ISO 14001 certification and financial performance: selection-effect versus treatment-effect
Introduction
Commitment to the natural environment has become an important variable within current competitive scenarios (Graff, 1997). “Business-led” initiatives such as development of firm-structured environmental management systems (EMSs), participation in trade association programmes emphasizing codes of environmental management, and adoption of international certification standards for environmental management are becoming widespread (Anton et al., 2004, Nakamura et al., 2001). This is illustrated by registrations to the ISO 14001 EMS standard which have grown nearly 50% in recent years with 188,815 firms in 155 countries registered at the end of 2009 (ISO, 2009). This suggests that there is a widespread belief in the international business community of the benefits of ISO 14001 registration.
Although there is a plethora of research articles that study ISO 14001 EMS standard and their association with environmental performance improvement (Dahlström and Skea, 2002, Florida and Davidson, 2001, King and Lenox, 2002, King et al., 2005, NDEMS, 2003, Potoski and Prakash, 2005, Russo and Harrison, 2001, Szymanski and Tiwari, 2004, Schaltegger and Synnestvedt, 2002), there are few articles that examine the relationship between ISO 14001 and financial performance, and there is little of this research that can attribute causality. The inference often drawn is that ISO accreditation leads to higher levels of performance. What tends to be forgotten is that the opposite direction of causality could be true, i.e., successful firms may well have a propensity to pursue certification. Thus, environmental performance and/or its accreditation could be a kind of ‘luxury good’ for a company when it has reached a certain level of economic performance (Schaltegger and Synnestvedt, 2002). In other words, financial performance may influence environmental management (Wagner, 2005) because a firm with a good financial performance can allocate more resources to environmental initiatives. Moreover, it must be taken into account, as has been stressed by other authors (King et al., 2005, Potoski and Prakash, 2005), ISO 14001 accreditation is often market driven, adopted because customers require it, or because competitors have it.
Therefore, the aim of this article is to examine the relationship between ISO 14001 and financial performance with a particular emphasis on trying to establish the direction of causality in that relationship. To achieve this we compare the actual sales and profitability of ISO 14001 accredited firms with their performance prior to registration.
Furthermore, most quantitative studies are based on surveys in which the ratings were given by respondents that had taken part in the EMS introduction process (e.g. Sulaiman et al., 2002, Hamschmidt and Dyllick, 2001, Summers, 2002, Schylander and Martinuzzi, 2007). Any analyses of the effect of EMSs conducted in this way are subject to possible weakness and methodological distortion, so to avoid this problem we use only objective variables in our analyses.
The paper is structured as follows. First, we present a review of literature that considers environmental management, certification and performance. This is then followed by a description of our research methodology and presentation of our findings. These are then discussed and conclusions drawn.
Section snippets
Literature review
Some authors see corporate environmental strategy as a tool which may help organisations gain competitive advantage and improve performance levels (Hart, 1995, Porter and Van der Linde, 1995, Shrivastava, 1995, Trung and Kumar, 2005). Specifically, through environmental management, firms may reduce costs and increase revenues (Ambec and Lanoie, 2008). Others, however, have questioned the optimism of environmental advocates (Jaffe et al., 1995, Walley and Whitehead, 1994), emphasizing that
Sample and data collection
The data analysed in this paper covers a six-year time period and analyses the comparative financial performance of ISO 14001 certified firms before and after certification compared to a control group of firms without certification.
The research was undertaken in the Basque Autonomous region, which is known to be one of the regions in Spain where ISO 14001 registrations are concentrated (Heras et al., 2008). The ISO 14001 certification data was gathered from the Catálogo Industrial Vasco y de
Testing for treatment-effect and selection-effect
We start by presenting the findings of our longitudinal study using a treatment-effect assumption i.e. where performance differences in return on assets employed (ROA) and sales growth between certified and non-certified firms are assumed to be due to adoption of an ISO 14001 EMS. These findings then provide a starting point that allows later comparison with the selection-effect results. For the treatment-effect results we use a dichotomous split between certified and non-certified firms
Summary
Our findings of the dominance of a selection-effect over a treatment-effect in explaining the better than average profitability and sales growth of ISO 14001 certified firms has also been found in research looking at longitudinal analyses of performance achievements in firms who are pursuing ISO 9001 in the USA, Spain and Denmark—for a review see Dick et al. (2008).
Furthermore, as stated in the literature review section, our pioneering findings for the specific case of ISO 14001 are consistent
Acknowledgment
This article is the result of a more extensive research supported by the Basque Institute of Competitiveness (IVC) in the Basque Autonomous Region in Spain. The Institute is a member of the worldwide network of competitiveness centres of the Harvard Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness. Our most sincere thanks go to the IVC for the support it has shown. We acknowledge the invaluable support given always by Professor Mikel Navarro, and the advice on statistical methods given by Dr. Aloña
References (109)
- et al.
