A comparative study of three ductile damage approaches for fracture prediction in cold forming processes
Introduction
Fracture prediction in real size structures subjected to complex loading conditions has been of utmost interest in the scientific and engineering community in the past century. Numerical simulations with nonlinear finite element (FE) codes allow investigating various complicated problems for damage and fracture prediction in real scale models, which is an important topic in many industries, including metal forming industry. For all industrial cold forming processes, the ability of numerical modeling to predict ductile fracture is crucial. However, this ability is still limited because of the complex loading paths (multi-axial and non-proportional loadings) and important shear effects in several forming processes where the stress triaxiality is nearly zero. Moreover, since forming processes involve large strain, the use of a suitable FE code with robust damage and fracture prediction models is essential to obtain realistic results for both geometry precision and mechanical properties. Regarding ductile damage models, three main approaches have been extensively used and developed for fifty years: uncoupled phenomenological damage models (or fracture criteria), coupled phenomenological models and micromechanical models. The role of microvoids in ductile failure was firstly modeled by the study of McClintock et al. (1966), which analyzed the evolution of an isolated cylindrical void in a ductile elastoplastic matrix. Rice and Tracey (1969) studied the evolution of spherical voids in an elastic-perfectly plastic matrix. In these studies, the interaction between microvoids, the coalescence process and the hardening effects were neglected and failure was assumed to occur when the cavity radius would reach a critical value specific for each material. These results showed that the voids growth is governed by the stress triaxiality, which is the ratio between the mean stress and the von Mises equivalent stress. Gurson (1977), in an upper bound analysis of a finite sphere containing an isolated spherical void in a rigid perfectly plastic matrix, employed the void volume fraction f (or porosity) as an internal variable to represent damage and its softening effect on material strength. This model was then extensively improved to account for different aspects: prediction accuracy (Tvergaard, 1981), void nucleation and void coalescence (Tvergaard and Needleman, 1984), void shape effect (e.g. Gologanu et al., 1993), void size effect (e.g. Wen et al., 2005), void/particle interaction (e.g. Siruguet and Leblond, 2004), isotropic strain hardening (e.g. Leblond et al., 1995), kinematic hardening (e.g. Muhlich and Brocks, 2003), plastic anisotropy (e.g. Benzerga and Besson, 2001), rate dependency (e.g. Tvergaard, 1989), shear effect (e.g. Xue, 2008).
On the other hand, the Continuum Damage Mechanics (CDM) models have been developed within a consistent thermodynamic framework, in which the evolution of the phenomenological damage parameter is obtained through a thermodynamic dissipation potential. This class of models has been continuously developed and widely used, especially the Lemaitre model Lemaitre (1986) – see Besson (2010) for a complete review of continuum models of ductile fracture).
In addition to the phenomenological CDM models and micromechanics-based damage models, uncoupled phenomenological models have been increasingly developed, especially for industrial applications. Uncoupled models employ an indicator variable to predict material failure when its critical value is reached. This variable is often taken as a weighted cumulative plastic strain, in which the weighting function accounts for the effect of stress state on the fracture initiation.
The early ductile damage models used only the stress triaxiality in order to account for the influence of stress state. Several recent studies (e.g. Barsoum and Faleskog, 2007) also demonstrated the important effect of the third stress invariant in damage evolution, especially at low stress triaxiality; the Lode angle parameter is generally used to include it. This parameter combines the second and third invariants of deviatoric stress tensor. Xue (2007) developed a damage-plasticity model, which accounts for the influence of hydrostatic pressure and the Lode angle. Bai and Wierzbicki (2008) constructed an asymmetric fracture locus using a weighting function of the stress triaxiality and the Lode parameter. More recently, the same authors transformed the stress-based Mohr–Coulomb failure criterion into the space of the stress triaxiality, the equivalent plastic strain and the Lode parameter (Bai and Wierzbicki, 2010). The common idea of these works is to account for the whole stress state in damage model formulation, which is defined by the stress triaxiality, the von Mises equivalent stress, and the Lode parameter. Gurson-based models have also been enhanced to better describe ductile damage for low stress triaxiality (e.g. Nahshon and Hutchinson, 2008).
Despite their increasing developments, among numerous ductile damage models proposed in the literature, very few were actually applied and validated on complex industrial applications, such as multi-stage forming processes. The comparison of the three above-mentioned damage approaches on real complex multi-stage manufacturing processes is important to clarify the advantages and drawbacks of each one. In the present study, multi-stage ultimate wire drawing and wire flat rolling processes were chosen to serve for this purpose.
Regarding damage in wire drawing process, defects in drawn wire come from both the initial defects from the preform and the deformation process itself. The common defect observed in drawing is chevron cracking or central burst (also called “cupping” – cup and cone fracture). However, under certain conditions of material and microstructure states (e.g. large defects on the surface of the initial wire), fracture can initiate at the surface due to the presence of important shear effect at this position. Interested readers are invited to the recent work of Cao et al. (2014d) for a study of ductile fracture in multi-stage drawing, and references therein for a literature review on ductile damage in this process.
