Broadband noise prediction of fan outlet guide vane using a cascade response function
Highlights
► An analytical model for the fan broadband noise is detailed. ► Both ingested turbulence interacting with a rotor and rotor–stator interaction are studied. ► An acoustic analogy in an annular duct is coupled with a strip theory. ► The unsteady blade loading are computing with a three-dimensional rectilinear-cascade model. ► A good agreement with the NASA SDT case is obtained and a detailed parametric study is done.
Introduction
Turbofan engines with higher bypass ratios ensure improved aircraft performances at lower nominal rotation speed. Both the exhaust velocities of burnt gases and the corresponding jet noise are reduced and the fan-OGV (outlet guide vane) stage becomes a major contributor to the total noise. Modern very-high bypass architectures involve lower fan tip speed, reduced number of blades, selected blade and vane counts, and acoustic liners. This ensures tonal noise reduction and shifts the tone frequencies to lower values associated with weaker loudness. As a result, the broadband noise contribution is expected to become relatively more significant and dedicated prediction schemes are a crucial step to be included in the design cycles, as early and as accurately as possible. More specifically, the present study is dedicated to the prediction of the broadband noise resulting from the impingement of incident turbulence on a blade row either rotating or stationary. Numerical simulations of the turbulent compressible three-dimensional flow around the blades or the vanes could in principle reproduce all sound generation and propagation phenomena accurately, but are still a daunting task for an actual fan (blade span of the order of 1 m and Reynolds number based on the chord length and mean velocity around 106) and are far from being compatible with industrial time constraints. Besides, fan broadband noise prediction requires the whole power spectral density (PSD) of the acoustic power for frequencies ranging up to 10 kHz. Fast-running analytical models then appear to be still more appropriate in an industrial context.
Many studies have been performed over the past 40 years to predict the fan broadband noise caused by turbulence ingestion and wake interactions. Mugridge and Morfey [1], Mani [2], Hanson [3] and Sevik [4], among others, have dealt with the interaction of an incident turbulence with a rotating blade or a stationary vane. Homicz and George [5] extended these works to rotating blades at low frequencies and George and Kim [6] and Amiet [7] at high frequencies. Detailed reviews of the methods and experiments carried out during the seventies on rotor broadband noise were proposed by Cumpsty [8], Brooks and Schlinker [9] and George and Chou [10]. Most of these works were dedicated to open rotors, in particular the main rotor of a helicopter, for which the moderate blade number, often smaller than 10, allows using an isolated-airfoil response function.
Dealing with turbofan engines requires including the in-duct propagation in the prediction methods. Glegg [11], De Gouville [12] and Joseph and Parry [13] developed broadband noise models for ducted fans using Green's function tailored to the duct, and the unsteady blade loadings as acoustic sources. Glegg [11] dealt with the interaction of the rotor blades with the boundary layer of the casing and with the interaction of rotor wakes with the OGV. Yet the blades were assumed to be acoustically compact along the chord. De Gouville [12] resorted to Graham's similarity rules [14] to account for the compressibility effects and the non-compactness of the airfoil to determine the turbulence ingestion noise, while Joseph and Parry [13] used the two-dimensional compressible Amiet's function to predict the noise due to the interaction of the casing boundary layer with the rotor blades. These investigations were based on an isolated-airfoil response function. Nevertheless, current turbofan engines involve higher and higher bypass ratio and chord lengths, and the blade number of the rotor and the vane number of the stator can easily exceed 20 and 50 respectively (e.g. [15]). As a result, cascade effects must also be included in the prediction methods. Ventres et al. [16] were the first to propose a fan broadband noise model for inlet and wake turbulence considering both the duct and the cascade effects. These two aspects are an important theoretical improvement. An in-duct formulation of the acoustic analogy was applied, using the unsteady blade loading as input data, but resorting to a two-dimensional cascade response function. The radial variation of the turbulence was then taken into account by means of a strip theory. More recently Nallasamy and Envia [17] enhanced and coupled this model to a Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes computation to get the turbulence input data for the acoustic model, showing a good agreement with measurements.
