Effects of urbanization on Neotropical wasp and bee assemblages in a Brazilian metropolis
Introduction
Urban environments are generally characterized as areas with a high density of buildings exposed to constant and intense human activity (McIntyre et al., 2001). Urbanization, the process by which these environments are generated, can be summarized as a local increase in the density of inhabitants coupled with increased per capita energy consumption and extensive modifications of the environment (including the microclimate) (Gilbert, 1991, Vitousek et al., 1997). This process generates unstable ecosystems that depend on large inputs of energy, and where great amounts of waste materials are accumulated (Stearns, 1970, McDonnell and Pickett, 1990). Despite covering a small fraction of the Earth’s surface (<5%), urban environments have a widespread influence on surrounding ecosystems (Vitousek et al., 1997, Goudie, 2000). Half of the world’s population currently lives in urban areas. This proportion is expected to increase to 60% in the year 2030 (United Nations, 1999). In Brazil, approximately 55% of the population was living in cities in 1970. Today, almost 80% of the population is living in urban areas (IBGE, 2001). This fast growth of cities is promoting an increasing interest in urban ecosystems and in the impact of urbanization on distinct biotas (Gilbert, 1991, Rebele, 1994, Grimm, 1997, Vitousek et al., 1997). Ecological studies of such ecosystems are essential to reduce local and regional impacts of urbanization (Gilbert, 1991, Bede et al., 1997, Niemela, 1999).
Different approaches have been used to study the fauna of urban environments (Moore, 1979, McDonnell and Pickett, 1990, Niemela, 1999). The theory of island biogeography, for instance, has been the foundation for many studies of insect and bird richness in “urban islands” (e.g. parks and public squares) (reviews in Davis and Glick, 1978, McIntyre, 2000). Despite being spatially heterogeneous, urban environments are structurally well defined (Turner, 1989). Generally, each part (or structural component) of the urban landscape presents clear limits (Wiens et al., 1993, Grimm, 1997). Public squares, for example, are well-defined habitat portions surrounded by a matrix of buildings equally well defined. Although “urban islands” may be easily perceived, this biogeographic approach has some limitations since the permeability of the urban matrix may be highly variable (Niemelä, 1999). Species with great dispersal ability, for example, may pass through the matrix; consequently they can use a portion of the urban habitat larger than a specific “island”. For these reasons different spatial scales have to be analyzed to study the effects of urbanization on a particular group of species (Hostetler, 1999). Additionally, it has to be considered that urbanization is a scale-dependent process. Urban planning and development are done in an hierarchical way (“from the mayor to the gardener”), and consequently, the effects of urbanization can not be fully appreciated by considering only one spatial scale (Savard et al., 2000).
Despite the ubiquity of insects, there are few studies especially concerned with the effects of urbanization on non-pest species, particularly in the Neotropical region (Laroca et al., 1982, Davis, 1982; Ruszczyk, 1986a, Ruszczyk, 1986b, Ruszczyk, 1986c, Ruszczyk, 1986d, Ruszczyk, 1996; Diefenbach and Becker, 1992, McIntyre, 2000). Earlier studies found a relatively high insect diversity in some cities (e.g. London and Rome), suggesting that these habitats may not be as restrictive as expected (Owen and Owen, 1975, Zapparoli, 1997). In addition, it has been observed that species richness and abundance can greatly vary within each city, indicating that different levels of urbanization have distinct effects on the local insect fauna (Owen and Owen, 1975, Frankie and Koehler, 1978, Zapparoli, 1997, McIntyre, 2000, McIntyre et al., 2001).