Concerning the wire flat rolling process, numerous studies were carried out by Kazeminezhad and Karimi Taheri. Kazeminezhad and Taheri (2005a) performed experimental studies on the rolling force and the deformation behavior of rolled wire. They found that the rolling force depends on rolling speed and rolling reduction, but lubricant has a negligible effect on both rolling force and geometry (width of contact area and lateral spread). An analytical relationship was proposed by these authors (Kazeminezhad and Taheri, 2005b) to evaluate the lateral spread for both low and high carbon steels, which is a function of the ratio between initial and final heights of flattened wire. In terms of stresses and strain analyses, Kazeminezhad and Taheri (2006a) used analytical analyses and found that there exists a maximum in the pressure distribution similar to that observed in strip rolling. They also revealed shear bands on the cross section of the flattened wire in form of a cross (the so-called “blacksmith” cross1) by using combined finite and slab element methods and metallographic observation (Kazeminezhad and Taheri, 2006b). In addition, the deformation pattern was found inhomogeneous, both on longitudinal and transverse cross sections. Vallellano et al. (2008) showed that this inhomogeneity of deformation has strong impacts on contact and residual stresses.
The above studies principally concentrated on geometry (e.g. spread) or loading (e.g. rolling force) predictions, there are few studies in the literature dealing with damage and fracture prediction in cold rolling of long products. Recently, (Massé et al., 2012) performed Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) observations of damage state in a wire flat rolling process. These authors reported a higher void density in the wire core and in the “blacksmith cross”, which led them to a conclusion that these zones were danger zones in such a process. They then used the Lemaitre damage model to study the localization of damage but it failed to predict the above-mentioned danger zones. These critical areas coincide with “sheared” zones. The use of more advanced damage models in this context is crucial to obtain more precise results in terms of maximum damage location prediction.
The present study aims at providing a critical assessment of different phenomenological and micromechanical models and characterizing their performance for complex loading configurations: multi-stage ultimate cold wire drawing (Section 2.3.1) and wire-flat rolling (Section 2.3.2) processes. The objective is to supply a critical comparison between six damage models of the three above-mentioned approaches on these two forming processes: Bai and Wierzbicki (Bai and Wierzbicki, 2010 – uncoupled phenomenological approach); Lemaitre (Lemaitre, 1986), Xue (Xue, 2007) and Lode dependent enhanced Lemaitre Cao et al. (2014b) (coupled phenomenological approach); GTN and modified GTN by Xue (2008) (micromechanical approach). From this comparison, the goal is to discuss the applicability of a selection of models to diverse processes with completely different states of stress. The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes experimental techniques used for damage models identification and experiments on forming processes. This section also presents experimental results of damage occurring during the ultimate wire drawing and wire flat rolling processes. Section 3 presents the numerical techniques and damage models developed and used. Section 4 provides numerical results of damage on the two applications: multi-stage wire drawing and rolling, obtained with the six damage models. From these results, Section 5 discusses the performance of the three approaches in the above-mentioned applications and also suggests a research trend that could be followed for other applications. Appendix A reviews all the damage models implemented and used in this work. The identification of these models is discussed in Appendix B. Appendix C Loading history in the wire flat rolling process, Appendix D Wire drawing – results of phenomenological damage models with present additional results on simulations of the processes.
Section snippets
Material
The material used in the present study is a high carbon steel grade, which presents a fine pearlite structure after a patenting process. All the specimens used in the mechanical tests are extracted from the longitudinal direction of steel rods of maximum diameter of 17 mm. The mechanical properties of this steel grade can be considered isotropic in the patented state. The structure is pearlitic: ferrite with lamellae of cementite (see Fig. 1, which shows cementite lamellae in white and ferrite
Finite element model
Implicit finite element (FE) simulations of all experiments are performed with Forge2009®, which is based on an implicit mixed FE formulation of velocity and pressure. The updated Lagrangian formulation is adopted, which allows using the small strain approach. The local integration of constitutive equations is solved by backward Euler method. Since the mesh is distorted at large deformation, an automatic adaptive remesher allows Forge2009® dealing with large strain simulations (e.g. forming
Mechanical analyses
In order to illustrate the mechanical state of material during the process, the evolutions of strain and stress states of drawn wire during the fourth pass are studied. For this pass, the section reduction ratio is 20.69% and the semi-angle is 0.105 rad. The drawing speed is around 600 mm/s.