However, experimental results (e.g. [18]) show clear evidence of the strong spanwise variation of the turbulence in the rotor wakes developing upstream of the OGV, which may hinder the above two-dimensional decomposition of the impinging turbulence on stator vanes. Another approach then consists in including the spanwise variations of the turbulence by means of a three-dimensional rectilinear-cascade model: incident gusts are three-dimensional but the cascade is still considered rectilinear. Hanson [19] and Hanson and Horan [20] proposed a model for the interaction of a homogeneous or radially inhomogeneous incident turbulence with a rectilinear flat-plate cascade resorting to Glegg's cascade model [21]. Hanson then extended it to swept and leaned cascades [22] and to the broadband noise of a complete fan stage [23]. Glegg [24] and Glegg and Walker [25] accounted for the duct wall in the unwrapped configuration giving the exact solution to this approximate problem by means of a cosine functions basis. Evers and Peake [26] finally extended the method of Hanson and Horan [20] to include blade geometry effects. These predictions agreed quite well with the available experimental results despite the crucial assumption of rectilinear cascade [20]. Cheong et al. [27] again using a rectilinear-cascade model based on Smith's two-dimensional theory [28], pointed out a critical frequency, below which cascade effects are important, and only a part of the turbulent wavenumbers contribute to the resulting noise. Above that frequency, cascade effects can be neglected and the whole incident turbulence contributes. Jurdic et al. [29] predicted the rotor/stator interaction noise with this model using RANS data as inputs. Hanson's model and similar ones can be declined in a strip theory to take the radial variation of the geometry of an actual annular cascade into account. Yet, it directly applies to the radiated field and associated acoustic power, and does not rely on the unsteady blade loading as in the previous methods. As a result, the propagation in an annular duct cannot be accounted for.
Finally a significant improvement in fan broadband noise predictions has been recently achieved through three-dimensional unsteady linearized-Euler (LEE) simulations, fully accounting for the actual blade geometry. For instance, Atassi and Vinogradov [30], [31] and Atassi and Logue [32] proposed a very accurate fan broadband interaction noise method based on a previously developed model [33]. This approach noticeably accounts for the three-dimensional effects of the actual geometry, swirling mean flow and three-dimensional turbulence excitation and points out the importance of these parameters [33].
The present paper describes an analytical model of the broadband noise produced by turbulence in a rotor–stator arrangement. Both the interaction of ingested turbulence with the rotor blades and the rotor-wake impingement on downstream stator vanes are addressed. The model is a strip-theory application [34] based of a previously published formulation of the unsteady blade loading for a rectilinear cascade [35] and of the subsequent developments by the authors [34]. More precisely, Glegg's analytical formulation [21] has first been extended to provide closed-form expressions of the acoustic field valid inside the inter-blade channels, and of the unsteady-blade loading [35]. A wavenumber correction has also been proposed to include some of the three-dimensionality inherent to the annular configuration into the unwrapped description of a cascade strip in Cartesian coordinates [34]. This makes the unsteady blade loading calculated on each strip an equivalent dipole source distribution in an acoustic analogy formulation inside an annular duct. Preliminary broadband noise prediction issues have been addressed by Posson and Roger [36] and Posson et al. [37] to assess the effect of simplifying assumptions and the role of specific corrections to account for the main three-dimensional effects. The model was compared with the reference three-dimensional LEE computation of Atassi et al. [33] and with Logue and Atassi's updated version of the linear cascade model of Atassi and Hamad [38]. Posson and Roger [39] also carried out a dedicated experiment involving a turbulence grid upstream of a stationary cascade mounted at the exit section of an open-jet anechoic wind-tunnel. The model was found in a rather good agreement with the experiment in an extended low and middle frequency range. Further validations in configurations closer to a real engine were however recognized as necessary. The final version of the broadband noise model is described in detail in Section 2. The predictions are then compared, in Section 3, with the experimental data of the 22-in source diagnostic test (SDT) fan rig of the NASA Glenn Research Center [40], [41], [42], [43], [44], [45], [46]. Both numerical assessment and experimental validation are achieved.
