volume is 30×30×30 mm. Fig. 9 shows the components of the miniaturized machine tool system. It consists of five subsystems: the first is the positioning subsystem, consisting of 3 high precision stages with the resolution of 50 nm; the second is the NSK electronic spindle subsystem with maximal rotation speed
Model validation
To use the proposed model to predict the forces and analyze micro scale milling process, extensive experiments are needed to validate the model over a widely range of conditions. In this section, experiments and simulations were performed to examine DOC and ft in the applicable conditions range of the miniaturized machine tool and the micro cutters. Four sets of correlations were done when DOC was 6, 10, 15 and 20 μm, respectively. For each set, ft was selected to be 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1 and 1.4
Chip formation analysis of micro scale machining
In this section, chip formation of micro scale machining was investigated through the FE simulations. The goal is to find out hmin and its relationship with the micro cutter edge radius. The uncut chip thickness for micro scale orthogonal machining was selected to be 0.1 R (0.2 μm), 0.2 R (0.4 μm), 0.3 R (0.6 μm). As Fig. 11 shows, it can be observed that there is no chip formed when h is 0.1 and 0.2 R, while chip forms when the h is 0.3 R. From these results, hmin is proposed to be 0.25 R (0.5 μm) for
Conclusions
- 1.
By applying SG plasticity, a constitutive equation was formulated to model the material strengthening behaviours. This flow stress can describe not only the characteristics of micro scale machining, size effect and minimum chip thickness, but the features of the macro scale process, including large strains, high strain rates and temperatures.
- 2.
An analytical micro scale milling force model is developed based on FE simulations using cutting principles and slip line theory. The model is well
Acknowledgements
The support of National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant #50575134, National Basic Research Program of China under Grant no.2005CB724100 and the Programme of Introducing Talents of Discipline to Universities under Grant no. B06012 are gratefully acknowledged.
References (26)
Precision finishing
CIRP Annals
(1995)Slip-line modelling of machining with a rounded-edge tool—Part I: new model and theory
Journal of Mechanics and Physics of Solids
(2003)- et al.
Investigation of micro-cutting operations
International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture
(2006) - et al.
Energy dissipation in the ultraprecision machining of copper
CIRP Annals
(1991) - et al.
Strain gradient plasticity: theory and experiments
Acta Metallurgica et Materialia
(1994) - et al.
A microbend test method for measuring the plasticity length scale
Acta Materialia
(1998) - et al.
A phenomenological theory for strain gradient effects in plasticity
Journal of Mechanics and Physics Solids
(1993) - et al.
Mechanism-based strain gradient crystal plasticity—I. Theory
Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids
(2005) Fracture characteristics of three metals subjected to various strains, strain rates, temperatures and pressures
Engineering Fracture Mechanics
(1985)- et al.
Determination of work material flow stress and friction for FEA of machining using orthogonal cutting tests
Journal of Materials Processing Technology
(2004)
A three-dimensional analytical cutting force model for micro end milling operation
International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture
Modelling micro-end-milling operations. Part I: analytical cutting force model
International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture
An experimental investigation of micro machinability of copper 101 using tungsten carbide micro endmill
International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture
Cited by (367)
Evolution of brittle-ductile transition and size effect in the micro-milling repairing process of soft-brittle KDP crystal with surface defect
2024, Journal of Manufacturing ProcessesHigh performance machining simulation of curved edge broach with surface material constitutive model and tool-chip friction
2024, Journal of Manufacturing ProcessesOccurrence of catastrophic tool wear patterns through systematic thermomechanical modeling
2024, Journal of Manufacturing ProcessesOn unsteady-cutting state material separation and dead metal zone modeling considering chip fracture
2023, Journal of Manufacturing ProcessesMechanical behavior and modeling of grinding force: A comparative analysis
2023, Journal of Manufacturing Processes