Information about the responses of wasps and bees to urbanization is important for a number of reasons. Many wasp species, especially the eusocial ones, are key predators in tropical ecosystems (LaSalle and Gauld, 1993, Raw, 1998b). Bees are the most important pollinators of angiosperms and consequently they are also key species in many terrestrial ecosystems (Neff and Simpson, 1993). Wasps and bees are sensitive to variations in abiotic conditions (e.g. temperature, luminosity and moisture), which may be related to changes in the urbanization level (Genise, 1981, Roubik, 1992, Morgan and Jeanne, 1992). In addition, wasps and bees are frequently found in urban environments, efficiently occupying different microhabitats (e.g. walls, roofs, ceilings, etc.) (Nogueira-Neto, 1970, Fowler, 1983, Martins and Pimenta, 1993, Knoll et al., 1994, West-Eberhard et al., 1995, Saure, 1996, Raw, 1998a). Despite their ecological importance and their potential as indicators of environmental conditions (Brown, 1991), few authors have analyzed the effects of urbanization on wasp and bee assemblages. The literature suggests considerable variation in the responses of these insects to urbanization (Skibinska, 1986, Gayubo et al., 1987, Gayubo and Torres, 1989, Gayubo and Torres, 1990, Gayubo and Torres, 1991, Torres and Gayubo, 1989, Saure, 1996). In Brazil, previous studies restricted to bees have found a great variation in species sensitivity to urbanization and a considerable reduction of diversity in highly urbanized areas (Laroca et al., 1982, Bortoli and Laroca, 1997, Knoll et al., 1994).
It is generally assumed that urbanization (not considering deserts), reduces habitat complexity, mostly by reducing natural vegetation cover. Consequently, it may be predicted that less urbanized areas are structurally more complex. For these reasons, it can also be predicted that less urbanized areas support a greater abundance and species richness of wasps and bees. Our main objective in this paper is to examine these predictions. Additionally, we have attempted to analyze the effects of urbanization at a smaller spatial scale, focusing on the microhabitats of public squares. Based on island biogeography theory, it was assumed that public squares surrounded by an urbanized matrix could be considered islands with different levels of isolation according to the structural complexity of their surroundings. Hence, the following predictions were also examined: (1) larger squares support a higher abundance and richness of wasps and bees, and (2) squares with more complex surroundings support a higher abundance and richness of wasps and bees.
Section snippets
Study area
Two regions of the city of Belo Horizonte (19°52′S, 43°58′W) in the state of Minas Gerais, southeastern Brazil were considered in the present study. Founded in 1897, Belo Horizonte was especially planned to be the capital of the state. Today the metropolitan area covers an area of approximately 330.9 km2 and has 6746.79 inhabitants per km2 (IBGE, 2001). In the 1980s, Belo Horizonte was considered to be the fastest growing capital in Brazil (da Silva, 1998). The two regions selected within the
Abundance and species richness of wasps and bees
Overall, 6268 individuals from 110 species, belonging to eleven families in the order Hymenoptera were captured (Fig. 2, Fig. 3). The most abundant families were Apidae (n=5150) and Vespidae (n=794). Sixty-nine species were found in the less urbanized area (L), 47 in the area with an intermediate level of urbanization (M) and 56 in the highly urbanized area (H). Only three species were found in all sites, and 58 species were collected in only one site.
A total of 5368 bees from 69 species were
Discussion
The advanced eusocial bee species, particularly the stingless Meliponini, dominated the urban system studied. Previous surveys of bee assemblages in other Brazilian cities (e.g. Curitiba and São Paulo), also have found a superior abundance of Meliponini (Laroca et al., 1982, Knoll et al., 1994). However, this pattern is not restricted to urban environments. Studies of the bee fauna of Minas Gerais in non-urban areas have also shown the dominance of stingless bees (Silveira et al., 1993,
Acknowledgements
We thank Eduardo A.B. Almeida and Fernando Silveira for bee identification. Servio T.P. Amarante and Orlando Silveira for wasp idendification. Claudia Maria Jacobi, Thomas Michael Lewinsohn and two anonymous referees for comments and suggestions. Belo Horizonte County Parks and Gardens Department for logistic help. This research was done during the tenure of a master degree scholarship of CAPES. R.P. Martins thanks to Brazilian CNPq and FAPEMIG for grants. This work is a product of the Graduate
References (87)
- et al.
