A meta-analysis of the relationship between market orientation and business performance: evidence from five continents
Introduction
In today's highly competitive global markets, managers seek to improve organizational effectiveness by identifying organizational metrics linked to business performance. Market orientation is one such metric that has emerged as a significant predictor of performance and is presumed to contribute to long-term success (Deshpandé & Farley, 1999). Market orientation is heavily influenced by the marketing concept Drucker, 1954, McCarthy, 1960, McKitterick, 1957, and is the cornerstone of the marketing management and marketing strategy paradigms (Hunt, 2002). The Marketing Science Institute has recognized the importance of market orientation for many years, and today it remains a research priority. Over time, scholars have acknowledged that market orientation research has significantly influenced the development of marketing knowledge Biggadike, 1981, Day, 1999, Kohli & Jaworski, 1990.
Scholars agree that meta-analysis is an important tool for conducting marketing research across different countries (Deshpandé & Farley, 1999). Early studies of the relationship between market orientation and business performance are limited to research conducted in the United States and, to a lesser extent, the United Kingdom Bhuian, 1998, Deshpandé & Farley, 1999, Subramanian & Gopalakrishna, 2001. Empirical studies incorporating samples from multiple countries are sparse (e.g., Deshpandé et al., 1997, Hooley et al., 2000, Saini et al., 2002). Efforts aimed at studying the relationship between market orientation and business performance across countries have been hampered by methodological differences Mavondo, 1999a, Shoham & Rose, 2001. Moreover, international studies in marketing most often compare developed, rather than developing countries. Marketing scholars recognize this limitation and called for the extension of research to an international context Deshpandé et al., 1997, Homburg & Pflesser, 2000, Kohli et al., 1993. This meta-analysis serves to bridge this gap in the literature by investigating studies of the relationship between market orientation and business performance conducted worldwide.
The notion that market orientation has a positive impact on business performance is well documented in scholarly research (e.g., Baker & Sinkula, 1999, Harris, 2001, Matsuno & Mentzer, 2000). Although a few studies report a negative or non-significant relationship (e.g., Grewal & Tansuhaj, 2001, Han et al., 1998, Siguaw & Honeycutt, 1995), overwhelming evidence shows a positive relationship between market orientation and business performance (Table 1). This study seeks to go beyond the assessment of the existence and the direction of this relationship by investigating two important research questions: (1) What is the strength of the relationship between market orientation and business performance? (2) What is the impact of contextual and methodological moderators on this relationship? For this purpose, a meta-analysis, which is appropriate to integrate research (Deshpandé & Farley, 1998), was conducted. Fifty-three (53) empirical studies representing an overall sample size of 12,043 respondents from 23 countries, across five continents, were included. This is the first such study to be undertaken.
Section snippets
Market orientation and business performance
Two streams of research have emerged in the last decade (Gray, Matear, Boshoff, and Matheson, 1998). First, Narver and Slater (1990) defined market orientation in terms of culture and related it to the fundamental characteristics of the organization (e.g., customer orientation, competitor orientation, and inter-functional coordination), although they operationalized market orientation in terms of employee behavior. Second, Kohli and Jaworski's (1990) approach defined market orientation in terms
Potential moderators
Arthur, Bennett, and Huffcutt (2001, p. 85) define a moderator variable in meta-analysis as “any variable that by its inclusion in the analysis accounts for, or helps explain, more variance than would otherwise be the case.” Potential moderators are identified and coded based on their theoretical justification and explanatory power of the between-study variance. The moderators of the relationship between market orientation and business performance may be classified into contextual and
Methodology
A large variety of marketing parameters have been meta-analyzed in the marketing literature (Appendix A), including research in advertising, channels, consumer behavior, research methods, new product development, diffusion of innovation, pricing, sales and strategy (Appendix A). Meta-analysis research in strategy is sparse and limited to the parameters of market share, profitability, and order of entry into the market (e.g., Szymanski, Bharadwaj, & Varadarajan, 1993). Although extensive
Sample description
The literature search generated 187 manuscripts comprised of 183 refereed publications, 3 dissertations, and 1 proceeding. Through the coding and recoding process, 134 studies not meeting the eligibility requirements were eliminated. The remaining 53 studies, drawn from 27 publications and 3 dissertations, produced 59 effect sizes. A review to assure mutual exclusivity of samples detected two overlapping studies; one study was eliminated yielding 58 useable effect sizes.
Two researchers coded
Discussion
The findings of this study support the widely held marketing notion that the attainment of organizational goals is achieved by satisfying the needs of customers more efficiently and effectively than competitors. A rapidly changing environment requires quick and continual adaptation by management, whose ability to enhance operational efficiencies may lie in their ability to develop and embrace an organization-wide commitment to market orientation (Wood, Bhuian, and Kiecker, 2000).