Fig. 5a and b represents the equivalent plastic strain rate and strain fields at steady state for the fourth pass. The strain-rate is higher at inlet and outlet contact points and also in the wire core, and is
Role of the cutoff value of triaxiality
As discussed above, based on series of tests on various types of steel under pressure by Bridgman (1952) and Bao and Wierzbicki (2005) suggested a cutoff value of stress triaxiality of −1/3, below which fracture does not occur. In the present study, this value has been used for the Lemaitre model from the work of Bouchard et al. (2011a). However, from several experiments results (e.g. Lou et al., 2014) this value has been shown to be far from universal. Lou et al. (2014) proposed the following
Closure remarks
This paper presents the application of three ductile damage approaches to predict fracture in cold forming processes. Damage occurring in multi-stage wire drawing and shear-dominated loading wire flat rolling processes is investigated numerically and compared with experimental results. The main conclusions can be summarized as
- •
Six damage models, namely the B&W model (uncoupled phenomenological approach), the Lemaitre, enhanced Lemaitre and Xue models (coupled phenomenological approach) and the
Acknowledgments
The financial support from ArcelorMittal, Cezus-Areva and Ugitech via the METAL project is appreciated.
References (57)
- et al.
A new model of metal plasticity and fracture with pressure and Lode dependence
Int. J. Plast.
(2008) - et al.
On fracture locus in the equivalent strain and stress triaxiality space
Int. J. Mech. Sci.
(2004) - et al.
On the cut-off value of negative triaxiality for fracture
Eng. Fract. Mech.
(2005) - et al.
Rupture mechanisms in combined tension and shear – experiments
Int. J. Solids Struct.
(2007) - et al.
Anisotropic ductile fracture: Part I: Experiments
Acta Mater.
(2004) - et al.
Plastic potentials for anisotropic porous solids
Eur. J. Mech. A/Solids
(2001) - et al.
A ductile damage criterion at various stress triaxialities
Int. J. Plast.
(2008) Numerical simulation of 3D ductile cracks formation using recent improved Lode-dependent plasticity and damage models combined with remeshing
Int. J. Solids Struct.
(2014)- et al.
A Lode-dependent enhanced Lemaitre model for ductile fracture prediction at low stress triaxiality
Eng. Fract. Mech.
(2014) - et al.
Identification methodology and comparison of phenomenological ductile damage models via hybrid numerical–experimental analysis of fracture experiments conducted on a zirconium alloy
Int. J. Solids Struct.
(2013)
Characterization of ductile damage for a high carbon steel using 3D X-ray micro-tomography and mechanical tests application to the identification of a shear modified GTN model
Comput. Mater. Sci.
Numerical modeling of elasto-plastic porous materials with void shape effects at finite deformations
Compos. B: Eng.
Hybrid experimental numerical analysis of basic ductile fracture experiments for sheet metals
Int. J. Solids Struct.
Approximate models for ductile metals containing non-spherical voids – case of axisymmetric prolate ellipsoidal cavities
J. Mech. Phys. Solids
Nonlocal models for damage and fracture: comparison of approaches
Int. J. Solids Struct.
An experimental investigation on the deformation behavior during wire flat rolling process
J. Mater. Process. Technol.
A theoretical and experimental investigation on wire flat rolling process using deformation pattern
Materials & Design
Calculation of the rolling pressure distribution and force in wire flat rolling process
J. Mater. Process. Technol.
The prediction of macroscopic shear bands in flat rolled wire using the finite and slab element method
Mater. Lett.
Local approach of fracture
Eng. Fract. Mech.
Extension of a shear-controlled ductile fracture model considering the stress triaxiality and the lode parameter
Int. J. Solids Struct.
Modeling of shear ductile fracture considering a changeable cut-off value for stress triaxiality
Int. J. Plast.
Initiation and growth of damage in a dual-phase steel observed by X-ray microtomography
Acta Mater.
Modification of the Gurson Model for shear failure
Eur. J. Mech. A/Solids
On the ductile enlargement of voids in triaxial stress fields
J. Mech. Phys. Solids
Effect of void locking by inclusions upon the plastic behavior of porous ductile solids I: Theoretical modeling and numerical study of void growth
Int. J. Plast.
Material Failure by Void Growth to Coalescence. Vol. 27 of Advances in Applied Mechanics
Analysis of the cup-cone fracture in a round tensile bar
Acta Metall.
Cited by (43)
Numerical prediction of the galling of aluminium alloys in cold strip drawing
2022, Journal of Manufacturing ProcessesAn improved shear modified GTN model for ductile fracture of aluminium alloys under different stress states and its parameters identification
2021, International Journal of Mechanical SciencesCoupled damage variable based on fracture locus: Prediction of ductile failure in a complex structure
2020, International Journal of Solids and StructuresOn the stress state-based coupled plasticity – Ductile damage model for aluminum alloys considering the influence of high-rate impulsive preload
2020, International Journal of Impact EngineeringCitation Excerpt :The continuum damage model has been generalized to take into account the effect of stress state on damage criteria as well as evolution equations of the damage strains. Cao et al. [24] studied the fracture prediction in cold forming processes of high carbon steel using the following three different approaches of ductile damage; uncoupled phenomenological models, coupled phenomenological models, and micromechanical models. Also, they calibrated those models through several mechanical tests under various stress states.
A study on central crack formation in cross wedge rolling
2020, Journal of Materials Processing TechnologyDamage in metal forming
2020, CIRP Annals