Section snippets
Fan broadband noise model
Although three-dimensional features, such as swirl and non-uniform mean flow, induce significant aerodynamic effects (e.g. [47], [48], [33]), Atassi and Vinogradov showed that a simplified two-dimensional cascade model is adequate for predicting the fan broadband acoustic response at high frequencies [30], [31]. Moreover, both Glegg's analytical formulation [24] and Hanson's model [20], [22], based on a three-dimensional rectilinear-cascade response [21], were found successful in predicting the
Experimental data and preliminary assessment
In order to assess the model, Posson and Roger [39] proposed a dedicated experiment in a subsonic anechoic wind-tunnel facility. The experimental set-up has been designed to isolate the noise due to the interaction of an incident turbulent flow with a stationary annular cascade of vanes as much as possible. The cascade has 49 or 98 vanes of 25 mm chord length, a tip radius of 230 mm, and a hub-to-tip ratio of 0.65. The mean velocity ranges from 50 m/s to 100 m/s. A turbulence-generating grid is
Concluding remarks
An analytical model for predicting the broadband noise produced by the interaction of ingested turbulence with the rotor blades of a fan and the rotor-wake impingement on outlet guide vanes has been described in detail. The model resorts to a strip-theory approach and an unsteady blade-loading rectilinear-cascade response [35] extending Glegg's analytical formulation [21]. The model has been extensively compared with experimental results of the 22-in source diagnostic test (SDT) fan rig of the
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to acknowledge Dr. Edmane Envia from NASA Glenn Research Center for providing the overall geometric and aerodynamic data of the NASA 22-in fan source diagnostic test. They also acknowledge Compute Canada and the RQCHP (Quebec, Canada) for providing computational resources.
References (79)
Noise due to interaction of inlet turbulence with isolated stators and rotors
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(1971)- et al.
Broadband and discrete frequency radiation from subsonic rotors
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(1974) - et al.
Computation of rotor wake turbulence noise
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(2005) The response of a swept blade row to a three-dimensional gust
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(1999)- et al.
On the use of a uniformly valid analytical cascade response function for broadband noise predictions
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(2010) Acoustic radiation from an airfoil in a turbulent stream
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(1975)- et al.
Sources of noise in axial flow fans
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
(1971) Unified analysis of fan stator noise
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
(1973)- Sevik, Sound radiation from a subsonic rotor subjected to turbulence, In its Fluid Mechanics, Acoustics, and Design of...
- et al.
High frequency broadband rotor noise
AIAA Journal
(1977)
Noise produced by turbulent flow into propeller or helicopter rotor
AIAA Journal
Review—a critical review of turbomachinery noise
Journal of Fluids Engineering, Transaction of ASME
Progress in rotor broadband noise research
Vertica (ISSN 0360-5450)
Comparison of broadband noise mechanisms, analyses, and experiments on rotors
Journal of Aircraft
Similarity rules for thin aerofoils in non-stationary subsonic flows
Journal of Fluid Mechanics
On sound generation by the interaction between turbulence and a cascade of airfoils with non-uniform mean flow
Journal of Fluid Mechanics
High-frequency formulation for the acoustic power spectrum due to cascade-turbulence interaction
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
Scattering of incidence disturbances by an annular cascade in a swirling flow
Journal of Fluid Mechanics
Upon a uniformly valid analytical rectilinear cascade response function
Journal of Fluid Mechanics
Cited by (99)
Large Eddy Simulation of the ACAT1 fan stage for broadband noise prediction
2023, Journal of Sound and VibrationImpact of three-dimensional turbulence modelling on rotor/stator interaction broadband noise
2022, Journal of Sound and VibrationParametric study on state-of-the-art analytical models for fan broadband interaction noise predictions
2021, Journal of Sound and VibrationCitation Excerpt :Previous studies by Atassi et al. [85] have identified the impact of using these three different models with their code BB3D. Posson et al. [34] also studied the discrepancies in predictions using both Liepmann’s and Gaussian spectra. Both authors carried out this analysis on the low-count SDT configuration.
Investigation of rotor–stator interaction broadband noise using a RANS-informed analytical method
2021, Chinese Journal of AeronauticsAn overview of testing methods for aeroengine fan noise
2021, Progress in Aerospace SciencesPrediction of fan acoustic blockage on fan/outlet guide vane broadband interaction noise using frequency domain linearised Navier–Stokes solvers
2021, Journal of Sound and VibrationCitation Excerpt :These methodologies are based on, at least, two independent blocks, namely turbulence modelling and computation of the acoustic response to vortical gusts. Moreover, response methods based on the Acoustic Analogy require a third block to relate the pressure jump on the blades to the acoustic field using either free-field or in-duct Green’s functions [3,7,8]. Turbulence is usually synthesised using isotropic spectra (commonly informed with a RANS description of the impinging wake [9]).