The relations among environmental disclosure, environmental performance, and economic performance: a simultaneous equations approach
Accounting, Organizations and Society
(2004) - et al.
Incentives for environmental self-regulation and implications for environmental performance
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
(2004) - et al.
The influence of motivations for seeking ISO 14001 certification: an empirical study of ISO 14001 certified facilities in Hong Kong
Journal of Environmental Management
(2002) - et al.
ISO 14001 certification in Brazil: motivations and benefits
Journal of Cleaner Production
(2008) - et al.
Corporate environmental initiatives and anticipated firm performance: the differential effects of process-driven versus product-driven greening initiatives
Journal of Management
(2000) - et al.
Environmental proactivity and business performance: an empirical analysis
Omega
(2005) Pollution as news: media and stock market reactions to the Toxics Release Inventory Data
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
(1995)- et al.
Perceptual measures of performance: fact or fiction?
Journal of Operations Management
(2004) - et al.
EPA’s Voluntary 33/50 Program: impact on toxic releases and economic performance of firms
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
(1999) - et al.
Assessing the impact of environmental management systems on corporate and environmental performance
Journal of Operations Management
(2003)
Challenges of the “green imperative”: a natural resource-based approach to the environmental orientation–business performance relationship
Journal of Business Research
Adopting corporate environmental management systems: motivations and results of ISO 14001 and EMAS certification
European Management Journal
Why Japanese firms chose to certify: a study of managerial responses to environmental issues
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
Achieving competitive advantage through implementing a replicable management standard: installing and using ISO 9000
Journal of Operations Management
Finding the connection: EMSd and environmental performance
Journal of Cleaner Production
An empirical study of the initial adoption of ISO 14001 in Japanese manufacturing firms
Ecological Economics
Panacea common sense or just a label? The value of ISO 14001 environmental management systems
European Management Journal
Linking performance drivers in production planning and inventory control to process choice
Journal of Operations Management
The link between ‘green’ and economic success: environmental management as the crucial trigger between environmental and economic performance
Journal of Environmental Management
Green management: the next competitive weapon
Futures
The effect of certification with ISO 9000 Quality Management Standards: a signalling approach
Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization
Resource use and waste management in Vietnam hotel industry
Journal of Cleaner Production
How to reconcile environmental and economic performance to improve corporate sustainability: corporate environmental strategies in the European paper industry
Journal of Environmental Management
Does it pay to be green? A systematic overview
The Academy of Management Executive
Mostly Harmless Econometrics. An Empiricist’s Companion
Beyond dichotomy: the curvilinear relationship between social responsibility and financial performance
Strategic Management Journal
Does it pay to be different? An analysis of the relationship between corporate social and financial performance
Strategic Management Journal
Repercusión económica de la certificación medioambiental ISO 14001
Cuadernos de Gestión
The ISO 14000 Handbook
Green Profits: The Manager’s Handbook for ISO 14001 and Pollution Prevention
Effects of “best practices” of environmental management on cost advantage: the role of complementary assets
Academy of Management Journal
A stakeholder framework for analyzing and evaluating corporate social performance
Academy of Management Review
Environmental and Financial Performance: Are They Related? Working Paper
The financial impact of ISO 9000 Certification in the United States: an empirical analysis
Management Science
Environmental proactivism and firm performance: evidence from security analyst earnings forecasts
Business Strategy and the Environment
EMSs and operator performance at sites regulated under integrated pollution control
Draft Research and Development Technical Report P6/TR, Prepared by the Policy Studies Institute
La protección ambiental y el resultado. Un análisis crítico de su relación
Investigaciones Europeas de Dirección y Economía de la Empresa
Is the socially responsible corporation a myth? The good, the bad, and the ugly of corporate social responsibility
Academy of Management Perspectives
Shedding light on causations between ISO 9001 and improved business performance
International Journal of Operations and Production Management
The stakeholder theory of the corporation: concepts, evidence and implications
Academy of Management Review
The Link between Company Environmental and Financial Performance
Towards the sustainable corporation: win–win–win business strategies for sustainable development
California Management Review
Gaining from green management: EMSsinside and outside the factory
California Management Review
The relationship between corporate social responsibility and shareholder value: an empirical test of the risk management hypothesis
Strategic Management Journal
ISO 14000: should your company develop an environmental management system?
Industrial Management
Econometric Analysis
The corporate social performance and corporate financial performance debate. Twenty-five years of incomparable research
Business & Society
ISO 14001: profitable? Yes! but is it eco-effective?
Greener Management International
Does it pay to be green? An empirical examination of the relationship between emission reduction and firm performance
Business Strategy and the Environment
Cited by (169)
Assessing the economic impacts of forest certification in Spain: A longitudinal study
2023, Ecological EconomicsHow to improve the survivability of environmentally innovative firms: The case of Vietnam's SMEs
2022, Journal of Cleaner ProductionEnvironmental self-regulation and firm survival: Evidence from China
2022, Journal of Cleaner Production