ReviewEffect of coal bottom ash as partial replacement of sand on properties of concrete
Highlights
► This paper discusses about use of coal bottom ash (CBA) in concrete. ► Presents properties of coal bottom ash and its applications. ► Effects of CBA on properties of fresh concrete, mechanical and durability properties.
Introduction
On burning of coal in furnace of coal fired thermal power plants, the non combustible material present in it results in production of coal ash. The finer and lighter particles of coal ash escape with the flue gases and are extracted in the Electrostatic Precipitators before reaching the environment. The coal ash collected from the Electrostatic Precipitators is named as fly ash. Some melted ash accumulates on the boiler walls and against steam tubes and solidifies to form masses called clinkers. The clinkers build up and fall to the bottom of boiler/furnace and are cooled in the water sump before passing through clinker grinder. The coal ash collected at bottom of furnace is called bottom ash. Bottom ash particles are physically coarse, porous, glassy, granular and grayish in color. Bottom ash forms up to 25% of the total ash while fly ash forms the remaining 75%. In India, coal fired thermal power plants are the main source of power generation and about 70% electricity requirements are fulfilled by them. About 360 million tons of coal is burnt by the coal fired thermal power plants every year. Indian coals have high amount of inorganic inclusions with varying properties and on combustion result in high ash content up to 46%. About 100 million tones of fly ash and 25 million tone of bottom ash is produced by these thermal power plants annually. With the addition of 59,000 MW of power generation by the end of year 2012, annual production of bottom ash will shoot up to 50 million tones. Worldwide fly ash is used in large volume in production of cement as mineral additive and in construction industry as partial cement replacement in concrete. Bottom ash is used as land fill material and as base material in road construction. In India up till now a small volume of fly ash is utilized in production of cement but bottom ash is not used in any form. Bottom ash along with unutilized fly ash is disposed off in ponds spread over thousand acres of land. The disposal of bottom ash in ponds poses risk to human health and the environment. The hazardous constituents in bottom ash migrate and can contaminate ground water or surface water, and hence living organisms. Also there is danger of ash dyke spill and filling the surrounding area of pond with ash. Environment concerns are increasing day by day and land fill space is declining, therefore it becomes essential to initiate the effort to utilize the bottom ash. Bottom ash has the appearance and particle size distribution similar to that of natural fine aggregate i.e. river sand. Because of these properties it attracted to be used as sand replacement in concrete. Recently research works have been focused on usage of bottom ash as partial sand replacement in concrete. The published research data indicate that bottom ash is a viable material as sand replacement in concrete. Therefore its suitability as sand replacement material in concrete and the ways in which bottom ash affects the fresh, hardened as well as durability properties of concrete has been critically evaluated in this review.
Bottom ash can be beneficially utilized in a variety of manufacturing and construction applications. At present in America, coal bottom ash is predominantly used for the following applications:
- •
Road base and sub-base
- •
Structural fill
- •
Backfill
- •
Drainage media
- •
Aggregate for concrete, asphalt and masonry
- •
Abrasives/traction
- •
Manufactured soil products
Section snippets
Chemical properties
Bottom ash is mainly composed of silica, alumina, and iron with small amounts of calcium, magnesium, sulfate, etc. Its chemical composition is controlled by the source of the coal. Table 1 shows the comparative study of Chemical composition of bottom ash obtained from different sources of coal.
Physical properties
The particles of coal bottom ash are angular, irregular and porous and have rough surface texture. The particle size ranges from fine gravel to fine sand. Coal bottom ash particles have interlocking
Workability
Water demand to achieve desired workability of concrete mainly depends on the number of fines and properties of fine aggregate in it. Natural river sand particles are dense and its shape, surface becomes smooth due to weathering affects. Weak minerals like mica are removed from it. Whereas bottom ash particles are angular and rough textured and are porous. Bottom ash has more number of particles of size smaller than 75 μm as compared to that in natural river sand. Therefore on use of bottom ash
Density
The research data reported by various researchers’ show that there is an appreciable decrease in unit weight of concrete when natural sand is substituted with bottom ash. The decrease in density of bottom ash concrete is attributed to the lower unit weight and porous structure of bottom ash as compared to natural sand. Another factor which is also responsible for lower density is the higher demand of mixing water by the bottom ash concrete which leaves behind more number of pores, larger size
Permeability
The permeability of concrete depends upon the size, distribution and continuity of pores present in cement paste and permeability of aggregates. The reports published by various researchers indicate that bottom ash concrete has higher permeability as compared to natural sand concrete. With the increase in bottom ash content in concrete its permeability increases. The main factors responsible for the increased permeability of bottom ash concrete are porous microstructure of bottom ash, increased
Observations and conclusions
The properties of fresh as well as hardened concrete are closely associated with the characteristics and relevant proportioning of its constituent materials. The research reports show that inclusion of bottom ash as sand replacement in concrete influences the workability, setting times, loss of water through bleeding, bleeding rate and plastic shrinkage of fresh concrete and density, strength, porosity, durability of hardened mass. The published research literature shows that the strength
References (25)
- et al.
Aspects of moisture kinetics of coal bottom ash in concrete
Cement and Concrete Research
(2007) - et al.
Influence of coal bottom ash as fine aggregate on fresh properties of concrete
Construction and Building Materials
(2009) - et al.
Strength and drying shrinkage properties of concrete containing furnace bottom ash as fine aggregate
Construction and Building Materials
(2005) - et al.
Pozzolanic properties of pulverized coal combustion bottom ash
Cement and Concrete Research
(1999) - et al.
A method of determine water retainability of porous fine aggregate for design and quality control of fresh concrete
Construction and Building Materials
(2007) - et al.
Use of power plant bottom ash as fine and coarse aggregate in high-strength concrete
Construction and Building Materials
(2011) - et al.
Usage of coal combustion bottom ash in concrete mixture
Construction and Building Materials
(2008) - et al.
Influence of high temperature on the properties of concretes made with industrial by-product as fine aggregate replacement
Construction Building Material
(2011) - et al.
Effect of bottom ash as replacement of fine aggregates in concrete
Asian Journal of Civil Engineering (Building and Housing)
(2007) Experimental study of concrete mix with bottom ash as fine aggregate in Thailand
A study on characterization and use of pond ash as fine aggregate in concrete
International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering
A study on the fundamental properties of concrete incorporating pond-ash in Korea
Cited by (209)
Towards increased adoption of furnace bottom ash as sustainable building materials: Characterization, standardization, and applications
2024, Journal of Building EngineeringTheoretical model for spontaneous combustion gangue coarse aggregate concrete filled steel tube stub columns
2024, Journal of Constructional Steel ResearchMechanochemical activation for transforming bottom ash to reactive supplementary cementitious material
2024, Construction and Building MaterialsEffect of temperature on thermal properties and residual strength of coal gangue concrete
2024, Case Studies in Thermal EngineeringUse of coal-fired slag in filling bodies with early strength for mining applications
2023, Journal of Cleaner ProductionCoal bottom ash as supplementary material for sustainable construction: A comprehensive review
2023, Construction and Building Materials