The results of
Limitations and future research
Several limitations to this study are now put forward. First, although the fail-safe N statistic diminishes the threat to validity from file drawer cases, selection bias may be a limitation of the study. Although diligence was exercised to reduce selection bias, this threat is inherent to the nature of meta-analysis, resulting in the potential exclusion of relevant studies. Second, market orientation accounts for about 12% of the variance in business performance leaving a substantial amount of
Acknowledgements
The authors want to thank Dr. Michael Brannick for his continued support and the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments.
References (166)
Benefits of customer and competitive orientations in industrial markets
Industrial Marketing Management
(1996)An empirical examination of market orientation in Saudi Arabian manufacturing companies
Journal of Business Research
(1998)- et al.
Excellence-market orientation link: Some consequences for service firms
Journal of Business Research
(1999) - et al.
Triad lessons: Generalizing results on high performance firms in five business-to-business markets
International Journal of Research in Marketing
(2000) - et al.
Macro-economic determinants of consumer price knowledge: A meta-analysis of four decades of research
International Journal of Research in Marketing
(2001) - et al.
Generalization about trust in marketing channel relationships using meta-analysis
International Journal of Research in Marketing
(1998) - et al.
Strategic human resource management, market orientation, and organizational performance
Journal of Business Research
(2001) - et al.
Market orientation in the transition economies of central Europe: Tests of the Narver and Slater market orientation scales
Journal of Business Research
(2000) Market orientation, interdepartmental integration, and product development performance
The Journal of Product Innovation Management
(2001)Effects of market orientation on the behaviors of salespersons and purchasers, channel relationships, and performance of manufacturers
International Journal of Research in Marketing
(2001)
The changing consumer in the European Union: A meta-analysis
International Journal of Research in Marketing
The information content of advertising: A meta-analysis
Journal of Advertising
Marketing behavior and executive action, a functionalist approach to marketing theory
Marketing activities and business performance: Evidence from foreign and domestic manufacturing firms in a liberalized developing economy
Marketing Intelligence and Planning
Market orientation and performance: Empirical test in a transition economy
Journal of Strategic Marketing
Class of mail does affect response rates to mailed questionnaires: Evidence from meta-analysis; reply
Journal of the Market Research Society
Conducting meta-analysis using SAS
How advertising affects sales: Meta-analysis of econometric results
Journal of Marketing Research
Learning orientation, market orientation, and innovation: Integrating and extending models of organizational performance
Journal of Market-Focused Management
Market orientation in the top 200 British charity organizations and its impact on their performance
European Journal of Marketing
When does advertising have an impact? A study of tracking data
Journal of Advertising Research
The contributions of marketing to strategic management
Academy of Management Review
On the interchangeability of objective and subjective measures of employee performance: A meta-analysis
Personnel Psychology
A theoretical and empirical exegesis of the consumer involvement construct: The psychology of the food shopper
Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice
Conflict and satisfaction in an industrial channel of distribution
International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management
A meta-analysis of relationships between ad-evoked feelings and advertising responses
Journal of Marketing Research
Antecedents and consequences of salesperson job satisfaction: Meta-analysis and assessment of causal effects
Journal of Marketing Research
Antecedents and consequences of attitude toward the ad: A meta-analysis
Journal of Consumer Research
The link between market orientation and performance in the Australian public sector
Asian Journal of Marketing
The market orientation-performance link: Some evidence from the public sector and universities
Journal of Nonprofit and Public Sector Marketing
Do universities that are more market orientated perform better?
International Journal of Public Sector Management
Market orientation and performance in the public sector: The role of organizational commitment
Journal of Global Marketing
Reliability generalization of NEO personality scales
Educational and Psychological Measurement
Antecedents and consequences of market orientation in public organizations
European Journal of Marketing
Meta-analysis with heteroscedastic effects
Journal of Marketing Research
Cultural values reflected in theme and execution: A comparative study of U.S. and Korean television commercials
Journal of Advertising
The determinants of salesperson performance: A meta-analysis
Journal of Marketing Research
Research design effects on the reliability of rating scales: A meta-analysis
Journal of Marketing Research
Do product warnings increase safe behavior? A meta-analysis
Journal of Public Policy and Marketing
Mapping the path to market leadership: Effectively combining various dimensions of strategy into an integrated process of strategic analysis and action maps the path to market leadership
Marketing Management
The relationship between subjective and objective company performance measures in market orientation research: Further empirical evidence
Marketing Bulletin
Market orientation and company profitability: Further evidence incorporating longitudinal data
Australian Journal of Management
The market driven organization: Understanding, attracting and keeping valuable customers
Measuring market orientation generalization and synthesis
Journal of Market-Focused Management
Executive insights: Corporate culture and market orientation: Comparing Indian and Japanese firms
Journal of International Marketing
Market orientation and market strategy profiling: An empirical test of environment–behaviour–action coalignment and its performance implications
Management Decision
Marketing and competitive performance: An empirical study
European Journal of Marketing
The practice of management
Cited by (0)
- 1
This author contributed equally to the manuscript.