Butterfly diversity and human land use: species assemblages along an urban gradient
Biol. Conserv.
(1997) Human effects on nest survivorship of urban synanthropic wasps
Urban Ecol.
(1983)Scale, birds, and human decisions: a potential for integrative research in urban ecosystems
Landscape Urban Plann.
(1999)- et al.
Ground arthropod community structure in a heterogeneous urban environment
Landscape Urban Plann.
(2001) - et al.
Biodiversity concepts and urban ecosystems
Landscape Urban Plann.
(2000) - et al.
Biotope mapping and nature conservation strategies in urban areas of the Federal Republic of Germany
Landscape Urban Plann.
(1988) - et al.
Estimating the cumulative effects of development on wildlife habitat
Landscape Urban Plann.
(1997) Urban development and insect biodiversity of the Rome area, Italy
Landscape Urban Plann.
(1997)The role of habitat complexity and heterogeneity in structuring tropical mammal communities
Ecology
(1983)- Bedê, L.C., Weber, M., Resende, S., Piper, W., Schulte, W., 1997. Manual de mapeamento de Biótopos no Brasil. Fundação...
Melissocenologia no Terceiro Planalto Paranaense. I: Abundância relativa de abelhas silvestres (Apoidea) de um biótopo urbano de Guarapuava (PR, Brasil)
Acta Biologica Paranaense
Nest-site selection in the great golden digger wasp, Sphex ichneumoneus L. (Sphecidae)
Ecol. Entomol.
Habitat fragmentation and native bees: a premature verdict?
Conserv. Ecol.
Urban ecosystems and island biogeography
Environ. Conserv.
Insects in fragmented forests: a functional approach
Trends Ecol. Evol.
Carabid taxocenes of an urban park in subtropical Brazil: II specific diversity and similarity (Insecta: Coleoptera: Carabidae)
Stud. Neotrop. Fauna Environ.
Ecology of insects in urban environments
Annu. Rev. Entomol.
Efecto de la presion urbana sobre abejas y avispas (Hymenoptera, Aculeata) en Salamanca. I: Consideraciones generales
Studia Oecologica
Efecto de la presion urbana sobre abejas y avispas (Hymenoptera, Aculeata) en Salamanca. III: Eumenidae y Vespidae
Studia Oecologica
Efecto de la presion urbana sobre abejas e avispas (Hymenoptera, Aculeata) en Salamanca. IV: Sphecidae
Boletı́n de la Real Sociedad Española de Historia Natural
Efecto de la presion urbana sobre abejas y avispas (Hymenoptera, Aculeata) en Salamanca. II: Mutillidae y Chrysididae
Graellsia
Influencia de factores meteorologicos en la actividad de Prionyx bifoveolatus (Tasch.) (Hymenoptera: Sphecidae)
Physis
Bird predation affects canopy-living arthropods in city parks
Can. J. Zool.
Community structure of neotropical flower visiting bees and wasps: diversity and phenology
Ecology
Statistical evaluation of the Jackknife estimate of diversity when using quadrat samples
Ecology
A associação de abelhas silvestres (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) de uma área restrita no interior da cidade de Curitiba (Brasil): Uma abordagem Biocenótica
Dusenia
Scale and the spatial concept of fragmentation
Conserv. Biol.
Cited by (145)
Determinants of honeybee hive survival and its implications for urban biodiversity in Toronto and Montreal: A Canadian case study
2024, Landscape and Urban PlanningBees and their interactions with flowering plants in disturbed and semi-natural settings
2024, Journal of Asia-Pacific EntomologyImage background assessment as a novel technique for insect microhabitat identification
2023, Ecological InformaticsBees and pollination in grassland habitats in Helsinki (Finland) are diverse but dominated by polylectic species
2023, Basic and Applied EcologyUrbanisation impacts the diversity, coloration, and body size of wild bees in a Mediterranean city
2024, Regional Environmental Change